Advancing high-speed train gearbox durability: enhanced bearing load and contact stress through transition from helical to herringbone gears

Abstract

High-speed trains typically utilize helical gear transmissions, which significantly impact the bearing load capacity and fatigue service performance of the gearbox bearings. This paper focuses on the gearbox bearings, establishing dynamic models for both helical gear and herringbone gear transmissions in high-speed trains. The modeling particularly emphasizes the precision of the bearings at the gearbox’s pinion and gear wheels. Using this model, a comparative analysis is conducted on the bearing loads and contact stresses of the gearbox bearings under uniform-speed operation between the two gear transmissions. The findings reveal that the helical gear transmission generates axial forces leading to severe load imbalance on the bearings at both sides of the large gear, and this imbalance intensifies with the increase in train speed. Consequently, this results in a significant increase in contact stress on the bearings on one side. The adoption of herringbone gear transmission effectively suppresses axial forces, resolving the load imbalance issue and substantially reducing the contact stress on the originally biased side of the bearings. The study demonstrates that employing herringbone gear transmission can significantly enhance the service performance of high-speed train gearbox bearings, thereby extending their service life.

Keywords

High-speed train / Herringbone gear / Helical gear / Gearbox bearings / Contact stress

References

[1] Chen Z, Zhai W, Wang K. Vibration feature evolution of locomotive with tooth root crack propagation of gear transmission system. Mech Syst Signal Process. 2019, 115: 29-44

[2] Zhang T, Chen Z, Zhai W, et al. . (2019) Establishment and validation of a locomotive–track coupled spatial dynamics model considering dynamic effect of gear transmissions. Mech Syst Signal Process. 2019, 119: 328-345

[3] Natali C, Battarra M, Dalpiaz G, et al. . A critical review on FE-based methods for mesh stiffness estimation in spur gears. Mech Mach Theory. 2021, 161

[4] Luo H, Bo L, Peng C, et al. . Fault diagnosis for high-speed train axle-box bearing using simplified shallow information fusion convolutional neural network. Sensors. 2020, 20(17): 4930

[5] Hou D, Qi H, Li D, et al. . High-speed train wheel set bearing fault diagnosis and prognostics: research on acoustic emission detection mechanism. Mech Syst Signal Process. 2022, 179

[6] Chen S, Meng Y, Tang H, et al. . Robust deep learning-based diagnosis of mixed faults in rotating machinery. IEEE/ASME Trans Mechatron. 2020, 25(5): 2167-2176

[7] Dolenc B, Boˇskoski P, Juričić D. Distributed bearing fault diagnosis based on vibration analysis. Mech Syst Signal Process. 2016, 66–67: 521-532

[8] Sohaib M, Kim CH, Kim JM. A hybrid feature model and deep-learning-based bearing fault diagnosis. Sensors. 2017, 17(12): 2876

[9] Nembhard AD, Sinha JK, Pinkerton A, et al. . Fault diagnosis of rotating machines using vibration and bearing temperature measurements. Diagnostyka. 2013, 14(3): 45-51

[10] Amarnath M, Sugumaran V, Kumar H. Exploiting sound signals for fault diagnosis of bearings using decision tree. Measurement. 2013, 46(3): 1250-1256

[11] Lu S, Wang X, He Q, et al. . Fault diagnosis of motor bearing with speed fluctuation via angular resampling of transient sound signals. J Sound Vib. 2016, 385: 16-32

[12] Hou Y, Wang X, Sun S, et al. . Measured load spectra of the bearing in high-speed train gearbox under different gear meshing conditions. Railw Eng Sci. 2023, 31(1): 37-51

[13] Hou Y, Wang X, Que H, et al. . Variation in contact load at the most loaded position of the outer raceway of a bearing in high-speed train gearbox. Acta Mech Sin. 2021, 37(11): 1683-1695

[14] Shi H, Wang J, Wu P, et al. . Field measurements of the evolution of wheel wear and vehicle dynamics for high-speed trains. Veh Syst Dyn. 2018, 56(8): 1187-1206

[15] Liu Y, Chen Z, Wang K, et al. . Dynamic characteristics analysis of gear transmission and its support bearings of high-speed train on the curve. Veh Syst Dyn. 2023, 2(3): 623-650

[16] Liu Y, Chen Z, Li W, et al. . Dynamic analysis of traction motor in a locomotive considering surface waviness on races of a motor bearing. Railw Eng Sci. 2021, 29(4): 379-393

[17] Liu Y, Chen Z, Zhai W, et al. . Dynamic investigation of traction motor bearing in a locomotive under excitation from track random geometry irregularity. Int J Rail Transp. 2022, 10(1): 72-94

[18] Wang Z, Song Y, Yin Z, et al. . Random response analysis of axle-box bearing of a high-speed train excited by crosswinds and track irregularities. IEEE Trans Veh Technol. 2019, 68(11): 10607-10617

[19] Wu H, Wu P, Li F, et al. . Fatigue analysis of the gearbox housing in high-speed trains under wheel polygonization using a multibody dynamics algorithm. Eng Fail Anal. 2019, 100: 351-364

[20] Patil S, Ambhore P (2020) Design and analysis herringbone gear use in industry. In: ICRRM 2019–system reliability, quality control, safety, maintenance and management: applications to civil, mechanical and chemical engineering, Pune, pp 53–59

[21] Yang J, Zhu R, Lee HP, et al. . Experimental and numerical dynamic analysis of marine herringbone planetary gearbox supported by journal bearings. J Sound Vib. 2023, 545

[22] Wang S, Zhu R. Research on dynamics and failure mechanism of herringbone planetary gearbox in wind turbine under gear surface pitting. Eng Fail Anal. 2023, 146

[23] Hou S, Wei J, Zhang A, et al. . Study of dynamic model of helical/herringbone planetary gear system with friction excitation. J Comput Nonlinear Dyn. 2018, 13(12)

[24] Shi H, Zeng J, Guo J. Disturbance observer-based sliding mode control of active vertical suspension for high-speed rail vehicles. Veh Syst Dyn. 2024

[25] Wu H, Wu P, Guo J, et al. . Current signal characteristics analysis of transmission system in high-speed train under abnormal vibration conditions. Veh Syst Dyn. 2023, 61(4)): 1151-1167

[26] Garg VK. Dynamics of railway vehicle systems. 2012, Orlando, Academic Press

[27] Hou S, Wei J, Zhang A, et al. . A novel comprehensive method for modeling and analysis of mesh stiffness of helical gear. Appl Sci. 2020, 10(19): 6695

[28] Xie C, Hua L, Han X, et al. . Analytical formulas for gear body-induced tooth deflections of spur gears considering structure coupling effect. Int J Mech Sci. 2018, 148: 174-190

[29] Li J, Xu M, Wang S. Finite element analysis of instantaneous mesh stiffness of cylindrical gears (with and without flexible gear body). Commun Numer Methods Eng. 1999, 15(8): 579-587

[30] Hedlund J, Lehtovaara A. A parameterized numerical model for the evaluation of gear mesh stiffness variation of a helical gear pair. Proc Inst Mech Eng C J Mech Eng Sci. 2008, 222(7): 1321-1327

[31] Harris TA, Kotzalas MN. Rolling bearing analysis—2 volume set. 2006, London, CRC Press

[32] Zhao H, Liang J, Liu C. High-speed EMUs: characteristics of technological development and trends. Engineering. 2020, 6(3): 234-244

Funding

National Key Research and Development Project of China(2022YFB3402901)

National Natural Science Foundation of China(52305070)