Effect of combined low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation and virtual reality training on upper limb function in subacute stroke: a double-blind randomized controlled trail

Abstract

The effect of combined low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (LF rTMS) and virtual reality (VR) training in patients after stroke was assessed. In a double-blind randomized controlled trial, 112 patients with hemiplegia after stroke were randomly divided into two groups: experimental and control. In experimental group, the patients received LF rTMS and VR training treatment, and those in control group received sham rTMS and VR training treatment. Participants in both groups received therapy of 6 days per week for 4 weeks. The primary endpoint including the upper limb motor function test of Fugl-meyer assessment (U-FMA) and wolf motor function test (WMFT), and the secondary endpoint including modified Barthel index (MBI) and 36-item Short Form Health Survey Questionnaire (SF-36) were assessed before and 4 weeks after treatment. Totally, 108 subjects completed the study (55 in experimental group and 53 in control group respectively). After 4-week treatment, the U-FMA scores [mean difference of 13.2, 95% confidence interval (CI) 3.6 to 22.7, P<0.01], WMFT scores (mean difference of 2.9, 95% CI 2.7 to 12.3, P<0.01), and MBI scores (mean difference 16.1, 95% CI 3.8 to 9.4, P<0.05) were significantly increased in the experimental group as compared with the control group. The results suggested the combined use of LF rTMS with VR training could effectively improve the upper limb function, the living activity, and the quality of life in patients with hemiplegia following subacute stroke, which may provide a better rehabilitation treatment for subacute stroke.

Keywords

stroke / low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation / virtual reality training

References

[1] Nichols-LarsenDS, ClarkPC, ZeringueA, et al. . Factors influencing stroke survivors’ quality of life during subacute recovery. Stroke, 2005, 36(7): 1480-1484 PMID: 15947263

[2] BrunnerIC, SkouenJS, StrandLI. Recovery of upper extremity motor function post stroke with regard to eligibility for constraint-induced movement therapy. Top Stroke Rehabil, 2011, 18(3): 248-257 PMID: 21642062

[3] KwakkelG, KollenB. Predicting improvement in the upper paretic limb after stroke: a longitudinal prospective study. Restor Neurol Neurosci, 2007, 25(5–6): 453-460 PMID: 18334763

[4] PaquetteC, ThielA. Rehabilitation interventions for chronic motor deficits with repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation. J Neurosurg Sci, 2012, 56(4): 299-306 PMID: 23111290

[5] MasieroS, CeliaA, RosatiG, et al. . Robotic-assisted rehabilitation of the upper limb after acute stroke. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 2007, 88(2): 142-149 PMID: 17270510

[6] ChenJC, ShawFZ. Progress in sensorimotor rehabilitative physical therapy programs for stroke patients. World J Clin Cases, 2014, 2(8): 316-326 PMCID: 4133420 PMID: 25133141

[7] Doğan-AslanM, Nakipoğlu-YüzerGF, DoğanA, et al. . The effect of electromyographic biofeedback treatment in improving upper extremity functioning of patients with hemiplegic stroke. J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis, 2012, 21(3): 187-192 PMID: 20880720

[8] KapadiaNM, NagaiMK, ZivanovicV, et al. . Functional electrical stimulation therapy for recovery of reaching and grasping in severe chronic pediatric stroke patients. J Child Neurol, 2014, 29(4): 493-499 PMID: 23584687

[9] McIntyreA, VianaR, JanzenS, et al. . Systematic review and meta-analysis of constraint-induced movement therapy in the hemiparetic upper extremity more than six months post stroke. Top Stroke Rehabil, 2012, 19(6): 499-513 PMID: 23192715

[10] KwonJS, ParkMJ, YoonIJ, et al. . Effects of virtual reality on upper extremity function and activities of daily living performance in acute stroke: a double-blind randomized clinical trial. NeuroRehabilitation, 2012, 31(4): 379-385 PMID: 23232161

[11] JangSH. Motor function-related maladaptive plasticity in stroke: a review. NeuroRehabilitation, 2013, 32(2): 311-316 PMID: 23535793

[12] KakudaW, AboM, ShimizuM, et al. . A multi-center study on low-frequency rTMS combined with intensive occup ational therapy for upper limbhemiparesis in post-stroke patients. J Neuroeng Rehabil, 2012, 9(1): 4 PMCID: 3271959 PMID: 22264239

[13] Simonetta-MoreauM. Non-invasive brain stimulation (NIBS) and motor recovery after stroke. Ann Phys Rehabil Med, 2014, 57(8): 530-542 PMID: 25193774

[14] MállyJ. Non-invasive brain stimulation (rTMS and tDCS) in patients with aphasia: mode of action at the cellular level. Brain Res Bull, 2013, 98(9): 30-35 PMID: 23872450

[15] EdwardsonMA, LucasTH, CareyJR, et al. . New modalities of brain stimulation for stroke rehabilitation. Exp Brain Res, 2013, 224(3): 335-358 PMID: 23192336

[16] HsuWY, ChengCH, LiaoKK, et al. . Effects of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation on motor functions in patients with stroke: a meta-analysis. Stroke, 2012, 43(7): 1849-1857 PMID: 22713491

[17] KakudaW, AboM, KobayashiK, et al. . Application of combined 6-Hz primed low-frequency rTMS and intensive occupational therapy for upper limb hemiparesis after stroke. NeuroRehabilitation, 2011, 29(4): 365-371 PMID: 22207064

[18] BrunnerI, SkouenJS, HofstadH, et al. . Virtual reality training for upper extremity in subacute stroke (VIRTUES): study protocol for a randomized controlled multicenter trial. BMC Neurol, 2014, 14(1): 186 PMCID: 4180981 PMID: 25261187

[19] HendersonA, Korner-BitenskyN, LevinM. Virtual reality in stroke rehabilitation: a systematic review of its effectiveness for upper limb motor recovery. Top Stroke Rehabil, 2007, 14(2): 52-61 PMID: 17517575

[20] FernandesAB, PassosJO, BritoDP, et al. . Comparison of the immediate effect of the training with a virtual reality game in stroke patients according side brain injury. NeuroRehabilitation, 2014, 35(1): 39-45 PMID: 24990008

[21] SaposnikG, TeasellR, MamdaniM, et al. . Effectiveness of virtual reality using Wii gaming technology in stroke rehabilitation: a pilot randomized clinical trial and proof of principle. Stroke, 2010, 41(7): 1477-1484 PMID: 20508185

[22] WadeE, WinsteinCJ. Virtual reality and robotics for stroke rehabilitation: where do we go from here?. Top Stroke Rehabil, 2011, 18(6): 685-700 PMID: 22436307

[23] ProchnowD, Bermúdez i BadiaS, SchmidtJ, et al. . A functional magnetic resonance imaging study of visuomotor processing in a virtual reality-based paradigm: Rehabilitation Gaming System. Eur J Neurosci, 2013, 37(9): 1441-1447 PMID: 23414211

[24] SharmaN, SimmonsLH, JonesPS, et al. . Motor imagery after subcortical stroke: a functional magnetic resonance imaging study. Stroke, 2009, 40(4): 1315-1324 PMID: 19182071

[25] SeniówJ, BilikM, LeśniakM, et al. . Transcranial magnetic stimulation combined with physiotherapy in rehabilitation of poststroke hemiparesis: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Neurorehabil Neural Repair, 2012, 26(9): 1072-1079 PMID: 22588639

[26] da Silva CameirãoM, BermúdezI, BadiaS, DuarteE, et al. . Virtual reality based rehabilitation speeds up functional recovery of the upper extremities afterstroke: a randomized controlled pilot study in the acute phase of stroke using the rehabilitation gaming system. Restor Neurol Neurosci, 2011, 29(5): 287-298 PMID: 21697589

[27] Fugl-MeyerAR, JaaskoL, LeymanI, et al. . The post-stroke hemiplegic patient. 1. A method for evaluation of physical performance. Scand J Rehab Med, 1975, 7(1): 13-31

[28] MorrisDM, UswatteG, GragoJE, et al. . The reliability of the wolf motor function test for assessing upper extremity function after stroke. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 2001, 82(6): 750-755 PMID: 11387578

[29] ShahS, VanclayF, CooperB. Improving the sensitivity of the Barthel Index for stroke rehabilitation. J Clin Epidemiol, 1989, 42(8): 703-709 PMID: 2760661

[30] BergfeldtU, SköldC, JulinP. Short Form 36 assessed health-related quality of life after focal spasticity therapy. J Rehabil Med, 2009, 41(4): 279-281 PMID: 19247549

[31] BenningerDH, LomarevM, WassermannEM, et al. . Safety study of 50 Hz repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in patients with Parkinson’s disease. Clin Neurophysiol, 2009, 120(4): 809-815 PMCID: 2667907 PMID: 19285918

[32] LomarevMP, KimDY, RichardsonSP, et al. . Safety study of high-frequency transcranial magnetic stimulation in patients with chronic stroke. Clin Neurophysiol, 2007, 118(9): 2072-2075 PMID: 17652018

[33] EtohS1, NomaT, IkedaK, et al. . Effects of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation on repetitive facilitation exercises of the hemiplegic hand in chronic stroke patients. J Rehabil Med, 2013, 45(9): 843-847 PMID: 23817976

[34] SasakiN, MizutaniS, KakudaW, et al. . Comparison of the effects of high- and low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation on upper limb hemiparesis in the early phase of stroke. J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis, 2013, 22(4): 413-418 PMID: 22177936

[35] AvenantiA, CocciaM, LadavasE, et al. . Low-frequency rTMS promotes use-dependent motor plasticity in chronic stroke: a randomized trial. Neurology, 2012, 78(4): 256-264 PMID: 22238412

[36] GillickBT, KrachLE, FeymaT, et al. . Primed low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation and constraint-induced movement therapy in pediatric hemiparesis: a randomized controlled trial. Dev Med Child Neurol, 2014, 56(1): 44-52 PMID: 23962321

[37] TretriluxanaJ, KantakS, TretriluxanaS, et al. . Low frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation to the non-lesioned hemisphere improves paretic arm reach-to-grasp performance after chronic stroke. Disabil Rehabil Assist Technol, 2013, 8(2): 121-124 PMID: 23244391

[38] KoyamaS, TanabeS, WarashinaH, et al. . NMES with rTMS for moderate to severe dysfunction after stroke. NeuroRehabilitation, 2014, 35(3): 363-368 PMID: 25227537

[39] VongvaivanichakulP, TretriluxanaJ, BovonsunthonchaiS, et al. . Reach-to-grasp training in individuals with chronic stroke augmented by low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation. J Med Assoc Thai, 2014, 97(Suppl7): S45-S49 PMID: 25141526

[40] Motamed VaziriP, BahrpeymaF, FiroozabadiM, et al. . Low frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation to improve motor function and grip force of upper limbs of patients with hemiplegia. Iran Red Crescent Med J, 2014, 16(8): e13579 PMCID: 4222002 PMID: 25389476