Test and damage assessment of shallow buried RC tunnel under explosion

Abstract

As a major element of the transportation network, tunnels are unavoidably threatened by accidental loads such as vehicle bombs and tank truck explosions. The goal of this research is to explore the dynamic characteristics and damage assessment of tunnel structures under contact blast loads. First, three scaled-down reinforced concrete tunnel models were made, and the explosion test and static loading test were carried out successively to evaluate the axial residual bearing capacity, axial displacement and failure mechanism of the tunnel. Secondly, the finite element model is built by utilizing LS-DYNA, and the reliability of the finite element method is confirmed by comparing the data of the explosion test with the static loading test. At the same time, the calculation method for damage coefficient and the classification criteria for damage grade based on axial residual bearing capacity are presented. Then, based on the finite element method, the propagation process of the explosion shock wave in the tunnel and the damage mechanism of the tunnel are investigated. Finally, seven explosion scenarios are developed, the damage degree of these seven tunnels under the blast load is quantitatively analyzed, and further anti-blast design ideas are put forth. The study in this article may give an intended reference for the damage assessment, anti-explosion design and strengthening work of reinforced concrete tunnels.

Keywords

Shallow buried tunnel / Blast location / Blast resistance / Axial residual bearing capacity / Damage assessment

References

[1] General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine of the People’s Republic of China (AQSIQ) (2011). GB/T 288.1— 2010: Metallic materials tensile testing part 1: Method of test at room temperature. Standard Press of China, Beijing, China (in Chinese).

[2] Arachchige B., & Ghasemnejad H. (2017). Post impact analysis of damaged variable-stiffness curved composite plates. Composite Structures, 166, 12-21.

[3] Cai R. Z., Li Y. Z., Zhang C. X., Cao H., Qi H., & Mao J. Z. (2022). Size effect on reinforced concrete slabs under direct contact explosion. Engineering Structures, 252, 113656.

[4] Chen H. L., Zhou J. N., Fan H. L., Jin F. N., Xu Y., Qiu Y. Y.,... Xie W. (2014). Dynamic responses of buried arch structure subjected to subsurface localized impulsive loading: Experimental study. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 65, 89-101.

[5] Chen G. Q., Lu J. X., & Wu H. (2023). Dynamic behavior and retrofitting of RC frame building under vehicular bomb explosion. Engineering Failure Analysis, 143, 106925.

[6] Cheng R. S., Chen W. S., Hao H., & Li J. D. (2021). A state-of-the-art review of road tunnel subjected to blast loads. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 112, 103911.

[7] Esmaeili M., & Tavakoli B. (2019). Finite element method simulation of explosive compaction in saturated loose sandy soils. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 116, 446-459.

[8] Fan L. L., Jin L., & Du X. L. (2022). Influence of medium-low strain rate on the axial failure of CFRP-confined concrete columns: Mesoscale modellings. Construction and Building Materials, 348, 128666.

[9] Goel M. D., Verma S., Mandal J., & Panchal S. (2021). Effect of blast inside tunnel on surrounding soil mass, tunnel lining, and superstruc- ture for varying shapes of tunnels. Underground Space, 6(6), 619-635.

[10] Han Y. Z., Zhang L., & Yang X. R. (2016). Soil-tunnel Interaction under Medium Internal Blast Loading. Procedia Engineering, 143, 403-410.

[11] Hong Z. X., Tao M., Cui X. J., Wu C. Q., & Zhao M. S. (2023). Experimental and numerical studies of the blast-induced overbreak and underbreak in underground roadways. Underground Space, 8, 61-79.

[12] Karthick P., & Ramajeyathilagam K. (2022). Numerical study on ballistic impact behavior of hybrid composites. Materials Today: Proceedings, 59, 995-1003.

[13] Koneshwaran S., Thambiratnam D. P., & Gallage C. (2015a). Blast Response of Segmented Bored Tunnel using Coupled SPH-FE Method. Structures, 2, 58-71.

[14] Koneshwaran S., Thambiratnam D. P., & Gallage C. (2015b). Blast Response and Failure Analysis of a Segmented Buried Tunnel. Structural Engineering International, 25(4), 419-431.

[15] Kwaffo I., Abdallah M. H., & Braimah A. (2022). Experimental assessment of the residual capacity of axially loaded blast-damaged square RC columns. Structures, 40, 469-484.

[16] Li M. H., Zong Z. H., Hao H., Zhang X. H., Lin J., & Xie G. Y. (2019). Experimental and numerical study on the behaviour of CFDST columns subjected to close-in blast loading. Engineering Structures, 185, 203-220.

[17] Li M. H., Zong Z. H., Hao H., Zhang X. H., Lin J., & Liao Y. C. (2020). Post-blast performance and residual capacity of CFDST columns subjected to contact explosions. Journal of Constructional Steel Research, 167, 105960.

[18] Linforth S., Tran P., Rupasinghe M., Nguyen N., Ngo T., Saleh M.,... Shanmugam D. (2019). Unsaturated soil blast: Flying plate experiment and numerical investigations. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 125, 212-228.

[19] Ma L. L., Wu H., & Fang Q. (2021). Damage mode and dynamic response of RC girder bridge under explosions. Engineering Structures, 243, 112676.

[20] Meng Q. F., Wu C. Q., Hao H., Li J., Wu P. T., Yang Y. K., & Wang Z. Q. (2020). Steel fibre reinforced alkali-activated geopolymer concrete slabs subjected to natural gas explosion in buried utility tunnel. Construction and Building Materials, 246, 118447.

[21] Meng Q. F., Wu C. Q., Li J., Wu P. T., Xu S. C., & Wang Z. Q. (2021). A study of pressure characteristics of methane explosion in a 20 m buried tunnel and influence on structural behaviour of concrete elements. Engineering Failure Analysis, 122, 105273.

[22] Mobaraki B., & Vaghefi M. (2015). Numerical study of the depth and cross-sectional shape of tunnel under surface explosion. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 47, 114-122.

[23] Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People’s Republic of China (MOHURD) (2011). GB 50010—2010: Code for design of concrete structures. China Architecture & Building Press, Beijing, China (in Chinese).

[24] MOHURD (2012). 2012 GB/T 50152—2012: Standard for test method of concrete structures. China Architecture & Building Industry Press, Beijing, China (in Chinese).

[25] MOHURD (2016). GB 50292—2015: Standard for appraisal of reliability of civil buildings. China Architecture & Building Press, Beijing, China (in Chinese).

[26] MOHURD (2018). 2017 GB 50017—2017: Standard for design of steel structures. China Architecture & Building Press, Beijing, China (in Chinese).

[27] Mussa M. H., Mutalib A. A., Hamid R., Naidu S. R., Radzi N. A. M., & Abedini M. (2017). Assessment of damage to an underground box tunnel by a surface explosion. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 66, 64-76.

[28] Osinov V. A., Chrisopoulos S., & Triantafyllidis T. (2019). Numerical analysis of the tunnel-soil interaction caused by an explosion in the tunnel. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 122, 318-326.

[29] Prochazka P., & Jandekova´ D. (2020). Effect of explosion source location on tunnel damage. International Journal of Protective Structures, 11(4), 1-20.

[30] Qian H. M., Li J., Zong Z. H., Wu C. Q., & Pan Y. H. (2021). Behavior of precast segmental utility tunnel under ground surface Explosion: A numerical study. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 115, 104071.

[31] Rashiddel A., Kharghani M., Dias D., & Hajihassani M. (2020). Numerical study of the segmental tunnel lining behavior under a surface explosion-Impact of the longitudinal joints shape. Computers and Geotechnics, 128, 103822.

[32] Saleh M., & Edwards L. (2015). Evaluation of soil and fluid structure interaction in blast modelling of the flying plate test. Computers & Structures, 151, 96-114.

[33] Wang D. Z., Zhi X. D., Fan F., & Lin L. (2017). The energy-based failure mechanism of reticulated domes subjected to impact. Thin- Walled Structures, 119, 356-370.

[34] Wang G. H., Lu W. B., Yang G. D., Yan P., Chen M., Zhao X. H., & Li Q. (2020). A state-of-the-art review on blast resistance and protection of high dams to blast loads. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 139(6), 103529.

[35] Wang X., Wang M. N., Chen J., Yan T., Bao Y. F., Chen J. Y.,... Yan G. F. (2020). Analysis of calculation of fresh-air demand for road tunnel ventilation design in China. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 103, 103469.

[36] Wang G. Y., Cao A. S., Wang X. Y., Yu R., Huang X., & Lin J. J. (2021). Numerical simulation of the dynamic responses and damage of underground cavern under multiple explosion sources. Engineering Failure Analysis, 120, 105085.

[37] Wang Z. H., Wen H. M., Zheng H., & Cheng J. S. (2022). Dynamic increase factors of concrete-like materials at very high strain rates. Construction and Building Materials, 345, 128270.

[38] Wang Y. P. (2023). A new insight into the three phases of secant stiffness degradation of concrete under fatigue loading. International Journal of Fatigue, 167, 107323.

[39] Xie W., Jiang M. R., Chen H. L., Zhou J. N., Xu Y., Wang P.,... Jin F. N. (2014). Experimental behaviors of CFRP cloth strengthened buried arch structure subjected to subsurface localized explosion. Composite Structures, 116, 562-570.

[40] Xu T. H., & Zhang L. M. (2015). Numerical implementation of a bounding surface plasticity model for sand under high strain-rate loadings in LS-DYNA. Computers and Geotechnics, 66, 203-218.

[41] Xue Y. Z., Chen G. H., Zhang Q., Xie M. L., & Ma J. J. (2021). Simulation of the dynamic response of an urban utility tunnel under a natural gas explosion. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 108, 103713.

[42] Yang G. D., Wang G. H., Fan Y., Deng K., Lu W. B., & Zhao J. S. (2021). Dynamic response and performance of submarine tunnel subjected to surface explosions. Marine Structures, 80, 103091.

[43] Zhang X. Y., Chen Y., Wan J., Wang K., He K., Chen X. X.,... Jiang G. P. (2018). Tests on residual ultimate bearing capacity of square CFST columns after impact. Journal of Constructional Steel Research, 147, 27-42.

[44] Zhang D. M., Zhou W. D., Bu X. H., Jiang Y., Jia K., & Yang G. H. (2022a). Failure mechanism and stiffness degradation of double lining with inner R/FRC lining subjected to internal water pressure. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 130, 104737.

[45] Zhang K. F., Lu F. Y., Peng Y., & Li X. X. (2022b). Study on dynamic response of gravity dam under air blast load based on similarity law. Engineering Failure Analysis, 138, 106225.

[46] Zhao Y. T., Chu C., & Yi Y. J. (2016). Study on an engineering measure to improve internal explosion resistance capacity of segmental tunnel lining structures. Journal of Vibroengineering, 18(5), 2997-3009.

[47] Zhao W. C., Feng H. D., Ye J. H., & Qian J. (2022). Performance of precast concrete bridge piers with grouted sleeve connections against vehicle impact. Structures, 44, 1874-1885.

[48] Zhou Q., He H. G., Liu S. F., Chen X. S., Tang Z. X., Liu Y.,... Jin F. N. (2021). Blast resistance evaluation of urban utility tunnel reinforced with BFRP bars. Defence Technology, 17, 512-530.

[49] Zhu L., Cai W., Chen M. S., Tian Y. K., & Bi L. Z. (2020). Experimental and numerical analyses of elastic-plastic responses of ship plates under ice floe impacts. Ocean Engineering, 218, 108174.