Highly Stretchable and Breathable Dry Bioelectrode with Low Impedance for Electrophysiological Monitoring

Abstract

The high impedance caused by the lack of interfacial hydrogel in dry electrodes seriously affects the quality of acquired electrophysiological signals. Although there are existing strategies to reduce impedance with micro–nanostructures, achieving stretchable and breathable electrodes while ensuring low impedance is extremely challenging. Herein, we successfully prepared a dry textile electrode (nanomesh film (NF)-ZnO–polypyrrole (PPy)) with low impedance, high stretchability, and breathability. Wrinkle-nanorod coupled microstructures are constructed to increase the effective surface area and roughness of NF-ZnO–PPy electrode, achieving an exponential reduction in impedance compared with the smooth textile dry electrode (15.64 kΩ·cm⁻² at 10 Hz, approximately 1/6 of the lowest impedance of reported electrodes). Simultaneously, the wrinkled structure formed by pre-stretching improves electrode’s stretchability (up to 910% strain) and cycle stability (R/R₀ is within 1.08 after 1000 cycles at 30% strain). Furthermore, the NF-ZnO–PPy electrode has excellent breathability (2233.52 g·m⁻²·d⁻¹) and good biocompatibility. Finally, as a proof of concept, the 16-channel NF-ZnO–PPy electrode can record electromyography signals in different states and parts of body for a long time ((22.03 ± 0.76) dB, which is twice that of the commercial electrode). Notably, we employ ZnO nanorods as a template to reduce impedance. This template strategy overcomes complex and expensive micro–nanomanufacturing technologies (photolithography, laser processing, etc.) and can be suitable for most flexible substrates, showing great potential in the field of soft electronics.

Graphical Abstract

References

[1] EskandarianL, PajootanE, ToossiA, NaguibHE. Dry fiber-based electrodes for electrophysiology applications. Adv Fiber Mater, 2023, 5: 819

[2] NiuY, TianG, LiangC, WangT, MaX, GongG, QiD. Thermal-sinterable EGaIn nanoparticle inks for highly deformable bioelectrode arrays. Adv Healthc Mater, 2023, 12: 2202531

[3] WangY, HaickH, GuoS, WangC, LeeS, YokotaT, SomeyaT. Skin bioelectronics toward long-term, continuous health monitoring. Chem Soc Rev, 2022, 51: 3759

[4] YangJC, MunJ, KwonSY, ParkS, BaoZ, ParkS. Electronic skin: recent progress and future prospects for skin-attachable devices for health monitoring, robotics, and prosthetics. Adv Mater, 2019, 31: 1904765

[5] LiH, HanF, WangL, HuangL, SamuelOW, ZhaoH, XieR, WangP, TianQ, LiQ, ZhaoY, YuM, SunJ, YangR, ZhouX, LiF, LiG, LuY, GuoP, LiuZ. A hybrid strategy-based ultra-narrow stretchable microelectrodes with cell-level resolution. Adv Funct Mater, 2023, 33: 2300859

[6] YangS, ChengJ, ShangJ, HangC, QiJ, ZhongL, RaoQ, HeL, LiuC, DingL, ZhangM, ChakrabartyS, JiangX. Stretchable surface electromyography electrode array patch for tendon location and muscle injury prevention. Nat Commun, 2023, 14: 6494

[7] JiangY, ZhangZ, WangY-X, LiD, CoenC-T, HwaunE, ChenG, WuH-C, ZhongD, NiuS, WangW, SaberiA, LaiJ-C, WuY, WangY, TrotsyukAA, LohKY, ShihC-C, XuW, LiangK, ZhangK, BaiY, GurusankarG, HuW, JiaW, ChengZ, DauskardtRH, GurtnerGC, TokJBH, DeisserothK, SolteszI, BaoZ. Topological supramolecular network enabled high-conductivity, stretchable organic bioelectronics. Science, 2022, 375: 1411

[8] ShiS, MingY, WuH, ZhiC, YangL, MengS, SiY, WangD, FeiB, HuJ. A bionic skin for health management: excellent breathability, in situ sensing, and big data analysis. Adv Mater, 2023, 36: 2306435

[9] ChiongJA, TranH, LinY, ZhengY, BaoZ. Integrating emerging polymer chemistries for the advancement of recyclable, biodegradable, and biocompatible electronics. Adv Sci, 2021, 8: 2101233

[10] TianG, YangD, LiangC, LiuY, ChenJ, ZhaoQ, TangS, HuangJ, XuP, LiuZ, QiD. A nonswelling hydrogel with regenerable high wet tissue adhesion for bioelectronics. Adv Mater, 2023, 35: 2212302

[11] YangD, TianG, LiangC, YangZ, ZhaoQ, ChenJ, MaC, JiangY, AnN, LiuY, QiD. Double-microcrack coupling stretchable neural electrode for electrophysiological communication. Adv Funct Mater, 2023, 33: 2300412

[12] ChengS, LouZ, ZhangL, GuoH, WangZ, GuoC, FukudaK, MaS, WangG, SomeyaT, ChengH-M, XuX. Ultrathin hydrogel films toward breathable skin-integrated electronics. Adv Mater, 2023, 35: 2206793

[13] JiangX, SunY, LyuY, KangH, ZhaoJ, ZhangK, BianL. Hydrogels for ameliorating osteoarthritis: mechanical modulation, anti-inflammation, and regeneration. BMEMat, 2024, 2: 12078

[14] Lo PrestiA, Andres MontoyaN, CriscuoloV, KhanG, KhanU, VecchioneR, FalconiC. Fundamentals of skin bioimpedances. Adv Mater, 2023, 35: 2302127

[15] ChenF, ZhuangQ, DingY, ZhangC, SongX, ChenZ, ZhangY, MeiQ, ZhaoX, HuangQ, ZhengZ. Wet-adaptive electronic skin. Adv Mater, 2023, 35: 2305630

[16] MengL, FuQ, HaoS, XuF, YangJ. Self-adhesive, biodegradable silk-based dry electrodes for epidermal electrophysiological monitoring. Chem Eng J, 2022, 427

[17] JiangZ, ChenN, YiZ, ZhongJ, ZhangF, JiS, LiaoR, WangY, LiH, LiuZ, WangY, YokotaT, LiuX, FukudaK, ChenX, SomeyaT. A 1.3-micrometre-thick elastic conductor for seamless on-skin and implantable sensors. Nat Electron, 2022, 5: 784

[18] SongD, LiX, JangM, LeeY, ZhaiY, HuW, YanH, ZhangS, ChenL, LuC, KimK, LiuN. An ultra-thin MXene film for multimodal sensing of neuroelectrical signals with artifacts removal. Adv Mater, 2023, 35: 2304956

[19] MinH, BaikS, KimJ, LeeJ, BokB-G, SongJH, KimM-S, PangC. Tough carbon nanotube-implanted bioinspired three-dimensional electrical adhesive for isotropically stretchable water-repellent bioelectronics. Adv Funct Mater, 2022, 32: 2107285

[20] XuZ, ChenL, LuL, DuR, MaW, CaiY, AnX, WuH, LuoQ, XuQ, ZhangQ, JiaX. A highly-adhesive and self-healing elastomer for bio-interfacial electrode. Adv Funct Mater, 2021, 31: 2006432

[21] OuyangJ, CaoJ, YangX, RaoJ, MitriashkinA, FanX, ChenR, ChengH, WangX, GohJ, LeoHL. Stretchable and self-adhesive PEDOT:PSS blend with high sweat tolerance as conformal biopotential dry electrodes. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces, 2022, 14: 39159

[22] ZhangP, GuoW, GuoZH, MaY, GaoL, CongZ, ZhaoXJ, QiaoL, PuX, WangZL. Dynamically crosslinked dry ion-conducting elastomers for soft iontronics. Adv Mater, 2021, 33: 2101396

[23] GogurlaN, KimY, ChoS, KimJ, KimS. Multifunctional and ultrathin electronic tattoo for on-skin diagnostic and therapeutic applications. Adv Mater, 2021, 33: 2170188

[24] DayanCB, ChunS, Krishna-SubbaiahN, DrotlefD-M, AkolpogluMB, SittiM. 3D printing of elastomeric bioinspired complex adhesive microstructures. Adv Mater, 2021, 33: 2103826

[25] LiuH, ChenX, WangZ, LiuY, LiangC, ZhuM, QiD. Development of soft dry electrodes: from materials to structure design. Soft Sci, 2023, 3: 27

[26] GauciSC, EhrmannK, GernhardtM, TutenB, BlascoE, FrischH, JayalatharachchiV, BlincoJP, HouckHA, Barner-KowollikC. Two functions from a single photoresist: tuning microstructure degradability from light-stabilized dynamic materials. Adv Mater, 2023, 35: 2300151

[27] BrownMA, ZappitelliKM, SinghL, YuanRC, BemroseM, BrogdenV, MillerDJ, SmearMC, CoganSF, GardnerTJ. Direct laser writing of 3D electrodes on flexible substrates. Nat Commun, 2023, 14: 3610

[28] LiangC, SunJ, LiuZ, TianG, LiuY, ZhaoQ, YangD, ChenJ, ZhongB, ZhuM, XuH, QiD. Wide range strain distributions on the electrode for highly sensitive flexible tactile sensor with low hysteresis. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces, 2023, 15: 15096

[29] JungW, JungY-H, PikhitsaPV, FengJ, YangY, KimM, TsaiH-Y, TanakaT, ShinJ, KimK-Y, ChoiH, RhoJ, ChoiM. Three-dimensional nanoprinting via charged aerosol jets. Nature, 2021, 592: 54

[30] KavandH, VisaM, KohlerM, van der WijngaartW, BerggrenP-O, HerlandA. 3D-printed biohybrid microstructures enable transplantation and vascularization of microtissues in the anterior chamber of the eye. Adv Mater, 2023, 36: 2306686

[31] AhnJ, HanH, HaJ-H, JeongY, JungY, ChoiJ, ChoS, JeonS, JeongJ-H, ParkI. Micro/nano hierarchical structures physically engineered on surface: analysis and perspectives. Adv Mater, 2023, 36: 2300871

[32] QinJ, YinL-J, HaoY-N, ZhongS-L, ZhangD-L, BiK, ZhangY-X, ZhaoY, DangZ-M. Flexible and stretchable capacitive sensors with different microstructures. Adv Mater, 2021, 33: 2008267

[33] DuM, GuanS, GaoL, LvS, YangS, ShiJ, WangJ, LiH, FangY. Flexible micropillar electrode arrays for in vivo neural activity recordings. Small, 2019, 15: 1900582

[34] ZhaoQ, ZhuM, TianG, LiangC, LiuZ, HuangJ, YuQY, TangS, ChenJ, ZhaoX, ZengQ, GuoC, QiD. Highly sensitive and omnidirectionally stretchable bioelectrode arrays for in vivo neural interfacing. Adv Healthc Mater, 2023, 12: 2203344

[35] ChenD, WangY, ZhouH, HuangZ, ZhangY, GuoCF, ZhouH. Current and future trends for polymer micro/nanoprocessing in industrial applications. Adv Mater, 2022, 34: 2200903

[36] YangG, BabuSK, LiyanageWPR, MartinezU, RoutkevitchD, MukundanR, BorupRL, CullenDA, SpendelowJS. Coaxial nanowire electrodes enable exceptional fuel cell durability. Adv Mater, 2023, 35: 2301264

[37] DervisevicM, AlbaM, YanL, SenelM, GengenbachTR, Prieto-SimonB, VoelckerNH. Transdermal electrochemical monitoring of glucose via high-density silicon microneedle array patch. Adv Funct Mater, 2022, 32: 2009850

[38] YoonH, ChoiJ, KimJ, KimJ, MinJ, KimD, JeongS, LeeJG, BangJ, ChoiSH, JeongY, KimCY, KoSH. Adaptive epidermal bioelectronics by highly breathable and stretchable metal nanowire bioelectrodes on electrospun nanofiber membrane. Adv Funct Mater, 2024, 19: 6087

[39] MoonH, LeeH, KwonJ, SuhYD, KimDK, HaI, YeoJ, HongS, KoSH. Ag/Au/Polypyrrole core-shell nanowire network for transparent, stretchable and flexible supercapacitor in wearable energy devices. Sci Rep, 2017, 7: 41981

[40] LeeH, HongS, LeeJ, SuhYD, KwonJ, MoonH, KimH, YeoJ, KoSH. Highly stretchable and transparent supercapacitor by Ag-Au Core-Shell nanowire network with high electrochemical stability. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces, 2016, 8: 15449

[41] WonP, ParkJJ, LeeT, HaI, HanS, ChoiM, LeeJ, HongS, ChoK-J, KoSH. Stretchable and transparent kirigami conductor of nanowire percolation network for electronic skin applications. Nano Lett, 2019, 19: 6087

[42] LiuX, JiaL, LiY, ZhaoR, WuC, XieZ, ChengZ, LiuY, ZhangD. Shape memory arrays top coated by adjustable mushroom with switchable adhesion to both solid and liquid. Adv Funct Mater, 2023, 34: 2312869

[43] NiuX, GaoX, WangT, WangW, LiuH. Ordered nanopillar arrays of low dynamic noise dry bioelectrodes for electrocardiogram surface monitoring. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces, 2022, 14: 33861

[44] JiangX, ZhangW, TerryR, LiW. The progress of fabrication designs of polymeric microneedles and related biomedical applications. BMEMat, 2023, 1: 12044

[45] GaoQ, AgarwalS, GreinerA, ZhangT. Electrospun fiber-based flexible electronics: fiber fabrication, device platform, functionality integration and applications. Prog Mater Sci, 2023, 137

[46] DuW, LiZ, ZhaoY, ZhangX, PangL, WangW, JiangT, YuA, ZhaiJ. Biocompatible and breathable all-fiber-based piezoresistive sensor with high sensitivity for human physiological movements monitoring. Chem Eng J, 2022, 446

[47] ZhiC, ShiS, ZhangS, SiY, YangJ, MengS, FeiB, HuJ. Bioinspired all-fibrous directional moisture-wicking electronic skins for biomechanical energy harvesting and all-range health sensing. Nano-Micro Lett, 2023, 15: 60

[48] GaoZ, XiaoX, CarloAD, YinJ, WangY, HuangL, TangJ, ChenJ. Advances in wearable strain sensors based on electrospun fibers. Adv Funct Mater, 2023, 33: 2214265

[49] WenY, ChenJ, GaoX, LiuW, CheH, LiuB, AoY. Two birds with one stone: cobalt-doping induces to enhanced piezoelectric property and persulfate activation ability of ZnO nanorods for efficient water purification. Nano Energy, 2023, 107

[50] KimH, LeeJ, HeoU, JayashankarDK, AgnoK-C, KimY, KimCY, OhY, ByunS-H, ChoiB, JeongH, YeoW-H, LiZ, ParkS, XiaoJ, KimJ, JeongJ-W. Skin preparation-free, stretchable microneedle adhesive patches for reliable electrophysiological sensing and exoskeleton robot control. Sci Adv, 2024, 10: eadk5260

[51] GoyalK, BorkholderDA, DaySW. Dependence of skin-electrode contact impedance on material and skin hydration. Sensor, 2022, 22: 8510

[52] PiaoH, ZhaoJ, TangY, ZhangR, ZhangS, HuangQ, ZuoS, LiuY, XiaoC, LiuS. On-demand switchable superamphiphilic nanofiber membrane reinforced by PET braided tube for efficient wastewater purification and photocatalytic regeneration. Appl Catal B-Environ Energy, 2024, 341

[53] ZouT, ZhangD, ShenK, HuangZ, XuT, PengX, ZhangH, DuY, SunL. Flame-retardant and fire-warning cotton composite fabrics based on the thermoelectric effect of polypyyrole doped with P-toluenesulfonic acid. Adv Compos Hybrid Mater, 2023, 6: 200

[54] SunwooS-H, HanSI, JungD, KimM, NamS, LeeH, ChoiS, KangH, ChoYS, YeomD-H, ChaM-J, LeeS, LeeS-P, HyeonT, KimD-H. Stretchable low-impedance conductor with Ag-Au-Pt core-shell-shell nanowires and in situ formed Pt nanoparticles for wearable and implantable device. ACS Nano, 2023, 17: 7550

[55] HouB, LiuX. Stretching boundaries in neurophysiological monitoring. BMEMat, 2023, 1: 12054

[56] HuD, Giorgio-SerchiF, ZhangS, YangY. Stretchable e-skin and transformer enable high-resolution morphological reconstruction for soft robots. Nat Mach Intell, 2023, 5: 261

[57] ClarkeB, GhandiK. The interplay of growth mechanism and properties of ZNO nanostructures for different applications. Small, 2023, 19: 2302864

[58] OhIH, ParkE, ChangST, LimS. Foldable RF energy harvesting system based on vertically layered metal electrodes within a single sheet of paper. Adv Mater, 2023, 35: 2300197

Funding

National Natural Science Foundation of China(Grants No. 52173237)

Nationally Funding Postdoctoral Researcher Program(Grants No. GZC20233469)

Fundamental Research Funds for Central Universities of the Central South University(Grants No. HIT.OCEF.2022018)

Natural Science Foundation of Heilongjiang Province, China(LH2022E051)

Interdisciplinary Research Foundation of HIT(IR2021207)

The Open Project Program of Key Laboratory for Photonic and Electric Bandgap Materials, Ministry of Education(PEBM202107)