Sustainable Efficiency Optimization for Synchronously Integrated Urban Rail Transit: SIMILP—A Hybrid Enhanced Approach Balancing Economy, Safety, and Capacity

Abstract

Integrated urban rail transit (IUR) systems are vital for the resilience of global megacities; however, integrating heterogeneous networks presents profound challenges due to technical disparities to operational paralysis. This paper proposes a sustainable efficiency assessment framework utilizing a synchronous integration mixed-integer linear programming (SIMILP) model to reconcile economic revenue with technical safety constraints, effectively addressing limitations of traditional MILP models in managing nonlinear technical compatibility. We established a multi-criteria compatibility matrix,

{\text{Kf}}_{\text{soe}}

\documentclass[12pt]{minimal}\usepackage{amsmath}\usepackage{wasysym}\usepackage{amsfonts}\usepackage{amssymb}\usepackage{amsbsy}\usepackage{mathrsfs}\usepackage{upgreek}\setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt}\begin{document}$${\text{Kf}}_{\text{s}\text{o}\text{e}}$$\end{document}

, by quantifying safety integrity levels (SIL), grades of automation (GoA), and type of alignment (TOA) through a geometric mean methodology. A Hybrid Quadratic Programming (QP) model, augmented by a Penalty Function and executed via SIMILP model, was developed to optimize operational frequencies (

X_{\text{opt}}

\documentclass[12pt]{minimal}\usepackage{amsmath}\usepackage{wasysym}\usepackage{amsfonts}\usepackage{amssymb}\usepackage{amsbsy}\usepackage{mathrsfs}\usepackage{upgreek}\setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt}\begin{document}$${X}_{\text{o}\text{p}\text{t}}$$\end{document}

) across ten distinct rail modes, including Metro (MS, MX), Commuter Rail (CS, CC), and Light Rail (LL). The study identifies a “Technical Gold Standard” in the MS-CS corridor (100% compatibility) while revealing “Technical Valleys” (efficiency < 30%) in lines such as MX due to safety-risk thresholds. Comparative analysis reveals that while conventional cost-minimization models lead to service shutdowns for branch lines, our SIMILP-based Enhanced Hybrid model restores 100% connectivity with an MX line capacity reaching 45 trips/h. To achieve sustainability, the model accepts a 39.28% increase in net operating costs, reviving frequencies from 0 to 27 trips/h for low-revenue corridors while anchoring capacity of decisive lines. This research proves that synchronous integration urban rail transit (SIUR) is a transition, providing a scalable tool to harmonize technical rigor with socioeconomic welfare, ensuring the high performance of assets is not compromised by system components.

Keywords

Integrated urban rail transit / Heterogeneous rail networks / Synchronous integration mixed-integer linear programming / Hybrid enhanced optimization / Quadratic programming / Network resilience

References

[1] Wei Y, Yang X, Xiao X, Ma Z, Zhu T, Dou F, Wu J, Chen A, Gao Z. Understanding the resilience of urban rail transit: concepts, reviews and trends. Engineering, 2024, 41: 7-18

[2] Lytton D. Through running and integration of FRA and FTA regulated passenger trains. Transp Res Rec, 2022, 2677: 875-888

[3] Lu F, Wang L, Hu J, Zhang Q, Li X. Integrated Optimization of train diagrams and rolling stock circulation with full-length and short-turn routes. Appl Sci, 2024, 14: 5006

[4] Wang T, An Z, Wang K, Zhang X. Integrated position and speed control for rail transit doors based on speed-current loop. IEEE Trans Ind Appl, 2023, 59: 4651-4661

[5] Dai Ziwen SUN, Yonghai QINQ. Integrated development of the stock land and urban rail transit in Shenzhen. Urban Transp China, 2023, 21(4): 21-31

[6] Carrese S, Sportiello S, Zhaksylykov T, Colombaroni C, Carrese S, Papaveri M, Patella SM. The integration of shared autonomous vehicles in public transportation services: a systematic review. Sustainability, 2023, 15: 13023

[7] Wang X, Lv Y, Sun H, Xu G, Qu Y, Wu J. A simulation-based metro train scheduling optimization incorporating multimodal coordination. Transp Res Part C, 2023, 146: 103964

[8] Flesser M, Shalaby A, Friedrich B. Integration of urban aerial cable cars into public transit: Operational capacity limits due to passenger queuing at stations. J Public Transp, 2024, 26: 100094

[9] Le Tien Hai T, Thi Thuy An T, Lu Phuong N, Thai Bao T, Thi Kim T (2025) Development of an index system to evaluate the readiness of transport infrastructure for the transition to climate-smart transportation. In: IOP conference series: earth and environmental science, vol 1539. IOP Publishing, p 012011

[10] Tuan NT, Hegedüs G, Phuong NT. Urbanization and forecast possibilities of land use changes by 2050: Ho Chi Minh City. Open Agric, 2025, 10: 20250421

[11] Nguyen TK, Le TN (2025) Analyzing coincident factors of public electric vehicles in Ho Chi Minh City: a Monte Carlo approach. J Tech Educ Sci

[12] Vuchic VR. Urban transit: operations, planning, and economics, 2017Wiley

[13] Van DD, Thai N, Hong LX. An In-depth investigation of innovative electric traction power supply systems for mass rapid transit. Eng Tech Appl Sci Res, 2023, 13: 12245-12252

[14] Van DD, Thai N, Hong LX. Feasibility study of traction power supply for medium-capacity rail system: Pham Van Dong Route. Appl Sci, 2024, 14: 5186

[15] Thai N, Van Doan D. A Research on passenger carrying capacity of an innovative electric traction power supply system based on ROCS of 750 V DC MRT. Eng Tech Appl Sci Res, 2024, 14(4): 15033-15038

[16] Czerliński M, Pawłowski P. Capacity of zero-emission urban public transport. Sustainability, 2025, 17: 5835

[17] Wei J, Long K, Gu J, Ju QQ, Zhu P. Optimizing bus line based on metro-bus integration. Sustainability, 2020, 12: 1493

[18] Huang J. Integrated layout and transfer of urban rail transit hubs. J Arch Res Dev, 2022, 6: 48-54

[19] Geng J, Zhang C, Yang L, Meng F, Qi J. Integrated scheduling of metro trains and shuttle buses with a passenger flow control strategy on an oversaturated metro line. Comput Ind Eng, 2024, 189 ArticleID: 109980

[20] Wang L, Pang Z, Li L, Peng Q. Enhancing urban rail network capacity through integrated route design and TOD. Mathematics, 2025, 13(16): 2558

[21] Yang Y, Huang H, Li G, Han B, Yuan Z, Ma H. A systematic review of resilience assessment and enhancement of urban integrated transportation networks. J Transp Geogr, 2025

[22] Wang L, Chen X, Li L. Integrating urban rail transit network reserve capacity analysis with rapid line planning within the metropolitan area. Int J Rail Transp, 2025, 14: 109

[23] Wang X, Lv Y, Sun H, Xu G, Qu Y, Wu J. A simulation-based metro train scheduling optimization incorporating multimodal coordination and flexible routing plans. Transp Res Part C: Emerg Tech, 2023, 14: 103964

[24] Yin P, Peng M. Station layout optimization and route selection: a case study of Shanghai Pudong international airport. Mathematics, 2023, 11: 1539

[25] Ma Y. Optimization algorithm of urban rail transit network route planning using deep learning technology. Comput Intell Neurosci, 2022, 2022(1): 2024686

[26] Huang Z, Ma C. Symmetry-based urban rail transit network planning using two-stage robust optimization. Symmetry (Basel), 2024, 16 ArticleID: 1149

[27] Du Z, Pan J, Wang X, Chu SA, Ni S. Enhancing urban rail transit train routes planning using surrogate-assisted fish migration optimization. J Bionic Eng, 2025, 22: 1702-1716

[28] Pu Y, Srikukenthiran S, Morrow E, Shalaby AS, Klumpenhouwer W. Capacity analysis of a passenger hub using integrated railway and pedestrian simulation. Urban Rail Transit, 2022, 8: 1-15

[29] Zhao S, Yang H, Wu Y. An integrated approach of train scheduling and rolling stock circulation with skip-stopping. Transp Res Part C, 2021, 128: 103170

[30] Wang X, Feng X, Sun P, Wang Q. Two-objective train operation optimization based on eco-driving and timetabling. IET Intell Transp Syst, 2023, 18: 377

[31] Su B, D’Ariano A, Su S, Wang Z, Tang T. A data-driven mixed-integer linear programming approach for real-time rescheduling of urban rail transit under rolling stock faults. Transp Res C Emerg Technol, 2024

[32] Jue Z, Xiaoming X, Long J, Jianxun D. Integrated optimization approach to metro crew scheduling and rostering. Transp Res C Emerg Technol, 2021, 123 ArticleID: 102975

[33] Chai S, Yin J, D’Ariano A, Yang L, Tang T. Model for intercity railway schedule optimization incorporating metrorail transfers. Transp Res Rec, 2024, 2678: 1395-1415

[34] Liu X, Dabiri A, Wang Y, de Schutter B. Real-time train scheduling with uncertain passenger flows: a scenario-based distributed model predictive control approach. IEEE Trans Intell Transp Syst, 2024, 25: 4219-4232

[35] Chai S, Yim J, D’Ariano A, Samà M, Tang T. Train schedule optimization for commuter-metro networks. Transp Res Part C: Emerg Tech, 2023, 155: 104278

[36] Bulková Z, Brumerčíková E, Bukova B, Mihalik T. Concept of an integrated urban public transport system linked to a railway network based on the principles of a timed-transfer timetable in the city of Prievidza. Syst, 2025, 13: 543

[37] Li W, Huang J, Fan W, Luo Q (2025) Integrated optimisation of train schedule and rolling stock circulation for Y-type metro lines using an online flexible train composition mode. Transp A: Transp Sci 1–30

[38] Yin X, Chen J, Li Y. Simulation-based resilience evaluation for urban rail transit transfer stations. Sustainability, 2024, 16: 3790

[39] Liu SC, Qiao YK, Peng FL (2024) Optimized identification for critical metro stations from an urban resilience perspective. In: IOP conference series: earth and environmental science, vol 1333. IOP Publishing, p 012025

[40] Chuwang DD, Chen W. Forecasting daily and weekly passenger demand for urban rail transit stations based on a time series model approach. Forecasting, 2022, 4: 904

[41] Dong N, Li T, Tu R, Lin F, Liu H, Bo Y (2023) A method for short-term passenger flow prediction in urban rail transit based on deep learning. Multimed Tools Appl 1-23

[42] Zhang S, Zhang J, Yang L, Yin J, Gao Z. Spatiotemporal attention fusion network for short-term passenger flow prediction on New Year’s Day holiday. IEEE ITS Mag, 2023, 15: 59-77

[43] Zhang J, Mao S, Zhang S, Yin J, Yang L, Gao ZL. EF-former for short-term passenger flow prediction during large-scale events. Inf Fusion, 2024, 117 ArticleID: 102916

[44] Xing X, Wang B, Ning X, Wang G, Tiwari P. Short-term OD flow prediction for urban rail transit control: a multi-graph spatiotemporal fusion approach. Inf Fusion, 2025, 118 ArticleID: 102950

[45] Shuo Z, Jinfei W, Zhenyi L, Ge M. Train operational plan optimization for urban rail transit lines considering circulation balance. Sustainability, 2022, 14: 5226

[46] Zhou W, Alemu A, Oldache M. Synchronized optimization method of frequency setting, timetabling, and train circulation planning. Mathematics, 2025, 13: 2654

[47] Peng H, Chen Y, Shangguan L, Zhou S, Li Y, Wang Q. Evaluation of urban rail transit system planning based on integrated empowerment method. Sustainability, 2025, 17: 4569

[48] Zhan Y, Ye M, Zhang R, He S, Ni S. Multi-objective optimization for train service integrating train operation plan and type selection. Transp Lett, 2023, 16: 1039-1058

[49] Gao Y, Jia C, Wang Z, Hu Z. A cost-effective approach for the integrated optimization of line planning and timetabling in an urban rail transit line. Appl Sci, 2024, 14: 6273

[50] Li Z, Zhao J, Peng Q. Train service design in an urban rail transit line incorporating multiple service routes and multiple train compositions. Transp Res Part C, 2021, 123 ArticleID: 102959

[51] Wu Y (2025) Multi-objective optimization of train scheduling using genetic model with short-turning strategy. In: 2025 international conference on algorithm, artificial intelligence and computer vision (AAICV). IEEE, pp 1–8

[52] Yuhua Y, Marcella S, Dario P, Ni S. Train timetabling with passenger data and heterogeneous rolling stock circulation. Soft Comput, 2022, 27: 12959-12977

[53] Masing B, Lindner N, Liebchen C (2023) Integrating Line planning for construction sites into periodic timetabling via track choice. Model ic Approaches for Transp

[54] Guilliard I, Trevizan FW, Sanner S. Mitigating the impact of light rail on urban traffic networks using mixed-integer linear programming. IET Intel Transp Syst, 2020, 14: 523-533

[55] Shi X, Zhou W, Li X. A mixed-integer linear programming method for time-dependent line planning in passenger railway systems. PLoS ONE, 2025, 20: e0322394

[56] Zhong Q, Zhang Y, Wang D, Zhong Q, Wen C, Peng Q. A mixed integer linear programming model for rolling stock deadhead routing. J Adv Transp, 2020, 2020: 3809734

[57] Zhuang M, Zhao K, D’Ariano A, Niu R, Li S, Luan X. Real-time integrated train rescheduling and rolling stock circulation planning. Transp Res Part B, 2021, 152: 87-117

[58] Zhou W, Oldache M. Integrated Optimization of line planning, timetabling, and rolling stock allocation for urban railway lines. Sustainability, 2021, 13: 13059

[59] Li C, Tang J, Zhang J, Zhao QY, Wang L, Li J. Integrated optimization of urban rail transit line planning, timetabling, and rolling stock scheduling. PLoS ONE, 2023

[60] Lin X, Xueliang W, Shang D, Shuai S. Optimization of rescheduling under temporary speed restrictions in urban rail transit. IEEE ITSC, 2024, 2024: 2774-2779

[61] Wu Z, Gao C, Tang T. A virtually coupled metro train platoon control approach based on model predictive control. IEEE Access, 2021, 9: 56354-56363

[62] Yuan F, Sum H, Zhu C, Deng W (2026) Integration optimization of commuter metro lines: train timetable, passenger flow control strategy, and short-turning scheme. Comp Ind Eng

[63] Leso M, Kacar L. Issues of safety of autonomous railway operation at the GoA3 and GoA4 level. Transp Sci, 2025

[64] Dimitrova EP (2019) Analysis of automatic control systems for metro trains. In: 2019 11th electrical engineering faculty conference (BulEF), p 1-4

[65] Cai X, Gao F. Study on joint regulation and safety supervision of urban rail transit system. J Phys Conf Ser, 2020

[66] Luo J, Tong Y (2021) Constrained optimal controller design for urban metro traffic regulation. In: Proceedings of the 2021 40th Chinese control conference (CCC), pp 1657–1662

[67] Zhao W, Zhang Z, Hou B, Huang Y, Xie Y. A hybrid similarity-based method for wind monitoring system deployment optimization along urban railways. Urban Rail Transit, 2023, 9: 310-322

[68] Ye M, Zhang R, Lai Y, Easa SM, Zhan Y, Lan W. Novel approach to optimizing express-local metro train timetable considering multiple train stopping patterns. Can J Civil Eng, 2025, 52: 1060-1075

[69] Management Authority for Urban Railways (MAUR) (2015) Technical design for signalling system–package CP3: E&M, rolling stock, and track work for Ho Chi Minh City Metro Line 1. Official Project Technical Documentation, March 2015

[70] Management Authority for Urban Railways (MAUR) (2025) Front-end engineering design (FEED) for technology selection: Ho Chi Minh City metro line 2 (Ben Thanh—Tham Luong section). Implementation Consultant Report (Rev. 3.0), November 2025

[71] Management Authority for Urban Railways (MAUR) (2025) Front-end engineering design (FEED) for technology selection: regional extension of Ho Chi Minh City metro line 1 to Binh Duong and Dong Nai. Implementation Consultant Report (Rev. 2.0), February 2025

[72] Zhou Y, Yang H, Wang Y, Yan X. Integrated line configuration and frequency determination with passenger path assignment. Transp Res Part B Methodol, 2021, 145: 134-151

[73] Berbey-Alvarez A, de Dios Sanz Bobi J, Caballero-George RJ (2025) CBTC capacity analysis from the conventional to the autonomous GoA4 model for the CBTC on Panama Metro line 2. In: 2025 IEEE VIII Congreso (AMITIC), pp 1–8

[74] Kim J, Lee T, Jung C (2025) A study on the priority factors by railway facilities in the precision diagnosis and performance evaluation of railway facilities (Focused on cases of incheon transit corporation). J Korean Soc Urban Railw

[75] Sameni MK, Moradi A. Railway capacity: a review of analysis methods. J Rail Transp Plan Manag, 2022, 24100357

[76] Idrovo R, Zabalegui P, Diez de Ulzurrun U, Ciaurriz P, Arana S, Mendizabal J. Toward automatic train operation for GoA3/4: Novel architecture and applicability criteria of speed profile optimization strategies. IEEE Trans Intell Transp Syst, 2025, 26: 18358-18384

[77] Kacar L (2025) Use of safety guarantees of train protection in the safety of autonomous train driving. Inżynieria Mineralna

[78] North A, Calgary B, Sacramento SD, Louis S, Diego S, Francisco (2003) Transit capacity and quality of service manual, 2nd edn

[79] Li J, Yi M, Wu Z, Qi H, Li X (2025) Research on passenger flow control in an urban rail transit network during peak demand period. In: 2025 IEEE international conference on service operations and logistics, and informatics (SOLI). IEEE, pp 7–12

[80] Gao X, Wang L, Shao Y (2024) Resilience assessment of Nanjing rail transit stations. In: Proceedings of the 2024 international conference on intelligent driving and smart transportation

[81] Gao G, Lu WB, Zhou C, Huang ZM (2022) Simulation-based passenger-carrying capacity analysis for urban rail transit transfer stations. In: Other conferences

[82] Kumar A, Shilton A, Rana S, Gupta S, Venkatesh S (2021) Kernel functional optimisation. Neural Information Processing Systems

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)

Just Accepted

This article has successfully passed peer review and final editorial review, and will soon enter typesetting, proofreading and other publishing processes. The currently displayed version is the accepted final manuscript. The officially published version will be updated with format, DOI and citation information upon launch. We recommend that you pay attention to subsequent journal notifications and preferentially cite the officially published version. Thank you for your support and cooperation.