Examining Job Accessibility of the Urban Poor by Urban Metro and Bus: A Case Study of Beijing

Abstract

Using data from Beijing, this paper evaluates job accessibility for people living in affordable housing to job centers by public transit, including urban metro and bus. By comparing the middle and low-income group who mainly use public transit and higher income group who mainly travel by car, results show an accessibility gap for different modes of transportation as travel by public transit takes nearly double the amount of time as travel by car. While commuting time is closely linked to the location of the provided affordable housing, it is also dependent on the quality of local public transit service. Areas with substantial travel time differences between public transit and car travel reveal the weaknesses of public transit provision. Furthermore, average commuting time by both public transit and car from areas of affordable housing built after 2004 is much longer than that from previously built areas implying that low-income groups are being driven to more disadvantaged locations with time changes. In contrast to the classical job-housing mismatch hypothesis in U.S. cities, the mismatch model in Chinese cities is that while major job opportunities are still concentrated in the central city, affordable housing residents who rely on urban metro and bus are being moved further afield into distant suburban areas. The paper will provide the implication for affordable housing and transportation planning in Chinese cities in the future. Improving job accessibility by further establishment of urban metro system for this demographic will promote the urban economy and provide social welfare for the disadvantaged.

Keywords

Accessibility / Job-housing mismatch / Urban metro / Affordable housing / Beijing

References

[1] Armstrong M, Sears B (2001) The new economy and jobs/housing balance in Southern California. Retrieved 1 April 2012

[2] Beijing Bus (2012) Report on Development of Beijing Bus in Recent Years. Retrieved 3 Dec 2012

[3] Beijing Statistical Bureau Beijing statistical yearbook, 2001, Beijing: China Statistic Press

[4] Blumenberg E, Ong P. Job accessibility and welfare usage: evidence from Los Angeles. J Policy Anal Manag, 1998, 17(4): 639-657

[5] Boustan L, Margob R. Race, segregation, and postal employment: new evidence on spatial mismatch. J Urban Econ, 2009, 65: 1-10

[6] Brooks R (2002) Covenants and conventions. Northwestern University School of Law

[7] Cervero R. Jobs-housing balance and regional mobility. J Am Plan Assoc, 1989, 55(2): 136-150

[8] Cervero R. Jobs/housing balance as public policy. Urban Land, 1991, 50(10): 10-14.

[9] Cervero R. Jobs-housing balance revisited: trends and impacts in San Francisco Bay area. J Am Plan Assoc, 1996, 62: 492-511

[10] Cervero R, Sandoval O Transportation as a stimulus of welfare-to work: private versus public mobility. J Plan Educ Res, 2002, 22(1): 53-63

[11] Chai, Y, Zhang, C (2009) Geographical approach to Chinese Cities’ Danwei: a key to understand the transition of Urban China. Int Urban Plan 24 (5): 2–6. [柴彦威, 张纯. 地理学视角下的城市单位:解读中国城市转型的钥匙. 国际城市规划, 2009,24 (5):2–6]

[12] Downs A. Stuck in traffic: coping with peak hour traffic congestion, 1992, Washington, DC: Brookings Institution

[13] Deng FF, Huang Y. Uneven land reform and urban sprawl in China: the case of Beijing. Prog Plan, 2004, 61: 211-236

[14] Ellwood D. Freeman R, Holzer H. The spatial mismatch hypothesis: Are there teenage jobs missing in the ghetto?. The black youth employment crisis, 1986, Chicago: University of Chicago Press

[15] Ewing R. Best development practices: doing the right thing and making money at the same time, 1996, Chicago: Planners Press

[16] Grengs J. Job accessibility and the modal mismatch in Detroit. J Transp Geogr, 2010, 18(1): 42-54

[17] Handy SL, Niemeier DA. Measuring accessibility: an exploration of issues and alternatives. Environ Plan A, 1997, 29(7): 1175-1194

[18] Hansen W. How accessibilitv shapes land use. J Am Inst Plan, 1959, 25: 73-76

[19] Holzer H. The spatial mismatch hypothesis: What has the evidence shown?. Urban Stud, 1991, 28(1): 105-122

[20] Huang, Y. (2005). From work-unit compounds to gated communities: housing inequality and residential segregation in transitional Beijing. Restructuring the Chinese city: changing society, economy and space. L. J. C. M. a. F. L. Wu. London, Routledge

[21] Kain J. Housing segregation, negro employment, and metropolitan decentralization. Q J Econ, 1968, 2: 175-197

[22] Kain J. The spatial mismatch hypothesis: there decades later. Hous Policy Debate, 1992, 3(2): 371-460

[23] Kawabata M. Job access and employment among low-skilled autoless workers in US metropolitan areas. Environ Plan A, 2003, 35(9): 1651-1668

[24] Ley D. Social geography of the City, 1993, New York: Harper & Row Press

[25] Liu W, Yan X, Xie L (2012) Employment and residential mobility and its spatial structure change based on the 3 years survey analysis. Geogr Res 31(9): 1685–1697. [刘望保,闫小培,谢丽娟.转型时期广州居民职住流动及其空间结构变化——基于3个年份的调查分析. 地理研究, 2012, 31(9):s1685–1697]

[26] Mattingly D. Job search, social networks, and local labor market dynamics: the case of paid household work in San Diego, California. Urban Geogr, 1999, 20(1): 46-74

[27] New Urban News (2010) http://www.newurbannews.com. Retrieved 6 Apr 2010

[28] Omer I. Evaluating accessibility using house-level data: a spatial equity perspective. Comput Environ Urban Syst, 2006, 30: 254-274

[29] Raphael S. The spatial mismatch hypothesis and black youth joblessness: evidence from the San Francisco Bay Area. J Urban Econ, 1998, 43: 79-111

[30] Shen Q. A spatial analysis of job openings and access in a US metropolitan area. J Am Plan Assoc, 2000, 67(1): 53-68

[31] Smart Growth America (2007) What is smart growth? Retrieved 13 Dec 2007

[32] Taylor B, Ong P. Spatial mismatch or automobile mismatch? An examination of race, residence, and commuting in US metropolitan areas. Urban Stud, 1955, 32(9): 1537-1557.

[33] Wachs M, Kumagai TG. Physical accessibility as a social indicator. Soc Econ Plan Sci, 1973, 7: 437-456

[34] Wang E, Song J, Xu T. From “spatial bond” to “spatial mismatch”: an assessment of changing jobs housing relationship in Beijing. Habitat Int, 2011, 35: 398-409

[35] Warner SBJ. Streetcar suburbs: The process of growth in Boston 1870–1990, 1978, Cambridge: Harvard University Press

[36] Weitz J, Schindler T. (1997) Are Oregon’s communities balanced? A test of the jobs-housing balance policy and the impact of balance on mean commute times. Unpublished manuscript. Department of Urban Studies and Planning, Portland State University

[37] Zhang C, Chai Y. Un-gated and integrated work unit communities in post-socialist urban China: a case study from Beijing. Habitat Int, 2014, 43: 79-89

[38] Zhao P, Lu B. Exploring job accessibility in the transformation context: an institutionalist approach and its application in Beijing. J Transp Geogr, 2010, 18: 393-401

[39] Zhao P, Lu B Consequences of governance restructuring for quality of urban living in the transformation era in Beijing: a view of job accessibility. Habitat Int, 2009, 33: 436-444

[40] Liu B, Shen F (2008) Study on the characters of job-housing spatial structure in Beijing metropolitan area. Hum Geogr 120(4):40–47 (In Chinese) [刘碧寒, 沈凡卜. 北京都市区就业—居住空间结构及特征研究. 人文地理, 2008, 120(4):40–47]

[41] Liu Z, Wang M (2011) The influence of job-housing mismatch on commuting behavior of residents in Beijing: based on the anaylsis of accessibility and commuting time. Acta Geogr Sin 65:191. [刘志林, 王茂军.北京市职住空间错位对居民通勤行为的影响分析——基于就业可达性与通勤时间的讨论. 地理学报, 2011, 66(4):457–467]

[42] Sun F, Wang Z (2003) Statistical analysis of the average speed of buses in Beijing. Automot Eng 25(3):219–242. [孙逢春, 王震坡 北京市公共汽车平均车速统计分析. 汽车工程, 2003, 25(3):219–242]

[43] Zhou J, Zhang C, Chen XJ, Huang W, Yu P (2014) Has the legacy of Danwei persisted in transformations? the jobs-housing balance and commuting efficiency in Xi’an. J Transp Geogr 40:64–76

[44] Lu B, Zhang C, Chen TM (2013) Study on changes in job accessibility for the urban low-income: a case study of Beijing. City Plan Rev 37(1):56–63. [吕斌, 张纯, 陈天鸣. 城市低收入群体的就业可达性变化研究—以北京为例. 城市规划, 2013, 37(1):56–63]

Funding

Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities of China(2014JBZ020)

the China Ministry of Education Social Science Founding Youth Program(13YJCZH240)