The influence mechanism of urban street environment on juvenile delinquency based on multi-source data fusion: a case study of Manhattan, New York

Abstract

Streets are an important component of urban public spaces and also a high-incidence area for urban crime. However, current research mainly involves adult crime, or fails to distinguish between adult and juvenile crime, which poses a severe challenge to the prevention of juvenile delinquency. Juveniles have lower self-control abilities and are more likely to be influenced by external environmental factors to trigger criminal behavior compared to adults. Therefore, this study uses New York’s Manhattan district as an example, based on CPTED and social disorganization theories, and utilizes street view data and deep learning techniques to extract street environment indicators. The GWR model is used to explore the influence mechanism of urban street environment on juvenile crime. The results of this study, considering spatial heterogeneity, demonstrate the impact of various physical environmental indicators of urban streets on juvenile delinquency, and reveal that some street indicators have differentiated effects on crime in different areas of the city. Overall, our research helps to uncover the relationship between juvenile delinquency and the built environment of streets in complex urban settings, providing important references for future urban street design and juvenile delinquency prevention.

References

[1] AgnewR. Foundation for a general strain theory of crime and delinquency. Criminology, 1992, 30(1): 47-88

[2] BiljeckiF, ItoK. Street view imagery in urban analytics and GIS: A review. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2021, 215: 104217

[3] BradshawCP, MilamAJ, Furr-HoldenCDM, Lindstrom JohnsonS. The School Assessment for Environmental Typology (SAfETy): An observational measure of the school environment. American Journal of Community Psychology, 2015, 56(3–4): 280-292

[4] BursikRJJr, WebbJ. Community change and patterns of delinquency. American Journal of Sociology, 1982, 88(1): 24-42

[5] DubeyA, NaikN, ParikhD, RaskarR, HidalgoCA. LeibeB, MatasJ, SebeN, WellingM. Deep learning the city: Quantifying urban perception at a global scale. Computer vision – ECCV 2016. Lecture notes in computer science, 2016Springer,196-212

[6] HanY, LiuL, XiaoL. Investigating the effect of people on the street and streetscape physical environment on the location choice of street theft crime offenders using street view images and a discrete spatial choice model. Applied Geography, 2023, 157: 103025

[7] HeL, PáezA, JiaoJ, AnP, LuC, MaoW, LongD. Ambient population and larceny-theft: A spatial analysis using mobile phone data. ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information, 2020, 9(6): 342

[8] HeL, PáezA, LiuD. Built environment and violent crime: An environmental audit approach using Google Street View. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, 2017, 66: 83-95

[9] HeZ, WangZ, XieZ, WuL, ChenZ. Multiscale analysis of the influence of street built environment on crime occurrence using street-view images. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, 2022, 97: 101865

[10] Hedayati MarzbaliM, AbdullahA, IgnatiusJ, Maghsoodi TilakiMJ. Examining the effects of crime prevention through environmental design (CPTED) on residential burglary. International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice, 2016, 46: 86-102

[11] HippJR, LeeS, KiD, et al. . Measuring the built environment with google street view and machine learning: Consequences for crime on street segments. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 2022, 38: 537-565

[12] HirschiT. Causes of delinquency, 1969University of California Press

[13] JacobsJ. The death and life of great American cities, 1961Vintage

[14] JefferyC. Crime prevention through environmental design. American Behavioral Scientist, 1971, 14(4): 598-598

[15] KangHW, KangHB. Prediction of crime occurrence from multi-modal data using deep learning. PLoS One, 2017, 12(4): e0176244

[16] KimS, LeeS. Nonlinear relationships and interaction effects of an urban environment on crime incidence: Application of urban big data and an interpretable machine learning method. Sustainable Cities and Society, 2023, 91: 104419

[17] KimYA, HippJR. Density, diversity, and design: Three measures of the built environment and the spatial patterns of crime in street segments. Journal of Criminal Justice, 2021, 77: 101864

[18] KuenK, WeisburdD, WhiteC, HinkleJC. Examining impacts of street characteristics on residents' fear of crime: Evidence from a longitudinal study of crime hot spots. Journal of Criminal Justice, 2022, 82: 101984

[19] LamoreauxD, SulkowskiML. An alternative to fortified schools: Using crime prevention through environmental design (CPTED) to balance student safety and psychological well-being. Psychology in the Schools, 2020, 57(1): 152-165

[20] LawJ, AbdullahAYM. An offenders-offenses shared component spatial model for identifying shared and specific hotspots of offenders and offenses: A case study of juvenile delinquents and violent crimes in the greater toronto area. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 2024, 40: 75-98

[21] LemertE. Human deviance, social problems, and social control, 1972Prentice-Hall

[22] LinJ, WangQ, HuangB. Street trees and crime: What characteristics of trees and streetscapes matter. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening, 2021, 65: 127366

[23] LongD, LiuL. Do juvenile, young adult, and adult offenders target different places in the Chinese context?. Cities, 2022, 130: 103943

[24] LorencT, ClaytonS, NearyD, WhiteheadM, PetticrewM, ThomsonH, CumminsS, SowdenA, RentonA. Crime, fear of crime, environment, and mental health and wellbeing: Mapping review of theories and causal pathways. Health & Place, 2012, 18(4): 757-765

[25] LuQ. Research on the government's response strategies for juvenile delinquency prevention and intervention: A case study of the United States. China Youth Study, 2022, 12: 110-119+100

[26] LuoL, DengM, ShiY, GaoS, LiuB, LiuB. Associating street crime incidences with geographical environment in space using a zero-inflated negative binomial regression model. Cities, 2022, 129: 103834

[27] MihinjacM, SavilleG. Third-Generation Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED). Social Sciences, 2019, 8(6): 182

[28] NewmanO. Reactions to the “defensible space” study and some further findings. International Journal of Mental Health, 1975, 4(3): 48-70

[29] ProzumentovLM, RachkovaNM. Street crime: Definition, characteristics and prevention. Russian Journal of Criminology, 2013, 2: 22-27

[30] RevitalSS, HavivN. Juvenile delinquency and COVID-19: The effect of social distancing restrictions on juvenile crime rates in Israel. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 2023, 19: 785-808

[31] SanchezS. 1.12. Street crime, corporate crime, and white-collar crime. SOUCCJ230 introduction to the American criminal justice system, 2019

[32] ScheingoldSA. The politics of law and order: Street crime and public policy, 2011 Quid Pro Books

[33] SchuermanL, KobrinS. ReissAJJr, TonryM. Community careers in crime. Crime and justice: a review of research, 1986University of Chicago Press67-100

[34] ShawCR, McKayHD. Juvenile delinquency and urban areas, 1942University of Chicago Press

[35] SimõesM, MartinsJ, MonteiroAP, RelvaIC. Juvenile delinquency. Palgrave Macmillan, 2024

[36] SuN, LiW, QiuW. Measuring the associations between eye-level urban design quality and on-street crime density around New York subway entrances. Habitat International, 2023, 131: 102728

[37] SuT, SunM, FanZ, NoymanA, PentlandA, MoroE. Rhythm of the streets: A street classification framework based on street activity patterns. EPJ Data Science, 2022, 11: 43

[38] TruntsevskyYV, LukinyII, SumachevAV, KopytovaAV. A smart city is a safe city: The current status of street crime and its victim prevention using a digital application. MATEC Web of Conferences, 2018, 170: 01067

[39] WolfeMK, MennisJ. Does vegetation encourage or suppress urban crime? Evidence from Philadelphia, PA. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2012, 108(2–4): 112-122

[40] XiaoJ, ZhouX. Crime exposure along my way home: Estimating crime risk along personal trajectory by visual analytics. Geographical Analysis, 2020, 52(1): 49-68

[41] YaoY, DongA, LiuZ, JiangY, GuoZ, ChengJ, GuanQ, LuoP. Extracting the pickpocketing information implied in the built environment by treating it as the anomalies. Cities, 2023, 143: 104575

[42] YueH, XieH, LiuL, ChenJ. Detecting people on the street and the streetscape physical environment from Baidu street view images and their effects on community-level street crime in a Chinese City. ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information, 2022, 11(3): 151

[43] YunusA, LooJ. London street crime analysis and prediction using crowdsourced dataset. Journal of Computational Mathematics and Data Science, 2024, 10: 100089

[44] ZengM, MaoY, WangC. The relationship between street environment and street crime: a case study of Pudong New Area, Shanghai China. Cities, 2021, 112: 103143

[45] ZhangF, FanZ, KangY, HuY, RattiC. "Perception bias": Deciphering a mismatch between urban crime and perception of safety. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2021, 207: 104003

[46] ZhaoH, ShiJ, QiX, WangX, JiaJ. Pyramid scene parsing network. 2017 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), 20176230-6239

[47] ZhouH, LiuL, LanM, ZhuW, SongG, JingF, ZhongY, SuZ, GuX. Using google street view imagery to capture micro built environment characteristics in drug places, compared with street robbery. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, 2021, 88: 101631