Reviewer guideline

1. Welcome and Mission

Thank you for agreeing to serve as a reviewer for Engineering·High-Performance Manufacturing (Eng·HPM).
Your expertise and professional judgment are essential to maintaining the journal’s high scientific and engineering standards and to advancing the frontiers of
high-performance manufacturing.

As a peer reviewer, you play a critical role in ensuring the integrity, rigor, relevance, and clarity of published research. These guidelines outline our expectations, review criteria, procedures, and ethical responsibilities to support you in this important task.

2. Peer Review Model

Eng·HPM operates a single-blind peer review process:

· Reviewer identities are kept confidential and are not disclosed to authors.

· Reviewers are informed of the authors’ identities and affiliations.

· All manuscripts, data, figures, and reviewer comments must be treated as strictly confidential.

· Submitted materials may not be used for any purpose other than the peer review process.

3. Review Process Overview

The editorial workflow of Eng·HPM is managed through an online manuscript submission and peer review system (e.g., ScholarOne Manuscripts™, URL to be determined).

The typical review process includes:

1. Invitation
You will receive an email invitation containing the manuscript title, abstract, and review deadline.

2. Response
Please accept or decline the invitation promptly using the provided link.

3. Access & Review
Upon acceptance, you may access the full manuscript and supplementary materials through the system.

4. Submission of Review
Complete the structured review form and provide comments directly in the system by the agreed deadline.

5. Decision Notification
You will be notified of the editorial decision. For manuscripts requiring major revision, you may be invited to review the revised version.

4. Criteria for Review

Reviewers are asked to evaluate manuscripts based on the following criteria:

Originality & Significance

· Does the manuscript present novel concepts, methods, models, or data?

· Does it make a substantial contribution to high-performance manufacturing, including processes, systems, materials, modeling, or intelligent manufacturing?

Scientific Rigor

· Are the research objectives clearly defined?

· Are the experimental, computational, or analytical methods appropriate, well-described, and reproducible?

· Is the modeling, simulation, or data-driven analysis technically sound?

Validity of Conclusions

· Are the conclusions logically supported by the presented results?

· Are assumptions, uncertainties, and limitations adequately discussed?

Clarity & Structure

· Is the manuscript well-organized and clearly written?

· Are figures and tables clear, necessary, and effective in supporting the text?

Relevance to Journal Scope

· Does the manuscript align with the Aims & Scope of Eng·HPM, particularly in terms of performance-driven manufacturing and engineering impact?

Ethical Compliance

· Does the study comply with ethical standards related to authorship, data integrity, conflicts of interest, and (if applicable) research involving humans, animals, or safety/environmental considerations?

5. How to Write a Constructive Review

Reviews should be objective, detailed, and professional, with the goal of helping authors improve their work and assisting editors in making informed decisions.

Structure of the Review Report

Summary
Briefly summarize the manuscript in your own words to demonstrate your understanding of the work and its contributions.

Major Comments
Address substantive scientific or engineering issues, such as:

· Methodological flaws

· Insufficient validation or benchmarking

· Unsupported claims

· Missing analysis or discussion
These comments typically determine whether the manuscript is publishable.

Minor Comments
Note smaller issues, including:

· Clarity of language

· Formatting or referencing errors

· Suggestions to improve figures or tables

Confidential Comments to the Editor
Use this section to raise concerns about:

· Ethical issues

· Potential plagiarism or duplicate publication

· Conflicts of interest
These comments will not be shared with the authors.

Provide Actionable Feedback

· Be specific and precise.
Example: Instead of “the model is unclear,” write “Please specify the boundary conditions and convergence criteria used in Section 3.1.”

· Justify critiques with references to the manuscript or established knowledge.

· When possible, suggest concrete improvements or alternative approaches.

· Clearly distinguish essential revisions from optional suggestions.

Recommendation Options

Reviewers will be asked to select one of the following recommendations:

· Accept with no (further) revision
The manuscript is of exceptional quality and ready for publication (rare).

· Accept after minor revision (no further review)
Only minor clarifications or corrections are required.

· Reconsider after major revision (re-review required)
Substantial scientific or technical revisions are necessary; the revised manuscript will likely be sent for re-evaluation.

· Reject
The manuscript has fundamental flaws, lacks novelty or significance, or falls outside the journal’s scope.

6. Ethical Responsibilities of Reviewers

Confidentiality

Treat all manuscripts as confidential documents. Do not share, discuss, or use their content prior to publication.

Conflict of Interest

Decline the review if you have a competing interest (e.g., close collaboration, direct competition, personal relationships, or financial ties). If uncertain, disclose the situation to the Editor.

Objectivity & Fairness

Evaluate manuscripts solely on scientific and engineering merit. Personal characteristics or institutional affiliations of the authors must not influence your judgment.

Timeliness

Respect review deadlines. If delays are unavoidable, notify the Editorial Office as soon as possible.

Acknowledgement of Sources

Inform the Editor if you suspect plagiarism, duplicate publication, or inadequate citation of prior work.

Professional Tone

Provide respectful, constructive criticism. Avoid personal, hostile, or dismissive language.

7. Handling Revised Manuscripts

When reviewing a revised manuscript:

· Carefully assess the authors’ point-by-point responses to all reviewer comments.

· Evaluate whether all major concerns have been adequately addressed.

· Review any new data, figures, or analyses added during revision.

Your recommendation should focus on whether the revisions sufficiently resolve the issues raised in the previous review round.

8. Confidentiality and Data Security

· Do not retain copies of manuscripts or review materials after completing your review.

· Do not share manuscripts with students or colleagues without explicit prior permission from the Editor.

· Use appropriate precautions when accessing the online review system.

9. Need Help or Have Questions?

For technical assistance with the submission system, please use the support links provided within the platform.

For questions related to the review process, ethical concerns, or specific manuscripts, please contact the Editorial Office:

Email: editorial@engineering-hpm.org (to be confirmed)

 




Pubdate:     Viewed: