Sustainable mitigation method for earthquake-induced liquefaction using gravel-tire chips mixture: an integrated approach

Abstract

This study investigates the potential of using Gravel-Tire Chips Mixture (GTCM) drains to mitigate soil liquefaction during earthquakes through an integrated experimental and numerical approach. The experiments involved a controlled setup with three distinct scenarios, evaluating the effectiveness of GTCM drain configurations in controlling excess pore water pressure in foundation soils, thereby reducing liquefaction and building settlement under seismic loading. Numerical simulations were performed to complement the physical tests and provide deeper insights into soil-drain interactions during dynamic events. The experimental results showed that GTCM drains significantly reduced settlement, with a reduction of up to 40 times in cases where GTCM drains were used compared to unmitigated conditions. Additionally, the presence of GTCM drains was effective in dissipating excess pore water pressure, which is a primary cause of liquefaction. Numerical simulations confirmed the experimental findings, indicating minimal pore water pressure buildup and reduced deformation in soils reinforced with GTCM drains. This research demonstrates that GTCM drains provide a sustainable and effective method to mitigate liquefaction and reduce earthquake-induced structural damage. The findings emphasize the importance of strategic drain placement and highlight the environmental benefits of repurposing waste materials such as tires for geotechnical applications, offering a cost-effective solution for enhancing infrastructure resilience in earthquake-prone regions.

Keywords

Liquefaction / Gravel-tire chips mixture / Shaking table test / Drainage / Numerical simulation

References

[1] Arulrajah A, Mohammadinia A, Maghool F, Horpibulsuk S. Tire derived aggregates as a supplementary material with recycled demolition concrete for pavement applications. J Clean Prod, 2019, 230: 129-136

[2] Aydingun O, Adalier K. Numerical analysis of seismically induced liquefaction in earth embankment foundations. Part I. Benchmark mode. Can Geotech J, 2003, 40: 753-765

[3] Biot MA. Theory of propagation of elastic waves in a fluid-saturated porous solid. J Acoust Soc Am, 1956, 28(2): 168-178

[4] Bolton MD. The strength and dilatancy of sands. Geotechnique, 1986, 36(1): 65-78

[5] Brennan AJ, Madabhushi SPG. Effectiveness of vertical drains in mitigation of liquefaction. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng, 2002, 22(9–12): 1059-1065

[6] Brennan AJ, Madabhushi SPG. Liquefaction remediation by vertical drains with varying penetration depths. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng, 2006, 26(5): 469-475

[7] Chan AHC. A generalised fully coupled effective stress based computer procedure for problems in geomechanics, 1988, Swandyne User Manual: Swansea

[8] Chang WJ, Rathje EM, Stokoe KH II, Cox BR. Direct evaluation of effectiveness of prefabricated vertical drains in liquefiable sand. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng, 2004, 24(9–10): 723-731

[9] Chiaro G, Palermo A, Granello G, Banasiak LJ (2019) Direct shear behaviour of gravel-granulated tyre rubber mixtures. In: Proc. of the 13th ANZ Geomechanics Conference. Perth,  Australian Geomechanics Society, 221-226

[10] Chiaro G, Palermo A, Granello G, Tasalloti A, Stratford C, Banasiak LJ (2019) Eco-rubber seismic-isolation foundation systems: a cost-effective way to build resilience. In: Proc. of the 11 Pacific Conference on Earthquake Engineering, April 4–6, Auckland, NZ

[11] Dewoolkar MM, Ko HY, Pak RYS. Seismic behavior of cantilever retaining walls with liquefiable backfills. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng, ASCE, 2001, 127(5): 424-435

[12] Español-Espinel C, Haigh SK, Madabhushi GSP. Liquefaction analysis of soil plugs within large diameter monopiles using numerical modelling. Bull Earthquake Eng, 2023, 21: 5443-5458

[13] Garcia-Torres S, Madabhushi SPG. Performance of vertical drains in liquefaction mitigation under structures. Bull Earthq Eng, 2019, 17(11): 5849-5866

[14] Haigh SK, Ghosh B, Madabhushi GSP. Importance of time step discretisation for nonlinear dynamic finite element analysis. Can Geotech J, 2005, 42(3): 957-963

[15] Hazarika H, Abdullah A. Improvement effects of two and three dimensional geosynthetics used in liquefaction countermeasures. Jpn Geotech Soc Special Public, 2016, 2(68): 2336-2341

[16] Hazarika H, Fukumoto Y. Sustainable solution for seawall protection against tsunami-induced damage. Int J Geomech, 2016, 16(5): C4016005

[17] Hazarika H, Kohama E, Sugano T. Underwater shake table tests on waterfront structures protected with tire chips cushion. J Geotech Environ Eng ASCE USA, 2008, 134(12): 1706-1719

[18] Hazarika H, Kuribayashi K, Kuroda S, Hu Y. Performance evaluation of waste tires in protecting embankment against earthquake loading. Bull Earthq Eng, 2023, 21: 4019-4035

[19] Hazarika H, Pasha SMK, Ishibashi I, Yoshimoto N, Kinoshita T, Endo S, Karmokar AK, Hitosugi T. Tire chips reinforced foundation as liquefaction countermeasure for residential buildings. Soils Found, 2020, 60(2): 315-326

[20] Hazarika H, Yasuhara K, Kikuchi Y, Karmokar AK, Mitarai Y. Multifaceted potentials of tire derived three dimensional geosynthetics in geotechnical application and their evaluation. Geotext Geomembr, 2010, 28(3): 303-315

[21] Hu Y, Hazarika H, Madabhushi GSP, Haigh SK (2023) Geosynthetics wrapped tire derived materials as drains for liquefaction mitigation. In: Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Geosynthetics (12ICG). CRC Press, Rome

[22] Iai S. Similitude for shaking table tests on soil-structure-fluid model in 1g gravitation field. Soils Found, 1989, 29(1): 105-118

[23] Indraratna B, Sun Q, Heitor A, Grant J. Performance of rubber tire-confined capping layer under cyclic loading for railroad conditions. J Mater Civ Eng, 2018, 30(3): 06017021

[24] Iwasaki T, Tatsuoka F, Tokida K, Yasuda S (1978) A practical method for assessing soil liquefaction potential based on case studies at various sites in Japan. In: 2nd International Conference on Microzonation for Safer Construction Research and Application, p 885–896

[25] Karmokar AK. Hazarika Yasuhara. Use of scrap tire derived shredded geomaterials in drainage application. Scrap tire derived geomaterials -opportunities and challenges, 2007, London: Taylor and Francis 127-138

[26] Kaushik MK, Kumar A, Bansal AK. Performance assessment of gravel-tire chips mixes as drainage layer materials using real active MSW landfill leachate. Geotech Geol Eng, 2015, 33: 1081-1098

[27] Kumari S, Sawant VA. Numerical simulation of liquefaction phenomenon considering infinite boundary. Soil Dyn Earthquake Eng, 2021, 142: 106556

[28] Madabhushi GSP, Cilingir U, Haigh SK, Hazarika H (2008) Finite element modelling of the seismic behaviour of waterfront structures. In: The 12th international conference of international association for computer methods and advances in geomechanics (IACMAG). Goa, Curran

[29] Madabhushi SSC, Madabhushi SPG. Finite element analysis of floatation of rectangular tunnels following earthquake induced liquefaction. Indian Geotech J, 2014, 45: 233-242

[30] Madabhushi GSP, Zeng X. Behaviour of gravity quay walls subjected to earthquake loading. Part II: numerical modelling. JNL Geotech Eng, 1998, 124: 418-428

[31] Novasari H, Hakam A (2023) Liquefaction mitigation analysis using vertical drain. In: IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, vol. 1173, no. 1. IOP Publishing Ltd., p 012034

[32] Pasha SMK, Hazarika H, Yoshimoto N. Dynamic properties and liquefaction potential of gravel-tire chips mixture (GTCM). J Jpn Soc Civil Eng, 2018, 74(4): 649-655

[33] Pasha SMK, Hazarika H, Yoshimoto N. Physical and mechanical properties of gravel-tire chips mixture (GTCM). Geosynth Int, 2019, 26(1): 92-110

[34] Pastor M, Zienkiewicz OC, Leung KH. Simple model for transient soil loading in earthquake analysis. II. Non-associative models for sands. Int J Numer Anal Meth Geomech, 1985, 9: 477-498

[35] Senanayake M, Arulrajah A, Maghool F, Horpibulsuk S. Wheel-tracking performance of recycled concrete aggregate with recycled glass and brick in unbound pavements under elevated loads. Smart Construct Sustainable Cities, 2023, 1(1): 6

[36] Tsang HH, Lam NT, Yaghmaei-Sabegh S, Sheikh MN, Indraratna B (2010) Geotechnical seismic isolation by scrap tire-soil mixtures. In: International Conferences on Recent Advances in Geotechnical Earthquake Engineering and Soil Dynamics. p 5

[37] Zienkiewicz OC, Pande GN. Soil mechanics, transient and cyclic loads constitutive relations, and numerical treatment, 1982, New York: Wiley