Business as usual in Indonesia: governance factors effecting the acceleration of the deforestation rate after the introduction of REDD+

Abstract

Indonesia has the third largest extent of tropical forest in the world and has been extensively involved in Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and forest Degradation (REDD+). Despite significant commitments from the Government of Indonesia (GOI) and the international community, the deforestation rate in Indonesia has not stabilized or decreased in the initial years after REDD+’s introduction in 2007, and as of 2012 was arguably the highest in the world. Globally, it is essential to understand how REDD+ is going to affect the deforestation rate as it is implemented in many countries. In order to constructively evaluate these continued increases in rates of deforestation in Indonesia, this article will explore some of the challenges of forest governance in Indonesia as identified by stakeholders of REDD+ and as described in the policy documents and other literature. Despite a number of changes in laws and regulations that came about as a result of REDD+ in Indonesia, weak institutional capacity and corruption have resulted in a situation that might be described as essentially, business as usual. Furthermore, new policies that have resulted from the introduction of REDD+ designed to help forest governance, such as the presidential moratorium on new licenses for forest use, may in fact have motivated some parties to initially act in ways that have contributed to the increase in deforestation—particularly through leakage from institutionally recognized forests to non-institutionally recognized forest areas. Problematic governance and corruption continue to pose problems that haunt the forestry sector and allow encroachment onto protected areas.

Keywords

REDD+ / Indonesia / Forest governance / Deforestation / Forest policy

References

[1] Abood SA, Lee JSH, Burivalova Z, Garcia-Ulloa J, Koh LP (2014) Relative contributions of the logging, fiber, oil palm, and mining industries to forest loss in Indonesia. Conserv Lett. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/conl.12103/full

[2] Agung P, Galudra G, Van Noordwijk M, Maryani R (2014) Reform or reversal: the impact of REDD+ readiness on forest governance in Indonesia. Climate Policy, (ahead-of-print), 1–21

[3] Amindoni A (2016) Jokowi and House agree to postpone KPK Law revision—The Jakarta Post. The Jakarta Post. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2016/02/22/jokowi-and-house-agree-postpone-kpk-law-revision.html

[4] Anderson BRO (2001) Violence and the State in Suharto’s Indonesia. SEAP Publications. http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=BF776q2oFKkC&oi=fnd&pg=PA7&dq=suharto+violence&ots=r4MvzZbMxo&sig=Pcv255X6CN1xWtMogOx84q8Y6lI

[5] Applegate G, Chokkalingam U, Suyanto S (2001) The underlying causes and impacts of fires in Southeast Asia. Final Report. CIFOR, ICRAF, USAID, USFS, Bogor. http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PNACT614.pdf

[6] Austin K, Sheppard S, Stolle F (2012) Indonesia’s moratorium on new forest concessions: key findings and next steps. World Resources Institute Working Paper. WRI, Washington DC

[7] Barber CV, Brown D, Matthews E, Brown TH, Curran L, Plume C (2002) State of the forest: Indonesia. Global Forest Watch and Forest Watch Indonesia. http://agris.fao.org/agris-search/search.do?recordID=GB2013202341

[8] Barr C (2001) Banking on sustainability: structural adjustment and forestry reform in post-Suharto Indonesia. WWF Macroeconomics Program Office Washington, DC. http://www.cifor.org/publications/pdf_files/books/profits.pdf

[9] Barr CM, Resosudarmo IAP, Dermawan A, McCarthy J, Moeliono M, Setiono B (Eds.) (2006) Decentralization of Forest Administration in Indonesia: implications for forest sustainability, economic development, and community livelihoods. CIFOR. http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=-bh1QmnPD_cC&oi=fnd&pg=PR5&dq=forest+concessions+sanctions+indonesia&ots=RnJsm167lp&sig=FnoVU9WCjYyrMZKqMGvlZATj7Eg

[10] Barr C, Dermawan A, Purnomo H, Komarudin H (2010) Financial governance and Indonesia’s Reforestation Fund during the Soeharto and post-Soeharto periods, 1989–2009: a political economic analysis of lessons for REDD+ (vol 52). CIFOR. http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=BaMf9LI-DSQC&oi=fnd&pg=PR5&dq=Financial+governance+and+Indonesia%E2%80%99s+Reforestation+Fund+during+the+Soeharto+and+post-Soeharto+periods,+1989%E2%80%932009&ots=8irvhYJQ0P&sig=EYxpA47hFSDSRmajR6huT0-aYXs

[11] Brockhaus M, Obidzinski K, Dermawan A, Laumonier Y, Luttrell C (2012) An overview of forest and land allocation policies in Indonesia: Is the current framework sufficient to meet the needs of REDD+? Forest Policy and Economics, 18, 30–37. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.forpol.2011.09.004

[12] Butt S. Anti-corruption reform in Indonesia: an obituary?. Bull Indones Econ Stud, 2011, 47(3): 381-394

[13] Cahyat A (2014) Export tax on coal for energy security, safety. Jakarta Post

[14] Carlson KM, Curran LM, Asner GP, Pittman AM, Trigg SN, Adeney JM. Carbon emissions from forest conversion by Kalimantan oil palm plantations. Nat Clim Change, 2013, 3(3): 283-287

[15] Center for Forestry Planning and Statistics, MoF (Ministry of Forestry) (2009) Indonesia Forestry Outlook Study (No. APFSOS II/WP/2009/13). Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific

[16] Contreras-Hermosilla A, Fay C, Effendi E, Forest Trends (2005) Strengthening forest management in Indonesia through land tenure reform: issues and framework for action. Forest Trends Washington, DC. http://www.worldagroforestrycentre.org/WCA2009/regions/southeast_asia/publications?do=view_pub_detail&pub_no=BK0092-05

[17] Cronin T, Santoso L (2010) REDD+ politics in the media: a case study from Indonesia. CIFOR Working Paper, (49). http://www.cabdirect.org/abstracts/20113382355.html

[18] Curran LM, Trigg SN, McDonald AK, Astiani D, Hardiono YM, Siregar P Lowland forest loss in protected areas of Indonesian Borneo. Science, 2004, 303(5660): 1000-1003

[19] de Sassi C, Joseph S, Bos AB, Duchelle AE, Ravikumar A, Herold M. Towards integrated monitoring of REDD+. Curr Opin Environ Sustain, 2015, 14: 93-100

[20] Dermawan A, Petkova E, Sinaga AC, Muhajir M, Indriatmoko Y (2011) Preventing the risks of corruption in REDD+ in Indonesia. CIFOR. http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=K2czHGS_iIcC&oi=fnd&pg=PR3&dq=Preventing+the+risks+of+corruption+in+REDD%2B+in+Indonesia&ots=1Sjq_KqXFo&sig=CG1dah9GI11-bOXRT_p2A-2cFsI

[21] Djajono A, Siswanty L (eds) (2011) Forest management unit development—concept, legislation and implementation. Directorate of area management and preparation of forest area utilisation

[22] Eilenberg M (2012) At the edges of states: Dynamics of state formation in the Indonesian borderlands. KITLV Press. http://www.kitlv.nl/book/show/1319

[23] Ekadinata A, van Noordwijk M, Dewi S, Minang PA (2010) Reducing emissions from deforestation, inside and outside the “forest.” ASB PolicyBrief, 16. http://www.worldagroforestrycentre.org/wca2009/regions/southeast_asia/publications?do=view_pub_detail&pub_no=PB0010-10

[24] FAO H (2006) Global forest resources assessment 2005. FAO Forestry Paper, 147

[25] Faure M, Wibisana A (2013) Regulating disasters, climate change and environmental harm. Edward Elgar Publishing. http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=xQsCAQAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR1&dq=Regulating+Disasters,+Climate+Change+and+Environmental+Harm&ots=0lIxr2YL9v&sig=Z4HACb6BaUE_Qp110icsXmu49KU

[26] Fitzherbert EB, Struebig MJ, Morel A, Danielsen F, Brühl CA, Donald PF, Phalan B. How will oil palm expansion affect biodiversity?. Trends Ecol Evol, 2008, 23(10): 538-545

[27] Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (2012) Forest management and climate change: a literature review (No. Paper 10). Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations

[28] Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (UN FAO) (2015) Forest resources assessment working paper: terms and definitions (Forest resources assessment working paper no. 180), Rome

[29] Government of Indonesia (2012) Forest investment program Indonesia forest investment plan. http://forestclimatecenter.org/files/2012-09-26%20Forest%20Investment%20Program%20-%20Indonesia%20Forest%20Investment%20Plan.pdf

[30] Government of Norway, Government of Indonesia (2010) Fact sheet Norway–Indonesia partnership REDD+. http://www.norway.or.id/PageFiles/404362/FactSheetIndonesiaGHGEmissionMay252010.pdf

[31] Gregersen H, El Lakany H, Bailey L, White A. The greener side of REDD+: lessons for REDD+ from countries where forest area is increasing, 2011 Washington DC Rights and Resources Initiative

[32] Hansen MC, Stehman SV, Potapov PV, Arunarwati B, Stolle F, Pittman K. Quantifying changes in the rates of forest clearing in Indonesia from 1990 to 2005 using remotely sensed data sets. Environ Res Lett, 2009, 4: 34001

[33] Hansen MC, Potapov PV, Moore R, Hancher M, Turubanova SA, Tyukavina A, Loveland TR. High-resolution global maps of 21st-century forest cover change. Science, 2013, 342(6160): 850-853

[34] Harris N, Minnemeyer S, Sizer N, Mann S, Payne O (2015a) With latest fires crisis, Indonesia surpasses Russia as world’s fourth-largest emitter | World Resources Institute. World Resources Institute. http://www.wri.org/blog/2015/10/latest-fires-crisis-indonesia-surpasses-russia-world%E2%80%99s-fourth-largest-emitter

[35] Harris N, Minnemeyer S, Stolle F, Payne O (2015) Indonesia’s fire outbreaks producing more daily emissions than entire US economy | World Resources Institute. World Resources Institute. http://www.wri.org/blog/2015/10/indonesia%E2%80%99s-fire-outbreaks-producing-more-daily-emissions-entire-us-economy

[36] Hoffman D (2014) Harapan rainforest. Retrieved 24 Jan 2014, from http://www.rspb.org.uk/supporting/campaigns/rainforests/indonesia.aspx

[37] Human Rights Watch (HRW) (2013) The dark side of green growth the human rights impacts of weak governance in Indonesia’s forestry sector. Human Rights Watch

[38] Indonesia Ministry of Forestry (2014a) Forest Area Statistics 2013. Jakarta: Indonesia Ministry of Forestry. http://www.dephut.go.id/uploads/files/2fba7c7da8536e31671e3bb84f141195.pdf

[39] Indonesia Ministry of Forestry (2014b) Ministry of Forestry Statistics 2013. Jakarta: Indonesia Ministry of Forestry. http://www.dephut.go.id/uploads/files/2fba7c7da8536e31671e3bb84f141195.pdf

[40] Indrarto GB, Murharjanti P, Khatarina J, Pulungan I, Ivalerina F, Justitia R et al. (2012) The context of REDD+ in Indonesia: drivers, agents and institutions. http://forestclimatecenter.org/files/2012-08-09%20The%20Context%20of%20REDD+%20in%20Indonesia.pdf

[41] Ipcc A. Climate change 2014: synthesis report, 2014 Switzerland IPCC Geneva

[42] Kissinger G, Herold M, De Sy V (2012) Drivers of deforestation and forest degradation: a synthesis report for REDD+ policymakers. Vancouver: Lexeme Consulting. http://www.era-mx.org/biblio/Drivers%20of%20deforestation%20and%20forest%20degradation.pdf

[43] Larson AM, Brockhaus M, Sunderlin WD, Duchelle A, Babon A, Dokken T et al. (2013). Land tenure and REDD+: the good, the bad and the ugly. Glob Environ Change. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.02.014

[44] Margono BA, Turubanova S, Zhuravleva I, Potapov P, Tyukavina A, Baccini A Mapping and monitoring deforestation and forest degradation in Sumatra (Indonesia) using Landsat time series data sets from 1990 to 2010. Environ Res Lett, 2012, 7(3): 34010

[45] Margono BA, Potapov PV, Turubanova S, Stolle F, Hansen MC (2014) Primary forest cover loss in Indonesia over 2000–2012. Nat Clim Change. http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/nclimate2277.html?utm_source=Daily+Carbon+Briefing&utm_campaign=1f7e4f67b5-DAILY_BRIEFING&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_876aab4fd7-1f7e4f67b5-303421281

[46] McCarthy J. The changing regime: forest property and reformasi in Indonesia. Dev Change, 2000, 31(1): 91-129

[47] McCarthy J. Changing to gray: decentralization and the emergence of volatile socio-legal configurations in central Kalimantan, Indonesia. World Dev, 2004, 32(7): 1199-1223

[48] McFarland W, Whitley S, Kissinger G (2015) Subsidies to key commodities driving forest loss: Implications for private climate finance. Overseas Development Institute

[49] Murdiyarso D, Dewi S, Lawrence D, Seymour F (2011) Indonesia’s forest moratorium: a stepping stone to better forest governance? CIFOR. http://www.google.com/books?hl=id&lr=&id=tK4i9uUZz10C&oi=fnd&pg=PP5&dq=daemeter+moratorium&ots=zmxP6Fq_tR&sig=1SpYHsMAFRpw1YMuSs–dWt2854

[50] Natahadibrata N (2013) Government recognizes customary forests. The Jakarta Post. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2013/05/18/government-recognizes-customary-forests.html

[51] Neef A, Sirisupluxana P, Wirth T, Sangkapitux C, Heidhues F, Thu DC, Ganjanapan A (2007) 6.2 resource tenure and sustainable land management—case studies from northern Vietnam and northern Thailand. In: Sustainable land use in mountainous regions of Southeast Asia: meeting the challenges of ecological, socio-economic and cultural diversity, p 317

[52] Parlina I (2015) RI-Norway agree to continue REDD+. The Jakarta Post. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2015/04/15/ri-norway-agree-continue-redd.html

[53] Purnomo H, Suyamto D, Abdullah L, Irawati RH. REDD+ actor analysis and political mapping: an Indonesian case study. Int For Rev, 2012, 14(1): 74-89

[54] Resosudarmo IAP, Atmadja S, Ekaputri AD, Intarini DY, Indriatmoko Y, Astri P. Does tenure security lead to REDD+ project effectiveness? Reflections from five emerging sites in Indonesia. World Dev, 2014, 55: 68-83

[55] Roswintiarti O, Tjahyaningsih A, Furby S, Wallace JM et al. (2013) Indonesia’s national carbon accounting remote sensing program—A national system for monitoring forest changes. In Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium (IGARSS), 2013 IEEE International (pp. 3930–3933). IEEE. http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpls/abs_all.jsp?arnumber=6723692

[56] Samadhi N (2013) Indonesia ONE MAP: Assuring Better Delivery of National Development Goals Monetizing Geospatial Value and Practices For National Developmental GoalsSamadhi. Presented at the Geospatial World Forum 2013, Rotterdam

[57] Santosa MA, Khatarina J, Suwana AS (2013) The progress on governing REDD+ in Indonesia. International Journal of Rural Law and Policy. http://epress.lib.uts.edu.au/journals/index.php/ijrlp/article/view/3356

[58] Schuette SA. Against the odds: anti-corruption reform in Indonesia. Public Adm Dev, 2012, 32(1): 38-48

[59] Simamora AP (2011) SBY vows to protect palm oil interests. The Jakarta Post. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2011/03/26/sby-vows-protect-palm-oil-interests.html

[60] Smith J, Obidzinski K, Subarudi S, Suramenggala I. Illegal logging, collusive corruption and fragmented governments in Kalimantan, Indonesia. Int For Rev, 2003, 5(3): 293-302

[61] Steni B, Hadad N (2012) REDD+ safeguards in Indonesia. Bank Information Center, World Resources Institute, HUMA

[62] Stevens C, Winterbottom R, Springer J, Reytar K. Securing rights, combating climate change: how strengthening community forest rights mitigates climate change, 2014 Washington, DC World Resources Institute

[63] Susilo Bambank Yudhoyono H (2013) Translation of presidential of the republic of Indonesia instruction number 6 year 2013 on suspension new licenses and improving forest governance of primary forest and peatland. Daemeter Consulting

[64] Suwarno A, Hein L, Sumarga E Governance, Decentralisation and Deforestation: the case of Central Kalimantan Province, Indonesia. Q J Int Agric, 2015, 54(1): 77-100

[65] Tacconi L (2003) Forest fire in Indonesia: cause, cost, policy implication. CIFOR Occasional Paper, (38)

[66] The Indonesian Civil Society Coalitions for Forest Protection and Global Climate (ICSCFPGC) (2012) Towards a performance-based moratorium: one year reflection on moratorium policy and indonesian civil society recommendations for strengthening and extending the deforestation moratorium, Jakarta

[67] Transparency International (2011) Forest Governance Integrity Report Indonesia. Indonesia: Transperancy International. http://www.ti.or.id/media/documents/2011/11/23/f/a/faaa1-report_indonesia_final_rev.pdf

[68] UN REDD Programme (2015) UN-REDD Programme—About REDD+. Retrieved 5 Jan 2015, from http://www.un-redd.org/aboutredd/tabid/102614/default.aspx

[69] Unit Kerja Presiden Bidang Pengawasan Dan Pengendalian Pembangunan (UKP4) (2012) One Map Indonesia. Presented at the One Map Midway Workshop 2012, Jakarta

[70] United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) (2010) National greenhouse gas inventory data for the period 1990–2008. Retrieved 16 Feb 2011, from http://unfccc.int/documentation/documents/advanced_search/items/3594.php?rec=j&priref=600006019#beg

[71] United Nations Office for REDD+ Coordination in Indonesia (2013) Presented at the national workshop on the forestry law: constitutional court ruling No. 35/PUU-X/2012, Jakarta

[72] USAID (2010) USAID Country Profile: Property Rights and Resource Governance Indonesia

[73] Van der Werf GR, Morton DC, DeFries RS, Olivier JG, Kasibhatla PS, Jackson RB CO₂ emissions from forest loss. Nat Geosci, 2009, 2(11): 737-738

[74] Vernaz F (2015) Weakening of the KPK: Corruptors’€™ fight-back manual—The Jakarta Post. The Jakarta Post. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2015/01/27/weakening-kpk-corruptors-fight-back-manual.html

[75] Wadley RL, Eilenberg M. Autonomy, identity, and “illegal” logging in the borderland of West Kalimantan, Indonesia. Asia Pac J Anthropol, 2005, 6(1): 19-34

[76] Wells P, Paoli G (2011) An analysis of Presidential Instruction No. 10, 2011: moratorium on granting of new licences and improvement of natural primary forest and peatland governance. Daemeter Consulting

[77] Wells P, Paoli G (2011) Preliminary Observations on the Indonesian Ministry of Forestry Decree SK.323/Menhut-II/2011 and Indicative Maps Concerning the Suspension of New Licenses for Forest and Peatland Utilisation. Daemeter Consulting

[78] Wells P, Franklin N, Paoli G (2011) Preliminary observations on the Indonesian ministry of forestry decree SK.7416/Menhut-VII/IPSDH/2011: The first revision of the indicative maps concerning the suspension of new licenses for forest and peatland utilisation (Daemeter Briefs on the Indonesian Moratorium No. 3)

[79] Wells P, Franklin N, Gunarso P, Paoli G, Mafira T, Kusumo DR, Clanchy B (2012) Indonesian constitutional court ruling number 45/PUU-IX/2011 in relation to Forest Lands: Implications for Forests, Development and REDD+. Daemeter Consulting

[80] World Resources Institute Global Forest Watch (WRI GFW) (2016) Indonesia | Global Forest Watch. http://www.globalforestwatch.org/country/IDN

[81] World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) (2013) Palming Off a National Park: Tracking Illegal Oil Palm Fruit in Riau, Sumatra. http://awsassets.wwf.or.id/downloads/wwf_indonesia_palming_off_a_national_park_final.pdf

[82] Yuliani L, Indriatmoko Y, Salim A, Farid IZ, Muhajir M, Prasetyo LB, Heri V (2010) Biofuel policies and their impact on local people and biodiversity: a case study from Danau Sentarum. https://mahider.ilri.org/handle/10568/20773

Funding

Fulbright U.S. Student Program

University of Maryland Dean's Dissertation Fellowship