Estimation of nosing load in existing railway transom top bridges based on field testing and finite element modelling

Abstract

A significant number of wind bracings in existing railway transom top bridges are numerically assessed deficient against the assessment nosing load recommended by the AS5100, where in almost all cases, there is no observed evidence of wind bracings being overloaded. This paper estimates the nosing load applied by various trains to a couple of random spans of an existing railway transom top bridge. Firstly, field testing of this bridge is conducted and the measured stresses at the mid-center of girders and wind bracings are collected during various normal train operations to validate the developed Finite Element (FE) models of this bridge. Then, the nosing loads due to different trains are estimated using the validated FE model through a two-staged validation approach, including automatic FE stress intensity optimization and rigorous manual FE model sensitivity analysis while transoms in various conditions are also incorporated in the FE model. Results demonstrate that the nosing load is significantly less than the required load in the AS5100 with magnitudes ranging between 8.6% to 9.4% of the maximum vertical axle load of the passed trains; suggesting that the AS5100 assessment nosing load should be revised to avoid unnecessary expensive upgrades of numerically assessed deficient wind bracings.

Keywords

Railway transom top bridges / Nosing load estimation / FE model / FE model validation / AS5100

References

[] American Railway Engineering and Maintenance-of-Way Association (AREMA) Part 2: Railroad Bridge Design, 1997.

[] AS5100.2, Bridge Design Part 2: Design loads, Australian Standard, 2017.

[] AS5100.6, Bridge Design Part 6: Steel and Composite Construction, Australian Standard, 2017.

[] AS5100.7, Bridge Design Part 7: Bridge Assessment, Australian Standard, 2017.

[] AS7636, Railway Structures, RISSB Rail Industry Safety and Standards Board, 2022.

[] AS 1085.1, Railway Track Materials Part 1: Steel rails, Australian Standards, 2002.

[] A. Prud'homme, Resistance of the Track to Lateral Loads Exerted by Rolling Stock, Revue Generale des Chemins de Fer, 1967.

[] Chen SZ, Zhong QM, Hou ST, Wu G. Two-stage stochastic model updating method for highway bridges based on long-gauge strain sensing. Structures, 2022, 37: 1165-1182,

[] S. Deng, A simplified model for assessing lateral railway bridge resonance behaivior, 2015.

[] EN 1991–2, Eurocode 1: Actions on Structures, 2006.

[] ETE-09–00, Section 9: Structures, Australian Rail Track Corporation-ARTC, 2023.

[] ETE-09–05, Section 9: Load Rating of Underbridges, Australian Rail Track Corporation-ARTC, 2022.

[] L. Georgiev, V. Tanev, L. Zdravkov, Equivalent nosing force for a steel railway bridge based on in situ measurements, IABSE Congress Ghent, 2021.

[] Ghiasi A, Moghaddam MK, Ng CT, Sheikh AH, Shi JQ. Damage classification of in-service steel railway bridges using a novel vibration-based convolutional neural network. Engine Struct, 2022, 264: 114474,

[] Ghiasi A, Ng CT, Sheikh AH. Damage detection of in-service steel railway bridges using a fine k-nearest neighbor machine learning classifier". Structures, 2022, 45: 190-1935,

[] Hughes TJ, Tessler A. An improved treatment of transverse shear in the Mindlin-type four-node quadrilateral element. Comp Methods Appl Mech Engine, 1983, 39: 311-335,

[] D. Jastrzebski (1959) Nature and Properties of Engineering Materials. Wiley, Michigan

[] L.T. James, G.A. Scott (1994) Parametric study, Lateral Forces on Railway Bridges. UIC, Paris

[] Khatibi F, Esaeili M, Mohammadzadeh S. DEM analysis of railway track lateral resistance. Soils Found, 2017, 57: 587-602,

[] Lateral Resistance of Railroad Track, U.S. Department of Transportation, 1977, FRA/ORD-77/41.

[] McLean DI. . ML Marsh, 1998 Washington Dynamic impact factors for bridges

[] A. Miri (2022) Mitigating severity of longitudinal interaction of rail-track-bridge system in transition zones for safer trains. Queensland University of Technology, Queensland

[] Mirza O, Shill SK, Johnston J. Performance of precast prestressed steel-concrete composite panels under static loadings to replace the timber transoms for railway bridge. Structures, 2019, 19: 30-40,

[] F. Moreu, A. M. Rokoczy, M. Sanaie Lateral Loads and Displacements of Railroad Bridges from Field Investigations, ASCE-Bridge Engineering, 2023, https://doi.org/10.1061/5982.

[] F. Moreu, J. M. LaFave, Railroad Bridges and Structural Engineering, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2012, 1940–9826. https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/10201376.pdf.

[] D. Otter, B. Doe, S. Belport, Rail Car Lateral Forces for Bridge Design and Rating, Technology Digest, 2005, TD-05–002.

[] Part 1030, Rail Structures, Department for Infrastructure and Transport, 2007.

[] Pipinato A, Patton R. . Innovative Bridge Design Handbook- Construction, 2015 Rehabilitation and Maintenance Elsevier

[] Qin S, Han S, Li S. In-situ testing and finite element model updating of a long-span cable-stayed bridge with ballastless track". Structures, 2022, 45: 1412-1423,

[] Qin S, Yuan Y, Han S, Li S. A Novel Multiobjective Function for Finite-Element Model Updating of a Long-Span Cable-Stayed Bridge Using In SituStatic and Dynamic Measurements." ASCE-Bridge Engineering 2022 https://doi.org/10.1061/1943-5592.0001974.

[] T HR CI 12008 ST, Capacity Assessment of Underbridges, Transport for NSW, 2019.

[] TMC 311, Transoms, RailCorp Engineering Manual, 2010.

[] WisDOT Bridge Manual, Chapter 38: Railroad Structures, 2019.

[] Zakeri JA. . Lateral Resistance of Railway Track, 2012 IntechOpen Iran University of Science and Technology