Continuum-discrete coupling model for mechanical response analysis of tunnels subjected to non-uniform reverse faulting

Abstract

In recent decades, there have been numerous reports of damage cases involving tunnels crossing active faults. The mechanical response and failure mechanisms of cross-fault tunnels have become a key issue in the field of tunnel engineering. This study established a continuum-discrete coupling model comprising intact rock mass, fault zones, and tunnel. In this model, the tunnel and intact rock are modeled as continuous media, while the fault zone is modeled as a discrete medium. The non-uniform fault displacement is adopted to simulate the mechanical response and damage patterns of tunnels crossing active faults under reverse faulting. The simulation results are validated by comparison with the damage of Longchi tunnel observed from 2008 Wenchuan earthquake in China, as well as the experimental phenomenon from the model test. The results demonstrate that the proposed coupling model effectively reproduces the tunnel failure modes caused by reverse faulting. In addition, the high consistency between the simulation results and experimental data further confirms computational accuracy and reliability of the coupling model. A parametric analysis based on the Xianglushan tunnel in China is carried out to investigate the effects of fault displacements, fault widths, dip angles and fault zone rock mass qualities on damage patterns of crossing-fault tunnels. This study provides a valuable reference for seismic fortification of the tunnel crossing reverse faults.

Keywords

Continuum-discrete coupling model / FDM-DEM method / Non-uniform fault displacement / Tunnel damage / Parametric analysis

Data availability

The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

CRediT authorship contribution statement

Zhenning Ba: Supervision, Funding acquisition, Writing - review & editing, Conceptualization. Yao Wang: Methodology, Writing - original draft, Conceptualization, Software. Zhiwei Fang: Visualization, Software. Dongqiao Li: Writing - review & editing.

Declaration of competing interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgement

This research was supported by the National Key Research and Development Program of China (Grant No. 2023YFC3007403), which the authors gratefully acknowledged.

References

[1] Ahmadi M., Moosavi M., & Jafari M. K. (2018). Experimental investigation of reverse fault rupture propagation through wet granular soil. Engineering Geology, 239, 229-240.

[2] Anastasopoulos I., Gazetas G., Bransby M. F., Davies M. C. R., & El Nahas A. (2007). Fault rupture propagation through sand: Finite element analysis and validation through centrifuge experiments. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 133(8), 943-958.

[3] Asakura T., & Sato Y. (1998). Mountain tunnels damage in the 1995 Hyogoken-Nanbu Earthquake. Quarterly Report of RTRI, 39(1), 9-16.

[4] Cai Q. P., Peng J. M., Ng C. W. W., Shi J. W., & Chen X. X. (2019). Centrifuge and numerical modelling of tunnel intersected by normal fault rupture in sand. Computers and Geotechnics, 111, 137-146.

[5] Chen P. L., Geng P., Chen J. B., & Gu W. Q. (2023). The seismic damage mechanism of Daliang tunnel by fault dislocation during the 2022 Menyuan Ms6.9 earthquake based on unidirectional velocity pulse input. Engineering Failure Analysis, 145, 107047.

[6] Chang Y. Y., Lee C. J., Huang W. C., Hung W. Y., Huang W. J., Lin M. L., & Chen Y. H. (2015). Evolution of the surface deformation profile and subsurface distortion zone during reverse faulting through overburden sand. Engineering Geology, 184, 52-70.

[7] Cui Z., Li J. H., Fu X. W., Shen Q., Zhou G. X., Ma Y., & Wang T. Q. (2022). Evaluating the response of a tunnel subjected to strike slip fault rupture in conjunction with model test and hybrid discretecontinuous numerical modeling. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering, 55(8), 4743-4764.

[8] Dowding C. H., & Rozen A. (1978). Damage to rock tunnels from earthquake shaking. Journal of Geotechnical Engineering Division, 104 (2), 175-191.

[9] Fei J. B., Wei J. Y., Khalid M. I., Zhou X. S., Li G. L., & Chen X. S. (2024). Failure of Daliang tunnel induced by active stick-slip faulting. Journal of Rock Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jrmge.2024.07.007 (In Press).

[10] Gao J. Q., Wang Q. Y., Wang R., Yang J., & Yang Y. W. (2024). Model test study on the deformation and failure characteristics of mountain tunnel under a strike-slip fault dislocation. Structures, 60, 105903.

[11] Gou Y. X., Huang Q. B., Kang X. S., Wang L. X., Yang X. Q., & Teng H. Q. (2023). Experimental study on the mechanical response of metro shield tunnels obliquely crossing ground fissures. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 132, 104849.

[12] Hashash Y. M. A., Hook J. J., Schmidt B., & I-Chiang Yao J. (2001). Seismic design and analysis of underground structures. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 16(4), 247-293.

[13] Huang J. Y. (2016). Research on the method for evaluating the earthquake surface rupture. [Doctoral dissertation, Institute of Engineering Mechanics, China]. (in Chinese).

[14] Itasca. (2022a). FLAC3D User's Manual. Itasca Consulting Group, version 9.0. USA.

[15] Itasca. (2022b). 3DEC User's Manual. Itasca Consulting Group, version 9.0. USA.

[16] Kiani M., Ghalandarzadeh A., Akhlaghi T., & Ahmadi M. (2016a). Experimental evaluation of vulnerability for urban segmental tunnels subjected to normal surface faulting. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 89, 28-37.

[17] Kiani M., Akhlaghi T., & Ghalandarzadeh A. (2016b). Experimental modeling of segmental shallow tunnels in alluvial affected by normal faults. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 51, 108-119.

[18] Li H. Y., Li X. G., & Liu H. (2023). Deformation and failure mechanism of metro shield tunnel subjected to buried fault dislocation. Engineering Failure Analysis, 153, 107551.

[19] Li H. Y., Li X. G., Yang Y., Liu Y., & Ma M. Z. (2022). Structural stress characteristics and joint deformation of shield tunnels crossing active faults. Applied Sciences, 12(7), 3229.

[20] Liu W., Huang C. J., Zhang S. F., & Song Z. Y. (2023). Centrifuge tests of large-diameter steel pipes crossing strike-slip faults. Engineering Structures, 279, 115124.

[21] Lin M. L., Chung C. F., Jeng F. S., & Yao T. C. (2007). The deformation of overburden soil induced by thrust faulting and its impact on underground tunnels. Engineering Geology, 92(3-4), 110-132.

[22] Liu Y. Q., Yao C. F., Luo W., He C., Sun M. H., Wang E. L., & Yuan F. Y. (2024). Deformations and damages of tunnels subjected to strike-slip faulting: Effects of tectonic stress and cross-sectional shape. Engineering Failure Analysis, 160, 108159.

[23] Ma Y., Sheng Q., Zhang G. M., & Cui Z. (2019). A 3D discretecontinuum coupling Approach for investigating the deformation and failure mechanism of tunnels across an active fault: A case study of Xianglushan tunnel. Applied Sciences, 9(11), 2318.

[24] O'Rourke, T. D., & Bonneau, A. L. (2007). Lifeline performance under extreme loading during earthquakes. In Earthquake geotechnical engineering (pp. 407-432). Springer.

[25] Owen G. N., & Scholl R. E. (1981). Earthquake engineering of large underground structures. Federal Highway Administration, Report No. FHWA/RD-80/195.

[26] Prentice C. S., & Ponti D. J. (1997). Coseismic deformation of the Wrights tunnel during the 1906 San Francisco earthquake: A key to understanding 1906 fault slip and 1989 surface ruptures in the southern Santa Cruz Mountains, California. Journal of Geophysical Research Solid Earth, 102(B1), 635-648.

[27] Qiao Y. F., Tang J., Liu G. Z., & He M. C. (2022). Longitudinal mechanical response of tunnels under active normal faulting. Underground Space, 7(4), 662-679.

[28] Rahman M. A., & Taniyama H. (2015). Analysis of a buried pipeline subjected to fault displacement: A DEM and FEM study. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 71, 49-62.

[29] Sabagh M., & Ghalandarzadeh A. (2020). Centrifugal modeling of continuous shallow tunnels at active normal faults intersection. Transportation Geotechnics, 22, 100325.

[30] Shen Y. S., Gao B., Yang X. M., & Tao S. J. (2014). Seismic damage mechanism and dynamic deformation characteristic analysis of mountain tunnel after Wenchuan earthquake. Engineering Geology, 180, 85-98.

[31] Tali N., Lashkaripour G. R., Moghadas N. H., & Ghalandarzadeh A. (2019). Centrifuge modeling of reverse fault rupture propagation through single-layered and stratified soil. Engineering Geology, 249, 273-289.

[32] Tang J., He M. C., Bian H. B., & Qiao Y. F. (2024). A novel numerical framework to simulate mechanical response and damage characteristics of mountain tunnels under faulting. Engineering Failure Analysis, 158, 108030.

[33] Tian S. M., Wu K. F., Yu L., Li X., Gong J. F., & Wang X. D. (2022). Key technology of anti-seismic for railway tunnels crossing active fault zone. Tunnel Construction, 42(8), 1351-1364 (in Chinese).

[34] Wang Q., Geng P., Li P. S., Wang T. Q., & Sun W. H. (2023a). Failure analysis and dislocation-resistant design parameters of mining tunnel under normal faulting. Engineering Failure Analysis, 143, 106902.

[35] Wang Q., Geng P., Li P. S., He D. W., & Shen H. M. (2024). Failure analysis of circumferential joints and preferable bolt form of shield tunnel under normal fault dislocation. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 146, 105648.

[36] Wang S. G. (2023). Research on dislocation response and fault resistance performance of tunnel structures across active faults considering dislocation modes. [Master's Thesis, Kunming University of Science and Technology, China]. (in Chinese).

[37] Wang T. Q., Geng P., Liu G. G., Chen C. J., & Gu W. Q. (2023b). Performance-based three-level fortification goal and its application in anti-dislocation countermeasures: A case study of Shantou Submarine tunnel. Underground Space, 12, 251-270.

[38] Wang W. L., Wang T. T., Su J. J., Lin C. H., Seng C. R., & Huang T. H. (2001). Assessment of damage in mountain tunnels due to the Taiwan Chi-Chi Earthquake. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 16(3), 133-150.

[39] Wang Z., Zhong Z. L., Zhao M., Du X. L., Huang J. Q., & Wang H. R. (2025). Experimental study on mechanical behavior and countermeasures of mountain tunnels under strike-slip fault movement. Underground Space, 21, 1-21.

[40] Wang Z. (2022). Disaster mitigation and damage mechanism of rock tunnels with countermeasures crossing active fault zones. [Doctoral dissertation, Beijing University of Technology, China]. (in Chinese).

[41] Xin C. L., Feng W. K., Song D. Q., Huang S., & Liu X. L. (2024). Seismic damage to non-fault-crossing and fault-crossing tunnels: Comparative study of the 2008 Wenchuan earthquake ( Mw 7.9 ) and the 2022 Menyuan earthquake (Mw 6.7). Engineering Failure Analysis, 166, 108843.

[42] Yang H. H., Wang M. N., Yu L., & Zhang X. (2024a). Analytical and numerical analysis on the mechanical response and damage characteristics of tunnels subjected to multiple normal faulting. Computers and Geotechnics, 169, 106254.

[43] Yang H. H., Wang M. N., Luo X., Yu L., Zhang X., & Tang L. Z. (2024b). Longitudinal and cross-sectional partitioned failure mechanism of tunnels subjected to stick-slip action of strike-slip faults. Journal of Central South University, 31(1), 250-271.

[44] Yao C. F., He C., Takemura J., Feng K., Guo D. P., & Huang X. (2021a). Active length of a continuous pipe or tunnel subjected to reverse faulting. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engeering, 148, 106825.

[45] Yao C. F., Takemura J., Ma G. Y., Dai C., & An Z. L. (2021b). Effect of boundary friction on revere fault rupture propagation in centrifuge tests. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 147, 106811.

[46] Yao C. F., Duan J. N., Liu Y. L., Luo W., He C., Yang W. B., Zhang J. C., & Xu G. W. (2025). Damage and failure analysis of twin tunnels with cross passages subjected to strike-slip faulting. Engineering Failure Analysis, 169, 109197.

[47] Yu H. T., Chen J. T., Bobet A., & Yuan Y. (2016). Damage observation and assessment of the Longxi tunnel during the Wenchuan earthquake. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 54, 102-116.

[48] Zhang C. Q., Liu X. Y., Zhu G. J., Zhou H., Zhu Y., & Wang C. (2020). Distribution patterns of rock mass displacement in deeply buried areas induced by active fault creep slip at engineering scale. Journal of Central South University, 27(10), 2849-2863.

[49] Zhang J. W., Cui Z., Sheng Q., Zhao W. H., & Song L. (2024). Experimental study on the effect of flexible joints of a deep-buried tunnel across an active fault under high in-situ stress conditions. Underground Space, 19, 189-207.

[50] Zhang X., Shen Y. S., Qiu J. T., Chang M. Y., Zhou P. F., Huang H. F., & Zhu P. L. (2024a). Failure and deformation mode for soil and tunnel structure crossing multiple slip surfaces of strike-slip fault in model test. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 179, 108541.

[51] Zhang X., Yu L., Wang M. N., & Yang H. H. (2024b). Mechanical response and failure characteristics of tunnels subjected to reverse faulting with nonuniform displacement: Theoretical and numerical investigation. Engineering Failure Analysis, 156, 107809.

[52] Zhang Y., Zhang Z. Q., Yin C., Wei R. H., & Zhang H. (2023a). Experimental study on forced response characteristics and antidislocation performance of articulated tunnel structure under dislocation action of normal fault. Structures, 48, 867-881.

[53] Zhang Z. Q., Zhang Y., Wei R. H., Yin C., & Zhang H. (2023b). The damage mode and forced response characteristics of articulated lining structure: A case study of metro tunnel under a reverse fault action. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 140, 105246.

[54] Zhong Z. L., Wang Z., Zhao M., & Du X. L. (2020). Structural damage assessment of mountain tunnels in fault fracture zone subjected to multiple strike-slip fault movement. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 104, 103527.