Catenary-Free Tramway Systems: Functional and Cost–Benefit Analysis for a Metropolitan Area

Abstract

New tramway technologies such as “ground-level power supply systems” fit with the purpose of preserving historical heritage and urban environments of city centers. Such public transportation systems do not require a traditional air supply system (+ 750 V) and are therefore referred to as “catenary-free systems” (i.e., APS system, tramwave system, Primove system). Their implementation is becoming increasingly widespread, especially for cities with prestigious historical heritage, where high levels of environmental sustainability, capacity, reliability and safety standards are required. The study compares some of the most well-known and novel catenary-free systems for the creation of a 68-km tramway system, to be implemented in a metropolitan city. For each of the 7 new tramways, AIMSUN microsimulations were run to identify the most appropriate tramway track geometry and road section to minimize the interference with the vehicle activity. Moreover, for each system a financial and economic performance analysis has been carried out for an investment of about 869 million euros, while taking into account different scenarios of transportation demand. In addition, a cost–benefit analysis of the tramway lines investment project has been presented, including the calculation of the financial net present value, the economic net present value, rate of return of the investment and cost–benefit ratio. The analysis demonstrates that the APS ground-level power supply system is a proven alternative with greater economic and financial performance.

Keywords

Tramway / Catenary-free systems / Cost–benefit analysis / Traffic microsimulation

References

[1] White Paper on transport, European Commission (2011)

[2] EMTA (2009) Barometer of public transport in European metropolitan areas. Availalble: https://www.emta.com

[3] Ortego A, Valero A, Abadías A. Environmental impacts of promoting new public transport systems in urban mobility: a case study. J Sustain Dev Energy Water Environ Syst, 2017, 5(3): 377-395

[4] Together towards competitive and resource-efficient urban mobility, European Commission (2013)

[5] MEMO/18/2762 (2017) Road safety statistics: what is behind the figures? European Commission—fact sheet

[6] Vuchic VR. Urban transit systems and technology, 2017, Hoboken: Wiley

[7] List of Tram systems (2019) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tram_and_light_rail_transit_systems

[8] Alpkokin P, Kiremitci ST, Black JA, Cetinavci S. LRT and street tram policies and implementation in turkish cities. J Transp Geogr, 2016, 54(1): 476-487

[9] Swanson J, Smatlak J (2015) State-of-the-art in light rail alternative power supplies. In: APTA/TRB 2015, light rail conference

[10] Guerrieri M (2017) Infrastrutture ferroviarie, metropolitane, tranviarie e per ferrovie speciali. Maggioli Editore

[11] Prud’homme R, Koning M, Kopp P. Substituting a tramway to a bus line in Paris: costs and benefits. Transp Policy, 2011, 18: 563-572

[12] Penyalver D, Turró M, Williamson JB. Measuring the value for money of transport infrastructure procurement; an intergenerational approach. Transp Res Part A, 2019, 119: 238-254.

[13] Dubéa J, Legrosb D, Devaux N. From bus to tramway: is there an economic impact of substituting a rapid mass transit system? An empirical investigation accounting for anticipation effect. Transp Res Part A, 2018, 110: 73-87.

[14] Becker F (2016) Catenary free operation of light rail vehicles—topology and operational concept. In: 18th European conference on power electronics and applications (EPE’16 ECCE Europe)

[15] EN 50126-1:2017, Railway Applications (2017) The specification and demonstration of reliability, availability, maintainability and safety (RAMS). Generic RAMS process, 06 Dec 2017

[16] Guidelines to Understanding Reliability Prediction (2005) EPSMA, European Power Supply Manufacturers Association

[17] Tzanakakis K (2017) The railway track and its long term behaviour. Springer

[18] FDR-System (2017) Final demonstration report—system. Dubai Tram, ELS10-00-D900-SYS-000-00872-B

[19] Chen CL. Tram development and urban transport integration in Chinese cities: a case study of Suzhou. Econ Transp, 2018, 15: 16-31

[20] CNIT Ministero delle Infrastrutture e dei Trasporti, Conto Nazionale delle Infrastrutture e dei Trasporti Anni 2015–2016, 2016, Roma: Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato S.p.A

[21] Guerrieri M. Tramways in urban areas: an overview on safety at road intersections. Urban Rail Transit, 2018, 4(4): 223-233

[22] Italian Road accidents year 2017 (2017) ISTAT, Istituto Nazionale di Statistica

[23] Fernández R. Modelling public transport stops by microscopic simulation. Transp Res Part C Emerg Technol, 2010, 18(6): 856-868

[24] Transportation Plan for the city of Palermo (2013) www.comune.palermo.it/

[25] Sermpis D, Papadakos P, Fousekis K. Tram priority at signalcontrolled junctions. Proc Inst Civ Eng Transp, 2012, 165(2): 87-96.

[26] Ter Zhao X, Li Y, Xu S, Zhai H. Modeling a modern tram system integrated with a road traffic simulation. Simulation, 2018, 94(1): 77-90

[27] Elefteriadou L (2014) An introduction to traffic flow theory. Springer

[28] Dowling R, Skabardonis A, Alexiadis V (2004) Traffic analysis toolbox volume III: guidelines for applying traffic microsimulation software. Report FHWA-HRT-04-040, Federal Highway Administration, Washington, DC

[29] Asperti G (2010) Trasporto pubblico locale: efficienza e qualità in Lombardia. MCE. http://www.mobilityconference.it/archivio/2010/allegati/Asperti.pdf

[30] Guide to Cost-Benefit Analysis of Investment Projects (2014) European commission

[31] Ricardo—AEA DG Move (2014) Update of the handbook on external costs of transport

[32] AMAT Transportation Service, Balance (2016) http://amat.pa.it/

[33] Cascetta E (2009) Transportation systems analysis. Springer

[34] Ortuzar JDS, Willumsen LG (2011) Modelling transport. Wiley

[35] D’Orso G, Migliore M. A GIS-based methodology to estimate the potential demand of an integrated transport system. Lect Notes Comput Sci, 2017, 10407: 525-540

[36] Prassas ES, Roess RP (2013) Engineering economic and finance for transportation infrastructure. Springer

[37] Guerrieri M, Parla G, Corriere F. A new methodology to estimate deformation of longitudinal safety barriers. ARPN J Eng Appl Sci, 2013, 8(9): 763-769.