Comparison of microwave and autoclave treatment for biomedical waste disinfection

Abstract

As the world is facing a Covid-19 pandemic, this virus teaches a lesson about the importance of on-site disinfection. On-site disinfection/sterilization with real-time monitoring of biomedical waste generated from the medical facilities is mandatory to prevent hospital-acquired infection (HAI). In this study, the life cycle assessment of two technologies, i.e., microwave (radiation-based) and autoclave (steam-based) were performed to summarize the inside-out evaluation of both technologies in terms of efficiency, efficacy, and cost-effectiveness. The results of disinfection efficacy indicated a log 10 reduction (almost 100%) in the vegetative load of microorganisms compared to the control, showing a similar level of disinfection efficacy of both strategies. Additionally, both technologies were compared on several parameters, and it was discovered that the autoclave uses more time and resources than the microwave. The total cost of an autoclave to the government is approximately double that of a microwave, while the operational cost of an autoclave is more than double that of a microwave. The findings from this study indicate that MACS may be used as a dry technique of biomedical disinfection, and its portability, tunability, and compactness make it a suitable alternative for biomedical disinfection and sterilization.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Biomedical waste management / Microwave / Disinfection / Sterilization / COVID-19

References

[1] SoaresSR, FinottiAR, Prudêncio da SilvaV, AlvarengaRAF. Applications of life cycle assessment and cost analysis in health care waste management. Waste Manag, 2013, 33: 175-183.

[2] GoswamiM, GoswamiPJ, NautiyalS, PrakashS. Challenges and actions to the environmental management of bio-medical waste during COVID-19 pandemic in India. Heliyon, 2021.

[3] El-RamadyH, BrevikEC, ElbasiounyH, ElbehiryF, AmerM, ElsakhawyT, et al. . Planning for disposal of COVID-19 pandemic wastes in developing countries: a review of current challenges. Environ Monit Assess, 2021.

[4] FagherazziG, GoetzingerC, RashidMA, AguayoGA, HuiartL. Digital health strategies to fight COVID-19 worldwide: challenges, recommendations, and a call for papers. J Med Internet Res, 2020.

[5] HaleemA, JavaidM, VaishyaR. Effects of COVID-19 pandemic in daily life. Curr Med Res Pract, 2020.

[6] IlyasS, SrivastavaRR, KimH. Disinfection technology and strategies for COVID-19 hospital and bio-medical waste management. Sci Total Environ, 2020.

[7] ChandS, ShastryCS, HiremathS, JoelJJ, KrishnabhatCH, MatetiUV. Updates on biomedical waste management during COVID-19: the Indian scenario. Clin Epidemiol Glob Heal, 2021.

[8] PandeV, PandeySC, SatiD, PandeV, SamantM. Bioremediation: an emerging effective approach towards environment restoration. Environ Sustain, 2020.

[9] Selvan ChristyrajJRS, Selvan ChristyrajJD, AdhimoorthyP, RajagopalanK, Nimita-JebaranjithamJ. Impact of biomedical waste management system on infection control in the midst of COVID-19 Pandemic. Impact COVID-19 pandemic green societies, 2021ChamSpringer.

[10] PatilGV, PokhrelK. Biomedical solid waste management in an Indian hospital: a case study. Waste Manag, 2005, 25: 592-599.

[11] ChauhanAFramework for sustainable healthcare waste management in India, 2020ChamSpringer.

[12] YadavSK, ChakrabortyI, BanerjeeS. Bio-Medical Waste Management in India: Contemporary approaches and way forward. Int J Sustain Building Technol, 2020, 3: 12-19

[13] CapoorMR, BhowmikKT. Current perspectives on biomedical waste management: Rules, conventions and treatment technologies. Indian J Med Microbiol, 2017.

[14] KollefMH, TorresA, ShorrAF, Martin-LoechesI, MicekST. Nosocomial infection. Crit Care Med, 2021.

[15] NguyenLKN, MegiddoI, HowickS. Simulation models for transmission of health care–associated infection: a systematic review. Am J Infect Control, 2020.

[16] PittetD, AllegranziB, StorrJ, NejadSB, DziekanG, LeotsakosA, et al. . Infection control as a major World Health Organization priority for developing countries. J Hosp Infect, 2008.

[17] DiazLF, SavageGM, EggerthLL. Alternatives for the treatment and disposal of healthcare wastes in developing countries. Waste Manag, 2005.

[18] YiTC, JusohMN. Overview of Clinical Waste Management in Malaysia. Front Water Environ, 2021, 1: 47-57

[19] World Health Organization (WHO)ChartierYSafe management of wastes from health-care activities, 2014GenevaWorld Health Organization

[20] DuttaJ, GoswamiS, MitraAMultidimensional approaches to impacts of changing environment on human health, 2021LondonCRC Press.

[21] DuCM, WuJ, HuangYN. Analysis of critical technology for hydrogen production in plasma pyrolysis and gasification of organic waste. Zhongguo Huanjing Kexue/China Environ Sci, 2016, 36: 3429-3440

[22] GhodratM, RashidiM, SamaliB. Life cycle assessments of incineration treatment for sharp medical waste. Miner Met Mater Ser, 2017.

[23] AhmadR, LiuG, SantagataR, CasazzaM, XueJ, KhanK, et al. . LCA of hospital solid waste treatment alternatives in a developing country: the case of District Swat, Pakistan. Sustain, 2019.

[24] DasAK, IslamMN, BillahMM, SarkerA. COVID-19 pandemic and healthcare solid waste management strategy: a mini-review. Sci Total Environ, 2021.

[25] GhasemiMK, YusuffRBM. Advantages and disadvantages of healthcare waste treatment and disposal alternatives: Malaysian scenario. Polish J Environ Stud, 2016.

[26] WangJ, ShenJ, YeD, YanX, ZhangY, YangW, et al. . Disinfection technology of hospital wastes and wastewater: Suggestions for disinfection strategy during coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic in China. Environ Pollut, 2019.

[27] Aguilar-ReynosaA, RomaníA, Ma Rodríguez-JassoR, AguilarCN, GarroteG, RuizHA. Microwave heating processing as alternative of pretreatment in second-generation biorefinery: an overview. Energy Convers Manag, 2017.

[28] Gautam K, Bhandari M, Nafouri N. New horizons for medical waste treatment technology. Arab Health, Infection control report 2019. 2019;1–15. https://insights.omnia-health.com/hospital-management/new-horizons-medical-waste-treatment-technology.

[29] Gautam K, Ayesha AR, Bhandari M. Microwave technology: a game changer for sterilization. BioSpectrum. 2020. https://www.biospectrumindia.com/microwave-technology-a-game-changer-for-sterilization.

[30] PatiniR, CattaniP, MarchettiS, IsolaG, QuarantaG, GallenziP. Evaluation of predation capability of periodontopathogens bacteria by Bdellovibrio Bacteriovorus HD100. An in Vitro Study. Materials (Basel), 2019.

[31] SaravananP, KumaranS, BharathiS, SivakumarP, SivakumarP, PugazhvendanSR, et al. . Bioremediation of synthetic textile dyes using live yeast Pichiapastoris. Environ Technol Innov, 2021.

[32] ChernovaA, PukhniarskaiaD, BiryukovM, PlotnikovE. Influence of lithium salt on Escherichiacoli growth and viability. Ind Biotechnol, 2022, 18: 32-37.

[33] GautamK, MarhabaAK, MoryaVK, BhandariM. A novel microwave mediated disinfection method for hospital linen. Indian J Exp Biol, 2019, 57: 806-812

[34] HedgesAJ. Estimating the precision of serial dilutions and viable bacterial counts. Int J Food Microbiol, 2002.

[35] DattaP, MohiG, ChanderJ. Biomedical waste management in India: critical appraisal. J Lab Physicians, 2018.

[36] ZimmermannK. Microwave as an emerging technology for the treatment of biohazardous waste: a mini-review. Waste Manag Res, 2017, 35: 471-479.

[37] Gautam K, Bhandari M, Nafouri N. New horizons for medical waste treatment technology. Arab Health, Infection control report 2019. 2019;1–15. https://insights.omnia-health.com/hospital-management/new-horizons-medical-waste-treatment-technology.

[38] GinawiIA, SaleemM, SighM, VaishAK, AhmadI, SrivastavaVK, et al. . Hospital acquired infections among patients admitted in the medical and surgical wards of a non-teaching secondary care hospital in northern India. J Clin Diagn Res, 2014.

[39] HaqueM, SartelliM, McKimmJ, BakarMA. Health care-associated infections: an overview. Infect Drug Resist, 2018.

[40] LeeBK, EllenbeckerMJ, Moure-ErsasoR. Alternatives for treatment and disposal cost reduction of regulated medical wastes. Waste Manag, 2004.

[41] MarinkovićN, VitaleK, HolcerNJ, DžakulaA, PavićT. Management of hazardous medical waste in Croatia. Waste Manag, 2008.

[42] EkerHH, BilgiliMS. Statistical analysis of waste generation in healthcare services: a case study. Waste Manag Res, 2011.

[43] FerdowsiA, FerdosiM, MehraniM. Incineration or autoclave? A Comparative Study in Isfahan Hospitals Waste Management System (2010). Mater Socio Medica, 2013.

[44] LarhedM, HallbergA. Microwave-assisted high-speed chemistry: a new technique in drug discovery. Drug Discov Today, 2001.

[45] TonuciLRS, PaschoalattoCFPR, PisaniR. Microwave inactivation of Escherichiacoli in healthcare waste. Waste Manag, 2008.

[46] GoldblithSA, WangDIC. Effect of microwaves on Escherichiacoli and Bacillussubtilis. Appl Microbiol, 1967.

[47] ScaglioneE, De FalcoG, MantovaG, CaturanoV, StornaiuoloA, D’AnnaA, et al. . An experimental analysis of five household equipment-based methods for decontamination and reuse of surgical masks. Int J Environ Res Public Health, 2022, 19: 3296.

[48] MyneeduVP, AggarwalA. Disposal of the large volume of sputum positive for Mycobacterium tuberculosis by using microwave sterilisation technology as an alternative to traditional autoclaving in a tertiary respiratory care hospital in Delhi. India Infect Prev Pract, 2020.

[49] BélangerJMR, ParéJRJ, PoonO, FairbridgeC, NgS, MutyalaS, et al. . Remarks on various applications of microwave energy. J Microw Power Electromagn Energy, 2008.

[50] SirohiR, TarafdarA, Kumar GaurV, SinghS, SindhuR, RajasekharanR, et al. . Technologies for disinfection of food grains: advances and way forward. Food Res Int, 2021.

[51] TudorTL, TownendWK, CheesemanCR, EdgarJE. An overview of arisings and large-scale treatment technologies for healthcare waste in the United Kingdom. Waste Manag Res, 2009.

[52] KaragiannidisA, PapageorgiouA, PerkoulidisG, SanidaG, SamarasP. A multi-criteria assessment of scenarios on thermal processing of infectious hospital wastes: a case study for Central Macedonia. Waste Manag, 2010.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Jiangnan University