Shear strength characteristics of mixing slag-stone ballast reinforcement with tire geo-scrap using large-scale direct shear tests

Abstract

Utilizing the ballast layer with more durable and stable characteristics can help avoid significant expenses due to decreased maintenance efforts. Strengthening the ballast layer with different types of reinforcements or substituting the stone aggregates with the appropriate granular materials could potentially help to achieve this goal by reducing the ballast deterioration. One of the exquisite and most effective solutions to eliminate these challenges is to use waste materials such as steel slag aggregates and useless tires. Utilizing these waste materials in the ballasted railway track will contribute to sustainable development, an eco-friendly system, and green infrastructure. So in a state-of-the-art insightful, the ballast aggregates, including a mixture of steel slag and stone aggregates, are reinforced with a novel kind of geo-grid made of waste tire strips known as geo-scraps. This laboratory research tried to explain the shear strength behavior of the introduced mixing slag-stone ballast reinforced with tire geo-scrap. To achieve this goal, a series of large-scale direct shear tests were performed on the ballast which is reinforced by tire geo-scrap and included various combinations of slag and stone aggregates. The concluded results indicate that the optimal mixing ratio is attained by a combination of 75% slag and 25% stone aggregates which is reinforced by tire geo-scrap at a placing level of 120 mm. In this case, the shear strength‌, internal friction angle, vertical displacement, and dilatancy angle of stone–slag ballast reinforced with geo-scraps exhibited average changes of + 28%, + 9%, − 28%, and − 15%, respectively.

References

[1] Sol-Sánchez M, D’Angelo G. Review of the design and maintenance technologies used to decelerate the deterioration of ballasted railway tracks. Constr Build Mater 2017, 157 402-415

[2] Esmaeili M, Yousefian K, Nouri R. Vertical load distribution in ballasted railway tracks with steel slag and limestone ballasts. Int J Pavement Eng 2019, 20 9 1065-1072

[3] Jing G, Wang J, Wang H . Numerical investigation of the behavior of stone ballast mixed by steel slag in ballasted railway track. Constr Build Mater 2020, 262 120015

[4] Wang L, Li J, Tao Y . Compressive characteristics of geogrid-reinforced steel slag. IOP Conf Ser: Earth Environ Sci 2019, 304 4 042002

[5] Indraratna B, Qi Y, Heitor A. Evaluating the properties of mixtures of steel furnace slag, coal wash, and rubber crumbs used as subballast. J Mater Civ Eng 2018, 30 1 04017251

[6] Qi Y, Indraratna B. Energy-based approach to assess the performance of a granular matrix consisting of recycled rubber, steel-furnace slag, and coal wash. J Mater Civ Eng 2020, 32 7 04020169

[7] Esmaeili M, Heydari-Noghabi H, Sayadi A. Field investigation on the lateral resistance of railway tracks including hot mix asphalt layer. Road Mater Pavement Des 2018, 19 1 154-166

[8] Heydari-Noghabi H, Zakeri J, Esmaeili M . Field study using additional rails and an approach slab as a transition zone from slab track to the ballasted track. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2018, 232 4 970-978

[9] Chen C, McDowell GR, Thom NH. Investigating geogrid-reinforced ballast: experimental pull-out tests and discrete element modelling. Soils Found 2014, 54 1 1-11

[10] Ali Zakeri J, Esmaeili M, Heydari-Noghabi H. A field investigation into the effect of under sleeper pads on the reduction of railway-induced ground-borne vibrations. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2016, 230 3 999-1005

[11] Indraratna B, Ngo NT, Rujikiatkamjorn C. Behavior of geogrid-reinforced ballast under various levels of fouling. Geotext Geomembr 2011, 29 3 313-322

[12] Nimbalkar S, Indraratna B. Improved performance of ballasted rail track using geosynthetics and rubber shockmat. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng 2016, 142 8 04016031

[13] Guo Y, Markine V, Qiang W . Effects of crumb rubber size and percentage on degradation reduction of railway ballast. Constr Build Mater 2019, 212 210-224

[14] Esmaeili M, Siahkouhi M. Tire-derived aggregate layer performance in railway bridges as a novel impact absorber: numerical and field study. Struct Control Health Monit 2019, 26 10 e2444

[15] Esmaeili M, Ali Zakeri J, Ebrahimi H . Experimental study on dynamic properties of railway ballast mixed with tire derived aggregate by modal shaker test. Adv Mech Eng 2016, 8 5 168781401664024

[16] Ngo T, Indraratna B, Coop M . Influence of recycled rubber mat on the behaviour of ballast under impact loading: experimental and numerical modelling. Géotechnique 2023

[17] Indraratna B, Qi Y, Malisetty RS . Recycled materials in railroad substructure: an energy perspective. Railw Eng Sci 2022, 30 3 304-322

[18] Qi Y, Indraratna B, Ngo T . Sustainable solutions for railway using recycled rubber. Transp Geotech 2024, 46 101256

[19] Heydari H, Zakeri JA, Taghipour A. Investigating the wheel–rail dynamic response of transition system of concrete slab and ballasted tracks through train–track interaction model. Innov Infrastruct Solut 2024, 9 7 240

[20] Esmaeili M, Heydari-Noghabi H, Kamali M. Numerical investigation of railway transition zones stiffened with auxiliary rails. Proc Inst Civ Eng Transp 2020, 173 5 299-308

[21] Heydari-Noghabi H, Varandas JN, Ali Zakeri J . Performance evaluation of a combined transition system in slab-ballasted railway track using a vehicle–track–substructure interaction model. KSCE J Civ Eng 2023, 27 9 3848-3860

[22] Koh T, Moon SW, Jung H, et al. . A feasibility study on the application of basic oxygen furnace (BOF) steel slag for railway ballast material. Sustainability 2018, 10 2 284

[23] Kumar A. Utilisation of wastes from integrated steel plant with special reference to India. Int J Eng Res & Technol (IJERT) 2014, 3 1 47-52

[24] Jing G, Aela P, Zhou Q et al (2022) Steel slag aggregate characteristics evaluation as railway ballast. Advances in Transportation Geotechnics IV. Springer, Cham

[25] Guo Y, Xie J, Fan Z . Railway ballast material selection and evaluation: a review. Constr Build Mater 2022, 344 128218

[26] Heydari H. Evaluating the dynamic behavior of railway–bridge transition zone: numerical and field measurements. Can J Civ Eng 2024, 51 4 399-408

[27] Fischer S. Geogrid reinforcement of ballasted railway superstructure for stabilization of the railway track geometry—a case study. Geotext Geomembr 2022, 50 5 1036-1051

[28] Liu C, Ngo NT, Indraratna B (2019) Improved performance of railroad ballast using geogrids. Geotechnics for transportation infrastructure. Springer, Singapore

[29] Dehghani M, Kalantari B. Lajevardi SH (2019) Evaluation of the performance of Geo Scrap Tire reinforcement with horizontal transverse members by large-scale pullout test. Amirkabir J Civil Eng 2021, 53 4 1459-1478

[30] Tajabadipour M, Esmaeili M, Askari A. Experimental evaluation of cyclic performance of steel slag and grids of truck scrap tire as a novel reinforced ballast material. Constr Build Mater 2024, 411 134472

[31] Esmaeili M, Heydari H, Darvishi S et al (2024) Investigating effects of tire geo-scrap reinforcement on shear strength characteristics of railway ballast using large-scale direct shear test. Int J Rail Transp:1–22, https://doi.org/10.1080/23248378.2023.2301591

[32] American Railway Engineering and Maintenance of Way Association (2004) Manual for railway engineering. Maryland

[33] Esmaeili M, Askari A. Laboratory investigation of the cyclic behavior of rock ballast mixed with slag ballast for use in railway tracks. Constr Build Mater 2023, 365 130136

[34] ASTM International (2017) ASTM C29/C29M-97, Standard test method for bulk density (“unit weight”) and voids in aggregate. Annual Book of ASTM Standards, West Conshohocken

[35] ASTM International (2016) ASTM C535. Standard test method for resistance to degradation of large-size coarse aggregate by abrasion and impact in the Los Angeles machine. Annual Book of ASTM Standards, West Conshohocken,

[36] ASTM International (2007) ASTM C127, Standard test method for density, relative density (specific gravity), and absorption of coarse aggregate. Annual Book of ASTM Standards, West Conshohocken

[37] Indraratna B, Ngo NT, Rujikiatkamjorn C. Improved performance of ballasted rail tracks using plastics and rubber inclusions. Procedia Eng 2017, 189 207-214

[38] Heydari-Noghabi H, Varandas JN, Esmaeili M . Investigating the influence of auxiliary rails on dynamic behavior of railway transition zone by a 3D train-track interaction model. Lat Am J Solids Struct 2017, 14 11 2000-2018

[39] Zhao C, Ping W. Effect of elastic rubber mats on the reduction of vibration and noise in high-speed elevated railway systems. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2018, 232 6 1837-1851

[40] Fathali M, Nejad FM, Esmaeili M. Influence of tire-derived aggregates on the properties of railway ballast material. J Mater Civ Eng 2017, 29 1 04016177

[41] Heydari H, Zakeri J, Esmaeili M. Evaluating the elastic sleeper efficiency in reduction of railway ground vibrations by in situ impact-response test. Int J Veh Noise Vib 2021, 17 3–4 237

[42] Esmaeili M, Noghabi HH. Investigating seismic behavior of ballasted railway track in earthquake excitation using finite-element model in three-dimensional space. J Transp Eng 2013, 139 7 697-708

[43] Qiang W, Jing G, Connolly DP . The use of recycled rubber in ballasted railway tracks: a review. J Clean Prod 2023, 420 138339

[44] ASTM International (2016) ASTM D412, Standard test methods for vulcanized rubber and thermoplastic elastomers-tension. Annual book of ASTM standards, West Conshohocken

[45] ASTM International (2010) ASTM D792, Standard test methods for density and specific gravity (relative density) of plastics by displacement. Annual book of ASTM standards, West Conshohocken

[46] Biabani MM, Indraratna B. An evaluation of the interface behaviour of rail subballast stabilised with geogrids and geomembranes. Geotext Geomembr 2015, 43 3 240-249

[47] Ferreira FB, Pereira PM, Vieira CS . Time-dependent response of a recycled C&D material-geotextile interface under direct shear mode. Materials (Basel) 2021, 14 11 3070

[48] Suhr B, Marschnig S, Six K. Comparison of two different types of railway ballast in compression and direct shear tests: experimental results and DEM model validation. Granul Matter 2018, 20 4 70

[49] Rohrman AK, Ho CL. Effects of fouling containing plastic fines on abraded ballast strength and deformation properties. Transp Geotech 2019, 21 100278

[50] Liu CN, Ho YH, Huang JW. Large scale direct shear tests of soil/PET-yarn geogrid interfaces. Geotext Geomembr 2009, 27 1 19-30

[51] ASTM International (2011) ASTM D3080, Standard test methods for direct shear test of soils under consolidated drained conditions. Annual book of ASTM standards, West Conshohocken

[52] Heydari H, Naseri R, Khanie N. Investigating the effect of ballast contamination in vertical and shear interlocking stiffness: experimental and numerical study. Constr Build Mater 2024, 428 136337

[53] Esmaeili M, Pourrashnoo A. Experimental investigation of shear strength parameters of ballast encased with geogrid. Constr Build Mater 2022, 335 127491

[54] Heydari H, Khanie N, Naseri R. Formulation and evaluation of the ballast shear interlocking coefficient based on analytical, experimental, and numerical analyses. Constr Build Mater 2023, 406 133457

[55] Hussaini SKK, Sweta K. Application of geogrids in stabilizing rail track substructure. Front Built Environ 2020, 6 20

[56] Sweta K, Hussaini SKK. Behavior evaluation of geogrid-reinforced ballast-subballast interface under shear condition. Geotext Geomembr 2019, 47 1 23-31

[57] Indraratna B, Ngo NT, Rujikiatkamjorn C . Behavior of fresh and fouled railway ballast subjected to direct shear testing: discrete element simulation. Int J Geomech 2014, 14 1 34-44

[58] Ngo NT. Improved performance of geosynthetics enhanced ballast: laboratory and numerical studies. Proc Inst Civ Eng Ground Improv 2018, 171 4 1-21

[59] Ngo NT, Indraratna B, Rujikiatkamjorn C. DEM simulation of the behaviour of geogrid stabilised ballast fouled with coal. Comput Geotech 2014, 55 224-231

[60] Mishra D, Naziur Mahmud SM (2017) Effect of particle size and shape characteristics on ballast shear strength: a numerical study using the direct shear test. In: 2017 Joint Rail Conference, Philadelphia, pp JRC2017–2322

[61] Jing G, Siahkouhi M, Wang H . The improvement of the dynamic behavior of railway bridge transition zone using furnace slag reinforcement: a numerical and experimental study. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2022, 236 4 362-374