Comparative Trends of Sociality Among Terrestrial Carnivores: A Multivariate Analysis

Abstract

Among the order Carnivora, there is variation in the extent to which species form social groups. Typically, such variation is often studied in the context of a single variable that may impact behavior. However, the multiple interacting processes that drive plastic behaviors such as sociality and space use are likely to operate over multiple temporal and spatial scales. To quantify the relative impacts of different drivers requires an integration of the different processes across the scales at which they operate. Here we use piecewise structural equation modeling (piecewise SEM) to quantify the direct and indirect impacts of variables on behaviors including social grouping, reproduction, and space use. We analyze the role of phylogeny, environment, and community structure on sociality. Home range, social group size, and diet were shown to be most strongly influenced by life history variables, whereas reproductive output was most strongly impacted by variation in the environment.

Keywords

carnivore / social / structural equation model

References

[1] Abrahams, M. V., and L. M. Dill. 1989. “A Determination of the Energetic Equivalence of the Risk of Predation.” Ecology 70, no. 4: 999–1007.

[2] Albery, G. F., T. H. Clutton-Brock, A. Morris, et al. 2022. “Ageing Red Deer Alter Their Spatial Behaviour and Become Less Social.” Nature Ecology & Evolution 6, no. 8: 1231–1238.

[3] Angerbjorn, A., B. Arvidson, E. Noren, and L. Stromgren. 1991. “The Effect of Winter Food on Reproduction in the Arctic Fox, Alopex lagopus: A Field Experiment.” Journal of Animal Ecology 60: 705–714.

[4] Bailey, I., J. P. Myatt, and A. M. Wilson. 2013. “Group Hunting Within the Carnivora: Physiological, Cognitive and Environmental Influences on Strategy and Cooperation.” Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 67: 1–17.

[5] Bekoff, M., T. J. Daniels, and J. L. Gittleman. 1984. “Life History Patterns and the Comparative Social Ecology of Carnivores.” Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 15: 191–232.

[6] Bell, M. B. V., M. A. Cant, C. Borgeaud, N. Thavarajah, J. Samson, and T. H. Clutton-Brock. 2014. “Suppressing Subordinate Reproduction Provides Benefits to Dominants in Cooperative Societies of Meerkats.” Nature Communications 5, no. 1: 4499.

[7] Benton, M. J. 1999. “Early Origins of Modern Birds and Mammals: Molecules vs. Morphology.” BioEssays 21: 1043–1051.

[8] Bininda-Emonds, O. R. P., M. Cardillo, K. E. Jones, et al. 2007. “The Delayed Rise of Present-Day Mammals.” Nature 446, no. 7135: 507–512.

[9] Borg, B. L., S. M. Brainerd, T. J. Meier, and L. R. Prugh. 2015. “Impacts of Breeder Loss on Social Structure, Reproduction and Population Growth in a Social Canid.” Journal of Animal Ecology 84: 177–187.

[10] Carbone, C., L. Frame, G. Frame, et al. 2005. “Feeding Success of African Wild Dogs (Lycaonpictus) in the Serengeti: The Effects of Group Size and Kleptoparasitism.” Journal of Zoology 266: 153–161.

[11] Carbone, C., and J. L. Gittleman. 2002. “A Common Rule for the Scaling of Carnivore Density.” Science 295: 2273–2276.

[12] Carbone, C., G. M. Mace, S. C. Roberts, and D. W. Macdonald. 1999. “Energetic Constraints on the Diet of Terrestrial Carnivores.” Nature 402: 286–288.

[13] Carbone, C., A. Teacher, and J. M. Rowcliffe. 2007. “The costs of carnivory.” PLoS Biology 5, no. 2: e22.

[14] Cassidy, K. A., D. R. MacNulty, D. R. Stahler, D. W. Smith, and L. D. Mech. 2015. “Group Composition Effects on Aggressive Interpack Interactions of Gray Wolves in Yellowstone National Park.” Behavioral Ecology 26: 1352–1360.

[15] Chakrabarti, S., and Y. V. Jhala. 2019. “Battle of the Sexes: A Multi-Male Mating Strategy Helps Lionesses Win the Gender War of Fitness.” Behavioral Ecology 30: 1050–1061.

[16] Chen, J. 2019. “Social Behavior and Structure in Wild and Captive Groups of the African Wild Dog, Lycaon pictus (Temminck, 1820) (Carnivora: Canidae).” Life: The Excitement of Biology 6: 123–149.

[17] Christiansen, P., and S. Wroe. 2007. “Bite Forces and Evolutionary Adaptations to Feeding Ecology in Carnivores.” Ecology 88: 347–358.

[18] Clutton-Brock, T. H., A. F. Russell, L. L. Sharpe, A. J. Young, Z. Balmforth, and G. M. McIlrath. 2002. “Evolution and Development of Sex Differences in Cooperative Behavior in Meerkats.” Science 297: 253–256.

[19] Creel, S. 1997. “Cooperative Hunting and Group Size: Assumptions and Currencies.” Animal Behaviour 54: 1319–1324.

[20] Creel, S. 2001. “Four Factors Modifying the Effect of Competition on Carnivore Population Dynamics as Illustrated by African Wild Dogs.” Conservation Biology 15: 271–274.

[21] Creel, S., and N. Creel. 1991. “Energetics, Reproductive Suppression and Obligate Communal Breeding in Carnivores.” Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 28: 263–270.

[22] Cusens, J., S. D. Wright, P. D. McBride, and L. N. Gillman. 2012. “What Is the Form of the Productivity Animal-Species-Richness Relationship? A Critical Review and Meta-Analysis.” Ecology 93: 2241–2252.

[23] Dalerum, F. 2007. “Phylogenetic Reconstruction of Carnivore Social Organizations.” Journal of Zoology 273: 90–97.

[24] Delahay, R. J., S. Langton, G. C. Smith, R. S. Clifton-Hadley, and C. L. Cheeseman. 2000. “The Spatio-Temporal Distribution of Mycobacterium Bovis (Bovine Tuberculosis) Infection in a High-Density Badger Population.” Journal of Animal Ecology 69: 428–441.

[25] Dietz, J. M. 1984. “Ecology and Social Organization of the Maned Wolf (Chrysocyon brachyurus).” Smithsonian Contributions to Zoology 392: 1–51.

[26] Dyck, M. G., W. Soon, R. K. Baydack, et al. 2007. “Polar Bears of Western Hudson Bay and Climate Change: Are Warming Spring Air Temperatures the “Ultimate” Survival Control Factor?” Ecological Complexity 4: 73–84.

[27] Ebensperger, L. A., D. S. Rivera, and L. D. Hayes. 2012. “Direct Fitness of Group Living Mammals Varies With Breeding Strategy, Climate and Fitness Estimates.” Journal of Animal Ecology, 1013–1023.

[28] Ehbrecht, M., D. Seidel, P. Annighöfer, et al. 2021. “Global Patterns and Climatic Controls of Forest Structural Complexity.” Nature Communications 12: 519.

[29] Ferguson, S. H., and S. Larivière. 2002. “Can Comparing Life Histories Help Conserve Carnivores?” Animal Conservation 5: 1–12.

[30] Ferguson, S. H., and S. Lariviere. 2008. “How Social Behaviour Links Environment and Body Size in Mammalian Carnivores.” Open Ecology Journal 1: 1–7.

[31] Ferretti, F., S. Lovari, M. Lucherini, M. Hayward, and P. A. Stephens. 2020. “Only the Largest Terrestrial Carnivores Increase Their Dietary Breadth With Increasing Prey Richness.” Mammal Review 50: 291–303.

[32] Fisher, D. N., R. J. Kilgour, E. R. Siracusa, et al. 2021. “Anticipated Effects of Abiotic Environmental Change on Intraspecific Social Interactions.” Biological Reviews 96: 2661–2693.

[33] Gaynor, K. M., B. Abrahms, K. R. Manlove, W. K. Oestreich, and J. A. Smith. 2024. “Anthropogenic Impacts at the Interface of Animal Spatial and Social Behaviour.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 379: 20220527.

[34] Gilchrist, J. S., A. P. Jennings, G. Veron, and P. Cavallini. 2009. “Family Herpestidae.” In Handbook of the Mammals of the World, edited by D. E. Wilson and R. A. Mittermeier. Lynx Ediciones.

[35] Gittleman, J. L. 1985. “Carnivore Body Size: Ecological and Taxonomic Correlates.” Oecologia 67: 540–554.

[36] Gittleman . 1989a. Carnivore Behavior, Ecology, and Evolution. Springer US.

[37] Gittleman . 1989b. “Carnivore Group Living: Comparative Trends.” In Carnivore Behavior, Ecology, and Evolution, edited by J. L. Gittleman, 183–207. Springer US.

[38] Gittleman, J. L., and P. H. Harvey. 1982. “Carnivore Home-Range Size, Metabolic Needs and Ecology.” Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 10, no. 1: 57–63.

[39] Grace, J. B., T. M. Anderson, H. Olff, and S. M. Scheiner. 2010. “On the Specification of Structural Equation Models for Ecological Systems.” Ecological Monographs 80: 67–87.

[40] Groenewoud, F., and T. Clutton-Brock. 2021. “Meerkat Helpers Buffer the Detrimental Effects of Adverse Environmental Conditions on Fecundity, Growth and Survival.” Journal of Animal Ecology 90: 641–652.

[41] Haskell, J. P., M. E. Ritchie, and H. Olff. 2002. “Fractal Geometry Predicts Varying Body Size Scaling Relationships for Mammal and Bird Home Ranges.” Nature 418, no. 6897: 527–530.

[42] Hawkins, B. A., R. Field, H. V. Cornell, et al. 2003. “Energy, Water, and Broad-Scale Geographic Patterns of Species Richness.” Ecology 84: 3105–3117.

[43] Hillebrand, H., and A. I. Azovsky. 2001. “Body Size Determines the Strength of the Latitudinal Diversity Gradient.” Ecography 24, no. 3: 251–256.

[44] Hunter, L., and P. Barrett. 2018. Field Guide to Carnivores of the World. Bloomsbury Wildlife.

[45] Isaac, J. 2009. “Effects of Climate Change on Life History: Implications for Extinction Risk in Mammals.” Endangered Species Research 7: 115–123.

[46] IUCN. 2019. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species.

[47] Janis, C. M., J. Damuth, and J. M. Theodor. 2000. “Miocene Ungulates and Terrestrial Primary Productivity: Where Have all the Browsers Gone?” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 97, no. 14: 7899–7904.

[48] Jetz, W., C. Carbone, J. Fulford, and J. H. Brown. 2004. “The Scaling of Animal Space Use.” Science 306: 266–268.

[49] Johnson, D. D. P., W. Jetz, and D. W. Macdonald. 2002. “Environmental Correlates of Badger Social Spacing Across Europe.” Journal of Biogeography 29, no. 3: 411–425.

[50] Jones, K. E., J. Bielby, M. Cardillo, et al. 2009. “Pantheria: A Species-Level Database of Life History, Ecology, and Geography of Extant and Recently Extinct Mammals: Ecological Archives E090-184.” Ecology 90: 2648.

[51] Kappeler, P. M., L. Barrett, D. T. Blumstein, and T. H. Clutton-Brock. 2013. “Constraints and Flexibility in Mammalian Social Behaviour: Introduction and Synthesis.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 368, no. 1618: 20120337.

[52] Karanth, K. U., A. Srivathsa, D. Vasudev, M. Puri, R. Parameshwaran, and N. Kumar. 2017. “Spatio-Temporal Interactions Facilitate Large Carnivore Sympatry Across a Resource Gradient.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 284, no. 1848.

[53] Kirk, D. A., A. C. Park, A. C. Smith, et al. 2018. “Our Use, Misuse, and Abandonment of a Concept: Whither Habitat?” Ecology and Evolution 8, no. 8: 4197–4208.

[54] Knight, M. H., A. S. V. Jaarsveld, and M. G. L. Mills. 1992. “Allo-Suckling in Spotted Hyaenas (Crocuta crocuta): An Example of Behavioural Flexibility in Carnivores.” African Journal of Ecology 30: 245–251.

[55] Komdeur, J., and L. Ma. 2021. “Keeping Up With Environmental Change: The Importance of Sociality.” Ethology 127, no. 10: 790–807.

[56] Komsta, L., and F. Novomestky. 2015. “Moments, Cumulants, Skewness, Kurtosis and Related Tests.” R package version 14, no. 1.

[57] Krausman, P. R., and M. L. Morrison. 2016. “Another Plea for Standard Terminology.” Journal of Wildlife Management 80, no. 7: 1143–1144.

[58] Lamb, C. T., G. Mowat, S. L. Gilbert, B. N. McLellan, S. E. Nielsen, and S. Boutin. 2017. “Density-Dependent Signaling: An Alternative Hypothesis on the Function of Chemical Signaling in a Non-Territorial Solitary Carnivore.” PLoS One 12: e0184176.

[59] Lefcheck, J. S. 2016. “Piecewisesem: Piecewise Structural Equation Modelling Inrfor Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics.” Methods in Ecology and Evolution 7: 573–579.

[60] Li, D., and A. R. Ives. 2017. “The Statistical Need to Include Phylogeny in Trait-Based Analyses of Community Composition.” Methods in Ecology and Evolution 8, no. 10: 1192–1199.

[61] Li, F., Z. Luo, C. Li, C. Li, and Z. Jiang. 2013. “Biogeographical Patterns of the Diet of Palearctic Badger: Is Badger An Earthworm Specialist Predator?” Chinese Science Bulletin 58: 2255–2261.

[62] Lindstedt, S. L., B. J. Miller, and S. W. Buskirk. 1986. “Home Range, Time, and Body Size in Mammals.” Ecology 67, no. 2: 413–418.

[63] Lislevand, T., J. Figuerola, and T. Székely. 2007. “Avian Body Sizes in Relation to Fecundity, Mating System, Display Behavior, and Resource Sharing: Ecological Archives E088-096.” Ecology 88: 1605.

[64] Maag, N., M. Paniw, G. Cozzi, M. Manser, T. Clutton-Brock, and A. Ozgul. 2022. “Dispersal Decreases Survival but Increases Reproductive Opportunities for Subordinates in a Cooperative Breeder.” American Naturalist 199, no. 5: 679–690.

[65] Macdonald, D. W. 1983. “The Ecology of Carnivore Social Behaviour.” Nature 301: 379–384.

[66] Macdonald, D. W. and Sillero-Zubiri, C., 2004. The biology and conservation of wild canids. OUP Oxford.

[67] MacNulty, D. R., D. W. Smith, L. D. Mech, J. A. Vucetich, and C. Packer. 2012. “Nonlinear Effects of Group Size on the Success of Wolves Hunting Elk.” Behavioral Ecology 23: 75–82.

[68] De Magalhães, J. P., and J. Costa. 2009. “A Database of Vertebrate Longevity Records and Their Relation to Other Life-History Traits.” Journal of Evolutionary Biology 22: 1770–1774.

[69] Manlik, O. 2019. “The Importance of Reproduction for the Conservation of Slow-Growing Animal Populations.” In Reproductive Sciences in Animal Conservation, Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology, edited by P. Comizzoli, J. L. Brown, and W. V. Holt, 13–39. Springer International Publishing.

[70] McGregor, H., S. Legge, M. E. Jones, and C. N. Johnson. 2015. “Feral Cats Are Better Killers in Open Habitats, Revealed by Animal-Borne Video.” PLoS One 10, no. 8: e0133915.

[71] Meiri, S., Y. Yom-Tov, and E. Geffen. 2007. “What Determines Conformity to Bergmann's Rule?” Global Ecology and Biogeography 16, no. 6: 788–794.

[72] Molina-Vacas, G., V. Bonet-Arboli, E. Rafart-Plaza, and J. Rodriguez-Teijeiro. 2009. Spatial ecology of European badgers (Meles meles L.) In Mediterranean habitats of the north-eastern Iberian Peninsula. I: Home range size, spatial distribution and social organization. Vie et milieu/Life & Environment 223.-232.

[73] Montgomery, T. M., E. L. Pendleton, and J. E. Smith. 2018. “Physiological Mechanisms Mediating Patterns of Reproductive Suppression and Alloparental Care in Cooperatively Breeding Carnivores.” Physiology & Behavior 193: 167–178.

[74] Muro, C., R. Escobedo, L. Spector, and R. P. Coppinger. 2011. “Wolf-Pack (Canis lupus) Hunting Strategies Emerge From Simple Rules in Computational Simulations.” Behavioural Processes 88: 192–197.

[75] Myneni, R., Y. Knyazikhin, and T. Park. 2015. MYD15A2H MODIS/Aqua Leaf Area Index/FPAR 8-Day L4 Global 500m SIN Grid V006. NASA EODIS Land Processes DAAC.

[76] Owen-Smith, N., and M. G. Mills. 2008. “Predator–Prey Size Relationships in an African Large-Mammal Food Web.” Journal of Animal Ecology 77, no. 1: 173–183.

[77] Ozgul, A., A. W. Bateman, S. English, T. Coulson, and T. H. Clutton-Brock. 2014. “Linking Body Mass and Group Dynamics in An Obligate Cooperative Breeder.” Journal of Animal Ecology 83: 1357–1366.

[78] Pangle, W. M., and K. E. Holekamp. 2010. “Functions of Vigilance Behaviour in a Social Carnivore, the Spotted Hyaena, Crocuta crocuta.” Animal Behaviour 80: 257–267.

[79] Paradis, E., and K. Schliep. 2019. “Ape 5.0: An Environment for Modern Phylogenetics and Evolutionary Analyses in R.” Bioinformatics 35: 526–528.

[80] Rabaiotti, D., T. Coulson, and R. Woodroffe. 2023. “Climate Change Is Predicted to Cause Population Collapse in a Cooperative Breeder.” Global Change Biology 29: 6002–6017.

[81] Radeloff, V. C., M. Dubinin, N. C. Coops, et al. 2019. “The Dynamic Habitat Indices (Dhis) From Modis and Global Biodiversity.” Remote Sensing of Environment 222: 204–214.

[82] Ramos-Fernández, G., D. Boyer, and V. P. Gómez. 2006. “A Complex Social Structure With Fission–Fusion Properties can Emerge From a Simple Foraging Model.” Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 60, no. 4: 536–549.

[83] Reed, R. A., M. E. Finley, W. H. Romme, and M. G. Turner. 1999. “Aboveground net Primary Production and Leaf-Area Index in Early Postfire Vegetation in Yellowstone National Park.” Ecosystems 2, no. 1: 88–94.

[84] Revilla, E., and F. Palomares. 2002. “Spatial Organization, Group Living and Ecological Correlates in Low-Density Populations of Eurasian Badgers, Meles meles.” Journal of Animal Ecology 71, no. 3: 497–512.

[85] Revilla, E., F. Palomares, and N. Fernández. 2001. “Characteristics, Location and Selection of Diurnal Resting Dens by Eurasian Badgers (Meles Meles) in a Low Density Area.” Journal of Zoology 255, no. 3: 291–299.

[86] Rode, K. D., E. V. Regehr, D. C. Douglas, et al. 2014. “Variation in the Response of An Arctic Top Predator Experiencing Habitat Loss: Feeding and Reproductive Ecology of Two Polar Bear Populations.” Global Change Biology 20, no. 1: 76–88.

[87] Rogers, L. M., C. L. Cheeseman, P. J. Mallinson, and R. Clifton-Hadley. 1997. “The Demography of a High-Density Badger (Meles meles) Population in the West of England.” Journal of Zoology 242, no. 4: 705–728.

[88] Saimun, M. S. R., and M. R. Karim. 2025. “Climatic Drivers of Leaf Area Index Dynamics in the Amazon Basin: Insights From Remote Sensing.” Theoretical and Applied Climatology 156: 448.

[89] Salguero-Gómez, R. 2024. “More Social Species Live Longer, Have Longer Generation Times and Longer Reproductive Windows.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 379, no. 1916: 20220459.

[90] Santema, P., and T. Clutton-Brock. 2013. “Meerkat Helpers Increase Sentinel Behaviour and Bipedal Vigilance in the Presence of Pups.” Animal Behaviour 85: 655–661.

[91] Schaller, G. B. 2009. The Serengeti lion: A Study of Predator-Prey Relations. University of Chicago Press.

[92] Smith, J. E., E. M. Swanson, D. Reed, and K. E. Holekamp. 2012. “Evolution of Cooperation Among Mammalian Carnivores and Its Relevance to Hominin Evolution.” Current Anthropology 53: S436–S452.

[93] Sparkman, A. M., J. Adams, A. Beyer, T. D. Steury, L. Waits, and D. L. Murray. 2011. “Helper Effects on Pup Lifetime Fitness in the Cooperatively Breeding Red Wolf (Canis rufus).” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 278: 1381–1389.

[94] Speakman, J. R. 2005. “Body Size, Energy Metabolism and Lifespan.” Journal of Experimental Biology 208, no. 9: 1717–1730.

[95] Stevens, G. C. 1989. “The Latitudinal Gradient in Geographical Range: How So Many Species Coexist in the Tropics.” American Naturalist 133, no. 2: 240–256.

[96] Terborgh, J. W. 2015. “Toward a Trophic Theory of Species Diversity.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 112: 11415–11422.

[97] Togunov, R. R., A. E. Derocher, N. J. Lunn, and M. Auger-Méthé. 2022. “Drivers of Polar Bear Behavior and the Possible Effects of Prey Availability on Foraging Strategy.” Movement Ecology 10, no. 1: 1–20.

[98] Townsend, S. W., M. Zöttl, and M. B. Manser. 2011. “All Clear? Meerkats Attend to Contextual Information in Close Calls to Coordinate Vigilance.” Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 65: 1927–1934.

[99] Tucker, M. A., T. J. Ord, and T. L. Rogers. 2014. “Evolutionary Predictors of Mammalian Home Range Size: Body Mass, Diet and the Environment.” Global Ecology and Biogeography 23: 1105–1114.

[100] Tuomi, J. 1980. “Mammalian Reproductive Strategies: A Generalized Relation of Litter Size to Body Size.” Oecologia 45, no. 1: 39–44.

[101] Ward, A., and M. Webster. 2016. Sociality: The Behaviour of Group-Living Animals 407. Springer.

[102] Wilson, D. E., and R. A. Mittermeier. 2009. Handbook of the mammals of the world. Vol. 1. Carnivores. Lynx Ediciones, Barcelona.

[103] Woodroffe, R. 1995. “Body Condition Affects Implantation Date in the European Badger, Meles Meles.” Journal of Zoology 236: 183–188.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2025 The Author(s). Wildlife Letters published by Northeast Forestry University and John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd.