Numerical analysis of mechanical anchors in hybrid bonded FRP strengthening system

Abstract

To address the issues of unreasonable torque control and unclear failure modes in concrete anchorage systems with chemical anchors in hybrid bonded Fiber-Reinforced Polymer (FRP) strengthening system, this study focuses on the numerical simulation analysis of bolt-concrete anchorage systems. The mechanical characteristics and concrete failure modes under different anchorage depths, load levels and torque limits are emphatically investigated. Using the finite element numerical simulation method, a three-dimensional model of the bolt-concrete anchorage system is established, in which concrete is modelled with 8-node hexahedral solid elements and bolts with 6-node pentahedral solid elements. A full-bond interface assumption with common nodes is adopted between the two components. Multiple groups of numerical simulations are carried out by varying the parameters of anchorage depth and tightening torque, and the bolt stress, concrete crack propagation and failure patterns are analyzed. The results show that anchorage depth is the dominant factor controlling the ultimate bearing capacity of the anchorage system, and different anchorage depths correspond to different stress attenuation paths. At a medium embedment depth of 50 mm, a mixed failure mode consisting of upper concrete cone failure and lower interfacial bond failure is observed. Based on the simulation results, the recommended limit for bolt tightening torque is determined to be 13 N·m, which can effectively prevent damage to the concrete substrate caused by excessive pre-tightening force. The findings can provide a theoretical reference for the engineering design and torque control of concrete anchorage systems with chemical anchors.

Keywords

Hybrid bonded FRP / Bolt failure / Threaded fasteners / FE simulation

References

[1] ACI (American Concrete Institute) (2023) Code requirements for nuclear safety Related Structures. American Concrete Institute (ACI), Farmington Hills, Michigan, USA

[2] Aghabagloo M, Carreras L, Barris C, Baena M. Experimental Investigation on bond behaviour of HB FRP strengthened concrete elements. Composite Struct, 2025, 362: 119069.

[3] Aghabagloo M, Carreras L, Sena-Cruz J, Baena M. Fatigue behavior of externally bonded and hybrid-bonded carbon fiber reinforced polymer-to-concrete Joints. Int J Fatigue, 2026, 206: 109482.

[4] Aktepe R, Aldemir A (2025 July) Effects of washer geometry, tightening torque, and bolt preload relaxation on the shear-out failure of single bolted pultruded GFRP/Steel Joints. Mech Adv Mater Struct 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1080/15376494.2025.2536582

[5] Al Shboul KW, Salahat FH, Rasheed HA. Effects of U-Wrap Anchored doubly FRP strengthened Reinforced concrete beams on ductility and serviceability improvements. Eng Struct, 2024, 314: 118349.

[6] Bank LC, Arora D. Analysis of RC beams strengthened with mechanically fastened FRP (MF-FRP) Strips. Composite Struct, 2007, 792180191.

[7] Cook RA. Behavior of chemically bonded anchors. J Struct Eng, 1993, 119927442762.

[8] Del Vecchio C, Di Ludovico M, Balsamo A, Prota A. Minimally invasive FRP strengthening of external beam–column Joints. J Compos Constr, 2024, 28404024026.

[9] Ding G, Feng P, Wang Y, Ai P, Wang Q. Long-term bolt preload relaxation and contact pressure distribution in clamping anchorages for CFRP plates. Composite Struct, 2024, 329: 117780.

[10] Gao L, Wei Q, Huang Y, Zhang F. Influence of anchor design parameters on flexural performance of hybrid bonded-fiber reinforced polymer strengthened reinforced concrete beams. Structures, 2023, 48: 1029-1045.

[11] Gao XH, Gao L, Zhang F. A New bond-slip model of hybrid bonded FRP-to-concrete Joints. KSCE J Civ Eng, 2023, 271270284.

[12] Guan Y, Jiang B, Song X. Experimental study and numerical simulation on bonding behavior of the New HB-FRP strengthening technology. J Perform Constr Facil, 2012, 262220227.

[13] Hou ZX. Design and Construction of high-strength bolt connections, 2012, Beijing: China Architecture & Building Press

[14] Hu CH (2011). Experimental study on improved composite bonded FRP technique. Ph.D. Thesis, 681 Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, China, 2011. [Online]. Available: https://kns.cnki.net/KCMS/detail/detail.aspx?dbcode=CDFD%26dbname=CDFD1214%26filename=1012171761.nh

[15] Hu CH, Wu ZM, Su Y, Shi CW. Experimental study on FRP composite anchorage technology. J Retailing Disaster Prev Mitigation Eng, 2010, 303309314.

[16] Ke Y, Shi FL, Zhang SS, Nie XF, Li WG. Strength model for debonding failure in RC beams flexurally strengthened with NSM FRP and Anchored with FRP U-Jackets. J Compos Constr, 2023, 27504023038.

[17] Ke Y, Zhang SS, Smith ST, Yu T. Novel embedded FRP anchor for RC beams strengthened in flexure with NSM FRP Bars: concept and behavior. J Compos Constr, 2023, 27104022093.

[18] Kim SJ, Smith ST. Pullout strength models for FRP anchors in uncracked concrete. J Compos Constr, 2010, 144406414.

[19] Lamanna AJ, Bank LC, Scott DW. Flexural strengthening of reinforced concrete beams by mechanically attaching fiber-reinforced Polymer Strips. J Compos Constr, 2004, 83203210.

[20] Liu J, Guo T, Wei Y, Wang L, Zou X (2023 Dec) Investigation of the effect of pre-tightening forces on bolted connection for FRP-steel joints. Case Stud Construct Mater 19:e02348. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cscm.2023.e02348

[21] Martin JA, Lamanna AJ. Performance of mechanically fastened FRP strengthened concrete beams in Flexure. J Compos Constr, 2008, 123257265.

[22] Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People’s Republic of China, JGJ 145–2013 (2013) Technical Specification for Post-installed anchorage in concrete Structures. China Architecture & Building Press, Beijing

[23] National Development and Reform Commission of the People’s Republic of China (2007) General technical requirements for heavy machinery: assembly. China Standards Press, Beijing

[24] Smith ST, Teng JG. Shear-bending interaction in debonding failures of FRP-plated RC beams. Adv Struct Eng, 2003, 63183199.

[25] Villanueva Llauradó P, Ibell T, Fernández Gómez J, González Ramos FJ. Pull-out and shear-strength models for FRP Spike Anchors. Compos Part B, 2017, 116: 239-252.

[26] Visintin P, Drakos D, Harris J, Lane T, McKenny H. Experimental and analytical investigation of the pullout behavior of FRP Bars in engineered timber. J Compos Constr, 2026, 30104025055.

[27] Wu Y, Huang Y. Hybrid bonding of FRP to reinforced concrete structures. J Compos Constr, 2008, 123266273.

[28] Wu Y, Wang Z, Liu K, He W, Wang Z. Numerical analyses of hybrid-bonded FRP strengthened concrete beams. Comput-Aided Civ Infrastruct Eng, 2009, 245371384.

[29] Wu Z, Hu C, Wu Y, Zheng J. Application of improved hybrid bonded FRP technique to FRP debonding prevention. Construct Building Mater, 2011, 25628982905.

[30] Xiao XP (2010) Study on debonding failure mechanism of U-bonded FRP shear-strengthened beams. Master’s Thesis, Jinan University, Guangzhou, China. https://kns.cnki.net/KCMS/detail/detail.aspx?dbcode=CMFD%26dbname=CMFD2010%26filename=2010123818.nhAccessed 16 Apr 2026

[31] Xu XF, Li PF, Li XX, Zhang LK, Gao L. Study on bond-slip behavior of HB-FRP based on arc-length method. China Foreign Highway, 2023, 436181187.

[32] Yan JH (2009) Experimental study on concrete beams strengthened with FRP hybrid bonding technique. Master’s Thesis, Hunan University, Changsha, China. https://kns.cnki.net/KCMS/detail/detail.aspx?dbcode=CMFD%26dbname=CMFD2010%26filename=2009163435.nhAccessed 17 Apr 2026

[33] Yuan H, Li Q, Xiao PW, Liu HR. Failure mechanism of shear-strengthened beams with side-bonded fiber-reinforced composites. J Educ Chang Jinan Univ (Nat Sci Med Ed), 2012, 335463467

[34] Yue QR, Li QW, Yang YX. Embedded strengthening technology of fiber reinforced composite materials. Ind Construct, 2004, 34414.

[35] Yun Y, Wu Y, Tang W. Performance of FRP bonding systems under fatigue loading. Eng Struct, 2008, 301131293140.

[36] Zhang HW, Smith ST. FRP-to-concrete joint assemblages anchored with multiple FRP anchors. Compos Struct, 2012, 942403414.

[37] Zhang J, Del Rey Castillo E, Allen T, Hogan L, Kanitkar R, Borwankar AD. Behavior and predictive model of large-scale externally bonded FRP strips anchored to reinforced concrete structures. J Compos Constr, 2026, 30304026009.

[38] Zhang J, Del Rey Castillo E, Kanitkar R, Lin S-H, Allen T, Hogan L, Borwankar AD. Unified strength model for FRP anchors under pullout and concrete-Related failure modes. J Compos Constr, 2026, 30304026012.

[39] Zhang Y, Zhang F, Wu L, Han H-Z, Wu Y-F. Flexural capacity design model of reinforced concrete beams strengthened with hybrid bonded CFRP. Eng Struct, 2024, 319: 118822.

[40] Zhao Z, Jin Z. Influence of bolt preload of anchors on bond-slip behavior of fiber fabric-steel interface. Structures, 2024, 69: 107281.

[41] Zhou Y, Wang X, Sui L, Xing F, Huang Z, Chen C, Li P, Mei L. Effect of mechanical fastening pressure on the bond behaviors of hybrid-bonded FRP to concrete interface. Composite Struct, 2018, 204: 731-744.

Rights & permissions

The Author(s)