Contributions of urban productive safety net program to enhancing food security and livelihood diversification: an in-depth analysis of household-Level perceptions among urban populations in Ethiopia

Abstract

The Urban Productive Safety Net Program is one of Africa’s most ambitious social protection initiatives, and it has achieved measurable successes. However, existing literature focusing on the role of programs in improving people’s lives, especially in ensuring food security and income diversification, gives more focus to rural areas and depends on data from individuals beyond those directly targeted by the program. Hence, this study examines beneficiaries’ perceptions of the program’s contribution to food security and livelihood diversification in the South Ethiopia Regional State. The study used a mixed research approach that included a questionnaire, interviews, observation, and focus group discussions. To select 310 survey household heads, a multistage sampling procedure was employed. We analyzed the quantitative data using SPSS version 27, while the qualitative data was analyzed through narration and summarization. The findings indicate that the selection process for beneficiaries, activities performed by public work groups, and beneficiaries graduating with reliable sources of income are generally positive, whereas negative assumptions exist regarding the adequacy and timeliness of cash transfers and the overall living status of residents. Therefore, the program managers and zonal-level team leaders should collaborate closely to directly engage with beneficiaries, monitor the support system, and raise awareness.

Keywords

Household-level perceptions / Livelihood diversification / Southern Ethiopia / Urban food security / UPSNP

References

[1] Ababa, A. (2023). Ethiopia wheat value chain development project (EWVCDP) environmental and social impact assessment study report–oromia region. ZG environment consultancy. https://www.afdb.org/sites/default/files/ewvcdp_esia_report_-_afar_region.pdf

[2] Abate, M. (2018). The Contribution of Urban Productive Safety Net Program to Households‟ Livelihood Improvement and Environmental Protection in Addis Ababa: Case Study of Addis Ketema and Arada Sub Cities. Ethiopia (Doctoral dissertation, MA Thesis, Addis Ababa University).

[3] Abay KA, Abay MH, Berhane G, Chamberlin J. Social protection and resilience: The case of the productive safety net program in Ethiopia. Food Policy, 2022, 112: 102367

[4] Abdelwahid, H. A., Dahlan, H. M., Mojemamy, G. M., Al-Harbi, T. J., Indarkiri, N. Y., & Tourkmani, A. M. (2024). Developing and standardizing a tool to assess the health education needs of diabetic patients at Jazan armed forces hospital. Journal of Health Education Research & Development

[5] Abdulahi Mohamed A. Impact of Ethiopia’s Productive Safety Net Programme (PSNP) on the household livelihood: The case of Babile District in Somali Regional State, Ethiopia. International Journal of Economy Energy and Environment, 2017, 2(2): 25

[6] Abduselam A. The effects of urban productive safety net program on household food security in Gulele Sub-city, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Ethiopian Journal of Development Research, 2023, 45(1): 89-112

[7] Adnan S, Michael P, Benson AC, Xiao J. Junior and senior students possess differential preferences towards multimodal digital anatomy resources. Clinical Anatomy, 2024

[8] Amoo, T., & Friedman, H. H. (2001). Do numeric values influence subjects’ responses to rating scales? Journal of International Marketing and Marketing Research, 26, 41–46. Available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=2423064.

[9] Amosha K, Abi M. The effects of Urban Productive Safety Net Program on Household Food Security Status in Gulele Sub-city, Addis Ababa. Ethiopian Journal of Development Research, 2023, 45(1): 87-112

[10] Andrade C. The P value and statistical significance: Misunderstandings, explanations, challenges, and Alternatives. Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine, 2019, 41(3): 210-215

[11] Archambault A, Venet M. Le développement De l’imagination selon Piaget et Vygotsky: D’un Acte spontané à une activité consciente. Revue Des Sciences De L’éducation, 2007, 33(1): 5-24

[12] Bahru BA, Jebena MG, Birner R, Zeller M. Impact of Ethiopia’s productive safety net program on household food security and child nutrition: A marginal structural modeling approach. SSM - Population Health, 2020, 12: 100660

[13] Balta A. Determinants of rural household food security in Wolaita Zone, South Ethiopia. Journal of Poverty Investment and Development, 2016, 29: 1-9

[14] Banks AR, Bell BA, Ngendahimana D, Embaye M, Freedman DA, Chisolm DJ. Identification of factors related to food insecurity and the implications for social determinants of health screenings. Bmc Public Health, 2021

[15] Bekele, W. (2011). A study on the contribution of productive safety net and family package programme of SNNPR state in ensuring food security. Retrieved from http://repository.smuc.edu.et/bitstream/123456789/1163/1/WUBINESH%20BEKELE.pdf

[16] Belli, P., Bodewig, C., Chase, R. S., & Raju, D. (2024). Seizing the crisis moment: Advancing social protection in Africa. https://blogs.worldbank.org/en/africacan/seizing-crisis-moment-advancing-social-protection-africa

[17] Beshay, & Beshay (2024). 2. Assessing the accuracy of estimates among demographic subgroups. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/methods/2023/09/07/assessing-the-accuracy-of-estimates-amongdemographic-subgroups/

[18] Borku AW, Utallo AU, Tora TT. The level of food insecurity among urban households in southern Ethiopia: A multi-index-based assessment. J Agriculture Food Res, 2024, 15: 101019

[19] Borku AW, Utallo AU, Tora TT. Determinants of urban households in the diversification of livelihood activities: The case of Wolaita zone in southern Ethiopia. Journal of Agriculture and Food Research, 2024, 16: 101193

[20] Borku AW, Utallo AU, Tora TT. Determinants of urban household vulnerability to food insecurity in southern Ethiopia. Discover Food, 2024, 4(1): 37

[21] Capacity Development. (n.d). Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations | Social Protection | Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. https://www.fao.org/social-protection/what-we-do/capacity-development/en/

[22] Cetin HK, Koramaz I, Zengin M, Demir T. The evaluation of YouTubeTM English videos’ quality about coronary artery bypass grafting. SiSli Etfal Hastanesi Tip Bulteni / the Medical Bulletin of Sisli Hospital, 2022

[23] Croasmun, J. T., & Ostrom, L. (2011). Using Likert-type scales in the social sciences. Journal of Adult Education, 40(1), 19–22. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ961998

[24] Dejene, M. (2019). Social protection policies, institutions and food insecurity in Ethiopia. Unpublished PhD thesis, Hawassa University, Hawassa.

[25] Demeke, E. (2016). The effectiveness of Productive Saftey Net Program among Food Insecured Rural households in some selected Kebeles of Ebinat Woreda, South Gondar Zone. Social Science Research Network. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2860641

[26] Demissie, S. (2024). Starvation looms as Ethiopia’s social safety net programme faces funding gap. The New Humanitarian. https://www.thenewhumanitarian.org/news-feature/2024/03/28/starvation-looms-ethiopias-social-safety-net-programme-faces-funding-gap

[27] Derso A, Bizuneh H, Keleb A, Ademas A, Adane M. Food insecurity status and determinants among urban productive safety net program beneficiary households in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. PloS One, 2021

[28] Development Pathways (2023). Universal social security can reduce poverty and inequality: new collaboration with Human Rights Watch. Development Pathways https://www.developmentpathways.co.uk/news/universal-social-security-can-reduce-poverty-and-inequality-human-rights-watch/

[29] Devereux S. Social protection for enhanced food security in sub-saharan Africa. Food Policy, 2016, 60: 52-62

[30] Devereux, S., & Teshome, A. (2013). From safety nets to social protection: Options for direct support beneficiaries. Food Security Safety nets and Social Protection in Ethiopia, 67.

[31] Devereux S, White P. Social Protection in Africa: Evidence, politics and rights. Poverty & Public Policy, 2010, 2(3): 53-77

[32] Dolnicar S, Grün B. Cross-cultural differences in survey response patterns. International Marketing Review, 2007, 24(2): 127-143

[33] Fenta, A. (2023). Urban productive safety net program: its impacts on food security and job creation: The case of woreda 4, Lideta sub-city, Addis Abeba. www.academia.edu. https://www.academia.edu/103521875/Urban_productive_safety_net_program_its_impacts_on_food_security_and_job_creation_The_case_of_woreda_4_Lideta_sub_city_Addis_Abeba?uc-sb-sw=36260817

[34] Filipski, Mateusz, J. E., Taylor, G. A., Abegaz, T., Ferede, A. S., & Taffesse (2017). and Xinshen Diao. General Equilibrium Impact Assessment of the Productive Safety Net Program in Ethiopia. New Delhi: International Initiative for Impact Evaluation (3ie).

[35] Gazeaud J. Proxy Means Testing vulnerability to measurement errors?. The Journal of Development Studies, 2020, 56(11): 2113-2133

[36] Gelagay, M. D. (2016). The impact of Productive Safety Net Program (PSNP) on economic empowerment of women: The case of North-East of Ethiopia [Master's dissertation, University of Antwerp]. Institute of development policy and management. https://medialibrary.uantwerpen.be/oldcontent/container2143/files/goingglobal/dissertations/megosdesalegne_gelagay_s_ua_N0035000_3.pdf

[37] Gentilini, U. (2024). What do we know (and what not) about safety nets in urban areas? https://blogs.worldbank.org/en/developmenttalk/what-do-we-know-and-what-not-about-safety-nets-urban-areas

[38] Gebresilassie, Y. H. (2020). Ethiopia's Urban productive safety net programme: its impact on households' food insecurity. African economic conference. https://aec.afdb.org/en/papers/ethiopias-urban-productive-safety-net-programme-its-impact-households-food-insecurity-410

[39] Gilligan, D. O., Hoddinott, J., Kumar, N., & Taffesse, A. S. (2009). Can social protection work in Africa? evidence on the impact of Ethiopia’s productive safety net program on food security, assets and incentives. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1457172

[40] Habtamu Ayele. (2023). Contributions of urban productive safety net program public work to household food security: A case of woreda 1 Jemo, Nefas Silk Lafto Addis Ababa. Retrieved from https://etd.aau.edu.et/items/81ddf5fe-6f52-4fcb-9ba3-70e98a923bf7

[41] Haider MZ, Mahamud A. Beneficiary selection and allowance utilization of social safety net programme in Bangladesh. Journal of Human Rights and Social Work, 2017, 2(1–2): 45-51

[42] Hailu AG, Amare ZY. Impact of productive safety net program on food security of beneficiary households in western Ethiopia: A matching estimator approach. PLoS One, 2022, 17(1): e0260817

[43] Hair JF Jr, Gabriel LDS, Silva M, Junior B. Development and validation of attitudes measurement scales: Fundamental and practical aspects. RAUSP Management Journal, 2019, 54(4): 490-507

[44] Hamed T. What Is the Best Response Scale for Survey and Questionnaire Design; Review of Different Lengths of Rating Scale / Attitude, Scale / Likert Scale. International Journal of Academic Research in Management, 2019, 8(1): 1-10

[45] Hoddinott, J., & Doruska, M. (2021). What works to reduce extreme poverty? A selective review. https://doi.org/10.55158/deepwpa1

[46] Hoddinott J, Gillespie S, Yosef S. Public-private partnerships and undernutrition: Examples and future prospects. Hidden Hunger, 2016, 115: 233-238

[47] IDS (n.d.). Ethiopia’s Productive Safety Net Programme (PSNP). Retrieved from https://www.ids.ac.uk/download.php?file=files%2FPSNPEthiopia.pdf

[48] International Labour Organization (2024). Social Protection for Sustainable Development. Retrieved by https://www.social-protection.org/gimi/WSPDB.action?id=42

[49] Jamieson S. Likert scales: How to (ab)use them. Medical Education, 2004, 38(12): 1212-1218

[50] Juergens, F., Galvani, F., HelpAge, I., & Aboma, G. (2019). Coverage of older people in Ethiopia’s social protection system. HelpAge International. https://socialprotection.org/sites/default/files/publications_files/Coverage%20of%20older%20people%20in%20Ethiopia%E2%80%99s%20social%20protection%20system.pdf

[51] Kassaw K, Worku M. The contribution of productive safety net program for households’ food security and asset building in drought prone woredas of northeast Ethiopia. Heliyon, 2024, 10(3): e25092

[52] Kebu H, Berisso O, Mulugeta M. Drivers of migration and determinants of wellbeing among internal youth migrants in Ethiopia: Towns along Addis Ababa-Adama route in focus. Heliyon, 2023, 9(3): e13780

[53] Khan Y, Daraz U, Bojnec T. Enhancing food security and nutrition through social safety nets: a pathway to sustainable development. Sustainability, 2023, 15(19): 14347

[54] Kostoulas, A. (2023). Mid-points, central tendencies and statistical significance in Likert scales. Achilleas Kostoulas. https://achilleaskostoulas.com/2013/11/19/likert-scales-central-tendency-statistical-significance/

[55] Latif, S. (2024). What Is Cognitive Development? 3 Psychology Theories. PositivePsychology.com. https://positivepsychology.com/cognitive-development/

[56] Lee J, Paek I. In search of the optimal number of response categories in a rating scale. Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment, 2014, 32(7): 663-673

[57] Lemma MD, Cochrane L. Social Protection implementation issues in Ethiopia: Client households’ perceived enablers and constrainers of the Productive Safety Net Program. Societies, 2020, 10(3): 69

[58] Leung SO. A comparison of psychometric properties and normality in 4-, 5-, 6-, and 11-point likert scales. Journal of Social Service Research, 2011, 37(4): 412-421

[59] Likert, R. (1932). A technique for the measurement of attitudes. Archives of Psychology, 22(140), 1–55

[60] Lyall K. What are quantitative traits and how can they be used in autism research?. Autism Research, 2023, 16(7): 1289-1298

[61] Maier, P. (2014). Food security in Ethiopia: the case of the productive safety net programme [Master's thesis, University of Vienna]. Retrieved from http://othes.univie.ac.at/32033/1/2014-03-19_0867554.pdf

[62] Melkegnaw, E., & Teshome, M. (2017). Beneficiaries' attitude towards productive safety net program in selected rural kebeles of Ebinat woreda, northwest Ethiopia. Ethiopian Renaissance Journal of Social Sciences and the Humanities, 4(2). https://www.ajol.info/index.php/erjssh

[63] Ministry of Agriculture (MoA). (2014). Productive safety net program phase 4 implementation manual version 1.0. Addis Ababa: Government of Ethiopia. https://2017-2020.usaid.gov/sites/default/files/documents/1866/psnp_iv_programme_implementation_manual_14_dec_14.pdf

[64] MoEUDH Urban Productive Safety Net Program, 2016 Implementation. Manual Addis Ababa Ethiopia

[65] Mume AA, Demissie ST, Kitila AW. Productive Safety Net Program and Its Impact on the Livelihood of Rural Households in Doba District, Ethiopia, 2022 Research Square

[66] Mustafa Muhammed N, Fetene Asfaw F, Adem Endris E, Bojago E. Evaluating the impact of productive safety net program on rural household food security achievement: Endogenous switching regression modeling approach. Journal of Agriculture and Food Research, 2023, 14: 100674

[67] Niño-Zarazúa M, Barrientos A, Hickey S, Hulme D. Social Protection in Sub-saharan Africa: Getting the Politics Right. World Development, 2011, 40(1): 163-176

[68] OECD (2020). Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. Retrieved from https://one.oecd.org/document/DELSA/ELSA/WD/SEM%282020%298/En/pdf

[69] Olive OO, Aloysius OC, Beauty DA. Food Security and Poverty Status of Cassava Processors in Awka North Local Government Area of Anambra State of Nigeria. Bangladesh Journal of Agricultural Economics, 2020, 41(1): 116

[70] Outes-Leon, I., & Sanchez, A. (2008). An assessment of the Young Lives sampling approach in Ethiopia. Bangladesh Journal of Agricultural Economics https://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid%3A1cc6b2df-3bf4-4aa9-8abd-f65d9cc1665d

[71] Rahman, A., & Pingali, P. (2024). Development Resilience as the Scope of Social Protection. In Palgrave studies in agricultural economics and food policy (pp. 25–56). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-50747-2_2

[72] Rully C, Benidiktus T, Jeinne M. Likert Scale in Social Sciences Research: Problems and difficulties. FWU Journal of Social Sciences Winter 2022, 2022, 16(4): 89-101

[73] Rutstein (2000). Characteristics of Households and Household Members. DHS Program. Retrieved from https://dhsprogram.com/pubs/pdf/FR175/02Chapter02.pdf

[74] Security, G. F., & a., N. (2024). Impact of urban productive safety net programme on poverty reduction and food security: Evidence from major cities of Eastern Ethiopia (Dire Dawa, Harar and Jigjiga) | Knowledge for policy. https://knowledge4policy.ec.europa.eu/publication/impact-urban-productive-safety-net-programme-poverty-reduction-food-security-evidence_en

[75] Seekings J. The implementation of social protection in a conservative African welfare regime: The values and beliefs of local state officials in Botswana. Social Policy and Administration, 2023, 57(6): 946-960

[76] Simms LJ, Zelazny K, Williams TF, Bernstein L. Does the number of response options matter? Psychometric perspectives using personality questionnaire data. Psychological Assessment, 2019, 31(4): 557-566

[77] Solomon R, Simane B, Zaitchik BF. The impact of climate change on agriculture production in Ethiopia: application of a dynamic computable general equilibrium model. American Journal of Climate Change, 2021, 10(01): 32-50

[78] SP4SDG (2021). Joint UN Programme: Social Protection for the Sustainable Development Goals (SP4SDG) https://sdgs.un.org/partnerships/joint-un-programme-social-protection-sustainable-development-goals-sp4sdg

[79] Tadesse, T., & Gebremedhin Zeleke, T. (2022). The impact of the productive safety net program (PSNP) on food security and asset accumulation of rural households’: Evidence from Gedeo Zone, Southern Ethiopia. Cogent Economics & Finance, 10(1);2087285. https://doi.org/10.1080/23322039.2022.2087285

[80] Tesgera, W. D., Beyene, A. B., & Wakjira, T. K. (2024). Does non-farm employment increase rural households’ consumption in western Ethiopia? Empirical evidence from the horo guduru wollega zone. Heliyon. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.100308[1]

[81] The New Humanitarian (2024). As starvation looms, Ethiopia’s social safety net programme faces funding gap

[82] Tora TT. Production preference barriers and lowland-appropriate strategies of sustaining local food systems in drought-affected southern Ethiopia. Discover Sustainability, 2024, 5(1): 23

[83] Turner L, O’Reilly N, Ralston K, Guthrie JF. Identifying gaps in the food security safety net: The characteristics and availability of summer nutrition programmes in California, USA. Public Health Nutrition, 2019, 22(10): 1824-1838

[84] U. N. D. P. (2018). Ethiopia’s progress towards eradicating poverty: Implementation of the third united nations decade for the eradication of poverty (2018–2027) Discussion Paper. UnitedNationsDevelopmentProgram. https://www.un.org/development/desa/dspd/wp-content/uploads/sites/22/2018/04/Ethiopia%E2%80%99s-Progress-Towards-Eradicating-Poverty.pdf

[85] UPSNJP. (2022). Ethiopia urban productive safety net and jobs project stakeholder engagement plan updated for additional financing. Ethiopian Construction Authority. Retrieved from https://www.eca.gov.et/ova_doc/ethiopia-urban-productive/

[86] Van Eeuwijk P, Angehrn Z. How to Conduct a Focus Group Discussion (FGD), 2017 Methodological Manual

[87] Vasileva O, Balyasnikova N. (Re) Introducing Vygotsky’s thought: from historical overview to contemporary psychology. Frontiers in psychology, 2019, 10: 411651

[88] Ward B. Resolving the raven Paradox: Simple Random Sampling, Stratified Random Sampling, and inference to best explanation. Philosophy of Science, 2022, 89(2): 360-377

[89] Wassie, T. G. (2022). Analysis of livelihoods and food security of poor urban households: The case of urban productive safety-net beneficiaries in Ethiopia (Doctoral dissertation). University of South Africa.

[90] Welteji, D., Mohammed, K., & Hussein, K. (2017). The contribution of Productive Safety Net Program for food security of the rural households in the case of Bale Zone, Southeast Ethiopia. Agriculture & Food Security. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40066-017-0126-4

[91] Williams KL, Burt BA, Hilton AA. Math achievement: A role strain and adaptation approach. Journal for Multicultural Education, 2016, 10(3): 368-383

[92] Woldemichael MG, Alamirew Alemu B. Does productive safety net program enhance livelihoods? Insights from vulnerable households in Wolaita Zone, Ethiopia. PloS One, 2024, 19(4): e0297780

[93] Wondim AK. Impact of productive safety net program in rural community of Ethiopia: A review study. Journal of Agricultural Extension and Rural Development, 2018, 10(5): 84-88

[94] Wong, S. (2012). What have been the impacts of World Bank Community-Driven Development Programs? CDD impact evaluation review and operational and research implications. World Bank, Washington, DC, 7.

[95] World Bank (2017). A stepping stone to job creation

[96] World Bank (2021). Towards an Inclusive and Empowered Ethiopia: Improving Social Safety Nets to Reduce Urban Poverty. Available on, https://www.worldbank.org/en/results/2021/01/14/towards-an-inclusive-and-empowered-ethiopia-improving-social-safety-nets-to-reduce-urban-poverty

[97] World Food Programme (2024). Food insecurity a real concern among the urban poor in Sub-Saharan Africa following pandemic - new report shows. https://www.wfp.org/news/food-insecurity-real-concern-among-urban-poor-sub-saharan-africa-following-pandemic-new-report

[98] World Bank. (2022). Additional financing - The Urban Productive Safety Net and Jobs Project (P177654). https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099122023102033576/pdf/P1699431b343f00261b3301b9f31ebf4b81.pdf

[99] Wubetie, H. T., Zewotir, T., Mitku, A. A., & Dessie, Z. G. (2024). The spatial effects of the household’s food insecurity levels in Ethiopia: by ordinal geo-additive model. Frontiers in Nutrition, 11. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnut.2024.1330822

[100] WZFED. (2018). Annual statistical abstract. Wolaita zone finance and economic development department, Wolaita Sodo

[101] WZPC. (2023). Annual Abstract, Wolaita Zone plan commission, South Ethiopia

[102] Yamane T. Statistics: an introductory analysis, 1967 2 Harper and Row

[103] Yimere A, Assefa E. Current and future Irrigation Water requirement and potential in the Abbay River Basin, Ethiopia. Air Soil and Water Research, 2022, 15: 117862212210979

[104] Zegeye, K. (2020). The contributions of urban productive safety net project to households livelihood improvement: The case of Nefas Silk Lafto Sub City Addis Ababa [Doctoral dissertation, St. Mary's University]. St. Mary's University Institutional Repository. http://repository.smuc.edu.et/handle/123456789/5571