PGM-free carbon-based catalysts for the electrocatalytic oxygen reduction reaction: active sites and activity enhancement

Abstract

Exploring high-activity, low-cost platinum group metal-free (PGM-free) oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) electrocatalysts to replace precious metal Pt is critical for large-scale fuel cell applications. Owing to their wide source, controllable composition, low price, and excellent performance, the PGM-free carbon-based electrocatalysts have attracted great interest in academia and are expected to be an ideal replacement for precious metal electrocatalysts. In this review, we mainly focus on PGM-free carbon-based electrocatalysts and first introduce the ORR mechanisms and the active site classification of PGM-free carbon-based electrocatalysts. Then, we propose four strategies to enhance the ORR activity of electrocatalysts from the active site perspective based on the relationship between the structure and function of active sites. Finally, we present the current challenges and prospects for developing ORR electrocatalysts exhibiting high performance and stability.

Keywords

Carbon-based electrocatalysts / oxygen reduction reaction mechanisms / active sites / activity enhancement strategy

References

[1] Thompson ST.Platinum group metal-free catalysts boost cost competitiveness of fuel cell vehicles.Nat Catal2019;2:558-61

[2] Fan Q,Wang H.Nanoscale redox reaction unlocking the next-generation low temperature fuel cell.Energy Mater2022;2:200002

[3] Zhao J,Li X.Structure, property, and performance of catalyst layers in proton exchange membrane fuel cells.Electrochem Energy Rev2023;6:13 PMCID:PMC10050052

[4] Zhang Y,Chen G.Fuel cell performance of non-precious metal based electrocatalysts.J Electrochem2020;26:563-72

[5] Cao S,Li J,Hou C.The cathode catalysts of hydrogen fuel cell: from laboratory toward practical application.Nano Res2023;16:4365-80

[6] Hamo ER.Transition metal carbides as cathode supports for PEM fuel cells.Nano Res2022;15:10218-33

[7] Nie Y,Wei Z.Recent advancements in Pt and Pt-free catalysts for oxygen reduction reaction.Chem Soc Rev2015;44:2168-201

[8] Yang X,Hou Y.Atomically dispersed dual-metal-site PGM-free electrocatalysts for oxygen reduction reaction: opportunities and challenges.SusMat2022;2:569-90

[9] Li Y,Lu B.Recent advances in exploring highly active & durable pgm-free oxygen reduction catalysts.J Electrochem2023;29:2215002

[10] Thompson ST,Huya-kouadio JM.Direct hydrogen fuel cell electric vehicle cost analysis: system and high-volume manufacturing description, validation, and outlook.J Power Sources2018;399:304-13

[11] Zeng R,Feng X.Nonprecious transition metal nitrides as efficient oxygen reduction electrocatalysts for alkaline fuel cells.Sci Adv2022;8:eabj1584 PMCID:PMC8809680

[12] Xia W,Liang Z,Guo S.Earth-abundant nanomaterials for oxygen reduction.Angew Chem Int Ed2016;55:2650-76

[13] He Y.PGM-free oxygen-reduction catalyst development for proton-exchange membrane fuel cells: challenges, solutions, and promises.ACC Mater Res2022;3:224-36

[14] Liu J,Chu Y.Construction and regulation of a surface protophilic environment to enhance oxygen reduction reaction electrocatalytic activity.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2020;12:41269-76

[15] Liu S,Ge B.Constructing graphitic-nitrogen-bonded pentagons in interlayer-expanded graphene matrix toward carbon-based electrocatalysts for acidic oxygen reduction reaction.Adv Mater2021;33:e2103133

[16] Chang Y,Jia J.The fluorine-doped and defects engineered carbon nanosheets as advanced electrocatalysts for oxygen electroreduction.Appl Catal B Environ2021;284:119721

[17] Liu K,Lin Y.Insights into the activity of single-atom Fe-N-C catalysts for oxygen reduction reaction.Nat Commun2022;13:2075 PMCID:PMC9018836

[18] Zhao T,Liu J.Highly dispersed L1₂-Pt₃Fe intermetallic particles supported on single atom Fe-N_x-C_y active sites for enhanced activity and durability towards oxygen reduction.Chin Chem Lett2023;34:107824

[19] Xie S,Wang C.A comparison study on single metal atoms (Fe, Co, Ni) within nitrogen-doped graphene for oxygen electrocatalysis and rechargeable Zn-air batteries.Chin Chem Lett2023;34:107681

[20] Ishihara A,Matsuzawa K,Ota K.Progress in non-precious metal oxide-based cathode for polymer electrolyte fuel cells.Electrochim Acta2010;55:8005-12

[21] Wang H,Peng Z.Cobalt-gluconate-derived high-density cobalt sulfides nanocrystals encapsulated within nitrogen and sulfur dual-doped micro/mesoporous carbon spheres for efficient electrocatalysis of oxygen reduction.J Colloid Interface Sci2020;561:829-37

[22] Yuan H,Li T.A review of transition metal chalcogenide/graphene nanocomposites for energy storage and conversion.Chin Chem Lett2017;28:2180-94

[23] Lv XW,Tian WW,Yuan ZY.Activity promotion of core and shell in multifunctional core-shell Co₂P@NC electrocatalyst by secondary metal doping for water electrolysis and Zn-air batteries.Small2021;17:e2101856

[24] Jasinski R.A new fuel cell cathode catalyst.Nature1964;201:1212-3

[25] Hu C.Carbon-based metal-free catalysts for electrocatalysis beyond the ORR.Angew Chem Int Ed2016;55:11736-58

[26] Jiang H,Zheng X.Defect-rich and ultrathin N doped carbon nanosheets as advanced trifunctional metal-free electrocatalysts for the ORR, OER and HER.Energy Environ Sci2019;12:322-33

[27] Wang F,Lin S,Hu Z.Axial ligand effect on the stability of Fe-N-C electrocatalysts for acidic oxygen reduction reaction.Nano Energy2020;78:105128

[28] Wang Q,Yang Y.Tailoring the microenvironment in Fe-N-C electrocatalysts for optimal oxygen reduction reaction performance.Sci Bull2022;67:1264-73

[29] Lu F,Cui L.Engineering FeN₄ active sites onto nitrogen-rich carbon with tubular channels for enhanced oxygen reduction reaction performance.Appl Catal B Environ2022;313:121464

[30] Xu M,Ge J,Xing W.Research progress of metal-nitrogen-carbon catalysts toward oxygen reduction reaction inm changchun institute of applied chemistry.J Electrochem2020;26:464-73

[31] Zhang L,Zheng R.Microenvironment regulation of M-N-C single-atom catalysts towards oxygen reduction reaction.Nano Res2023;16:4468-87

[32] Yang Y,Zeng R.Operando methods in electrocatalysis.ACS Catal2021;11:1136-78

[33] Zhao J,Zhao Z,Zhang J.A review of in-situ techniques for probing active sites and mechanisms of electrocatalytic oxygen reduction reactions.Nanomicro Lett2022;15:19 PMCID:PMC9800687

[34] Jia Y,Wang D.Atomically dispersed Fe-N₄ modified with precisely located S for highly efficient oxygen reduction.Nanomicro Lett2020;12:116 PMCID:PMC7770948

[35] Jiao Y,Jaroniec M.Design of electrocatalysts for oxygen- and hydrogen-involving energy conversion reactions.Chem Soc Rev2015;44:2060-86

[36] Chen G,Chen RR.A discussion on the possible involvement of singlet oxygen in oxygen electrocatalysis.J Phys Energy2021;3:031004

[37] Borden WT,Stuyver T.Dioxygen: what makes this triplet diradical kinetically persistent?.J Am Chem Soc2017;139:9010-8

[38] Fridovich I.Oxygen: how do we stand it?.Med Princ Pract2013;22:131-7 PMCID:PMC5685332

[39] Biz C,Fianchini M.Review on magnetism in catalysis: from theory to PEMFC applications of 3D metal Pt-based alloys.Int J Mol Sci2022;23:14768 PMCID:PMC9739051

[40] Biz C,Gracia J.Strongly correlated electrons in catalysis: focus on quantum exchange.ACS Catal2021;11:14249-61

[41] Nørskov JK,Logadottir A.Origin of the overpotential for oxygen reduction at a fuel-cell cathode.J Phys Chem B2004;108:17886-92

[42] Jiang WJ,Li L.Understanding the high activity of Fe-N-C electrocatalysts in oxygen reduction: Fe/Fe₃C nanoparticles boost the activity of Fe-N_x.J Am Chem Soc2016;138:3570-8

[43] Zhao Z,Liu Z.Pt-based nanocrystal for electrocatalytic oxygen reduction.Adv Mater2019;31:e1808115

[44] Prabhakaran V,Parrondo J.Contribution of electrocatalyst support to PEM oxidative degradation in an operating PEFC.J Electrochem Soc2016;163:F1611

[45] Banham D,Zhou Y.Critical advancements in achieving high power and stable nonprecious metal catalyst-based MEAs for real-world proton exchange membrane fuel cell applications.Sci Adv2018;4:eaar7180 PMCID:PMC5866058

[46] Radwan A,He D.Design engineering, synthesis protocols, and energy applications of MOF-derived electrocatalysts.Nanomicro Lett2021;13:132 PMCID:PMC8169752

[47] Yao Y,Zhang G.Highly functional bioinspired Fe/N/C oxygen reduction reaction catalysts: structure-regulating oxygen sorption.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2016;8:6464-71

[48] Abild-Pedersen F,Studt F.Scaling properties of adsorption energies for hydrogen-containing molecules on transition-metal surfaces.Phys Rev Lett2007;99:016105

[49] Biz C,Gracia J.Catalysis meets spintronics; spin potentials associated with open-shell orbital configurations enhance the activity of Pt₃Co nanostructures for oxygen reduction: a density functional theory study.ACS Appl Nano Mater2020;3:506-15

[50] Gracia J.Spin dependent interactions catalyse the oxygen electrochemistry.Phys Chem Chem Phys2017;19:20451-6

[51] Zhang L,Biz C,Gracia J.Ferromagnetic ligand holes in cobalt perovskite electrocatalysts as an essential factor for high activity towards oxygen evolution.Phys Chem Chem Phys2019;21:2977-83

[52] Hong J,Yuan J.Atomic defects in two-dimensional materials: from single-atom spectroscopy to functionalities in opto-/electronics, nanomagnetism, and catalysis.Adv Mater2017;29:1606434

[53] Wang X,Qu Y.Review of metal catalysts for oxygen reduction reaction: from nanoscale engineering to atomic design.Chem2019;5:1486-511

[54] Martinez U,Holby EF,Yin X.Progress in the development of Fe-based PGM-free electrocatalysts for the oxygen reduction reaction.Adv Mater2019;31:e1806545

[55] Alt H,Sandstede G.Mechanism of the electrocatalytic reduction of oxygen on metal chelates.J Catal1973;28:8-19

[56] Zheng Y,Kweun JM.Rational design of common transition metal-nitrogen-carbon catalysts for oxygen reduction reaction in fuel cells.Nano Energy2016;30:443-9

[57] Peng H,Liu X.Effect of transition metals on the structure and performance of the doped carbon catalysts derived from polyaniline and melamine for ORR application.ACS Catal2014;4:3797-805

[58] Venegas R,Candia-onfray C,Zagal JH.Experimental reactivity descriptors of M-N-C catalysts for the oxygen reduction reaction.Electrochim Acta2020;332:135340

[59] Ramaswamy N,Jia Q.Activity descriptor identification for oxygen reduction on nonprecious electrocatalysts: linking surface science to coordination chemistry.J Am Chem Soc2013;135:15443-9

[60] Masa J,Xia W,Schuhmann W.Metal-free catalysts for oxygen reduction in alkaline electrolytes: influence of the presence of Co, Fe, Mn and Ni inclusions.Electrochim Acta2014;128:271-8

[61] Shen H,Ma J.Synergistic effects between atomically dispersed Fe-N-C and C-S-C for the oxygen reduction reaction in acidic media.Angew Chem Int Ed2017;56:13800-4

[62] Li J,Samarakoon W.Thermally driven structure and performance evolution of atomically dispersed FeN₄ sites for oxygen reduction.Angew Chem Int Ed2019;58:18971-80

[63] Li Y,Zheng L.Preparation of Fe-N-C catalysts with FeN_x (x = 1, 3, 4) active sites and comparison of their activities for the oxygen reduction reaction and performances in proton exchange membrane fuel cells.J Mater Chem A2019;7:26147-53

[64] Zhu C,Xu BZ.Hierarchically porous M-N-C (M = Co and Fe) single-atom electrocatalysts with robust MN_x active moieties enable enhanced ORR performance.Adv Energy Mater2018;8:1801956

[65] Kabir S,Kiefer B.Computational and experimental evidence for a new TM-N₃/C moiety family in non-PGM electrocatalysts.Phys Chem Chem Phys2015;17:17785-9

[66] Zhang J,Zhu Z.A density functional theory study on mechanism of electrochemical oxygen reduction on FeN₃-graphene.J Electrochem Soc2015;162:F1262

[67] Huang J,Ma X.Bio-inspired FeN₅ moieties anchored on a three-dimensional graphene aerogel to improve oxygen reduction catalytic performance.J Mater Chem A2018;6:18488-97

[68] Zhu Y,Liu X,Su DS.Unravelling the structure of electrocatalytically active Fe-N complexes in carbon for the oxygen reduction reaction.Angew Chem Int Ed2014;53:10673-7

[69] Zitolo A,Armel V.Identification of catalytic sites for oxygen reduction in iron- and nitrogen-doped graphene materials.Nat Mater2015;14:937-42

[70] Chung HT,Higgins D.Direct atomic-level insight into the active sites of a high-performance PGM-free ORR catalyst.Science2017;357:479-84

[71] Shen H,Ma J.Atomically FeN₂ moieties dispersed on mesoporous carbon: a new atomic catalyst for efficient oxygen reduction catalysis.Nano Energy2017;35:9-16

[72] Song P,Pan J,Zhuang L.Structure-activity relationship in high-performance iron-based electrocatalysts for oxygen reduction reaction.J Power Sources2015;300:279-84

[73] Lefèvre M,Bertrand P.Molecular oxygen reduction in PEM fuel cells:  evidence for the simultaneous presence of two active sites in Fe-based catalysts.J Phys Chem B2002;106:8705-13

[74] Li J,Zitolo A.Identification of durable and non-durable FeN_x sites in Fe-N-C materials for proton exchange membrane fuel cells.Nat Catal2021;4:10-9

[75] Liu S,Wu G.Solving the activity-stability trade-off riddle.Nat Catal2021;4:6-7

[76] Xu X,Kuang Z.Investigation on the demetallation of Fe-N-C for oxygen reduction reaction: the influence of structure and structural evolution of active site.Appl Catal B Environ2022;309:121290

[77] Liu S,Zachman MJ.Atomically dispersed iron sites with a nitrogen-carbon coating as highly active and durable oxygen reduction catalysts for fuel cells.Nat Energy2022;7:652-63

[78] Yang L,Xu H.Unveiling the high-activity origin of single-atom iron catalysts for oxygen reduction reaction.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA2018;115:6626-31 PMCID:PMC6042067

[79] Wang X,Mao X.Edge-rich Fe-N₄ active sites in defective carbon for oxygen reduction catalysis.Adv Mater2020;32:e2000966

[80] Liu K,Wang G.Role of local carbon structure surrounding FeN₄ sites in boosting the catalytic activity for oxygen reduction.J Phys Chem C2017;121:11319-24

[81] Fu X,Ren B.Tailoring FeN₄ sites with edge enrichment for boosted oxygen reduction performance in proton exchange membrane fuel cell.Adv Energy Mater2019;9:1803737

[82] Mineva T,Atanassov P.Understanding active sites in pyrolyzed Fe-N-C catalysts for fuel cell cathodes by bridging density functional theory calculations and ⁵⁷Fe mössbauer spectroscopy.ACS Catal2019;9:9359-71

[83] Matter PH,Millet JM.Characterization of the iron phase in CN_x -based oxygen reduction reaction catalysts.J Phys Chem C2007;111:1444-50

[84] Li D,Chang G.A defect-driven metal-free electrocatalyst for oxygen reduction in acidic electrolyte.Chem2018;4:2345-56

[85] Fellinger TP,Strasser P.Mesoporous nitrogen-doped carbon for the electrocatalytic synthesis of hydrogen peroxide.J Am Chem Soc2012;134:4072-5

[86] Artyushkova K,Rojas-carbonell S.Chemistry of multitudinous active sites for oxygen reduction reaction in transition metal-nitrogen-carbon electrocatalysts.J Phys Chem C2015;119:25917-28

[87] Parvez K,Hernandez Y.Nitrogen-doped graphene and its iron-based composite as efficient electrocatalysts for oxygen reduction reaction.ACS Nano2012;6:9541-50

[88] Liu G,Ganesan P.Studies of oxygen reduction reaction active sites and stability of nitrogen-modified carbon composite catalysts for PEM fuel cells.Electrochim Acta2010;55:2853-8

[89] Lai L,Zhan D.Exploration of the active center structure of nitrogen-doped graphene-based catalysts for oxygen reduction reaction.Energy Environ Sci2012;5:7936-42

[90] Cui X,Yan X.Pyridinic-nitrogen-dominated graphene aerogels with Fe-N-C coordination for highly efficient oxygen reduction reaction.Adv Funct Mater2016;26:5708-17

[91] Huang X,Niu Y,Xu M.Effect of nanoparticle composition on oxygen reduction reaction activity of Fe/N-C catalysts: a comparative study.Catal Sci Technol2019;9:711-7

[92] Li G,Li W,Xu C.3D interconnected hierarchical porous N-doped carbon constructed by flake-like nanostructure with Fe/Fe₃C for efficient oxygen reduction reaction and supercapacitor.Nanoscale2018;10:9252-60

[93] Zhang SL,Wu HB.Metal-organic framework-assisted synthesis of compact Fe₂O₃ nanotubes in Co₃O₄ host with enhanced lithium storage properties.Nanomicro Lett2018;10:44 PMCID:PMC6199090

[94] Faubert G,Côté R.Heat-treated iron and cobalt tetraphenylporphyrins adsorbed on carbon black: Physical characterization and catalytic properties of these materials for the reduction of oxygen in polymer electrolyte fuel cells.Electrochim Acta1996;41:1689-701

[95] Varnell JA,Schulz CE.Identification of carbon-encapsulated iron nanoparticles as active species in non-precious metal oxygen reduction catalysts.Nat Commun2016;7:12582 PMCID:PMC4992170

[96] Choi CH,Kasian O.Unraveling the nature of sites active toward hydrogen peroxide reduction in Fe-N-C catalysts.Angew Chem Int Ed2017;56:8809-12 PMCID:PMC5519930

[97] Qiao Y,Hu Y.Sulfuration of an Fe-N-C catalyst containing Fe_xC/Fe species to enhance the catalysis of oxygen reduction in acidic media and for use in flexible Zn-air batteries.Adv Mater2018;30:e1804504

[98] Hu E,Chen F,Hu Y.Graphene layers-wrapped Fe/Fe₅C₂ nanoparticles supported on N-doped graphene nanosheets for highly efficient oxygen reduction.Adv Energy Mater2018;8:1702476

[99] Wang Y,Liu H.Fe₃O₄/Fe₂O₃/Fe nanoparticles anchored on N-doped hierarchically porous carbon nanospheres as a high-efficiency ORR electrocatalyst for rechargeable Zn-air batteries.J Mater Chem A2021;9:2764-74

[100] Kramm UI,Behrends J,Fiechter S.On an easy way to prepare metal-nitrogen doped carbon with exclusive presence of MeN₄-type sites active for the ORR.J Am Chem Soc2016;138:635-40

[101] Wang Y,Wang K,Yu T.Fe₃O₄@N-doped interconnected hierarchical porous carbon and its 3D integrated electrode for oxygen reduction in acidic media.Adv Sci2020;7:2000407 PMCID:PMC7375250

[102] Gong K,Xia Z,Dai L.Nitrogen-doped carbon nanotube arrays with high electrocatalytic activity for oxygen reduction.Science2009;323:760-4

[103] Zhao Y,Yao H.Few-layer graphdiyne doped with sp-hybridized nitrogen atoms at acetylenic sites for oxygen reduction electrocatalysis.Nat Chem2018;10:924-31

[104] Yang L,Du L.Carbon-based metal-free ORR electrocatalysts for fuel cells: past, present, and future.Adv Mater2019;31:e1804799

[105] Liu J,Xu W.Structure-activity relationship of doped-nitrogen (N)-based metal-free active sites on carbon for oxygen reduction reaction.Carbon2017;115:763-72

[106] Rao CV,Ishikawa Y.In search of the active site in nitrogen-doped carbon nanotube electrodes for the oxygen reduction reaction.J Phys Chem Lett2010;1:2622-7

[107] Li H,Wang L.Synthesis of three-dimensional flowerlike nitrogen-doped carbons by a copyrolysis route and the effect of nitrogen species on the electrocatalytic activity in oxygen reduction reaction.Carbon2013;54:249-57

[108] Meng J,Liu X.Scalable fabrication and active site identification of MOF shell-derived nitrogen-doped carbon hollow frameworks for oxygen reduction.J Mater Sci Technol2021;66:186-92

[109] Wang N,Li L.Graphitic nitrogen is responsible for oxygen electroreduction on nitrogen-doped carbons in alkaline electrolytes: insights from activity attenuation studies and theoretical calculations.ACS Catal2018;8:6827-36

[110] Liu R,Feng X.Nitrogen-doped ordered mesoporous graphitic arrays with high electrocatalytic activity for oxygen reduction.Angew Chem Int Ed2010;49:2565-9

[111] Kim H,Woo SI.On the mechanism of enhanced oxygen reduction reaction in nitrogen-doped graphene nanoribbons.Phys Chem Chem Phys2011;13:17505-10

[112] Wang J,Wei Z.Density functional theory study of oxygen reduction reaction on different types of N-doped graphene.Acta Phys Chim Sin2016;32:321-8

[113] Li M,Wang F.The influence of the type of N dopping on the performance of bifunctional N-doped ordered mesoporous carbon electrocatalysts in oxygen reduction and evolution reaction.J Energy Chem2017;26:422-7

[114] Quílez-bermejo J,San-fabián E,Cazorla-amorós D.Towards understanding the active sites for the ORR in N-doped carbon materials through fine-tuning of nitrogen functionalities: an experimental and computational approach.J Mater Chem A2019;7:24239-50

[115] Liu Z,Wang Y.In situ exfoliated, edge-rich, oxygen-functionalized graphene from carbon fibers for oxygen electrocatalysis.Adv Mater2017;29:1606207

[116] Shen A,Wang Q.Oxygen reduction reaction in a droplet on graphite: direct evidence that the edge is more active than the basal plane.Angew Chem Int Ed2014;53:10804-8

[117] Tao L,Dou S.Edge-rich and dopant-free graphene as a highly efficient metal-free electrocatalyst for the oxygen reduction reaction.Chem Commun2016;52:2764-7

[118] Xue L,Liu X.Zigzag carbon as efficient and stable oxygen reduction electrocatalyst for proton exchange membrane fuel cells.Nat Commun2018;9:3819 PMCID:PMC6145918

[119] Ye G,Huang K.Domain-confined etching strategy to regulate defective sites in carbon for high-efficiency electrocatalytic oxygen reduction.Adv Funct Mater2022;32:2111396

[120] Zhang L,Lu K,Li DS.Engineering synergistic edge-N dipole in metal-free carbon nanoflakes toward intensified oxygen reduction electrocatalysis.Adv Funct Mater2021;31:2103187

[121] Kou Z,He D,Mu S.Transforming two-dimensional boron carbide into boron and chlorine dual-doped carbon nanotubes by chlorination for efficient oxygen reduction.ACS Energy Lett2018;3:184-90

[122] Zhao Y,Chen S.Can boron and nitrogen co-doping improve oxygen reduction reaction activity of carbon nanotubes?.J Am Chem Soc2013;135:1201-4

[123] Jiang H,Hao J,Li W.N and P co-functionalized three-dimensional porous carbon networks as efficient metal-free electrocatalysts for oxygen reduction reaction.Carbon2017;122:64-73

[124] Gao Y,Liang J.Inside-out dual-doping effects on tubular catalysts: structural and chemical variation for advanced oxygen reduction performance.Nano Res2022;15:361-7

[125] Zan Y,Dou M.Enhancement mechanism of sulfur dopants on the catalytic activity of N and P co-doped three-dimensional hierarchically porous carbon as a metal-free oxygen reduction electrocatalyst.Catal Sci Technol2019;9:5906-14

[126] Zhang H,Li R.Doping engineering: modulating the intrinsic activity of bifunctional carbon-based oxygen electrocatalysts for high-performance zinc-air batteries.J Mater Chem A2022;10:21797-815

[127] Yang N,Li J,Wei Z.Modulating the oxygen reduction activity of heteroatom-doped carbon catalysts via the triple effect: charge, spin density and ligand effect.Chem Sci2018;9:5795-804 PMCID:PMC6050597

[128] Pei Z,Huang Y.Texturing in situ: N,S-enriched hierarchically porous carbon as a highly active reversible oxygen electrocatalyst.Energy Environ Sci2017;10:742-9

[129] Guo L,Li B.Promoting atomically dispersed MnN₄ sites via sulfur doping for oxygen reduction: unveiling intrinsic activity and degradation in fuel cells.ACS Nano2021;15:6886-99

[130] Liu H,Wang Y.Boosting oxygen reduction with coexistence of single-atomic Fe and Cu sites decorated nitrogen-doped porous carbon.Chem Eng J2023;452:138938

[131] Wang Z,Zhu C.Atomically dispersed Co₂-N₆ and Fe-N₄ costructures boost oxygen reduction reaction in both alkaline and acidic media.Adv Mater2021;33:e2104718

[132] Yin H,Lu BA.Phosphorus-driven electron delocalization on edge-type FeN₄ active sites for oxygen reduction in acid medium.ACS Catal2021;11:12754-62

[133] Sun Y,Yang H,Gracia J.Spin-related electron transfer and orbital interactions in oxygen electrocatalysis.Adv Mater2020;32:e2003297

[134] Yang G,Yuan P.Regulating Fe-spin state by atomically dispersed Mn-N in Fe-N-C catalysts with high oxygen reduction activity.Nat Commun2021;12:1734 PMCID:PMC7979714

[135] Li X,Yang B.Fundamental understanding of electronic structure in FeN₄ Site on electrocatalytic activity via dz₂-orbital-driven charge tuning for acidic oxygen reduction.Angew Chem Int Ed2023;62:e202215441

[136] Jiang R,Sheng T,Chen Y.Edge-site engineering of atomically dispersed Fe-N₄ by selective C-N bond cleavage for enhanced oxygen reduction reaction activities.J Am Chem Soc2018;140:11594-8

[137] Gong L,Wang Y.Bridge bonded oxygen ligands between approximated FeN₄ sites confer catalysts with high ORR performance.Angew Chem Int Ed2020;59:13923-8

[138] Shah SSA,Yang J,Peng L.Modulating the microenvironment structure of single Zn atom: ZnN₄P/C active site for boosted oxygen reduction reaction.Chin J Catal2022;43:2193-201

[139] Wang S,Rashkeev SN.Dopants adsorbed as single atoms prevent degradation of catalysts.Nat Mater2004;3:143-6

[140] Yin P,Wu Y.Single cobalt atoms with precise N-coordination as superior oxygen reduction reaction catalysts.Angew Chem Int Ed2016;55:10800-5

[141] Li J,Cullen DA.Atomically dispersed manganese catalysts for oxygen reduction in proton-exchange membrane fuel cells.Nat Catal2018;1:935-45

[142] Xin C,Hu J.Integration of morphology and electronic structure modulation on atomic iron-nitrogen-carbon catalysts for highly efficient oxygen reduction.Adv Funct Mater2022;32:2108345

[143] Li Z,Ji S.Engineering the morphology and electronic structure of atomic cobalt-nitrogen-carbon catalyst with highly accessible active sites for enhanced oxygen reduction.J Energy Chem2022;73:469-77

[144] Ding W,Xiong K.Shape fixing via salt recrystallization: a morphology-controlled approach to convert nanostructured polymer to carbon nanomaterial as a highly active catalyst for oxygen reduction reaction.J Am Chem Soc2015;137:5414-20

[145] Wan X,Li Y.Fe-N-C electrocatalyst with dense active sites and efficient mass transport for high-performance proton exchange membrane fuel cells.Nat Catal2019;2:259-68

[146] Qiao M,Wang Q.Hierarchically ordered porous carbon with atomically dispersed FeN₄ for ultraefficient oxygen reduction reaction in proton-exchange membrane fuel cells.Angew Chem Int Ed2020;59:2688-94

[147] Chen Y,Gong Y.Ultra-thin carbon nanosheets-assembled 3D hierarchically porous carbon for high performance zinc-air batteries.Carbon2019;152:325-34

[148] Zhang X,Yang Y.A general method for transition metal single atoms anchored on honeycomb-like nitrogen-doped carbon nanosheets.Adv Mater2020;32:e1906905

[149] Chakraborty R,Pradhan M.Recent advancement of biomass-derived porous carbon based materials for energy and environmental remediation applications.J Mater Chem A2022;10:6965-7005

[150] Ma Z,Wang X,Li Y.Lignin-derived hierarchical porous flower-like carbon nanosheets decorated with biomass carbon quantum dots for efficient oxygen reduction.Colloids Surf A Physicochem Eng Asp2022;652:129818

[151] Liu L,Chen J,Dai L.N-doped porous carbon nanosheets as pH-universal ORR electrocatalyst in various fuel cell devices.Nano Energy2018;49:393-402

[152] Jalalah M,Nayak AK.Biomass-derived metal-free porous carbon electrocatalyst for efficient oxygen reduction reactions.J Taiwan Inst Chem Eng2023;147:104905

[153] Wang S,Song L.Recent progress in defective carbon-based oxygen electrode materials for rechargeable zink-air batteries.Batteries Supercaps2019;2:509-23

[154] Jia Y,Yao X.Defect electrocatalytic mechanism: concept, topological structure and perspective.Mater Chem Front2018;2:1250-68

[155] Qiao Y,Zhang C,Kong A.Highly efficient oxygen electrode catalyst derived from chitosan biomass by molten salt pyrolysis for zinc-air battery.Electrochim Acta2020;339:135923

[156] Cheng W,Lv Z.Boosting defective carbon by anchoring well-defined atomically dispersed metal-N₄ sites for ORR, OER, and Zn-air batteries.Appl Catal B Environ2020;260:118198

[157] Jia Y,Zhuang L.Identification of active sites for acidic oxygen reduction on carbon catalysts with and without nitrogen doping.Nat Catal2019;2:688-95

[158] Huang X,Sun S.Synergistic modulation of carbon-based, precious-metal-free electrocatalysts for oxygen reduction reaction.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2021;13:6989-7003

[159] He Y,Priest C,Wu G.Atomically dispersed metal-nitrogen-carbon catalysts for fuel cells: advances in catalyst design, electrode performance, and durability improvement.Chem Soc Rev2020;49:3484-524