A narrative review of stroke incidence, risk factors and treatment in Indigenous Peoples of the world

Abstract

Stroke is the second leading cause of death and the third greatest cause of disability worldwide. In some countries, stroke disproportionally affects Indigenous Peoples, with greater incidence and mortality at younger ages, higher rates of conventional cardiovascular risk factors and lower treatment rates. Worldwide there are 470 million Indigenous Peoples, residing in 90 countries. Analogous to the general health of all populations, the cause of stroke and its outcomes are the result of complex interactions between factors that act at societal, service, and individual levels. Colonisation, including the cultural and material losses associated with it, is a major indirect driver of disparities in lifestyle, biological and other risk factors for stroke in Indigenous Peoples. In addition, structural racism and the inability to access culturally safe education, employment and health care, further contribute to stroke health inequities for Indigenous Peoples globally. In this narrative review we provide an outline of stroke incidence rates, common risk factors for stroke, treatment rates with intravenous thrombolysis and endovascular clot retrieval in adult Indigenous populations in comparison to the non-Indigenous population of the same region. Our objective is to describe the differences that exist between the Indigenous and non-Indigenous populations with stroke in a particular region and discuss potential solutions that support a “strengths-based” approach driven by Indigenous People.

Keywords

Stroke / Indigenous Peoples / first nations / incidence / risk factors / treatment / management

References

[1] United-Nations.org [internet]. Background - International Day of the World’s Indigenous Peoples | United Nations. Available from: https://www.un.org/en/observances/Indigenous-day/background. [Last accessed on 6 Apr 2020]

[2] World Health Organisation, 2020. Health Topics: Indigenous Populations. Available from: https://www.who.int/topics/health_services_indigenous/en/. [Last accessed on 6 Apr 2021]

[3] Gracey M.Indigenous health part 1: determinants and disease patterns.Lancet2009;374:65-75

[4] Paradies Y.Colonisation, racism and Indigenous health.Journal of Population Research2016;33:83-96

[5] Anand SS,Arbour L.Explaining the variability in cardiovascular risk factors among First Nations communities in Canada: a population-based study.Lancet Planet Health2019;3:e511-e20

[6] King M,Gracey M.Indigenous health part 2: the underlying causes of the health gap.Lancet2009;374:76-85

[7] Feigin VL,Mensah GA.Global Burden of Stroke.Circulation Research2017;120:439-48.

[8] Feigin VL,Krishnamurthi R.Global and regional burden of stroke during 1990-2010: findings from the Global Burden of Disease Study 2010.Lancet2014;383:245-54 PMCID:PMC4181600

[9] Feigin VL,Bennett DA,Parag V.Worldwide stroke incidence and early case fatality reported in 56 population-based studies: a systematic review.Lancet Neurol2009;8:355-69

[10] Strong K,Bonita R.Preventing stroke: saving lives around the world.Lancet Neurol2007;6:182-7

[11] Balabanski AH,Leyden JM.Excess stroke incidence in young Aboriginal people in South Australia: 946 pooled results from two population-based studies.Int J Stroke2018;13:811-14

[12] Anderson I,Connolly M.Indigenous and tribal peoples’ health (The Lancet-Lowitja Institute Global Collaboration): a population study.Lancet2016;388:131-57

[13] Ferrari R.Writing narrative style literature review.Medical Writing2015;24(4):230-5

[14] Katzenellenbogen JM,Somerford P,Semmens JB.Burden of stroke in Indigenous Western Australians: a study using data linkage.Stroke2011;42:1515-21

[15] Balabanski AH,Giarola B.Stroke incidence and subtypes in Aboriginal people in remote Australia: a healthcare network population-based study.BMJ Open2020;10:e03953 PMCID:PMC7545633

[16] You J,Zhao Y.Stroke incidence and case-fatality among Indigenous and non-Indigenous populations in the Northern Territory of Australia, 1999-2011.Int J Stroke2015;10:716-22

[17] Feigin VL,Barker-Collo S.ARCOS IV Group30-year trends in stroke rates and outcome in Auckland, New Zealand (1981-2012): A Multi-Ethnic Population-Based Series of Studies.PLoS One2015;10:e0134609 PMCID:PMC4546383

[18] Waloki M,Tikolevu L,Bissell K.Stroke rehabilitation in Fiji: are patients receiving services?.Public Health Action2014;4:150-4 PMCID:PMC4533805

[19] Zhao Y,D’Souza W.An epidemiological survey of stroke in Lhasa, Tibet, China.Strok41:2739-43

[20] Zimhony N,Sagy I.Increase in ischemic stroke incident hospitalizations among Bedouin Arabs during ramadan month.J Am Heart Assoc2018;7:e008018 PMCID:PMC6015316

[21] Zhang MY,Welty OT.Incidence and risk factors for stroke in American Indians: The Strong Heart Study.Circulation2008;118:1577-84 PMCID:PMC2754380

[22] Harris R,Muller C.Stroke in American Indians and Alaska Natives: A Systematic Review.Am J Public Health2015;105:e16-e26 PMCID:PMC4504319

[23] Muller CJ,Forster J.Stroke incidence and survival in American Indians, Blacks, and Whites: The Strong Heart Study and atherosclerosis risk in Communities Study.J Am Heart Assoc2019;8:e010229 PMCID:PMC6645631

[24] Boden-Albala B,Roberts ET,Trimble B.Ascertainment of Alaska Native Stroke Incidence, 2005-2009: Lessons for Assessing the Global Burden of Stroke.J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis2017;26:2019-26

[25] Sacco RL,Gan R.Stroke incidence among white, black, and Hispanic residents of an urban community: the Northern Manhattan Stroke Study.Am J Epidemiol1998;147:259-68

[26] Hu XF,Kenny TA.Prevalence of heart attack and stroke and associated risk factors among Inuit in Canada: A comparison with the general Canadian population.Int J Hyg Environ Health2019;222:319-26

[27] Martens PJ,Prior HJ.What is the comparative health status and associated risk factors for the Métis?.BMC Public Health2011;11:814 PMCID:PMC3257314

[28] Saposnik G.Iberoamerican Society of Cerebrovascular DiseasesStroke in South America: a systematic review of incidence, prevalence, and stroke subtypes.Stroke2003;34:2103-7

[29] United Nations Statistics Division. United Nations 2020. Available from: https://unstats.un.org/unsd/demographic-social/products/dyb/index.cshtml. [Last accessed on 6 Apr 2021]

[30] Heckmann JG,Galeoto J.The incidence of neurological disorders in tropical South America. Experience in the Bolivian lowlands.Fortschr Neurol Psychiatr1997;65:291-6

[31] Mienna C, Axelsson P. Somatic health in the Indigenous Sami population - a systematic review.Int J Circumpolar Health2019;78:1638195 PMCID:PMC6610513

[32] Sjölander P,Janlert U.Stroke and acute myocardial infarction in the Swedish Sami population: Incidence and mortality in relation to income and level of education.Scand J Public Health2008;36:84-91

[33] Chugunova SA.The ethnic differences of stroke in Yakutia.Int J Circumpolar Health2013;72 PMCID:PMC3754494

[34] World Health Organisation. Cardiovascular disease. Available from: https://www.who.int/cardiovascular_diseases/resources/atlas/en/. [Last accessed on 6 Apr 2021]

[35] Harris R,Muller C.Stroke in American Indians and Alaska natives: a systematic review.Am J Public Health2015;105:e16-26 PMCID:PMC4504319

[36] Katzenellenbogen JM,Sanfilippo FM,Thompson SC.Prevalence of stroke and coexistent conditions: disparities between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Western Australians.Int J Stroke2014;9:61-8

[37] Owolabi M,Howard VJ.SIREN-REGARDS Collaboration (Stroke Investigative Research and Educational Network-Reasons for Geographic and Racial Differences in Stroke)Stroke in Indigenous Africans, African Americans and European Americans. Interplay of racial and geographic factors.Stroke2017;48:1169-75 PMCID:PMC5404953

[38] Siri SR,Jacobsen BK.Changes in conventional cardiovascular risk factors and the estimated 10-year risk of acute myocardial infarction or cerebral stroke in Sami and non-Sami populations in two population-based cross-sectional surveys: the SAMINOR Study.BMJ Open2019;9:e028939 PMCID:PMC6661668

[39] Sacco RL,Broderick JP.Risk Factors.Stroke1997;28:1507-17

[40] Kilkenny M,Ritchie E,Cadilhac D.Hospital management and outcomes of stroke in Indigenous Australians: evidence from the 2009 Acute Care National Stroke Audit.Int J Stroke2013;8:164-171

[41] Dos Santos A,Jude M.A prospective analysis of stroke recognition, stroke risk factors, thrombolysis rates and outcomes in Indigenous Australians from a large rural referral hospital.Intern Med J2020;

[42] Tiedeman C,Julien B,Oakley P.Management of stroke in the Australian Indigenous population: From hospitals to communities.Intern Med J2019;49:962-8

[43] Gardiner FW,Dos Santos A.Aeromedical retrieval for stroke in Australia.Cerebrovasc Dis2020;49:334-40

[44] Nakagawa K,Asai SM,Seto TB.Disparities among Asians and Native Hawaiians and Pacific Islanders with ischemic stroke.Neurology2013;80:839-43 PMCID:PMC3598459

[45] Churchwell K,Benjamin R,Change E.Call to action: Structural Racism as a fundamental driver of health disparities: A presidential advisory from the American Heart Association.Circulation2020;142:454-68

[46] Nakagawa K,Seto TB,Chang CW.Racial Disparities among Native Hawaiians and Pacific Islanders with intracerebral hemorrhage.Neurology2012;79:675-80 PMCID:PMC3414664

[47] Nakagawa K,Asai SM.Stroke Disparities: Disaggregating Native Hawaiians from other Pacific Islanders.Ethn Dis2015;25:157-61 PMCID:PMC4487777

[48] Akpalu A,Ovbiagele B.Phenotyping Stroke in Sub-Saharan Africa: Stroke Investigative Research and Education Network (SIREN) Phenomics Protocol.Neuroepidemiology2015;45:73-82. PMCID:PMC4604029

[49] Howard VJ,Pulley L.The reasons for geographic and racial differences in stroke study: objectives and design.Neuroepidemiology2005;25:135-43

[50] Soto A,Provoste R.Association between Mapuche Ethnicity and Stroke: A Case-Control Study.J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis2019;28:1311-6

[51] Del Brutto OH,Montalvan M.Cardiovascular health status and metabolic syndrome in Ecuadorian Natives/Mestizos aged 40 years or more with and without stroke and ischaemic heart disease - An Atahualpa Project Case-Control Nested Study.J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis2014;23:643-8

[52] He VY,You J,Burrow JN.Adverse outcome after incident stroke hospitalisation for Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians in the Northern Territory.Int J Stroke2015;10:89-95

[53] McGorrian C,Islam S.Estimating modifiable coronary heart disease risk in multiple regions of the world: the INTERHEART Modifiable Risk Score.Eur Heart J2011;32:581-89

[54] Siri SRA,Jacobsen BK,Eliassen BM.Distribution of risk factors for cardiovascular disease and the estimated 10-year risk of acute myocardial infarction or cerebral stroke in Sami and non-Sami populations: The SAMINOR-2 Clinical survey.Scand J Public Health2018;46:638-46 PMCID:PMC6094547

[55] Nystad T,Selmer R.Distribution of apoB/apoA-1 ratio and blood lipids in Sami, Kven and Norwegian populations: the SAMINOR study.Int J Circumpolar Health2008;67:67-81

[56] Selmer R,Ariansen I.NORRISK 2: A Norwegian risk model for acute cerebral stroke and myocardial infarction.Eur J Prev Cardiol2017;24:773-82.

[57] Hung KH,Hsu KN.Disparities in Ischaemic Stroke Subtypes and Risk Factors between Taiwanese Aborigines and Han Chinese in Taitung, Taiwan.Int J Gerontol2016;10:17-21

[58] Langhorne P,Gilchrist W.Do stroke units save lives?.Lancet1993;342:395-8

[59] Emberson J,Lyden P.Effect of treatment delay, age, and stroke severity on the effects of intravenous thrombolysis with alteplase for acute ischaemic stroke: a meta-analysis of individual patient data from randomised trials.Lancet2014;384:1929-35 PMCID:PMC4441266

[60] Parsons M,Bivard A.A randomised trial of tenecteplase versus alteplase for acute ischemic stroke.N Engl J Med2012;366:1099-107

[61] Goyal M,Zwam WH.Endovascular thrombectomy after large-vessel ischaemic stroke: a meta-analysis of individual patient data from five randomised trials.Lancet2016;387:1723-31

[62] Kapral MK,Green ME.Hospital admission for stroke or transient ischemic attack among First Nations people with diabetes in Ontario: a population-based cohort study.CMAJ Open2020;8:156-62 PMCID:PMC7082109

[63] Attenello FJ,Wen G.Racial and socioeconomic disparities in access to mechanical revascularisation procedures for acute ischemic stroke.J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis2014;23:327-34 PMCID:PMC4467551

[64] Kimball M,Waters M.Race and income disparities in ischemic stroke care: Nationwide inpatient sample database, 2002 to 2008.J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis2014;23:17-24

[65] Hsia AW,Morgenstern LB.Racial disparities in tissue plasminogen activator treatment rate for stroke. A Population-Based Study.Stroke2011;42:2217-21 PMCID:PMC3148849

[66] Reed SD,Blough DK,Jarvik JG.Treatment with tissue plasminogen activator and inpatient mortality rates for patients with ischaemic stroke treated in community hospitals.Stroke2001;32:1832-40

[67] Johnson SC,Gillum LA.Utilisation of intravenous tissue-type plasminogen activator for ischemic stroke at academic medical centers: the influence of ethnicity: editorial comment: it is time to implement stroke practice improvement programs and prevent the racial disparity in stroke care.Stroke2001;32:1061-8

[68] Aparicio HJ,Kasner SE.Racial disparities in intravenous recombinant tissue plasminogen activator use persist at primary stroke centers.JAHA2015;4:e001877 PMCID:PMC4845141

[69] Brinjikji W,McDonald JS.Socioeconomic disparities in the utilisation of mechanical thrombectomy for acute ischemic stroke in US hospitals.AJNR Am J Neuroradiol2014;35:553-6 PMCID:PMC7964730

[70] Brinjikji W,Cloft HJ.Socioeconomic disparities in the utilisation of mechanical thrombectomy for acute ischemic stroke.J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis2014;23:979-84

[71] Blacker D.Indigenous stroke care: differences, challenges and a need for change.Intern Med J2019;49:945-7

[72] Dalton R.Tribe blasts 'exploitation' of blood samples.Nature2002;420:111

[73] Mello MM.The Havasupai Indian Tribe Case - Lessons for Research Involving Stored Biologic Samples.NEJM2010;363:204-7

[74] Ortiz-Prado E,Gómez-Barreno L.Potential research ethics violations against an indigenous tribe in Ecuador: a mixed methods approach.BMC Med Ethics2020;21:100 PMCID:PMC7568418

[75] Emberson J,Lyden P,Albers G.Effect of treatment delay, age, and stroke severity on the effects of intravenous thrombolysis with alteplase for acute ischaemic stroke: a meta-analysis of individual patient data from randomised trials.Lancet2014;384:1929-35 PMCID:PMC4441266

[76] Cruz-Flores S,Biller J.Racial-ethnic disparities in stroke care: The American experience: A statement for healthcare professionals from the American Heart Association / American Stroke Association.Stroke2011;42:2091-116

[77] Cramer SC,Brown DM.Organization of a United States county system for comprehensive acute stroke care.Stroke2012;43:1089-93 PMCID:PMC3314728

[78] Lazaridis C,Jauch EC.Telestroke in South Carolina.J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis2013;22:946-50

[79] Zhao Y,You J,He V.Assessing improvements in survival for stroke patients in the Northern Territory 1992-2013: a marginal structural analysis.Aust Health Rev2015;39:437-43

[80] Sandiford P,Ghafel M.Are ethnic inequalities in 30-day ischaemic stroke survival emerging as treatment becomes more effective?.N Z Med J2016;129:8-14

[81] Kukutai T. Indigenous data sovereignty: towards an agenda. Canberra: Australian National University; 2016.

[82] Carroll ,Garba ,Figueroa-Rodríguez .The CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance.Data Science Journal2020;19:43

[83] Potvin L.No research about “them” without “them”: CJPH policy with regard to publication of health research on First Nations, Inuit, Métis and Indigenous Peoples.Can J Public Health2020;111:818-21

[84] NPY Women’s Council Aboriginal Corporation. Traditional Healers of Central Australia: Ngangkari. Australia: Magabala Books; 2013.