Electron Tomography in Structural Determination of Mesostructured Materials: A Comprehensive Evaluation of Reconstruction Algorithms

Abstract

The development of synthetic techniques has enabled the fabrication of mesostructured materials with high complexity. However, their large unit cell parameter and inadequate repeating units pose substantial challenges in accurately determining their intricate three-dimensional (3D) architectures using conventional X-ray diffraction and electron crystallographic techniques. Electron tomography (ET), which reconstructs a 3D volume from a series of 2D projections at different tilt angles, is an ideal tool for structure solution of mesostructures. Nonetheless, there has been no detailed comparison of reconstruction algorithms specifically for mesostructures, and obtaining high-quality ET for solving complex 3D structures remains challenging. Herein, we evaluated typical ET reconstruction algorithms, including simultaneous iterative reconstruction technique (SIRT), algebraic reconstruction technique (ART), generalized Fourier iterative reconstruction (GENFIRE) and real-space iterative reconstruction (RESIRE), for the determination of mesostructures. By applying these methods to a highly complex structure with shifted double diamond (SDD) networks, we assessed the feasibility and accuracy of structure determination abilities. Our results demonstrated that common iterative algorithms are capable of determining the SDD structure, while more recent algorithms, such as GENFIRE and RESIRE reveal more details with fewer artifacts. Combined with advanced imaging and computation apparatus, ET shows great potential for the structure determination of future mesostructured structures.

Keywords

Electron tomography / Transmission electron microscopy / Structure determination / 3D reconstruction / Mesostructured material

References

[1] LaddM, PalmerRStructure Determination by X-Ray Crystallography: Analysis by X-rays and Neutrons, 2013, New York. Springer. .

[2] BishD L, ReynoldsR CModern Powder Diffraction, 1989, Berlin, Boston. De Gruyter. 73

[3] SheldrickGActa Crystallographica Section C, 2015, 713.

[4] EwaldP PFifty Years of X-Ray Diffraction, 1962, New York. Springer. .

[5] DorsetDActa Crystallographica Section B, 1996, 52753.

[6] DowningK H, MeishengH, WenkH-R, O’KeefeM ANature, 1990, 348525.

[7] MidgleyP A, Dunin-BorkowskiR ENat. Mater., 2009, 8271.

[8] KremerJ R, MastronardeD N, McIntoshJ RJ. Struct. Biol., 1996, 11671.

[9] ScottM C, ChenC C, MecklenburgM, ZhuC, XuR, ErciusP, DahmenU, ReganB C, MiaoJNature, 2012, 483444.

[10] KakA C, SlaneyMPrinciples of Computerized Tomographic Imaging, 2001, Philadelphia. Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics. .

[11] GordonR, BenderR, HermanG TJ. Theor. Biol., 1970, 29471.

[12] GilbertPJ. Theor. Biol., 1972, 36105.

[13] HermanG TFundamentals of Computerized Tomography: Image Reconstruction from Projections, 2009, Berlin. Springer Science & Business Media. .

[14] PryorAJr., YangY, RanaA, Gallagher-JonesM, ZhouJ, LoY H, MelinteG, ChiuW, RodriguezJ A, MiaoJSci. Rep., 2017, 710409.

[15] YangY, ChenC C, ScottM C, OphusC, XuR, PryorA, WuL, SunF, TheisW, ZhouJ, EisenbachM, KentP R, SabirianovR F, ZengH, ErciusP, MiaoJNature, 2017, 54275.

[16] MidgleyP A, WeylandM, ThomasJ M, JohnsonB F GChem. Commun., 2001, 10907.

[17] YatesT J V, ThomasJ M, FernandezJ-J, TerasakiO, RyooR, MidgleyP AChem. Phys. Lett., 2006, 418540.

[18] YuanP, TanL, PanD, GuoY, ZhouL, YangJ, ZouJ, YuCNew J. Chem., 2011, 352456.

[19] HsuehH Y, LingY C, WangH F, ChienL Y, HungY C, ThomasE L, HoR MAdv. Mater., 2014, 263225.

[20] YuanY, KimD S, ZhouJ, ChangD J, ZhuF, NagaokaY, YangY, PhamM, OsherS J, ChenO, ErciusP, SchmidA K, MiaoJNat. Mater., 2022, 2195.

[21] YangY, ZhouJ, ZhuF, YuanY, ChangD J, KimD S, PhamM, RanaA, TianX, YaoY, OsherS J, SchmidA K, HuL, ErciusP, MiaoJNature, 2021, 59260.

[22] HanL, XuD, LiuY, OhsunaT, YaoY, JiangC, MaiY, CaoY, DuanY, CheSChem. Mater., 2014, 267020.

[23] HawkesP WElectron Tomography: Three-dimensional Imaging with the Transmission Electron Microscope, 1992, Boston. Springer. 17.

[24] PhamM, YuanY, RanaA, OsherS, MiaoJSci. Rep., 2023, 135624.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Jilin University, The Editorial Department of Chemical Research in Chinese Universities and Springer-Verlag GmbH

Just Accepted

This article has successfully passed peer review and final editorial review, and will soon enter typesetting, proofreading and other publishing processes. The currently displayed version is the accepted final manuscript. The officially published version will be updated with format, DOI and citation information upon launch. We recommend that you pay attention to subsequent journal notifications and preferentially cite the officially published version. Thank you for your support and cooperation.