Prussian Blue Analogs for Zinc Hybrid Ion Batteries: A Promising and Competitive Alternative to Aqueous Zinc-Ion Batteries

Abstract

Zinc hybrid ion batteries (ZHIBs) represent an innovative alternative building upon the strengths of zinc-ion batteries (ZIBs) while overcoming their inherent challenges. ZHIBs employ a versatile strategy of utilizing monovalent ions as charge carriers, which not only accelerates the diffusion kinetics but also fortifies the structural integrity of the cathode materials. This approach effectively addresses the issues of slow divalent zinc ion migration and the strong coulombic interactions that have been noted in ZIBs. Prussian blue analogs (PBAs) are notable for their open framework, structural robustness, and adaptability to various ions. Despite their advantages, challenges such as the irreversible phase transitions upon cycling, low electrical conductivity, and abundant defects and crystal water impede the broader application of PBAs in ZHIBs. This review discusses the advantages of PBA cathodes, comprehensively summarizing the challenges encountered and proposing corresponding strategies aimed to these challenges. Recent applications of PBAs in ZHIBs are summarized, highlighting their potential and limitations. Finally, the review outlines the opportunities and challenges facing the field, proposing potential research pathways to further develop PBA cathodes for ZHIBs.

Keywords

cathodes / hybrid ion batteries / metal-organic frameworks / Prussian blue analogs / zinc batteries

References

[1] Y. P. Deng, R. L. Liang, G. P. Jiang, Y. Jiang, A. P. Yu, and Z. W. Chen, “The Current State of Aqueous Zn-Based Rechargeable Batteries,” ACS Energy Letters5 (2020): 1665.

[2] F. J. M. M. Nijsse, J.-F. Mercure, N. Ameli, et al., “The Momentum of the Solar Energy Transition,” Nature Communications14 (2023): 6542.

[3] a) B. Obama, “The Irreversible Momentum of Clean Energy,” Science355 (2017): 126-129. b) X. L. Xu, Y. Chen, W. R. Li, et al., “Achieving Ultralong-Cycle Zinc-Ion Battery via Synergistically Electronic and Structural Regulation of a MnO₂ Nanocrystal-Carbon Hybrid Framework,” Small19 (2023): 2207517.

[4] a) X. Cao, C. Tan, M. Sindoro, and H. Zhang, “Hybrid Micro-/Nano-Structures Derived From Metal-Organic Frameworks: Preparation and Applications in Energy Storage and Conversion,” Chemical Society Reviews46 (2017): 2660-2677. b) A. M. Haregewoin, A. S. Wotango, and B.-J. Hwang, “Electrolyte Additives for Lithium Ion Battery Electrodes: Progress and Perspectives,” Energy & Environmental Science9 (2016): 1955-1988. c) J. B. Goodenough, “How We Made the Li-Ion Rechargeable Battery,” Nature Electronics1 (2018): 204.

[5] O. Schmidt, A. Hawkes, A. Gambhir, and I. Staffell, “The Future Cost of Electrical Energy Storage Based on Experience Rates,” Nature Energy2 (2017): 17110.

[6] L. Tang, H. Peng, J. Kang, et al., “Zn-Based Batteries for Sustainable Energy Storage: Strategies and Mechanisms,” Chemical Society Reviews53 (2024): 4877-4925.

[7] W. Du, E. H. Ang, Y. Yang, Y. Zhang, M. Ye, and C. C. Li, “Challenges in the Material and Structural Design of Zinc Anode Towards High-Performance Aqueous Zinc-Ion Batteries,” Energy & Environmental Science13 (2020): 3330-3360.

[8] a) W. Wang, C. Li, S. Liu, et al., “Flexible Quasi-Solid-State Aqueous Zinc-Ion Batteries: Design Principles, Functionalization Strategies, and Applications,” Advanced Energy Materials13 (2023): 2300250. b) J. Yang, R. Zhao, Y. Wang, et al., “Insights on Artificial Interphases of Zn and Electrolyte: Protection Mechanisms, Constructing Techniques, Applicability, and Prospective,” Advanced Functional Materials33 (2023): 2213510. c) C. Y. Zhu, P. Z. Li, G. Y. Xu, H. Cheng, and G. Gao, “Recent Progress and Challenges of Zn Anode Modification Materials in Aqueous Zn-ion Batteries,” Coordination Chemistry Reviews485 (2023): 215142.d) M. Li, Z. Li, X. Wang, et al., “Comprehensive Understanding of the Roles of Water Molecules in Aqueous Zn-Ion Batteries: From Electrolytes to Electrode Materials,” Energy & Environmental Science14 (2021): 3796-3839. e)Y. Shang, P. Kumar, U. Mittal, X. Liang, and D. Kundu, “Targeted Leveling of the Undercoordinated High Field Density Sites Renders Effective Zinc Dendrite Inhibition,” Energy Storage Materials55 (2023): 117-129.

[9] a) R. Y. Wang, B. Shyam, K. H. Stone, et al., “Reversible Multivalent (Monovalent, Divalent, Trivalent) Ion Insertion in Open Framework Materials,” Advanced Energy Materials5 (2015): 1401869. b) H.-W. Lee, M. Pasta, R. Y. Wang, R. Ruffo, and Y. Cui, “Effect of the Alkali Insertion Ion on the Electrochemical Properties of Nickel Hexacyanoferrate Electrodes,” Faraday Discussions176 (2014): 69-81. c) C. D. Wessells, S. V. Peddada, M. T. McDowell, R. A. Huggins, and Y. Cui, “The Effect of Insertion Species on Nanostructured Open Framework Hexacyanoferrate Battery Electrodes,” Journal of the Electrochemical Society159 (2012): A98-A103.d) R. Y. Wang, C. D. Wessells, R. A. Huggins, and Y. Cui, “Highly Reversible Open Framework Nanoscale Electrodes for Divalent Ion Batteries,” Nano Letters13 (2013): 5748-5752.

[10] J. Yan, J. Wang, H. Liu, Z. Bakenov, D. Gosselink, and P. Chen, “Rechargeable Hybrid Aqueous Batteries,” Journal of Power Sources216 (2012): 222-226.

[11] Y. Q. Deng, Y. H. Wu, K. F. Zhang, et al., “Inhibition of Side Reactions and Dendrite Growth Using a Low-Cost and Non-Flammable Eutectic Electrolyte for High-Voltage and Super-Stable Zinc Hybrid Batteries,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A11 (2023): 8368-8379.

[12] Z. X. Zhou, H. Y. Wang, W. L. Yi, S. Wu, X. Y. Sun, and J. Li, “Engineering of Hydrogel Electrolyte for Aqueous Zn||LiFePO4 Battery on Subzero-Temperature Adaptability, Long Cycles and Mechanical Safety,” Journal of Power Sources570 (2023): 233066.

[13] C. Wang, L. Sun, M. Li, et al., “Aqueous Zn2+/Na+ Dual-Salt Batteries With Stable Discharge Voltage and High Columbic Efficiency by Systematic Electrolyte Regulation,” Science China Chemistry65 (2021): 399-407.

[14] G. Wang, B. Kohn, U. Scheler, et al., “A High-Voltage, Dendrite-Free, and Durable Zn-Graphite Battery,” Advanced Materials32 (2020): 1905681.

[15] Y. H. Yang, G. M. Qu, H. Wei, et al., “Weakly Solvating Effect Spawning Reliable Interfacial Chemistry for Aqueous Zn/Na Hybrid Batteries,” Advanced Energy Materials13 (2023): 2203729.

[16] J. F. Qian, C. Wu, Y. L. Cao, et al., “Prussian Blue Cathode Materials for Sodium-Ion Batteries and Other Ion Batteries,” Advanced Energy Materials8 (2018): 1702619.

[17] K. Hurlbutt, S. Wheeler, I. Capone, and M. Pasta, “Prussian Blue Analogs as Battery Materials,” Joule2 (2018): 1950-1960.

[18] J. Peng, W. Zhang, Q. N. Liu, et al., “Prussian Blue Analogues for Sodium-Ion Batteries: Past, Present, and Future,” Advanced Materials34 (2022): 2108384.

[19] a) J. Song, L. Wang, Y. H. Lu, et al., “Removal of Interstitial H₂O in Hexacyanometallates for a Superior Cathode of a Sodium-Ion Battery,” Journal of the American Chemical Society137 (2015): 2658-2664. b) L. Wang, J. Song, R. M. Qiao, et al., “Rhombohedral Prussian White as Cathode for Rechargeable Sodium-Ion Batteries,” Journal of the American Chemical Society137 (2015): 2548-2554.

[20] a) M. Gu, A. M. Rao, J. Zhou, and B. Lu, “Molecular Modulation Strategies for Two-Dimensional Transition Metal Dichalcogenide-Based High-Performance Electrodes for Metal-Ion Batteries,” Chemical Science15 (2024): 2323-2350. b) H. Ge, L. Qin, B. Zhang, et al., “An Ionically Cross-Linked Composite Hydrogel Electrolyte Based on Natural Biomacromolecules for Sustainable Zinc-Ion Batteries,” Nanoscale Horizons9 (2024): 1514-1521.

[21] a) H. C. Yi, R. Z. Qin, S. X. Ding, et al., “Structure and Properties of Prussian Blue Analogues in Energy Storage and Conversion Applications,” Advanced Functional Materials31 (2021): 2006970. b) M. Li, M. Maisuradze, R. Sciacca, I. Hasa, and M. Giorgetti, “A Structural Perspective on Prussian Blue Analogues for Aqueous Zinc-Ion Batteries,” Batteries & Supercaps6 (2023): e20230340. c) X. L. Xu, Y. Chen, D. S. Liu, et al., “Metal-Organic Framework-Based Materials for Aqueous Zinc-Ion Batteries: Energy Storage Mechanism and Function,” Chemical Record22 (2022): e202200079. d) Y. X. Li, J. X. Zhao, Q. Hu, et al., “Prussian Blue Analogs Cathodes for Aqueous Zinc Ion Batteries,” Materials Today Energy29 (2022): 101095.

[22] a) L. Ma, S. Chen, C. Long, et al., “Achieving High-Voltage and High-Capacity Aqueous Rechargeable Zinc Ion Battery by Incorporating Two-Species Redox Reaction,” Advanced Energy Materials9 (2019): 1902446. b) Q. Li, K. Ma, G. Yang, and C. Wang, “High-Voltage Non-Aqueous Zn/K1.6Mn1.2Fe(CN)6 Batteries With Zero Capacity Loss in Extremely Long Working Duration,” Energy Storage Materials29 (2020): 246-253. c) L. Zhang, L. Chen, X. Zhou, and Z. Liu, “Morphology-Dependent Electrochemical Performance of Zinc Hexacyanoferrate Cathode for Zinc-Ion Battery,” Scientific Reports5 (2015): 18263.

[23] A. J. Zhou, W. J. Cheng, W. Wang, et al., “Hexacyanoferrate-Type Prussian Blue Analogs: Principles and Advances Toward High-Performance Sodium and Potassium Ion Batteries,” Advanced Energy Materials11 (2021): 2000943.

[24] a) Y. You, X. L. Wu, Y. X. Yin, and Y. G. Guo, “High-Quality Prussian Blue Crystals as Superior Cathode Materials for Room-Temperature Sodium-Ion Batteries,” Energy & Environmental Science7 (2014): 1643-1647. b) L. Li, Z. Hu, Y. Lu, et al., “A Low-Strain Potassium-Rich Prussian Blue Analogue Cathode for High Power Potassium-Ion Batteries,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition60 (2021): 13050-13056.

[25] J. Lee, W. Jeong, J. Baek, et al., “A Moisture-Controlled Prussian White/CNT Composite High Energy Cathode for Next-Generation Sodium-Ion Batteries,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A11 (2023): 25724-25733.

[26] Y. Zeng, J. Xu, Y. Wang, S. Li, D. Luan, and X. W. Lou, “Formation of CuMn Prussian Blue Analog Double-Shelled Nanoboxes Toward Long-Life Zn-Ion Batteries,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition61 (2022): e202212031.

[27] Y. Shang, X. X. Li, J. J. Song, et al., “Unconventional Mn Vacancies in Mn-Fe Prussian Blue Analogs: Suppressing Jahn-Teller Distortion for Ultrastable Sodium Storage,” Chemistry6 (2020): 1804-1818.

[28] H. Wu, J. Hao, Y. Jiang, et al., “Alkaline-Based Aqueous Sodium-ion Batteries for Large-Scale Energy Storage,” Nature Communications15 (2024): 575.

[29] J. Ji, F. Cheng, W. Cai, et al., “Constructing Ion “Tongs” and Double-Network for Cellulose-Based Semi-Solid Electrolytes Towards Dendrite-Free Dual-ion Batteries,” Chemical Engineering Journal482 (2024): 149172.

[30] Y. You, H. R. Yao, S. Xin, et al., “Subzero-Temperature Cathode for a Sodium-Ion Battery,” Advanced Materials28 (2016): 7243-7248.

[31] M. Chen, X. Li, Y. Yan, et al., “Polypyrrole-Coated K₂Mn[Fe(CN)₆] Stabilizing Its Interfaces and Inhibiting Irreversible Phase Transition During the Zinc Storage Process in Aqueous Batteries,” ACS Appl Mater Interfaces14 (2022): 1092-1101.

[32] M. Fiore, S. Wheeler, K. Hurlbutt, et al., “Paving the Way Toward Highly Efficient, High-Energy Potassium-Ion Batteries With Ionic Liquid Electrolytes,” Chemistry of Materials32 (2020): 7653-7661.

[33] a) H. Zhang, Y. Gao, J. Peng, et al., “Prussian Blue Analogues With Optimized Crystal Plane Orientation and Low Crystal Defects Toward 450 Wh Kg −1 Alkali-Ion Batteries,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition62 (2023): e202303953. b) Z. Liang, F. Tian, G. Yang, and C. Wang, “Enabling Long-Cycling Aqueous Sodium-ion Batteries via Mn Dissolution Inhibition Using Sodium Ferrocyanide Electrolyte Additive,” Nature Communications14 (2023): 3591.

[34] L. Q. Deng, J. L. Qu, X. G. Niu, et al., “Defect-Free Potassium Manganese Hexacyanoferrate Cathode Material for High-Performance Potassium-ion Batteries,” Nature Communications12 (2021): 2167.

[35] J. Zhan, W. Zhu, Y. Liu, et al., “Low-Cost, Safe, and Ultra-Long Cycle Life Zn-K Hybrid Ion Batteries,” Advanced Functional Materials33 (2023): 2301935.

[36] X. Li, T. Guo, Y. Shang, et al., “Interior-Confined Vacancy in Potassium Manganese Hexacyanoferrate for Ultra-Stable Potassium-Ion Batteries,” Advanced Materials36 (2024): 2310428.

[37] A. Li, Y. Man, J. Liao, L. Duan, X. Ji, and X. Zhou, “KI-Assisted Formation of Spindle-Like Prussian White Nanoparticles for High-Performance Potassium-Ion Battery Cathodes,” Nano Letters21 (2023): 10066-10073.

[38] T. Gupta, A. Kim, S. Phadke, et al., “Improving the Cycle Life of a High-Rate, High-Potential Aqueous Dual-Ion Battery Using Hyper-Dendritic Zinc and Copper Hexacyanoferrate,” Journal of Power Sources305 (2016): 22-29.

[39] X. Y. Liu, Y. Cao, and J. Sun, “Defect Engineering in Prussian Blue Analogs for High-Performance Sodium-Ion Batteries,” Advanced Energy Materials12 (2022): 2202532.

[40] K. Wang, Z. Xu, H. Li, et al., “Realizing the Highly Reversible Zn2+ and Na+ Dual Ions Storage in High-Crystallinity Nickel Hexacyanoferrate Microcubes for Aqueous Zinc-ion Batteries,” Journal of Materials Science and Technology164 (2023): 102-110.

[41] M. M. Shao, B. Wang, M. C. Liu, et al., “A High-Voltage and Cycle Stable Aqueous Rechargeable Na-Ion Battery Based on Na₂Zn₃ [Fe(CN)₆]₂ -NaTi₂(PO₄)₃ Intercalation Chemistry,” ACS Applied Energy Materials2 (2019): 5809-5815.

[42] J. Ge, L. Fan, A. M. Rao, J. Zhou, and B. Lu, “Surface-substituted Prussian Blue Analogue Cathode for Sustainable Potassium-Ion Batteries,” Nature Sustainability5 (2022): 225-234.

[43] H. S. Ao, W. D. Zhu, M. K. Liu, et al., “High-Voltage and Super-Stable Aqueous Sodium-Zinc Hybrid Ion Batteries Enabled by Double Solvation Structures in Concentrated Electrolyte,” Small Methods5 (2021): 2100418.

[44] Y. Sun, Z. Xu, X. Xu, et al., “Low-cost and Long-life Zn/Prussian Blue Battery Using a Water-in-ethanol Electrolyte With a Normal Salt Concentration,” Energy Storage Materials48 (2022): 192-204.

[45] M. Huang, J. S. Meng, Z. J. Huang, X. P. Wang, and L. Q. Mai, “Ultrafast Cation Insertion-Selected Zinc Hexacyanoferrate for 1.9 V K-Zn Hybrid Aqueous Batteries,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A8 (2020): 6631-6637.

[46] M. Huang, J. X. Zhu, R. H. Yu, et al., “Liquid Phase-Induced Solid Solution Phase Mechanisms for Highly Stable and Ultrafast Energy Storage,” Advanced Energy Materials11 (2021): 2102342.

[47] a) J. Peng, Y. Gao, H. Zhang, et al., “Ball Milling Solid-State Synthesis of Highly Crystalline Prussian Blue Analogue Na_2−x MnFe(CN)₆ Cathodes for all-Climate Sodium-Ion Batteries,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition61 (2022): e202205867. b) W. L. Wang, Y. Gang, Z. Hu, et al., “Reversible Structural Evolution of Sodium-Rich Rhombohedral Prussian Blue for Sodium-ion Batteries,” Nature Communications11 (2020): 980.

[48] W. Deng, Z. Li, Y. Ye, et al., “Zn²⁺ Induced Phase Transformation of K₂ MnFe(CN)₆ Boosts Highly Stable Zinc-Ion Storage,” Advanced Energy Materials11 (2021): 2003639.

[49] G. Ni, Z. Hao, G. Y. Zou, F. H. Cao, L. Qin, and C. G. Zhou, “High-Performance Aqueous Rechargeable K/Zn Hybrid Batteries Based on Berlin Green Cathode Materials,” ChemElectroChem9 (2022): e202101351.

[50] W. Chen, J. Wu, K. Fu, et al., “Co-Solvent Electrolyte Design to Inhibit Phase Transition Toward High Performance K⁺/Zn²⁺ Hybrid Battery,” Small Methods8 (2023): e2300617.

[51] G. Ni, M. M. Sun, Z. Hao, et al., “Binary Solvents Assisting the Long-Term Stability of Aqueous K/Zn Hybrid Batteries,” Materials Today Energy31 (2023): 101204.

[52] G. Yang, Z. Liang, Q. Li, Y. Li, F. Tian, and C. Wang, “Epitaxial Core-Shell MnFe Prussian Blue Cathode for Highly Stable Aqueous Zinc Batteries,” ACS Energy Letters8 (2023): 4085-4095.

[53] Z. Li, T. Liu, R. Meng, et al., “Insights Into the Structure Stability of Prussian Blue for Aqueous Zinc Ion Batteries,” Energy & Environmental Materials4 (2021): 111-116.

[54] Q. Yang, F. N. Mo, Z. X. Liu, et al., “Activating C-Coordinated Iron of Iron Hexacyanoferrate for Zn Hybrid-Ion Batteries with 10 000-Cycle Lifespan and Superior Rate Capability,” Advanced Materials31 (2019): 1901521.

[55] C. Y. Li, D. X. Zhang, F. X. Ma, et al., “A High-Rate and Long-Life Aqueous Rechargeable Ammonium Zinc Hybrid Battery,” Chemsuschem12 (2019): 3732-3736.

[56] C. D. Wessells, M. T. McDowell, S. V. Peddada, M. Pasta, R. A. Huggins, and Y. Cui, “Tunable Reaction Potentials in Open Framework Nanoparticle Battery Electrodes for Grid-Scale Energy Storage,” ACS Nano6 (2012): 1688-1694.

[57] C. Y. Li, J. H. Wu, F. X. Ma, et al., “High-Rate and High-Voltage Aqueous Rechargeable Zinc Ammonium Hybrid Battery From Selective Cation Intercalation Cathode,” ACS Applied Energy Materials2 (2019): 6984-6989.

[58] W. Yang, L. Xu, W. Luo, et al., “Rechargeable Zinc-Ammonium Hybrid Microbattery With Ultrahigh Energy and Power Density,” Matter6 (2023): 3006-3020.

[59] D. Wang, H. Lv, T. Hussain, et al., “A Manganese Hexacyanoferrate Framework With Enlarged Ion Tunnels and Two-Species Redox Reaction for Aqueous Al-ion Batteries,” Nano Energy84 (2021): 105945.

[60] a) P. Ruan, S. Liang, B. Lu, H. J. Fan, and J. Zhou, “Design Strategies for High-Energy-Density Aqueous Zinc Batteries,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition61 (2022): e202200598. b) D. Chao and S.-Z. Qiao, “Toward High-Voltage Aqueous Batteries: Super- or Low-Concentrated Electrolyte?,” Joule4 (2020): 1846-1851.

[61] W. J. Deng, Z. A. Li, Y. Chen, et al., “Bidirectional Interface Protection of a Concentrated Electrolyte, Enabling High-Voltage and Long-Life Aqueous Zn Hybrid-Ion Batteries,” ACS Applied Material Interfaces14 (2022): 35864-35872.

[62] C. Li, Q. Li, Z. Wu, et al., “Completely Activated and Phase-Transformed KFeMnHCF for Zn/K Hybrid Batteries With 14500 Cycles by an OH-Rich Hydrogel Electrolyte,” Advanced Materials36 (2023): 2304878.

[63] P. Luo, Z. Huang, W. W. Zhang, et al., “Incorporating near-Pseudocapacitance Insertion Ni/Co-Based Hexacyanoferrate and Low-Cost Metallic Zn for Aqueous K-Ion Batteries,” Chemsuschem15 (2022): e202200706.

[64] Q. Li, K. Ma, C. Hong, et al., “High-Voltage K/Zn Dual-Ion Battery With 100,000-cycles Life Using Zero-Strain ZnHCF Cathode,” Energy Storage Mater42 (2021): 715-722.

[65] D. H. Wang, C. Li, Q. Li, et al., “Unraveling the High Energy Efficiency for Zn||Metal Hexacyanoferrate Batteries in a Zinc-Potassium Hybrid Configuration,” Nano Energy104 (2022): 107990.

[66] J. Q. Huang, X. W. Chi, J. H. Yang, and Y. Liu, “An Ultrastable Na-Zn Solid-State Hybrid Battery Enabled by a Robust Dual-Cross-linked Polymer Electrolyte,” ACS Applied Material Interfaces12 (2020): 17583-17591.

[67] F. X. Ma, X. H. Yuan, T. Xu, et al., “A High-Quality Monoclinic Nickel Hexacyanoferrate for Aqueous Zinc-Sodium Hybrid Batteries,” Energy & Fuels34 (2020): 13104-13110.

[68] X. Yuan, F. Ma, X. Chen, et al., “Aqueous Zinc-Sodium Hybrid Battery Based on High Crystallinity Sodium-iron Hexacyanoferrate,” Materials Today Energy20 (2021): 100660.

[69] C. L. Liu, Y. P. Sun, J. B. Nie, D. Dong, J. Xie, and X. B. Zhao, “Stable Cycling of a Prussian Blue-Based Na/Zn Hybrid Battery in Aqueous Electrolyte With a Wide Electrochemical Window,” New Journal of Chemistry44 (2020): 4639-4646.

[70] S. Liu, T. Lei, Q. Q. Song, J. Zhu, and C. B. Zhu, “High Energy, Long Cycle, and Superior Low Temperature Performance Aqueous Na-Zn Hybrid Batteries Enabled by a Low-Cost and Protective Interphase Film-Forming Electrolyte,” ACS Applied Material Interfaces14 (2022): 11425-11434.

[71] X. L. Li, M. Li, Q. Yang, et al., “Phase Transition Induced Unusual Electrochemical Performance of V₂ CT_X MXene for Aqueous Zinc Hybrid-Ion Battery,” ACS Nano14 (2020): 541-551.

[72] B. H. Zhang, Y. Liu, X. W. Wu, et al., “An Aqueous Rechargeable Battery Based on Zinc Anode and Na_0.95 MnO₂,” Chemical Communications50 (2014): 1209-1211.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2025 The Author(s). Exploration published by Henan University and John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd.