Third-Rail Insulator Failure Causes and Mitigating Practices: A Comparative Study of Multiple Case Studies in the U.S.

Abstract

Rail transit systems are one of the most important and popular types of transit systems used daily in metropolitan areas all around the world. The third rail is one of the providers of traction power in electrified rail systems, but it faces several issues, such as insulator failures. The purpose of this study is to investigate the causes of insulator failures, which have not been comprehensively studied and presented in the literature. To accomplish this objective, eight transit systems with third rails were selected to (1) investigate the characteristics of third-rail systems, (2) determine the causes of insulator failures, (3) analyze the costs associated with insulator failures, and (4) determine mitigating practices to reduce the number and cost of insulator failures. After a thorough literature review, details of eight case studies were collected from different transit agencies, and their subject matter experts were asked to complete a survey and provide input. The results revealed that a build-up of dirt was the major cause of the 17 identified causes of insulator failures; carbon dust and dirt were identified as the most present particles in third-rail systems. It was noted that transit agencies often implement multiple mitigating practices such as cleaning the insulator, performing visual inspections, and conducting regular maintenance to reduce the number and cost of insulator failures. The findings of this study will help decision-makers for transit systems make timely decisions to prevent third-rail insulator failures and adopt appropriate practices that best fit their transit system.

Keywords

Third-rail system / Insulator / Failure / Mitigating strategy

References

[1] Gorur RS, Cherney EA, Burnham JT. Outdoor insulators, 1999, New Jersey: Ravi S Gorur Inc.

[2] Bao X. Urban rail transit present situation and future development trends in China: overall analysis based on national policies and strategic plans in 2016–2020. Urban Rail Trans, 2018, 4(1): 1-12

[3] Kumosa M, Kumosa L, Armentrout D. Causes and potential remedies of brittle fracture failure of composite non-ceramic insulators. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul, 2004, 11(6): 1037-1048

[4] Xu G, McGrath PB, Burns CW (1996) Accelerated environmental and electrical aging of polymer insulators. In: Proceedings of conference on electrical insulation and dielectric Phenomena-CEIDP’96, 1:404–407

[5] Luder D, Ariely S, Yalin M. Stress corrosion cracking and brittle failure in a fiber-reinforced plastic (FRP) insulator from a 400 kV transmission line in humid environment. Eng Fail Anal, 2019, 95: 206-213

[6] Verma AV, Reddy BS. Tracking and erosion resistance of LSR and HTV silicone rubber samples under acid rain conditions. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul, 2018, 25(1): 46-52

[7] Cherney EA, Gorur RS, Krivda A, Jayaram SH, Rowland SM, Li S, Marzinotto M, Ghunem RA, Ramirez I. DC inclined-plane tracking and erosion test of insulating materials. Prepared by the IEEE DEIS outdoor insulation technical committee. IEEE Trans Electr Insul, 2015, 22: 211-217

[8] Reddy S. Failure analysis of BMC insulators used for third rail traction system. Eng Fail Anal, 2019, 101: 1-8

[9] Vohra A (2008) Cleaning device for electrified third rail insulators–Phase 2 (No. Transit IDEA Project 47)

[10] Ibrahem A (2017) Leakage current detection and protection for electrical railway systems. M.Sc. thesis

[11] Fourmigue JM, Noel M, Riquel G (1995) Aging of polymeric housing for HV insulators: comparison between natural and artificial testing. In: Proceedings of 1995 conference on electrical insulation and dielectric phenomena, pp 404–407

[12] Chughtai AR, Smith DM, Kumosa LS, Kumosa M. FTIR analysis of non-ceramic composite insulators. IEEE Trans Dielect Elect Insul, 2004, 11(4): 585-596

[13] Forman KG (2013) Aluminum/stainless steel conductor technology: a case for its adoption in the US In 2013 joint rail conference. american society of mechanical engineers digital collection

[14] Sun J, Gao G, Zhou L, Wu G. Pollution accumulation on rail insulator in high-speed aerosol. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul, 2013, 20(3): 731-738

[15] Papailiou KO, Schmuck F. Silicone composite insulators: materials, design, applications, 2012, Berlin: Springer

[16] Hu Z, Li W, Lin Y. Present and future development of detection methods for composite insulator. Insul Surge Arresters, 2006, 8(1): 133-137.

[17] Ehsani M, Borsi H, Gockenbach E, Morshedian J, Bakhshandeh GR, Shayegani AA (2004) Effect of aging on dielectric behavior of outdoor polymeric insulators. In: Proceedings of the 2004 IEEE international conference on solid dielectrics, 2004. ICSD 200, 1: 312–315

[18] Sun Y, Chen X, Jian X, Xiao Z (2019) Identification and localization method of the insulator based on three-dimensional point cloud modeling. In: Chinese control conference (CCC), pp 7051–7056

[19] Slama MEI-A, Beroual A, Hadi H. Influence of the linear non-uniformity of pollution layer on the insulator flashover under impulse voltage-estimation of the effective pollution thickness. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul, 2011, 18(2): 384-392

[20] Douar MA, Mekhaldi A, Bouzidi MC. Flashover process and frequency analysis of the leakage current on insulator model under non-uniform pollution condition. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul, 2010, 17(4): 1284-1297

[21] Sima W, Yuan T, Yang Q, Xu K, Sun C. Effect of nonuniform pollution on the withstand characteristics of extra high voltage (EHV) suspension ceramic insulator string. IET Gener Transm Distrib, 2009, 4(3): 445-455

[22] Nyamupangedengu C, Luhlanga LP, Letlape T (2007) Acoustic and HF detection of defects on porcelain pin insulators. In: IEEE power engineering society conference and exposition in Africa-PowerAfrica, pp 1–5

[23] Cavallin A, Chandrasekar S, Montanari GC, Puletti F (2007) Inferring ceramic insulator pollution by an innovative approach resorting to PD detection. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul 14:23–29

[24] Jiang Y, Lu J, Wu H, Tan S, Zhang Y, Cai X. Analysis of GFRP insulator characteristics under multiphysical fields in electromagnetic rail launchers. Compos Struct, 2019, 221: 110900

[25] Nekeb AS, Harid N, Haddad A (2011) Effect of UV irradiation on the leakage current of polymeric insulators. In: 2011 46th international universities’ power engineering conference (UPEC), pp 1–4

[26] Sundararajan R, Mohammed A, Chaipanit N, Karcher T, Liu Z. In-service aging and degradation of 345 kV EPDM transmission line insulators in a coastal environment. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul, 2004, 11(2): 348-361

[27] Sundararajan R, Olave C, Romero E, Trepanier B. Modified IEC 5000-h multistress aging of 28-kV thermoplastic elastomeric insulators. IEEE Trans Power Deliv, 2007, 22(2): 1079-1085

[28] Venkatesulu B, Thomas MJ. Long-term accelerated weathering of outdoor silicone rubber insulators. IEEE Trans Dielectr Electr Insul, 2011, 18(2): 418-424

[29] Stewart E, Weston P, Hillmansen S, Roberts C. Using bogie-mounted sensors to understand the dynamics of 3rd rail current collection systems. Proc IMechE Part F J Rail Rapid Trans, 2011, 225(2): 219-227

[30] Vohra A (2004) Cleaning device for electrified third rail insulators. Transit IDEA Project Report 36

[31] Hu Y (2001) The analysis of the pollution of network on Fab. 22th and counter measures from pollution flashover. Insul Surge Arrester, pp 4–11

[32] Shu Y, Hu Y, Li X. Maintenance and live working technology for ultra-high voltage transmission line. Gaodianya Jishu/High Voltage Eng, 2007, 33(6): 1-5.

[33] To WM. Centrality of an urban rail system. Urban Rail Trans, 2015, 1(4): 249-256

[34] Zerbst U, Beretta S. Failure and damage tolerance aspects of railway components. Eng Fail Anal, 2011, 18: 534-542

[35] Sekine H, Beaumont PWR. Stress-corrosion cracking in unidirectional GFRP composites. Key Eng Mater, 2010, 430: 101-113

[36] Schneider HM, Guidi WW, Burnham JT, Gorur RS, Hall JF. Accelerated aging and flashover tests on 138 kV nonceramic line post insulators. IEEE Trans Power Deliv, 1993, 8(1): 325-336

[37] Chakraborty R. Performance of silicone rubber insulators under thermal and electrical stress. IEEE Trans Ind Appl, 2017, 53(3): 2446-2454

[38] Kermanshachi S, Rouhanizadeh B (2020) TCRP synthesis J-07/topic SD-05: third rail insulator failures—current state of the practice. Research Report, pp 1–74