Why do offshore breakwaters trap low levels of fine-grained sediments? Insights from Vietnam

Abstract

Offshore structures were originally designed to protect sandy beaches, but they are increasingly being built to protect mangrove-dominated muddy coasts from further erosion. So far, these structures have had limited success in trapping sediments. It is unclear whether these offshore breakwaters were installed in the most suitable locations for sediment accumulation. We selected hollow triangular offshore breakwaters in Tan Thanh, Tien Giang, Vietnam (herein called the Tan Thanh HTBs), Tien Giang in Vietnam as a case study to partially address this question. Using the MIKE 21/3 Coupled Model FM, we developed sedimentation scenarios related to the positions of the Tan Thanh HTBs taking into account detailed field observations made during site visits. Our findings showed that the Tan Thanh HTBs were not installed adequately due to their positions in areas with low total gross depositional accumulation (150–200 kg/m² in the dry season and 200–250 kg/m² in the wet season), low suspended sediment concentrations (0.1–0.2 kg/m³ in the dry season and 0.3–0.4 kg/m³ in the wet season), and in the wrong sediment transport direction. This partly explains the low amount of sediment accumulation in the areas in front and behind the Tan Thanh HTBs. The findings of the study will serve as a technical reference for future lessons and replication.

Keywords

Coastal erosion / Mangrove forest / Natural regeneration / Sediment accumulation / Suspended sediment

References

[1] Akbar AA, Sartohadi J, Djohan TS, Rytohardoyo S. The role of breakwaters on the rehabilitation of coastal and mangrove forests in West Kalimantan, Indonesia. Ocean Coast Manag. 2017, 138: 50-59.

[2] Al-Nassar W, Neelamani S, Al-Banaa K, Al-Ragum A, Ljubic J. Wave action on a mild sloped offshore breakwater for the protection of a promenade. J Coast Res. 2007, 50: 195-200.

[3] Birben AR, Özölçer IH, Karasu S, Kömürcü M. Investigation of the effects of offshore breakwater parameters on sediment accumulation. Ocean Eng. 2007, 34(2): 284-302.

[4] Burt J, David F, Paolo U, Andrew B, Peter SF. The influence of wave exposure on coral community development on man-made breakwater reefs, with a comparison to a natural reef. Bull Mar Sci. 2010, 86(4): 839-859.

[5] Cappietti L. Converting emergent breakwaters into submerged breakwaters. J Coast Res. 2011, 64: 479-483

[6] Davidson MA, Splinter KD, Turner IL. A simple equilibrium model for predicting shoreline change. Coast Eng. 2013, 73: 191-202.

[7] Dong WS, Ariffin EH, Saengsupavanich C, Rashid MAZ, Shukri MHM, Ramli MZ, Miskon MF, Jeofry MH, Yuns K, Ghazali NHM. Adaptation of coastal defence structure as a mechanism to alleviate coastal erosion in monsoon dominated coast of Peninsular Malaysia. J Environ Manage. 2023, 333: 117391.

[8] Dong WS, Ariffin EH, Saengsupavanich C, Rashid MM, Shukri MHM, Ramli MZ, Miskon MF, Jeofry MH, Yunus K, Ghazali NHM, Md Nasir Md Noh (2023) Adaptation of coastal defence structure as a mechanism to alleviate coastal erosion in monsoon dominated coast of Peninsular Malaysia. J Environ Manag 333:117391. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2023.117391

[9] Huang WP. Impact of coastal development on coastal morphology of Taiwan: case studies and proposed countermeasures. J Sea Res. 2022, 186102234.

[10] Luom TT, Nguyen TP, Tung NT, Tu LX, Duong TA. Using fine-grained sediment and wave attenuation as a new measure for evaluating the efficacy of offshore breakwaters in stabilizing an eroded muddy coast: insights from Ca Mau, the Mekong Delta of Vietnam. Sustainability. 2021, 13(9): 4798.

[11] Magdalena I, Phang YAD, Rif'atin HQ, Saengsupavanich C, Sanitwong-Na-Ayutthaya S. Trapezoidal breakwater on reducing resonant wave amplitude on a rectangular basin. J King Saud Univ Sci. 2024, 3610103425.

[12] Masucci GD, Acierno A, Reimer JD. Eroding diversity away: impacts of a tetrapod breakwater on a subtropical coral reef. Aquat Conserv Mar Freshw Ecosyst. 2020, 302290-302.

[13] Minh NN, Duong DV, Tu LD, San DC, Chuong L,T, Hai TD, Cong TN, Wright DP, Tamin AH, Truong PN, Phong NT, Anh DT. Experimental and numerical modeling of pile-rock breakwater gap arrangement for optimal coastal erosion protection in deltaic coasts. Ocean Eng. 2023, 280: 114625.

[14] Miranda NA, Bintoro RS, Prasita VD. The pattern of coastline changes and wave modelling around the expansion of PPI Popoh Tulung Agung, East Java. Marit Technol Res. 2023, 54262926.

[15] MonRE (2020) Climate Change Scenarios for in Vietnam. Hanoi, Vietnam, Vietnam MonRE

[16] Muroi SK, Bertone B, Cartwright N, Alvarez F. Hybrid one-line/ 2DH model of submerged breakwater for coastal protection. Environ Model Softw. 2024, 172105897.

[17] Nash JE, Sutcliffe JV (1970) River flow forecasting through conceptual models part I — A discussion of principles. J Hydrol 10(3):282–290. https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-1694(70)90255-6

[18] Nguyen TP, Loi LT. Extent of reference to science and the efficacy of coastal management policies: insights from the Vietnamese Mekong Delta. J Coast Conserv. 2023, 2755.

[19] Pan S, Fairbairn G. Impacts of submerged breakwaters on nearshore sediment transport. J Coast Res. 2016, 751212-1216.

[20] Plomaritis TA, Collins MB. Hydrodynamic and sediment dynamic modifications of tidal flow in the near-field area of offshore breakwaters. Ocean Dyn. 2013, 63: 225-241.

[21] Robert A, Dalrymple A, Martin PA. Wave diffraction through offshore breakwaters. J Waterw Port Coast Ocean Eng. 1991, 1166727-741.

[22] Saengsupavanich C, Ratnayake AS, Yun LS, Arifn EH. Current challenges in coastal erosion management for southern Asian regions: examples from Thailand, Malaysia, and Sri Lanka. Anthropocence Coasts. 2023, 6: 15.

[23] San DC, Duong NB, Phong NC, Tu LX, Damien PVB, Guillou S, Dan NK. Numerical study on measures for protecting the Go-Cong coastlines (Vietnam) from erosion. Water. 2022, 143850.

[24] Schmitt K ,Albers T (2014) 5 - area coastal protection and the use of bamboo breakwaters in the Mekong Delta. Coastal disasters and climate change in Vietnam: engineering and planning perspectives. 107 – 132. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-800007-6.00005-8

[25] Sheng-Wen T, Cheng-Chung C. A highly wave dissipation offshore breakwater. Ocean Eng. 2000, 27315-330.

[26] Splinter KD, Turner IL, Davidson MA, Barnard P, Castelle B, Oltman-Shay J. A generalized equilibrium model for predicting daily to interannual shoreline response. J Geophys Res Earth Surf. 2014, 119(9): 1936-1958.

[27] Stauble Dk, Tabar JR. The use of submerged narrow-crested breakwaters for shoreline erosion control. J Coast Res. 2003, 19(3): 682-722

[28] Sumer BM, Fredsøe J, Lamberti A, Zanuttigh B, Dixen M, Gislason K, Di Penta AF. Local scour at roundhead and along the trunk of low crested structures. Coast Eng. 2005, 52(10-11): 995-1025.

[29] Taslin PNA, Zainuddin SNH, Albani A, Maulud KNA, Mokhtar M, Ariffin EH. Wave-driven process influencing aeolian sediment transport in beach dune systems: a review. Marit Technol Res. 2025, 74276936.

[30] Tien Giang PPC (2013) Decision to approve forest protection and planning in Tien Giang between 2011 and 2020. Tien Giang: Tien Giang PPC

[31] Tien Giang PPC (2017) Report on adjusted planning of developing agriculture, forestry, aquaculture in Tien Giang until 2020 with an orientation up to 2030. Tien Giang: Tien Giang PPC

[32] Tu LX, Manh LH, Ba HT, Duong DV, Vu HTD, Wright D, Bui VH, Anh DT. Wave energy dissipation through a hollow triangle breakwater on the coastal Mekong Delta. Ocean Eng. 2022, 245: 110419.

[33] Tu LX, Phong NC, Thanh VQ, Quan TQ, Wright DP, Anh DT. Multi‑scale modelling for hydrodynamic and morphological changes of breakwater in coastal Mekong Delta in Vietnam. J Coast Conserv. 2022, 2618.

[34] VPM (2022) Resolution on socio-economic development orientation, national defence and security in the Mekong Delta of Vietnam until 2030 with a vision up to 2045. Hanoi, Vietnam: VPM

[35] Wibowo M, Khoirunnisa H, Wijayanti R, Istiyanto DC, Widagdo AB. Sediment transport modelling: effect of the coastal reservoirs development plan in the Cisadane estuary-Indonesia. Environ Earth Sci. 2024, 83562.

[36] Winterwerp JC, Erftemeijer PLA, Suryadiputra N, Van Eijk P, Zhang L. Defining eco-morphodynamic requirements for rehabilitating eroding mangrove-mud coasts. Wetlands. 2013, 33515-526.

[37] Yun-Ta W, Shih-Chun H. Propagation of solitary waves over a submerged permeable breakwater. Coast Eng. 2013, 81: 1-18.

Funding

Foundation of Science and Technology Development of Ton Duc Thang University(FOSTECT.2025.40)

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)