An integrated market flood risk insurance framework for urban households in South Africa

Abstract

Flood risk in South Africa remains a problem due to climate change, rapid urbanisation and persistent disparities in the region and low-income urban households are disproportionately impacted because of poor access to affordable flood insurance. This paper constructs the Integrated Market Flood Risk Insurance Framework (IMFRIF) based on a qualitative, desk-based research design consisting of contextual policy analysis, systematic literature review and analytical synthesis through systems thinking. The policy and document analysis reviewed the legislation on national disaster management, insurance and industry reports to determine institutional and market limitations on the provision of flood insurance. A PRISMA-ScR systematic literature review filtered 312 records on Scopus, Web of Science, and Google Scholar, which led to the identification of 47 peer-reviewed articles and 15 policy and comparative case studies. Thematic analysis led to the identification of six prevailing clusters of barriers based on the influence on insurance uptake, which included affordability and product design, trust and risk perception, data and risk assessment gaps, regulatory capacity, multi-stakeholder coordination, and community engagement. The results of these studies were used to design the IMFRIF, a system incorporating 9 major stakeholder groups and 5 interdependent system components into a single market-based design. The framework provides a systematic foundation to the resolution of systemic exclusion of flood insurance, but specifically acknowledges the implementation limitations regarding data availability, regulation capacity, fiscal sustainability and communal level of trust. The IMFRIF is placed as a progressive and responsive system that offers a point of future empirical confirmation and policy implementation to promote inclusive disaster risk financing in South Africa and comparable low- and middle-income contexts.

Keywords

Adaptation / Low-income households / Resilience / Disaster risk financing / DRR

References

[1] Tramblay Y, Villarini G, El Khalki EM, Gründemann G, Hughes D. Evaluation of the drivers responsible for flooding in Africa. Water Resour Res 2021; 57(6).

[2] IPCC. IPCC sixth assessment report working group 1: the physical science basis. Geneve: Technical Summary; 2021.

[3] Dube K, Nhamo G, Chikodzi D. Flooding trends and their impacts on coastal communities of Western Cape Province, South Africa. GeoJournal 2021.

[4] Robertson S. Transparency, trust, and integrated assessment models: an ethical consideration for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Wiley Interdiscip Rev: Clim Change 2021; 12(e679).

[5] Mawasha TS. Flash floods prediction in south african urban areas: jukskei river catchment as case study, phd thesis. Nelson Mandela University, Faculty of Science, School of Environmental Sciences; 2021.

[6] World Bank Group. Climate risk profile: south africa. Washington, DC: World Bank Group ; 2021.

[7] Kaky E. Potential habitat suitability of Iraqi amphibians under climate change. Biodiversitas J Biol Divers 2020; 21(2): 731-42.

[8] Gao M, Wang Z, Yang H. Review of Urban Flood resilience: insights from scientometric and systematic analysis. Int J Env Res Public Health 2022; 19(8837).

[9] Okpara JN, Afiesimama EA, Anuforom AC, Owino A, Ogunjobi KO. The applicability of Standardized Precipitation Index: drought characterization for early warning system and weather index insurance in West Africa. Nat Hazards 2017; 89: 555-83.

[10] Kong F, Sun S. Better understanding insurance mechanism in dealing with climate change risk, with special reference to China. Int J Env Res Public Health 2021; 18(6): 2996.

[11] InsuResilience. Mapping the role of insurance in managing disaster losses: a study of low and low-middle income countries. Bonn, Germany: InsuResilience Secretariat; 2017.

[12] Munyai RB. An assessment of community flood vulnerability and adaptation: a case study of greater tzaneen local municipality, south africa 2017.

[13] Adhana DK, Saxena M. Micro insurance in India: a powerful tool to empower poor. Asia Pac J Res Bus Manag 2017; 8(7). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3024113.

[14] Lefutso D. Transformative policy and legislative strategies for flood disaster management in post-apartheid South Africa. J Disaster Sci Manag 2025; 1(1): 15.

[15] Treasury National. Technical paper: financing a sustainable economy. Pretoria: South African Government; 2021.

[16] Kramer B, Rusconi R, Glauber J. Five years of regional risk pooling an updated cost-benefit analysis of the african risk capacity. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute; 2020.

[17] Impact Insurance Facility. (2014). Mzansi short term voluntary insurance- Hollard Insurance . Retrieved 2021 September, from Insurance Facility: http://www.impactinsurance.org/projects/lessons/mzansi-short-term-voluntary-insurance.

[18] Cenfri.. Insurance products standards to reach low-income consumers in south africa: help or hindrance? Bellville, South Africa: Centre for Financial Regulation and Inclusion; 2011.

[19] SwissRe. (2024, July 24). Swiss re institute . Retrieved from www.swissre.com: https://www.swissre.com/dam/jcr:b0160fc3-b71b-433a-a6d5-f230cd1c3cac/swiss-re-institute-world-insurance-sigma-top-ten-insurance-penetration-data-to-download-2021.xlsx.

[20] Huneberg S. Promoting financial inclusion in the South African insurance industry: is insurtech the missing link? Tydskr Hedendaagse Romeins-Holl Reg (J Contemp Roman-Dutch Law) 2022; 85(1): 1-20.

[21] Daniso N. Assessing the possible effects of revitalisation of the bisho central business district (CBD) of fire response: case study bisho cbd in eastern cape. thesis in submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree masters in disaster management. University of the Free State: Disaster Management Training and Education Center for Africa; 2021.

[22] Financial Sector Charter. (2005). Access to financial sector short-term insurance position paper. Johannesburg.

[23] Lefutso D, Ogundeji AA, Danso-Abbeam G, Nyam YS. Assessment of knowledge, attitudes, and perceptions toward flood risk insurance amongst low-income households in South Africa. Clim Serv 2025; 38: 100542.

[24] Mojtahedi M, Oo BL. Critical attributes for proactive engagement of stakeholders in disaster risk management. Int J Disaster Risk Reduct 2017; 21: 35-43.

[25] Thaler T, Seebauer S. Bottom-up citizen initiatives in natural hazard management: why they appear and what they can do? Env Sci Policy 2019; 94: 101-11.

[26] Lechowska E. What determines flood risk perception? A review of factors of flood risk perception and relations between its basic elements. Nat Hazards 2018; 94: 1341-66.

[27] Kousky C. Understanding disaster insurance: new tools for a more resilient future. Island Press; 2022.

[28] Guerriero R, Penning-Rowsell EC. Innovation in flood risk management: an ‘Avenues of Innovation’ analysis. J Flood Risk Manag 2021; 14(1): e12677.

[29] Fras M, Pauch D, Walczak D, Bera A. Determinants of the behaviour of entities on the insurance market in the light of changes introduced by the IDD Directive. J Consum Policy 2024: 1-34.

[30] Balog-Way D, McComas K, Besley J. The evolving field of risk communication. Risk Anal 2020; 40(S1): 2240-62.

[31] Inpin W, Juwitasari R, Dania M, Miyake Y, Maki T, Takeuchi Y. Actor-network in disaster education: mainstreaming the role of higher education in climate resilience for sustainable development in Northern Thai school. J Soc Stud Educ Res 2023; 14(3): 328-56.

[32] Khaspuria G, Ranjan A, Soni P, Dadhich K. Natural disaster mitigation strategies: a comprehensive review. J Sci Res Rep 2024; 30(8): 20-34.

[33] Coppola DP. Participants-multilateral organizations and international financial institutions. Introd Int Disaster Manag 2015: 588.

[34] Roberts FJB, Archer F, Spencer C. We just want to help. Nonprofits contributions to community resilience in the disaster space . Prehosp Disaster Med 2019; 34: s22.- s22.

[35] Veldkamp L. Information choice in macroeconomics and finance. Princeton University Press; 2023.

[36] Trell EM, Van Geet MT. The governance of local urban climate adaptation: towards participation, collaboration and shared responsibilities. Plan Theory Pract 2019; 20(3): 376-94.

[37] Maria V. Insurance market regulation. Ann-Econ Ser 2023; 6: 240-4.

[38] Mehryar S, Surminski S. National laws for enhancing flood resilience in the context of climate change: potential and shortcomings. Clim Policy 2021; 21(2): 133-51.

[39] Frazier T, Boyden EE, Wood E. Socioeconomic implications of national flood insurance policy reform and flood insurance rate map revisions. Nat Hazards 2020; 103(1): 329-46.

[40] Singhal N, Goyal S, Singhal T. Regulatory, economic, and political challenges for decentralized insurance: a global perspective. Potential, risks, and ethical implications of decentralized insurance. Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore; 2024. p. 165-210.

[41] Andreeva T. Risk management in the insurance company. Ethics Sustain Account Finance 2021; II: 131-8. Volume.

[42] Lefutso D, Ogundeji AA, Danso-Abbeam G, Nyam YS. Low-income households' willingness to pay for flood risk insurance in South Africa. Prog Disaster Sci 2025; 25: 100403.

[43] Tesselaar M, Botzen WW, Haer T, Hudson P, Tiggeloven T, Aerts JC. Regional inequalities in flood insurance affordability and uptake under climate change. Sustainability 2020; 12(20): 8734. p.

[44] Kraehnert K, Osberghaus D, Hott C, Habtemariam LT, Wätzold F, Hecker LP, Fluhrer S. Insurance against extreme weather events: an overview. Rev Econ 2021; 72(2): 71-95.

[45] Hemstock, S., Buliruarua, L., Chan, E.Y., Chan, G., Des Combes, H.J., Davey, P., Farrell, P., Griffiths, S., Hansen, H., Hatch, T., & Ronan, K. (2016). Accredited qualifications for capacity development in disaster risk reduction and climate change adaptation.

[46] Rubenstein J. Between samaritans and states: the political ethics of humanitarian INGOs. OUP Oxford; 2015.

[47] Shaw R. Thirty years of science, technology, and academia in disaster risk reduction and emerging responsibilities. Int J Disaster Risk Sci 2020; 11(4): 414-25.

[48] Yore Rebekah, Walker Joanna Faure. Microinsurance for disaster recovery: business venture or humanitarian intervention? An analysis of potential success and failure factors of microinsurance case studies. Int J Disaster Risk Reduct 2019; 33: 16-32.

[49] Cvetković VM, Aleksova B, Renner R, Gačić J, Ivanov A, Milašinović S. Community-based disaster risk reduction: overcoming barriers to build stronger communities. Int J Disaster Risk Manag 2025; 7(2): 113-30.

[50] Sarabia MM, Kägi A, Davison AC, Banwell N, Montes C, Aebischer C, Hostettler S. The challenges of impact evaluation: attempting to measure the effectiveness of community-based disaster risk management. Int J Disaster Risk Reduct 2020; 49: 101732.

[51] Lassa, J.A. (2018). Roles of non-government organizations in disaster risk reduction. In Oxford research encyclopedia of natural hazard science.

[52] Cinceoglu V, Strauß N. Unmasking greenwashing-the role of the news media in giving voice to whistleblowers in sustainable finance. Journalism 2025; 26(2): 445-63.

[53] Strauß N. Covering sustainable finance: role perceptions, journalistic practices and moral dilemmas. Journalism 2021; 23(6): 14648849211001784.

[54] Underkuffler LS. Challenging equality: property loss, government fault, and the global warming catastrophe. Northwest Univ Law Rev 2022; 117(1): 335. p.

[55] Shively D. Flood risk management in the USA: implications of national flood insurance program changes for social justice. Reg Env Change 2017; 17: 1663-72.

[56] Elliott R. Stopping the flow: the aspirational elimination of flood insurance cross-subsidies in the United States and the United Kingdom. In: Booth B, Lucas C, French S, editors. Climate, society and elemental insurance. Oxford: Routledge; 2022. p. 59-69.

[57] Kundzewicz ZW, Hegger DL, Matczak P, Driessen PP. Flood-risk reduction: structural measures and diverse strategies. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2018; 115(49): 12321-5.

[58] Mikša K, Kalinauskas M, Inácio M, Pereira P. Implementation of the European Union Floods Directive-Requirements and national transposition and practical application: lithuanian case-study. Land Use Policy 2021; 100: 104924.

[59] Priest, S.J., Suykens, C., Van Rijswick, H.F., Schellenberger, T., Goytia, S., Kundzewicz, Z.W., van Doorn-Hoekveld, W.J., Beyers, J.C., & Homewood, S. (2016). The European Union approach to flood risk management and improving societal resilience: lessons from the implementation of the Floods Directive in six European countries. Ecol Soc, 21(4).

[60] Nones M. Flood hazard maps in the European context. Water Int 2017; 42(3): 324-32.

[61] Marano P. Sources and tools of the insurance regulation in the European Union. In: Marano P , Siri M, editors. Insurance regulation in the european union: solvency ii and beyond. Palgrave Macmillan; 2017. p. 5-29.

[62] Thistlethwaite J. The emergence of flood insurance in Canada: navigating institutional uncertainty. Risk Anal 2017; 37(4): 744-55.

[63] Porrini D. Risk classification efficiency and the insurance market regulation. Risks 2015; 3(4): 445-54.

[64] Keskitalo E, Vulturius G, Scholten P. Adaptation to climate change in the insurance sector: examples from the UK, Germany and the Netherlands. Nat Hazards 2014; 71: 315-34.

[65] Defever KM. Comparative analysis of European Union and United States insurance law systems - with emphasis on Consumer Protection law. EJCCL 2018; 10: 9. p.

[66] Nicholson JE. Challenges for the insurance industry in the future. J Insur Regul 2019; 38(6): 1-26.

[67] Surminski S. Fit for purpose and fit for the future? An evaluation of the UK's new flood reinsurance pool. Risk Manag Insur Rev 2018; 21(1): 33-72.

[68] Surminski S, Aerts JC, Botzen WJ, Hudson P, Mysiak J, Pérez-Blanco CD. Reflections on the current debate on how to link flood insurance and disaster risk reduction in the European Union. Nat Hazards 2015; 79: 1451- 79.