Numerical modeling techniques for noise emission of free railway wheels

Abstract

In this article, we consider the numerical prediction of the noise emission from a wheelset in laboratory conditions. We focus on the fluid–structure interaction leading to sound emission in the fluid domain by analyzing three different methods to account for acoustic sources. These are a discretized baffled piston using the discrete calculation method (DCM), a closed cylindrical volume using the boundary element method (BEM) and radiating elastic disks in a cubic enclosure solved with the finite element method (FEM). We provide the validation of the baffled piston and the BEM using measurements of the noise emission of a railway wheel by considering ground reflections in the numerical models. Selected space-resolved waveforms are compared with experimental results as well as with a fluid–structure interaction finite element model. The computational advantage of a discretized disk mounted on a baffle and BEM compared to FEM is highlighted, and the baffled pistons limitations caused by a lack of edge radiation effects are investigated.

Keywords

Discretized baffled piston / Finite element / Boundary element / Railway noise / Acoustic emission / Vibrations

References

[1] Thompson D. Railway noise and vibration, 2009 Amsterdam Elsevier Ltd

[2] Cui K Qin X. Numerical computation of wheel-rail impact noises with considering wheel flats based on the boundary element method. J Vibroeng, 2016 18 6 3930-3940

[3] Liu K Jing L. A finite element analysis-based study on the dynamic wheel-rail contact behaviour caused by wheel polygonization. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit, 2020 234 10 1285-1298

[4] Thompson DJ Fodiman P Mahé H. Experimental validation of the TWINS prediction program for rolling noise, part 2: results. J Sound Vib, 1996 193 1 137-147

[5] Thompson D Squicciarini G Zhang J . Assessment of measurement-based methods for separating wheel and track contributions to railway rolling noise. Appl Acoust, 2018 140 48-62

[6] Hannema G, Tröbs H-M, Damme BV et al (2018) Validation of a FEM structure-borne sound radiation model for railway rolling noise. In: NOVEM 2018. Noise and vibration emerging methods (Ibiza, Spain)

[7] Jeong D Choi HS Choi YJ . Measuring acoustic roughness of a longitudinal railhead profile using a multi-sensor integration technique. Sensors, 2019 19 7 1610

[8] Gutiérrez-Gil J, Garcia-Andrés X, Martínez-Casas J et al (2019) Mitigation of railway wheel rolling noise by using advanced optimization techniques. In: EngOpt 2018 proceedings of the 6th international conference on engineering optimization, Lisboa, Portugal, 17–19 September 2019. Springer, pp 1141–1153

[9] Morin B, Plummer CJG, Kalyanasundaram B et al (2023) A fast analytical tool to investigate effects of railway superstructure components on track dynamics. In: The fifth international conference on railway technology: research, development and maintenance, (Montpellier). Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 1–5

[10] Thompson D. Predictions of acoustic radiation from vibrating wheels and rails. J Sound Vib, 1988 120 2 275-280

[11] Remington PJ. Wheel/rail noise—Part I: characterization of the wheel/rail dynamic system. J Sound Vib, 1976 46 3 359-379

[12] Zhong T Chen G Sheng X . Vibration and sound radiation of a rotating train wheel subject to a vertical harmonic wheel-rail force. J Modern Transp, 2018 26 2 81-95

[13] Thompson DJ Jones CJC. Sound radiation from a vibrating railway wheel. J Sound Vib, 2002 253 2 401-419

[14] Finnveden S Fraggstedt M. Waveguide finite elements for curved structures. J Sound Vib, 2008 312 4–5 644-671

[15] Fabre F Theyssen JS Pieringer A . Sound radiation from railway wheels including ground reflections: a half-space formulation for the Fourier boundary element method. J Sound Vibr, 2021 493

[16] Squicciarini G Thompson DJ Toward MG . The effect of temperature on railway rolling noise. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit, 2015 230 8 1777-1789

[17] Fingberg U. A model of wheel-rail squealing noise. J Sound Vib, 1990 143 3 365-377

[18] Thompson DJ Jones CJ. Sound radiation from a vibrating railway wheel. J Sound Vib, 2002 253 2 401-419

[19] Cutanda Henríquez V, Juhl PM (2010) OpenBEM—an open source boundary element method software in acoustics. In: Proceedings of INTER-NOISE 2010. 39th International Congress on Noise Control Engineering : noise and sustainability, Lisbon, Portugal, 13–16 June 2010. Curran Associates, Inc., pp 1–10

[20] Pritchard RL. Mutual acoustic impedance between radiators in an infinite rigid plane. J Acoust Soc Am, 1960 32 730

[21] Arase EM. Mutual radiation impedance of square and rectangular pistons in a rigid infinite baffle. J Acoust Soc Am, 1964 36 1521

[22] Stepanishen PR. Evaluation of mutual radiation impedances between circular pistons by impulse response and asymptotic methods. J Sound Vib, 1978 59 2 221-235

[23] Schneider E Popp K Irretier H. Noise generation in railway wheels due to rail-wheel contact forces. J Sound Vib, 1988 120 2 227-244

[24] Hashimoto N. Measurement of sound radiation efficiency by the discrete calculation method. Appl Acoust, 2001 62 4 429-446

[25] Kolber K Snakowska A Kozupa M. The effect of plate discretization on accuracy of the sound radiation efficiency measurements. Arch Acoust, 2014 39 4 511-518

[26] Bai M Ih J-G Benesty J. Acoustic array systems: theory, implementation, and application, 2013 New York Wiley

[27] Kirkup S. The boundary element method in acoustics, 1998 Hebden Bridge Integrated Sound Software

[28] Pierce AD. Radiation from vibrating bodies, 2019 Cham Springer 177-239

[29] Santoni A, Bonfiglio P, Fausti P et al (2016) Sound radiation efficiency measurements on cross-laminated timber plates. In: Proceedings of the INTER-NOISE 2016. 45th international congress and exposition on noise control engineering. Towards a quieter future, (Hamburg), DEGA

[30] Strutt JW. The theory of sound, 2011 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

[31] Skudrzyk E. The foundations of acoustics: basic mathematics and basic acoustics, 1971 1 Wien Springer

[32] Porter DT. Self- and mutual-radiation impedance and beam patterns for flexural disks in a rigid plane. J Acoust Soc Am, 2005 36 6 1154

[33] Sha K Yang J Gan WS. A simple calculation method for the self- and mutual-radiation impedance of flexible rectangular patches in a rigid infinite baffle. J Sound Vib, 2005 282 1–2 179-195

[34] Ansys Inc (2022) Theory reference ANSYS. 20th edn. Available from: https://www.ansys.com/

[35] Langer P Maeder M Guist C . More than six elements per wavelength: the practical use of structural finite element models and their accuracy in comparison with experimental results. J Comput Acoust, 2017 25 04 1750025

[36] Brick H Ochmann M. A half-space BEM for the simulation of sound propagation above an impedance plane. J Acoust Soc Am, 2008 123 5 3418

Funding

Bundesamt für Umwelt(1337000438)