Assessment, Prediction, and Mitigation of Metro-Induced Vibrations for an Opera Theatre Adjacent to a Station: A Case Study

Abstract

Rapid urban expansion and the development of urban rail transit networks have led to a deteriorating vibration environment along metro lines. These long-term vibrations pose significant challenges to adjacent buildings, such as opera theatres, and to the well-being of nearby residents. Consequently, there is a critical need for vibration evaluation and the implementation of mitigation solutions. This work provides a numerical investigation into the dynamics of vibrations observed in an opera theatre located above a metro station. A unified coupling method, known as the train-track-station-solum-opera model, is proposed and validated with field experiments. By employing contact theory, deformation coordination criteria, and spring elements, various components are meticulously modeled and coupled. Using this unified coupled approach, metro-induced vibrations at the opera theatre are predicted and evaluated. Additionally, vibration control measures are employed from the perspectives of transfer paths and vibration receivers to mitigate and isolate excessive theatre vibrations. The results, based on a case where the distance between the metro line and the opera theatre is 42 m, demonstrate that metro operations can lead to vibrations exceeding acceptable limits at the opera theatre near the metro station. Therefore, it is imperative that vibrations are assessed before constructing vibration-sensitive buildings along metro lines and that mitigation measures are implemented to meet specifications. In this work, the application of extruded polystyrene (XPS) plates and optimization of building structures effectively reduced excessive theatre vibrations by 1–2.5 dB, offering viable attenuation options without requiring modifications to the existing metro system.

Keywords

Metro-induced vibrations / Opera theatre / Digital twin model / Environmental impact assessment (EIA) / Vibration reduction measures

References

[1] Connolly DP, Kouroussis G, Woodward PK, Giannopoulos A, Verlinden O, Forde MC. Scoping prediction of re-radiated ground-borne noise and vibration near high speed rail lines with variable soils. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng, 2014, 66: 78-88

[2] Thompson D. Railway noise and vibration : mechanisms, modelling and means of control, 2008 1 Oxford: Elsevier Ltd

[3] Li MH, Ma M, Cao ZL, Xia Q, Liu WN. Dynamic response analysis of train-induced vibration impact on the Probhutaratna pagoda in Beijing. Earthq Eng Eng Vib, 2021, 20(1): 223-243

[4] Ma M, Liu WN, Qian CY, Deng GH, Li YD. Study of the train-induced vibration impact on a historic bell tower above two spatially overlapping metro lines. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng, 2016, 81: 58-74

[5] Cai XP, Zhong YL, Hao XC, Zhang YR, Cui RX. Dynamic behavior of a polyurethane foam solidified ballasted track in a heavy haul railway tunnel. Adv Struct Eng, 2019, 22(3): 751-764

[6] Cai XP, Li DC, Zhang YR, Miao Q, Cui RX. Experimental study on the vibration control effect of long elastic sleeper track in subways. Shock Vib, 2018, 2018: 1-13

[7] Sanayei M, Maurya P, Moore JA. Measurement of building foundation and ground-borne vibrations due to surface trains and subways. Eng Struct, 2014, 72: 102-111

[8] Xia H, Chen JG, Wei PB, Xia CY, De Roeck G, Degrande G. Experimental investigation of railway train-induced vibrations of surrounding ground and a nearby multi-story building. Earthq Eng Eng Vib, 2009, 8(1): 137-148

[9] Toygar O, Ulgen D. A full-scale field study on mitigation of environmental ground vibrations by using open trenches. Build Environ, 2021, 203: 1-13

[10] Correia dos Santos N, Barbosa J, Calcada R, Delgado R. Track-ground vibrations induced by railway traffic: experimental validation of a 3D numerical model. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng, 2017, 97: 324-344

[11] Lopes P, Ruiz JF, Costa PA, Rodriguez LM, Cardoso AS. Vibrations inside buildings due to subway railway traffic. Experimental validation of a comprehensive prediction model. Sci Total Environ, 2016, 568: 1333-1343

[12] Zoccali P, Cantisani G, Loprencipe G. Ground-vibrations induced by trains: filled trenches mitigation capacity and length influence. Constr Build Mater, 2015, 74: 1-8

[13] Cai XP, Wang QH, Li DC, Liang YK. Theoretical study of long elastic sleeper track to reduce vibrations induced by subway trains. P I Mech Eng F-J Rai, 2020, 234(5): 538-549

[14] Takemiya H. Prediction of train/traffic induced ground vibrations and mitigation by WIB, environmental vibrations: prediction, monitoring, mitigation and evaluation (ISEV. CRC Press, 2005, 2021: 399-409.

[15] Hong J, Kang H, Jung S, Sung S, Hong T, Park HS, Lee DE. An empirical analysis of environmental pollutants on building construction sites for determining the real-time monitoring indices. Build Environ, 2020, 170: 1-17

[16] Forrest JA, Hunt HEM. A three-dimensional tunnel model for calculation of train-induced ground vibration. J Sound Vib, 2006, 294(4–5): 678-705

[17] Galvin P, Romero A, Dominguez J. Fully three-dimensional analysis of high-speed train-track-soil-structure dynamic interaction. J Sound Vib, 2010, 329(24): 5147-5163

[18] Hung HH, Yang YB. Analysis of ground vibrations due to underground trains by 2.5D finite/infinite element approach. Earthq Eng Eng Vib, 2010, 9(3): 327-335

[19] Kouroussis G, Verlinden O. Prediction of railway induced ground vibration through multibody and finite element modelling. Mech Sci, 2013, 4(1): 167-183

[20] Yang YB, Ge PB, Li QM, Liang XJ, Wu YT. 2.5D vibration of railway-side buildings mitigated by open or infilled trenches considering rail irregularity. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng, 2018, 106: 204-214

[21] Hung HH, Chen GH, Yang YB. Effect of railway roughness on soil vibrations due to moving trains by 2.5D finite/infinite element approach. Eng Struct, 2013, 57: 254-266

[22] Zhu ZH, Wang LD, Costa PA, Bai Y, Yu ZW. An efficient approach for prediction of subway train-induced ground vibrations considering random track unevenness. J Sound Vib, 2019, 455: 359-379

[23] Wang LD, Bu XM, Han Y, Zhu ZH, Hu P, Cai CS. Time-frequency random approach for prediction of subway train-induced tunnel and ground vibrations. Int J Struct Stab Dy, 2021, 21(07): 2150101

[24] Zou C, Moore JA, Sanayei M, Tao ZY, Wang YM. Impedance model of train-induced vibration transmission across a transfer structure into an overtrack building in a metro depot. J Struct Eng, 2022

[25] Li XM, Chen YK, Zou C, Wu JH, Shen ZX, Chen Y. Building coupling loss measurement and prediction due to train-induced vertical vibrations. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng, 2023

[26] Yang JJ, Zhu SY, Zhai WM, Kouroussis G, Wang Y, Wang KY, Lan K, Xu FZ. Prediction and mitigation of train-induced vibrations of large-scale building constructed on subway tunnel. Sci Total Environ, 2019, 668: 485-499

[27] Kouroussis G, Verlinden O, Conti C. A two-step time simulation of ground vibrations induced by the railway traffic. P I Mech Eng C-J Mec, 2012, 226(C2): 454-472

[28] Lopes P, Costa PA, Ferraz M, Calcada R, Cardoso AS. Numerical modeling of vibrations induced by railway traffic in tunnels: from the source to the nearby buildings. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng, 2014, 61–62: 269-285

[29] Smith MG, Ogren M, Morsing JA, Waye KP. Effects of ground-borne noise from railway tunnels on sleep: a polysomnographic study. Build Environ, 2019, 149: 288-296

[30] Vogiatzis K, Mouzakis H. Ground-borne noise and vibration transmitted from subway networks to multi-storey reinforced concrete buildings. Transport-Vilnius, 2018, 33(2): 446-453

[31] Connolly DP, Marecki GP, Kouroussis G, Thalassinakis I, Woodward PK. The growth of railway ground vibration problems - a review. Sci Total Environ, 2016, 568: 1276-1282

[32] Zhai WM, Wang KY, Cai CB. Fundamentals of vehicle-track coupled dynamics. Vehicle Syst Dyn, 2009, 47(11): 1349-1376

[33] Xin T, Gao L. Reducing slab track vibration into bridge using elastic materials in high speed railway. J Sound Vib, 2011, 330(10): 2237-2248

[34] Railway applications - In-service wheelset operation requirements - In-service and off-vehicle wheelset maintenance. EN 15313. Madrid: ES-AENOR, 2017

[35] Nielsen JCO, Johansson A. Out-of-round railway wheels - a literature survey. P I Mech Eng F-J Rai, 2000, 214(2): 79-91

[36] Cao ZL, Guo T, Zhang ZQ, Li AQ. Measurement and analysis of vibrations in a residential building constructed on an elevated metro depot. Measurement, 2018, 125: 394-405

[37] Chen G, Zhai WM. A new wheel/rail spatially dynamic coupling model and its verification. Vehicle Syst Dyn, 2004, 41(4): 301-322

[38] Atalan M, Prendergast LJ, Grizi A, Thom N. A review of numerical models for slab-asphalt track railways. Infrastructures, 2022, 7(4): 1-24

[39] Lewis R, Olofsson U. Wheel-rail interface handbook, 2009, Cambridge: Woodhead Publishing

[40] Zhai WM, Wei K, Song XL, Shao MH. Experimental investigation into ground vibrations induced by very high speed trains on a non-ballasted track. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng, 2015, 72: 24-36

[41] Sun HF, Jing LP, Meng XC. Selection of artificial boundary condition on soil-structure dynamic interaction. Key Eng Mater, 2011, 450: 498-501

[42] Lopes P, Costa PA, Calcada R, Cardoso AS. Influence of soil stiffness on building vibrations due to railway traffic in tunnels: numerical study. Comput Geotech, 2014, 61: 277-291

[43] Standard for limit and measuring method of building vibration and secondary noise caused by Urban Rail Transit(in Chinese) (2009) JGJ/T 170-2009. China Architecture & Building Press, Beijing

[44] Guide for the Evaluation of Human Exposure to Whole-Body Vibration. ISO 2631/1-1997. Geneva: International Organization for Standardization, 1997

[45] Coenraad E, Modern railway track, second ed., MRT-Productions, Zaltbommel, The Netherlands, 2001.

Funding

National Natural Science Foundation of China(52178405)