Comparative study of science-based monitoring methods for coral reef ecological disaster mitigation in the Spermonde Archipelago

Abstract

Coral reef degradation in the Spermonde Archipelago has reached alarming levels, driven by natural and anthropogenic factors. This study integrated quantitative (community perception surveys, ecological monitoring using Line Intercept Transect (LIT), Underwater Photo Transect (UPT), and drone methods) and qualitative (Focus Group Discussion - FGD) approaches to analyze coral reef conditions and design a community-based mitigation model. The results showed that: (1) There is a gradient in coral reef damage closely related to water quality, with Lae-Lae Island (turbid waters) dominated by dead coral and coral debris, while Lanyukang Island (clear waters) maintains significant live coral cover; (2) Community awareness of degradation is high (58% of respondents stated that conditions are worsening), but understanding of ecological mechanisms particularly the relationship between nutrient waste and algal blooms remains limited; (3) Readiness to participate in mitigation varies (only 29.4% are very ready), with the main barriers being a lack of experience, tools, and funding; (4) Integration of monitoring methods (LIT, UPT, drone) and local knowledge resulted in site-specific mitigation models: waste management and substrate restoration in Lae-Lae, hybrid patrol and coral transplantation in Kodingareng Lompo, and strengthening regulations and sustainable ecotourism in Lanyukang. This study concluded that the effectiveness of mitigation depends on the synergy between scientific data, local knowledge, and multidimensional partnerships that empower communities as key conservation actors.

Keywords

Coral reef / Spermonde Archipelago / Ecological threat integration / Community-based mitigation / Monitoring methods comparison

References

[1] Adebayo AI, Olubanjo KT, Fadeke AM, Uyanah JJ, Zirra AT, Igbaoreto WA, Fakoyede PD. From static sampling to dynamic insights: the future of water quality monitoring with sensors, IOT, and drones. Science World Journal, 2024, 20(1): 454-466

[2] Allen ME, Fleming CS, Zito BM, Gonyo SB, Regan SD, Towle EK (2021) National Coral Reef Monitoring Program Socioeconomic Monitoring Component: Summary Findings for South Florida, 2019 (C. R. C. P. (U.S.) (ed.)). https://doi.org/10.25923/w6pa-hv50

[3] Baumann JH, Zhao LZ, Stier AC, Bruno JF. Remoteness does not enhance coral reef resilience. Glob Change Biol, 2022, 28(2): 417-428

[4] Bennett MK, Younes N, Joyce K. Automating drone image processing to map coral reef substrates using Google earth engine. Drones, 2020, 4(3): 50

[5] Bennett NJ, Dearden P. Why local people do not support conservation: community perceptions of marine protected area livelihood impacts, governance and management in Thailand. Mar Policy, 2014, 44: 107-116

[6] Bianchelli S, Fraschetti S, Martini F, Lo Martire M, Nepote E, Ippoliti D, Rindi F, Danovaro R. Macroalgal forest restoration: the effect of the foundation species. Front Mar Sci, 2023, 10: 1213184

[7] Caldwell IR, McClanahan TR, Oddenyo RM, Graham NA, Beger M, Vigliola L, Sandin SA, Friedlander AM, Randriamanantsoa B, Wantiez L, Green AL, Humphries AT, Hardt MJ, Caselle JE, Feary DA, Karkarey R, Jadot C, Hoey AS, Eurich JG, Cinner JE (2024) Protection efforts have resulted in ~10% of existing fish biomass on coral reefs. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 121(42). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2308605121

[8] Chen X, Yu K, Huang X, Wang Y, Liao Z, Zhang R, Yao Q, Wang J, Wang W, Tao S. Atmospheric nitrogen deposition increases the possibility of macroalgal dominance on remote coral reefs. J Geophys Res Biogeosciences, 2019, 124(5): 1355-1369

[9] Cinner JE, Huchery C, MacNeil MA, Graham NAJ, McClanahan TR, Maina J, Maire E, Kittinger JN, Hicks CC, Mora C, Allison EH, D’Agata S, Hoey A, Feary DA, Crowder L, Williams ID, Kulbicki M, Vigliola L, Wantiez L, Mouillot D (2016) Bright spots among the world’s coral reefs. Nature 535(7612):416–419. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature18607 

[10] Danielsen F, Eicken H, Funder M, Johnson N, Lee O, Theilade I, Argyriou D, Burgess ND. Community monitoring of natural resource systems and the environment. Annu Rev Environ Resour, 2022, 47(1): 637-670

[11] Darby J, Clairbaux M, Bennison A, Quinn JL, Jessopp MJ. Underwater visibility constrains the foraging behaviour of a diving pelagic seabird. Proc R Soc B Biol Sci, 2022, 289(1978): 20220862

[12] Donovan MK, Burkepile DE, Kratochwill C, Shlesinger T, Sully S, Oliver TA, Hodgson G, Freiwald J, van Woesik R. Local conditions magnify coral loss after marine heatwaves. Science, 2021, 372(6545): 977-980

[13] Edmunds PJ. Why keep monitoring coral reefs?. Bioscience, 2024, 74(8): 552-560

[14] English S, Wilkinson C, Baker V (1998) Survey manual for tropical marine resources. Second edition. In: Survey manual for tropical marine resources. Second edition. Australian Institute of Marine Science

[15] Faizal A, Jompa J, Nessa N, Rani C. Dinamika spasio-temporal tingkat kesuburan perairan di Kepulauan Spermonde, Sulawesi Selatan. Jurnal Ilmu Kelautan, 2011, 3(2): 1-16

[16] Frid M, Frid V. Vital views into drone-based GPR application: precise mapping of soil-to-rock boundaries and ground water level for foundation engineering and site-specific response. Appl Sci, 2024, 14(17): 7889

[17] Ghafran C, Yasmin S (2025) Participation Strategies and Ethical Considerations in NGO Led Community-Based Conservation Initiatives. J Bus Ethics 196(3):659–675. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-024-05665-4

[18] Gilmour JP, Cook KL, Ryan NM, Puotinen ML, Green RH, Heyward AJ. A tale of two reef systems: local conditions, disturbances, coral life histories, and the climate catastrophe. Ecol Appl, 2022, 32(3): e2509

[19] Good AM, Bahr KD. The coral conservation crisis: interacting local and global stressors reduce reef resiliency and create challenges for conservation solutions. SN Appl Sci, 2021, 3(3): 1-14

[20] Gove JM, Williams GJ, Lecky J, Brown E, Conklin E, Counsell C, Davis G, Donovan MK, Falinski K, Kramer L, Kozar K, Li N, Maynard JA, McCutcheon A, McKenna SA, Neilson BJ, Safaie A, Teague C, Whittier R, Asner GP. Coral reefs benefit from reduced land–sea impacts under ocean warming. Nature, 2023, 621(7979): 536-542

[21] Hedley JD, Roelfsema CM, Chollett I, Harborne AR, Heron SF, Weeks SJ, Skirving WJ, Strong AE, Eakin CM, Christensen TRL. Remote sensing of coral reefs for monitoring and management: a review. Remote Sens, 2016, 8(2): 118

[22] Hondula KL, König M, Grunert BK, Vaughn NR, Martin RE, Dai J, Jamalinia E, Asner GP. Mapping water quality in nearshore reef environments using airborne imaging spectroscopy. Remote Sens, 2024, 16(11): 1845

[23] Hossain MJ, Das M, Islam MW, Shahjahan M, Ferdous J. Community engagement and social participation in dengue prevention: a cross‐sectional study in Dhaka City. Health Sci Rep, 2024, 7(4): e2022

[24] Jarriel SD, Formel N, Ferguson SR, Jensen FH, Apprill A, Mooney TA. Unidentified fish sounds as indicators of coral reef health and comparison to other acoustic methods. Front Remote Sens, 2024, 5: 1-14

[25] Jiménez-Jiménez SI, Ojeda-Bustamante W, Marcial-Pablo MdeJ, Enciso J. Digital terrain models generated with low-cost UAV photogrammetry: methodology and accuracy. ISPRS Int J Geo Inf, 2021, 10(5): 285

[26] Jones BLH, Unsworth RKF, Nordlund LM, Ambo-Rappe R, La Nafi EYA, Lopez MR, Udagedara S, Cullen-Unsworth LC (2022) Local Ecological Knowledge Reveals Change in Seagrass Social–Ecological Systems. Oceans 3(3):419–430. https://doi.org/10.3390/oceans3030028

[27] Jones E (2024) Exploring the socio-ecology of science: the case of coral reefs. Eur J Philos Sci 14(3):29. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13194-024-00589-2

[28] Kench PS, Mann T. Reef island evolution and dynamics: insights from the Indian and Pacific Oceans and perspectives for the Spermonde Archipelago. Front Mar Sci, 2017, 4: 00145

[29] Lu H, Li Y, Xu X, He L, Li Y, Dansereau D, Serikawa S. Underwater image descattering and quality assessment. IEEE International Conference on Image Processing (ICIP), 2016, 2016: 1998-2002

[30] Marzo RR, Chen HWJ, Anuar H, Abdul Wahab MK, Nizam MH, Ariffin IA, Hamzah H, Ahmad AI, Kawuki J, Halim S. Knowledge, attitude, and practice of coral reef conservation among Terengganu community of Malaysia. Front Environ Sci, 2023, 11: 1267980

[31] Mengist W, Soromessa T, Feyisa GL. A global view of regulatory ecosystem services: existed knowledge, trends, and research gaps. Ecol Process, 2020, 9(1): 40

[32] Mora C, Graham NAJ, Nyström M. Ecological limitations to the resilience of coral reefs. Coral Reefs, 2016, 35(4): 1271-1280

[33] Morgan KM, Perry CT, Arthur R, Williams HTP, Smithers SG. Projections of coral cover and habitat change on turbid reefs under future sea-level rise. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci, 2020, 287(1929): 20200541

[34] Norström AV, Cvitanovic C, Löf MF, West S, Wyborn C, Balvanera P, Bednarek AT, Bennett EM, Biggs R, de Bremond A, Campbell BM, Canadell JG, Carpenter SR, Folke C, Fulton EA, Gaffney O, Gelcich S, Jouffray J-B, Leach M, Le Tissier M, Martín-López B, Louder E, Loutre M-F, Meadow AM, Nagendra H, Payne D, Peterson GD, Reyers B, Scholes R, Speranza CI, Spierenburg M, Stafford-Smith M, Tengö M, van der Hel S, van Putten I, Österblom H. Principles for knowledge co-production in sustainability research. Nat Sustain, 2020, 3(3): 182-190

[35] Nurdjaman S, Nasution MI, Johan O, Napitupulu G, Saleh E. Impact of climate change on coral reefs degradation at West Lombok, Indonesia. J Kelaut Trop, 2023, 26(3): 451-463

[36] Obura DO, Aeby G, Amornthammarong N, Appeltans W, Bax N, Bishop J, Brainard RE, Chan S, Fletcher P, Gordon TAC, Gramer L, Gudka M, Halas J, Hendee J, Hodgson G, Huang D, Jankulak M, Jones A, Kimura T, Wongbusarakum S (2019) Coral reef monitoring, reef assessment technologies, and ecosystem-based management. Front Marine Sci 6:1–21. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2019.00580

[37] Pais MP, Cabral HN. Effect of underwater visual survey methodology on bias and precision of fish counts: a simulation approach. PeerJ, 2018, 6: e5378

[38] Pinheiro HT, MacDonald C, Santos RG, Ali R, Bobat A, Cresswell BJ, Francini-Filho R, Freitas R, Galbraith GF, Musembi P, Phelps TA, Quimbayo JP, Quiros TEAL, Shepherd B, Stefanoudis PV, Talma S, Teixeira JB, Woodall LC, Rocha LA. Plastic pollution on the world’s coral reefs. Nature, 2023, 619(7969): 311-316

[39] Prouty NG, Cohen A, Yates KK, Storlazzi CD, Swarzenski PW, White D. Vulnerability of coral reefs to bioerosion from land‐based sources of pollution. J Geophys Res Oceans, 2017, 122(12): 9319-9331

[40] Raveendran NP. Promoting responsible tourism: assessing sustainable practices, community engagement, and environmental conservation for balancing economic growth and ecological preservation in global travel destinations. Int J Multidimens Res Perspect, 2024, 2: 30-44

[41] Renck V, Ludwig D, Bollettin P, Reis-Filho JA, Poliseli L, El-Hani CN (2023) Taking fishers’ knowledge and its implications to fisheries policy seriously. Ecol Soc 28(2). https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-14104-280207

[42] Reverter M, Helber SB, Rohde S, de Goeij JM, Schupp PJ. Coral reef benthic community changes in the Anthropocene: biogeographic heterogeneity, overlooked configurations, and methodology. Glob Change Biol, 2022, 28(6): 1956-1971

[43] Sauder J, Banc-Prandi G, Meibom A, Tuia D. Scalable semantic 3D mapping of coral reefs with deep learning. Methods Ecol Evol, 2024, 15(5): 916-934

[44] Senkal E, Kaplan G, Avdan U. Accuracy assessment of digital surface models from unmanned aerial vehicles’ imagery on archaeological sites. Int J Eng Geosci, 2021, 6(2): 81-89

[45] Suggett DJ, Guest J, Camp EF, Edwards A, Goergen L, Hein M, Humanes A, Levy JS, Montoya-Maya PH, Smith DJ. Restoration as a meaningful aid to ecological recovery of coral reefs. NPJ Ocean Sustain, 2024, 3(1): 20

[46] Sully S, Hodgson G, van Woesik R. Present and future bright and dark spots for coral reefs through climate change. Glob Change Biol, 2022, 28(15): 4509-4522

[47] Teixidó N, Albajes-Eizagirre A, Bolbo D, Le Hir E, Demestre M, Garrabou J, Guigues L, Gili J-M, Piera J, Prelot T. Hierarchical segmentation-based software for cover classification analyses of seabed images (Seascape). Mar Ecol Prog Ser, 2011, 431: 45-53

[48] Trialfhianty TI, Suadi. . The role of the community in supporting coral reef restoration in Pemuteran, Bali. Indonesia. J Coast Conserv, 2017, 21(6): 873-882

[49] United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) (2009) Converting Waste Plastics Into a Resource, Division of Technology, Industry and Economics International Environmental Technology Centre, Osaka/Shiga

[50] Urbina-Barreto I, Garnier R, Elise S, Pinel R, Dumas P, Mahamadaly V, Facon M, Bureau S, Peignon C, Quod JP, Dutrieux E, Penin L, Adjeroud M (2021) Which Method for Which Purpose? A Comparison of Line Intercept Transect and Underwater Photogrammetry Methods for Coral Reef Surveys. Front Marine Sci 8. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2021.636902

[51] Wang M, Lian S, Xiong X, Yang J, Chen C, Shi X. Assessing the consistency and reliability of the line intercept transect method in coral cover estimation using structure from motion photogrammetry techniques. Geocarto Int, 2024, 39(1): 2322065

[52] Webster FJ, Babcock RC, Van Keulen M, Loneragan NR. Macroalgae inhibits larval settlement and increases recruit mortality at Ningaloo Reef, Western Australia. PLoS ONE, 2015, 10(4): e0124162

[53] Widiarti R, Kusumawardhani AD, Patria MP, Fadhilah MF (2025) The enhancement of community perception and participation in gaining sustainable coral reef management models. 1–15. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2025.1577199

[54] Zheng Y, Wu J, Wang A, Chen J. Object-and pixel-based classifications of macroalgae farming area with high spatial resolution imagery. Geocarto Int, 2018, 33(10): 1048-1063

Funding

Directorate of Research, Technology, and Community Service grant, Ministry of Higher Education, Science, and Technology, Indonesia under the BIMA Fundamental Basic Research (069/C3/DT.05.00/PL/2025)

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)