Synergistic effect of cation substitution and p-type anion doping to improve thermoelectric properties in Zintl phases

Abstract

Altogether, seven Zintl compounds in the solid solution Ca_9-xYb_xZn_4.5-yCu_ySb₉ (0 ≤ x ≤ 1.5, 0 ≤ y ≤ 0.15) system were successfully prepared by the molten Pb-flux and hot-pressing method. From the powder X-ray and single crystal X-ray diffraction investigations, all these isotypic phases were observed to have been crystallized in the Ca₉Mn₄Bi₉-type phase (space group Pbam, Z = 2, Pearson code oP45). The overall crystal structure consists of complex anionic [Zn₄Sb₉] clusters and the space-filling cationic elements. Notably, the central Zn1 site in a triangular coordinate exhibited a partial occupation and a relatively large atomic displacement parameter, which was necessary for the charge balance of the title compounds. All five intra-layer and inter-layer cationic sites showed the Ca/Yb mixed-occupancy with Yb presenting a specific site-preference for the A3 site. Density functional theory calculations unveiled a synergistic effect of the Yb-substitution and the p-type Cu-doping increased carrier concentration by reducing bond polarity through the tuning of the electronegativity difference. Thermoelectric property measurements further validated that the given synergistic effect was successful in enhancing the electrical conductivities of the quinary title compounds compared to the parental ternary compound Ca₉Zn_4.5Sb₉. As a result, the title compound Ca₈YbZn_4.4Cu_0.1Sb₉ achieved the largest figure-of-merit of 0.81 at 843 K, which should be attributed to improved electrical transport properties while maintaining balanced thermal conductivity.

Keywords

Zintl phase / thermoelectric materials / Yb-substitution / p-type Cu-doping

References

[1] Qin B,Zhao LD.The development and impact of tin selenide on thermoelectrics.Science2024;386:eadp2444

[2] Jia Y,Sun H.Wearable thermoelectric materials and devices for self-powered electronic systems.Adv Mater2021;33:2102990

[3] Shuai J,Mao J,Wang Y.Significant role of Mg stoichiometry in designing high thermoelectric performance for Mg₃(Sb,Bi)₂-based n-type Zintls.J Am Chem Soc2018;140:1910-5

[4] Justl AP,Pike A.Unlocking the thermoelectric potential of the Ca₁₄AlSb₁₁ structure type.Sci Adv2022;8:eabq3780 PMCID:PMC9451163

[5] Justl AP.Probing high-temperature oxidation of thermoelectric phases Yb₁₄MSb₁₁ (M = Mg, Mn, Zn).ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2022;14:47246-54

[6] Guo K,Zhao J.Zintl phase compounds AM₂Sb₂ (A=Ca, Sr, Ba, Eu, Yb; M=Zn, Cd) and their substitution variants: a class of potential thermoelectric materials.J Rare Earths2013;31:1029-38

[7] Jeong J,Yox P.Tuning the radius ratio to enhance thermoelectric properties in the Zintl compounds AM₂Sb₂ (A = Ba, Sr; M = Zn, Cd).Chem Mater2023;35:3985-97

[8] Lee J,Pi JH.Insights into the crystal structure and thermoelectric properties of the Zintl phase Ca₉Cd_3+x-yM_x+ySb₉ (M = Cu, Zn) system.Chem Mater2025;37:368-77

[9] Chen C,Li X.Enhanced thermoelectric performance of Zintl phase Ca₉Zn_4+xSb₉ by beneficial disorder on the selective cationic site.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2019;11:37741-7

[10] Bux SK,Janka O.Glass-like lattice thermal conductivity and high thermoelectric efficiency in Yb₉Mn_4.2Sb₉.J Mater Chem A2014;2:215-20

[11] Kazem N,Ohno S,Kauzlarich SM.Coinage-metal-stuffed Eu₉Cd₄Sb₉: metallic compounds with anomalous low thermal conductivities.Chem Mater2015;27:7508-19

[12] Brechtel E,Schafer H.Darstellung und kristallstruktur von Ca₉Mn₄Bi₉ und Ca₉Zn₄Bi₉/Preparation and crystal structure of Ca₉Mn₄Bi₉ and Ca₉Zn₄Bi₉.Z Naturforsch1979;34:1229-33

[13] Liu XC,Xia SQ,Bobev S.Structural variability versus structural flexibility. A case study of Eu₉Cd_4+xSb₉ and Ca₉Mn_4+xSb₉ (x ≈ 1/2).Inorg Chem2015;54:947-55

[14] Liu XC,Wang QQ,Pan MY.Exploring new Zintl phases in the 9-4-9 family via Al substitution. Synthesis, structure, and physical properties of Ae₉Mn_4-xAl_xSb₉ (Ae = Ca, Yb, Eu).Inorg Chem2020;59:3709-17

[15] Wang Y.Rare-earth metal substitutions in Ca_9-xRE_xMn₄Sb₉ (RE = La-Nd, Sm; x ≈ 1). Synthesis and characterization of a new series of narrow-gap semiconductors.Chem Mater2018;30:3518-27

[16] Smiadak DM,Rylko M.Single crystal growth and characterization of new Zintl phase Ca₉Zn_3.1In_0.9Sb₉.J Solid State Chem2021;296:121947

[17] Uvarov CA,Kauzlarich SM.Enhanced high-temperature thermoelectric performance of Yb_14-xCa_xMnSb₁₁.Inorg Chem2012;51:7617-24

[18] Shuai J,Liu Z.Enhancement of thermoelectric performance of phase pure Zintl compounds Ca_1-xYb_xZn₂Sb₂, Ca_1-xEu_xZn₂Sb₂, and Eu_1-xYb_xZn₂Sb₂ by mechanical alloying and hot pressing.Nano Energy2016;25:136-44

[19] Ohno S,Amsler M.Achieving zT > 1 in inexpensive Zintl phase Ca₉Zn_4+xSb₉ by phase boundary mapping.Adv Funct Mater2017;27:1606361

[20] APEX2, Version 2013.6-2. Madison, WI: Bruker AXS Inc., 2013.

[21] SAINT. Madison, WI: Bruker AXS Inc., 2002.

[22] Sheldrick, G. M. SADABS. Göttingen: University of Göttingen, 2003.

[23] Gelato LM.STRUCTURE TIDY - a computer program to standardize crystal structure data.J Appl Cryst1987;20:139-43

[24] Andersen OK.Linear methods in band theory.Phys Rev B1975;12:3060-83

[25] Andersen OK.Explicit, first-principles tight-binding theory.Phys Rev Lett1984;53:2571-4

[26] Lambrecht WRL.Minimal basis sets in the linear muffin-tin orbital method: application to the diamond-structure crystals C, Si, and Ge.Phys Rev B Condens Matter1986;34:2439

[27] Jepsen O. The STUTTGART TB-LMTO program. Available from: https://www2.fkf.mpg.de/andersen/LMTODOC/LMTODOC.html [Last accessed on 25 Jun 2025]

[28] Andersen OK,Glötzel D. Canonical description of the band structures of metals. 1985; pp. 65-72. Available from: https://www2.fkf.mpg.de/andersen/docs/pub/85CanonicalVarenna.pdf [Last accessed on 25 Jun 2025]

[29] Jepsen O.Calculated electronic structure of the sandwichd¹ metals LaI₂ and CeI₂: application of new LMTO techniques.Z Physik B Condensed Matter1995;97:35-47

[30] Blöchl PE,Andersen OK.Improved tetrahedron method for Brillouin-zone integrations.Phys Rev B Condens Matter1994;49:16223-33

[31] Borup KA,Wang H.Measuring thermoelectric transport properties of materials.Energy Environ Sci2015;8:423-35

[32] Kim H,Tang Y,Snyder GJ.Characterization of Lorenz number with Seebeck coefficient measurement.APL Mater2015;3:041506

[33] Xia SQ.Interplay between size and electronic effects in determining the homogeneity range of the A₉Zn_4+xPn₉ and A₉Cd_4+xPn₉ phases (0 < or = x < or = 0.5), A = Ca, Sr, Yb, Eu; Pn = Sb, Bi.J Am Chem Soc2007;129:10011-8

[34] Bobev S,Sarrao JL,Hope H.Probing the limits of the Zintl concept: structure and bonding in rare-earth and alkaline-earth zinc-antimonides Yb₉Zn_4+xSb₉ and Ca₉Zn_4.5Sb₉.Inorg Chem2004;43:5044-52

[35] Shannon RD.Revised effective ionic radii and systematic studies of interatomic distances in halides and chalcogenides.Acta Cryst A1976;32:751-67

[36] Wachter J.The Elements. Von J. Emsley. Clarendon Press, Oxford 1989. 256 S., Paperback £ 9.95. – ISBN 0-19-855237-8.Angew Chem Int Ed1990;102:115

[37] Lei J,Zhao K.Efficient lanthanide Gd doping promoting the thermoelectric performance of Mg₃Sb₂-based materials.J Mater Chem A2021;9:25944-53

[38] Wu Z,Li X.Tuning the thermoelectric properties of Ca₉Zn_4+xSb₉ by controlled doping on the interstitial structure.Chem Mater2016;28:6917-24