Features of geotechnical testing of square section piles in seasonally frozen soils

Abstract

This study compares the bearing capacity results of piles obtained through static and dynamic load tests, using different safety factors. The Static Load Test (SLT) based on GOST standards indicated a bearing capacity of 1400 kN. After applying a safety factor of 1.2, the ultimate capacity was calculated as 1167 kN, considered as the baseline (100%) for comparison. The Cone Penetration Test (CPT) at a depth of 7 m yielded a lower bearing capacity of 930 kN, which, after applying a safety factor of 1.25, resulted in an ultimate capacity of 744 kN (63.8% of the SLT value). The Dynamic Load Test (PDA) according to ASTM standards showed the highest bearing capacity, with an average of 1799 kN. Applying a safety factor of 1.4, the ultimate capacity was determined to be 1285 kN, which is 10% higher than the SLT value (110%). This analysis underscores significant variations in pile bearing capacity depending on the testing method, with dynamic tests generally yielding higher ultimate capacities after adjusting for safety factors.

Keywords

Pile test / PDA / SLT / Bearing capacity / Frozen soils / Safety factor

References

[1] ForbesD, AlkemadeN, MitchellD, ZhussupbekovA, OmarovA, ZhumadilovL, TleulenovaG, IssakulovA, MukhanovD. Evaluation of the effectiveness of methods for testing piles in soil conditions of New Mosque in Astana. Curr Trends Civ Eng Eng Sci, 2024, 1: 97-110.

[2] MontayevaA, ZhussupbekovA, KaliakinVN, MontayevS. Analysis on technological features of pile foundations construction in frozen and seasonal thawing soils. IOP Conf Ser Earth Environ Sci, 2021, 7271012006.

[3] ZhussupbekovAZ, MontayevaAS, MontayevSA. The effect of antifreeze reagent on seasonal frozen soils. Period Eng Nat Sci, 2021, 9(3): 245-259.

[4] Omarov AR, Zhussupbekov AZ, Mussakhanova ST, Issakulov AB (2023) Accuracy of determining pile capacity by static and dynamic methods in difficult ground conditions in Astana. Smart Geotech Smart Socs pp. 1375–1379. https://doi.org/10.1201/9781003299127-202

[5] OmarovA, ZhussupbekovA, KaliakinV, ChangDW, DhanyaJS. Comparison of the results of different types of testing piles with static load to predict the load capacity of piles. J Appl Sci Eng, 2025, 28(1): 163-174

[6] OmarovA, SarsembayevaA, ZhussupbekovA, NurgozhinaM, TleulenovaG, YeleussinovaA, IsakulovB. Bearing capacity of precast concrete joint micropile foundations in embedded layers: predictions from dynamic and static load tests according to ASTM standards. Infrastructures, 2024, 97104.

[7] ZhussupbekovA, ChangD-W, UtepovY, BorgekovaK, OmarovA. Estimating the driven pile capacities for COF project in West Kazakhstan. Soil Mech Found Eng, 2019, 56(2): 121-127.

[8] ZhussupbekovA, MorevI, BorgekovaK, ZhukenovaG. Geotechnical considerations of piling testing in problematical soils of West Kazakhstan. Int J of GEOMATE, 2018, 15(47): 111-117.

[9] Zhussupbekov AZh, Syrlybaev MK, Lukpanov RE, Omarov AR (2015) The applications of dynamic and static piling tests of Astana. 15th Asian Regional Conference on Soil Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering, ARC 2015: New Innovations and Sustainability pp. 2726–2729. https://doi.org/10.3208/jgssp.TC305-12

[10] Omarov AR, Zhussupbekov AZ, Tulegulov AD, Zhukenova GA, Tanyrbergenova GK (2016) The analysis of the piling tests on construction site “The future of the free country. Challenges and Innovations in Geotechnics - Proceedings of the 8th Asian Young Geotechnical Engineers Conference, 8AYGEC 2016 127–130

[11] SindeteMathiroJosé, UsuiHirofumi, SomeDonzalaDavid, HinoTakenori. Sustainable approach to quality assurance in cement-improved soil: applications of handheld XRF for geotechnical solutions. Smart Constr Sustain Cities, 2024, 2. 9

[12] OmarovAR, KuderinM, ZhussupbekovA, KaliakinVN, IskakovS. Vibration measurements at a new monument in Nursultan city. Int J GEOMATE, 2011, 21(85): 24-31.

[13] SP RK 5.01.103–2013 (2013) Pile foundation, JSC "KazNIISA", LLP "Monolitstroy-2011" 2021

[14] GOST 20522–2012 Soils. Statistical treatment of the test results, Gersevanov Research Institute of Bases and Underground Structures of the State Construction Committee of Russia

[15] GOST 20276–2012 (2012) Soils. Laboratory methods for determining strength and deformation characteristics

[16] GOST 5686–2012 2012: Soils. Methods for field testing of piles

[17] GOST 19912–2012 (2012) Soils. Field test methods: cone penetration test and dynamic probing. Republic Kazakhstan

[18] GOST 19912–2001 (2001) Soils. Field test methods: cone penetration test and dynamic probing

[19] Hong WP, Chai SG (2003) The Skin Friction Capacity of SDA (Separated Doughnut Auger) Pile. Proceedings of the International Offshore and Polar Engineering Conference pp. 1287–1292

[20] Hussein MH, Goble GG (2004) August A Brief History of the Application of StressWave Theory to Piles. Current Practices and Future Trends in Deep Foundations, Geotechnical Special Publication No. 125, DiMaggio JA, and Hussein MH, (Eds) American Society of Civil Engineers: Reston, VA pp 186–201. https://doi.org/10.1061/40743(142)1

[21] MontayevaA, OmarovA, TleulenovaG, SarsembayevaA, IwasakiY. Field studies of frozen soils composed of alluvial quaternary deposits. Technobius, 2025, 510073.

[22] Pile Driving Analyzer Manual (2009) PDA-W Manual of Operation

[23] Vaidya R (2004) Low Strain Integrity & High Strain Dynamic Testing of Piles - an Indian Overview. Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on the Application of Stress Wave Theory to Piles Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. August. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)1090-0241(2003)129:11(1057)

[24] ChanC, ChongW, MukhtarRA. Pile dynamic analyzer (PDA) test: an overview of the pile integrity evaluation technique. Prog Eng Appl Technol, 2020, 1(1): 48-54

[25] SmithEA. Pile driving analysis by the wave equation. J Soil Mech Found Div, 1986, 86(4): 35-61.

[26] Goble G, Rausche F, Moses F (1970) Dynamic Studies on the Bearing Capacity of Piles - Phase III. Final Report to the Ohio Department of High-ways, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio

[27] Fakharian Kazem A (2000) Case Study On the Application of Pile Driving Analyzer (PDA) And CAPWAP Analysis to Bearing Capacity of Piles. Paper presented at the Tenth International Offshore and Polar Engineering Conference, Seattle, Washington, USA

[28] BudiGS, KosasiM, WijayaDH. Bearing capacity of pile foundations embedded in clays and sands layer predicted using PDA test and static load test. Procedia Eng, 2015, 125: 406-410.

[29] OmarovA, WulansariR, AnwarS. Comparison of Pile Bearing Capacity Based on Standard Penetration Test (SPT), Hydraulic Static Pile Driven (HSPD), and Pile Driving Analyzer (PDA) Test in The Project of Flyover Antapani – Bandung. J Green Sci Technol, 2018, 2(1): 29-38.

[30] MontayevaA, ZhussupbekovA, MontayevS, NashiraliyevZ. The use of quicklime for soil thawing in pile foundation setting. Period Eng Nat Sci, 2021, 9(4): 134-148.

[31] Likins GE, Rausche F (2004) Correlation of CAPWAP with Static Load Tests. Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on the Application of Stresswave Theory to Piles 2004: Petaling Jaya, Selangor”, Malaysia, August pp. 153–165

[32] SN RK 5.01–03–2013 (2013) Pile foundation, JSC "KazNIISA", LLP "Monolitstroy-2011" 2013

[33] Omarov AR, Zhussupbekov AZ, Mussakhanova ST, Issakulov AB (2023) Analysis of interaction of precast concrete joint piles with problematic soil conditions Prorva. Smart Geotech Smart Soc pp. 1385–1394. https://doi.org/10.1201/9781003299127-204

[34] ZhussupbekovA, OmarovA, KaliakinV, ChangD-W. Investigation of interaction of piles at new cargo sea transportation route and LRT projects with problematic soils of Kazakhstan. Lect Notes Civ Eng, 2022, 164: 945-957.

[35] ZhussupbekovA, OmarovA, MangushevR. Geotechnical piling construction and testing on problematical soil ground of Kazakhstan and Russia. Lect Notes Civ Eng, 2021, 112: 89-107.

[36] Zhussupbekov AZh, Omarov AR (2020) Geotechnical considerations of piling construction and testing in problematical soils of Kazakhstan. 16th Asian Regional Conference on Soil Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering ARC 2019

[37] ZhussupbekovA, OmarovA, ShakirovaN, RazuevaD. Complex analysis of bored piles on LRT construction site in Astana. Lecture Notes in Civil Engineering, 2020, 49: 461-471.

[38] ZhussupbekovA, OmarovA, ZhukenovaG, TanyrbergenovaG. Pile foundations of mega projects: new railway station and LRT in problematical soil ground of Astana. Procedia Eng, 2017, 189: 511-518.

[39] Zhussupbekov A, Omarov A, Morev I, Ashkey E, Borgekova K, Popov V (2017) Analysis results of static and dynamic loads tests of pile foundations in constructions site of Expo-2017, Astana, Kazakhstan. ICSMGE 2017 19th International Conference on Soil Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering pp. 3079–3082

Funding

Science Committee of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan(AP22684471)

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)