Multidimensional evaluation of three rainwater retention basins in Brazilian Southeastern region

Abstract

Inundation has become a recurrent issue in urban areas, highlighting the need for effective mitigation strategies. Various interventions have been implemented, underscoring the importance of systematically evaluating their long-term performance. This study presents a case analysis of three rainwater retention basins in Sorocaba, São Paulo, Brazil, applying a multidimensional model to assess interventions made several years ago. Field works included water and sediment sampling, along with in situ measurements of key environmental parameters. A composite index was developed to evaluate each basin’s environmental quality and find improvement opportunities. Two basins were classified as having good environmental conditions, while one (RT basin), showed average performance due to the discharge of untreated sewage from upstream sources, negatively affecting water and sediment quality. Despite these issues, all basins demonstrated potential for ecological and social improvement. The results indicate a favorable situation for local authorities implement effective, targeted actions. For broader impact, future interventions should be strategically planned, with careful attention to site selection and infrastructure sizing, as these factors are essential for long-term sustainability and community benefit.

Keywords

Environmental control / Environmental mitigation / Inundation controller / Urban planning

References

[1] ChaiJ, WuHZ. Prevention/mitigation of natural disasters in urban areas. Smart Constr Sustain Cities, 2023, 14.

[2] Canholi AP (2014) Drenagem urbana e controle de enchentes. 2nd Edition. Oficina de Textos, São Paulo SP 361

[3] JakubínskýJ, ProkopovaM, RaškaP, SalvatiL, BezakN, CudlínO, et al.. Managing floodplains using nature-based solutions to support multiple ecosystem functions and services. WIREs Water, 2021, 85. e1545

[4] Droste N, Schröter-Schlaack C, Hansjürgens B, Zimmermann H (2017) Implementing nature-based solutions in urban areas: financing and governance aspects. In: Kabisch, N., Korn, H., Stadler, J., Bonn, A. Nature-based solutions to climate change adaptation in urban areas: linkages between science, policy and practice. Springer Nature. Cham, Switzerland 337 

[5] TurnerB, DevisscherT, ChabaneixN, WoronieckiS, MessierC, SeddonN. The role of nature-based solutions in supporting social-ecological resilience for climate change adaptation. Annu Rev Environ Resour, 2022, 47(1): 123-148.

[6] Directorate-General for Research and Innovation (European Commission), Arnbjerg-Nielsen K. (2021) Evaluating the impact of nature-based solutions: A handbook for practitioners. Eur Union. https://doi.org/10.2777/244577 https://backend.orbit.dtu.dk/ws/portalfiles/portal/245664823/KI0420586ENN.en.pdf

[7] Kabisch N, Korn H, Stadler J, Bonn A (2017) Nature-based solutions to climate change adaptation in urban areas: linkages between science, policy and practice. Springer Nature. Cham, Switzerland 337

[8] FangX, LiJ, MaQ, ZhouR, DuS. A quantitative review of nature-based solutions for urban sustainability (2016–2022): from science to implementation. Sci Total Environ, 2024, 927. 172219

[9] RemmeRP, MeachamM, PelloweKE, AnderssonE, GuerryAD, JankeB, et al.. Aligning nature-based solutions with ecosystem services in the urban century. Ecosystem Serv, 2024, 66. 101610

[10] DunlopT, KhojastehD, Cohen-ShachamE, GlamoreW, HaghaniM, van den BoschM, et al.. The evolution and future of research on nature-based solutions to address societal challenges. Commun Earth Environ, 2024, 51. 132

[11] StandishRJ, ParkhurstT. Interventions for resilient nature-based solutions: an ecological perspective. J Ecol, 2024, 112(11): 2502-2509.

[12] LongatoD, CortinovisC, BalzanM, GenelettiD. Identifying suitable policy instruments to promote nature-based solutions in urban plans. Cities, 2024, 154. 105348

[13] MaiaSMF, de SouzaMA, dos SantosTC, LyraGB, LalR, AssadED, CerriCEP. Potential of no-till agriculture as a nature-based solution for climate-change mitigation in Brazil. Soil Tillage Res, 2022, 220. 105368

[14] SantosLB. Nature-based solutions in urban periphery communities in Brazil. Societal Impacts, 2024, 3. 100050

[15] PereiraP, WangF, InacioM, KalinauskasM, BogdzevičK, BogunovicI, et al.. Nature-based solutions for carbon sequestration in urban environments. Curr Opin Environ Sci Health, 2024, 37. 100536

[16] MagnierJ, Fribourg-BlancB, LemannT, WitingF, CritchleyW, VolkM. Natural/small water retention measures: their contribution to ecosystem-based concepts. Sustainability, 2024, 163. 1308

[17] De AbreuIA, De Arimatéia Dias ValadãoJ, Da SilvaCA. Nature-based solutions: literature review of the emerging field of sustainability in Brazilian academia. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Change, 2023, 286. 32

[18] SeleguimFB, WeinsNW, GutierrezEP, SoeiraMRC, NichiJ, FerreiraLDC. Nature-based solutions to adapt to local climate change: political strategies in Brazilian cities. Braz Polit Sci Rev, 2024, 18. e0008

[19] De LemosGL, De Aquino EslabãoA, Dos SantosJF, RodriguesAT, Da CostaLF, De Medeiros CostaHK, et al.. Nature-based solutions experiences: a systematic literature review for public policies. Nature-Based Solutions, 2024, 5. 100121

[20] De Oliveira Demarco J, Hutchinson SL, Moore T (2024) Ecological engineering or nature-based solutions: does the term matter? Environ Dev Sustain 27:1–26

[21] KumarP, DebeleSE, SahaniJ, RawatN, Marti-CardonaB, AlfieriSM, et al.. An overview of monitoring methods for assessing the performance of nature-based solutions against natural hazards. Earth-Science Reviews, 2021, 217. 103603

[22] RödlA, ArlatiA. A general procedure to identify indicators for evaluation and monitoring of nature-based solutions projects. Ambio, 2022, 51(11): 2278-2293.

[23] MoazzemS, BhuiyanM, MuthukumaranS, FaganJ, JegatheesanV. A critical review of nature-based systems (NbS) to treat stormwater in response to climate change and urbanization. Curr Pollut Rep, 2024, 10(2): 286-311.

[24] IBGE (Brazilian Institute for Geography and Statistics) (2025) Cid@des – O Brazil município por município. Access in March 2025. https://cidades.ibge.gov.br/brasil/sp/sorocaba/panorama

[25] INEMET (National Institute of Meteorology of Brazil) (2024) Climatological data of Brazilian municipalities and regions. Access: November 2024

[26] Silva FC (2009) Manual de análises químicas de solos, plantas e fertilizantes. 2nd Edition. Embrapa Informação Tecnológica, Brasília, DF, Brazil, 634

[27] Teixeira PC, Donagemma GK, Fontana A, Teixeira WG (2017) Manual de Métodos de Análise de Solo. 3rd Edition. Embrapa Informação Tecnológica, Brasília, DF, Brazil, 24

[28] Silva AM, Schulz HE, Camargo PB (2007) Erosão e Hidrossedimentologia em Bacias Hidrográficas. 2nd Edition. São Carlos, SP, Brazil 153

[29] Odum EP, Barrett GW (2008) Fundamentos de Ecologia. Cengage Learning. Translate of the 5th North American Edition. São Paulo, SP, Brazil 612

[30] CoelhoS, Cardoso-LeiteE, CastelloACD. Composição florística e caracterização sucessional como subsídio para conservação e manejo do PNMCBio, Sorocaba-SP. Cienc Florest, 2016, 26: 331-344.

[31] MMA (Brazilian Federal Ministry for Environment (2004) Resolution CONAMA 344/2004. Link: https://conama.mma.gov.br/index.php?option=com_sisconama&task=documento.download&id=19496

[32] MMA (Brazilian Federal Ministry for Environment (2012). Resolution CONAMA 454/2012. Link: https://www.icmbio.gov.br/cepsul/images/stories/legislacao/Resolucao/2012/res_conama_454_2012_materialserdragadoemaguasjurisdicionaisbrasileiras.pdf

[33] Silva DS (2016) Qualidade da água e sedimento em reservatório. MSc Dissertation. Instituto de Pesquisas Energéticas e Nuclares. São Paulo University, 172 p. Link: https://www.teses.usp.br/teses/disponiveis/85/85134/tde-08072016-103350/publico/2016SilvaQualidade.pdf

[34] GiaconAJJr, SilvaAM. Flood susceptibility mapping in river basins: a risk analysis using AHP-TOPISIS-2 N support and vector machine. Nat Hazard, 2025, 121: 3239-3266.

[35] Esteves FA (1988) Fundamentos de Limnologia. Editora Interciência Ltda. Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

[36] NYSFOLA (New York State Federation of Lake Associations). 2009. Diet for a small lake: the expanded guide to New York State Lake and Watershed Management. 2nd Edition, New York State Federation of Lake Associations, Inc., 319

[37] Esraz-Ul-ZannatM, Dedekorkut-HowesA, MorganEA. A review of nature-based infrastructures and their effectiveness for urban flood risk mitigation. WIREs Clim Change, 2024, 155. e889

[38] JongmanB. Effective adaptation to rising flood risk. Nat Commun, 2018, 9(1): 1-3.

[39] Breil P, Pons MN, Armani G, Amer R, Pienaar H, Oberholster P, Namour P (2022) Natural‐based solutions for bioremediation in water environment. Sustainable solutions for environmental pollution. Air, water and soil reclamation. 1–93

[40] BuckleyYM, AustinA, BardgettR, CatfordJA, HectorA, IlerA, MariotteP. The plant ecology of nature-based solutions for people, biodiversity and climate. J Ecol, 2024, 112(11): 2424-2431.

[41] VerheyenK, GillerotL, BlondeelH, De FrenneP, De PauwK, DepauwL, et al.. Forest canopies as nature‐based solutions to mitigate global change effects on people and nature. J Ecol, 2024, 112(11): 2451-2461.

[42] NettiAM, AbdelwahabOM, DatolaG, RicciGF, DamianiP, OppioA, GentileF. Assessment of nature-based solutions for water resource management in agricultural environments: a stakeholders’ perspective in Southern Italy. Sci Rep, 2024, 141. 24668

[43] DongHB, ZhangGH, YanMJ, TianYL. Soil environmental quality in Nanling commodity grain base based on equal intercept transformation radar chart. Sci Rep, 2021, 111. 10460

[44] Sowińska-ŚwierkoszB, GarcíaJ. A new evaluation framework for nature-based solutions (NBS) projects based on the application of performance questions and indicators approach. Sci Total Environ, 2021, 787. 147615

[45] Sowińska-ŚwierkoszB, GarcíaJ. What are nature-based solutions (NBS)? Setting core ideas for concept clarification. Nature-Based Solutions, 2022, 2. 100009

[46] DuboT, PalomoI, CamachoLL, LocatelliB, CugnietA, RacinaisN, LavorelS. Nature-based solutions for climate change adaptation are not located where they are most needed across the Alps. Reg Environ Change, 2023, 23112.

Funding

Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico(301955/2022)

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)