Review of the optimal timing and technique for extensor tendon reconstruction in composite dorsal hand wounds

Abstract

Aim: The management of complex dorsal hand wounds with extensor tendon loss is controversial. Treatment has focused on soft tissue coverage, but there is limited evidence comparing immediate vs. staged tendon reconstruction. This review evaluates existing literature to determine the optimal management of composite hand defects.

Methods: A MEDLINE database review was performed including objective measurements such as number of operations, total active motion, grip strength, days to maximum range of motion (ROM), and return to work. Data extraction included demographics, surgical techniques, complications, and relative outcome. We compared primary and secondary staged reconstruction to correlate any significant differences in outcome and determine optimal timing and technique for extensor tendon reconstruction. We extracted information on flap types including regional and free tissue transfer with tendinous components vs. staged tendon grafts.

Results: Comparison of outcomes showed that patients with immediate reconstruction had fewer operations, faster return to maximum ROM, and greater chance of returning to work. The most successful single stage flaps include the radial forearm, suitable for reconstructing one to three tendons and the dorsalis pedis for three or four tendons; however, there were significantly more complications in immediate reconstruction particularly regarding donor site morbidity. Pedicled flaps had better total active motion. The two-stage approach resulted in acceptable functional outcomes without significant complications.

Conclusion: Immediate cutaneous tendinous flaps have clear advantages over staged approaches for reconstruction of composite dorsal hand wounds. Benefits include less operations, faster time to maximum ROM, and higher percent of patients returning to work; however, significantly more flap related complications were seen. Immediate pedicled radial forearm provided the best total active motion with least complications. When patient circumstances dictate, a fascial perforator free flap offers a suitable environment for staged tendon grafts with good functional outcomes reported albeit longer time to achieve them.

Keywords

Composite dorsal hand wound flap extensor tendon reconstruction

References

[1] Amirtharajah M.Open extensor tendon injuries..J Hand Surg Am2015;40:391-7

[2] Lutz K,Grewal R.Management of complications of extensor tendon injuries..Hand Clin2015;31:301-10

[3] Carty MJ.Complex Flexor and Extensor Tendon Injuries..Hand Clin2013;29:283-93

[4] Dessai SS,Levine SL.Microsurgical reconstruction of the extensor system..Hand Clin1995;11:471-82

[5] Reid DA.Hand Injuries requiring skin-replacement and restoration of tendon function..Br J Plast Surg1974;27:5-18

[6] Taylor GI.Composite free flap and tendon transfer: an anatomical study and clinical technique..Br J Plast Surg1979;6:31-7

[7] Vila-Rovira R,Guinot A.Transfer of vascularized extensor tendons from the foot to the hand with a dorsalis pedis flap..Plast Reconstr Surg1985;76:421-5

[8] Hentz VR.Hand reconstruction following avulsion of all dorsal soft tissues. A cutaneo-tendinous free tissue transfer..Ann Chir Main1987;6:31-7

[9] Caroli A,Castagnetti C,Squarzina PB.Dorsalis pedis flap with vascularized extensor tendons for dorsal hand reconstruction..Plast Reconstr Surg1993;92:1326-30

[10] Lee KS,Kim HY.Tendocutaneous free flap transfer from the dorsum of the foot..Microsurgery1994;15:882-5

[11] Cho BC,Weinsweig N.Use of free innervated dorsalis pedis tendocutaneous flap in composite hand reconstruction..Ann Plast Surg1998;40:268-76

[12] Reid CD.One-stage flap repair with vascularized tendon grafts in a dorsal hand injury using the “Chinese” forearm flap..Br J Plast Surg1983;36:473-9

[13] Foucher G,Merle M.A compound radial artery forearm flap in hand surgery: an original modification of the Chinese forearm flap..Br J Plast Surg1984;37:139-148

[14] Yajima H,Shono M.Radial forearm flap with vascularized tendons for hand reconstruction..Plast Reconstr Surg1996;98:328-33

[15] Glasson DW.The ulnar island flap in hand and forearm reconstruction..Br J Plast Surg1988;41:349-353

[16] Costa H,Martins A,Reis J.Further experience with the posterior interosseous flap..Br J Plast Surg1991;44:449-55

[17] Lu LJ,Lu XM.The reverse posterior interosseous flap and its composite flap: experience with 201 flaps..J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg2007;60:876-82

[18] Gosain AK,Yousif NJ.The composite lateral arm free flap: vascular relationship to triceps tendon and muscle..Ann Plast Surg1992;29:496-507

[19] Ulusal BG,Ulusal AE.Free lateral arm flap for 1-stage reconstruction of soft tissue and composite defects of the hand: A retrospective analysis of 118 cases..Ann Plast Surg2007;58:173-8

[20] Zhang WF,Li JY,Zhang XF.Repair of tissue defects with free composite anterolateral femoral fascia lata perforator tissue flaps..Zhonghua Shao Shang Za Zhi2013;29:427-31

[21] Cui MY.Anterolateral thigh free flap for simultaneous reconstruction of digital extensor tendon and defect of the dorsal hand: A case report..Chin J Traumatol2016;19:309-10 PMCID:PMC5068141

[22] Yazar S,Kilic B.Use of composite anterolateral thigh flap as double-vascularised layers for reconstruction of complex hand dorsum defect..J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg2008;61:1549-50

[23] Schubert CD.Extensor tendon repair and reconstruction..Clin Plastic Surg2014;41:525-531

[24] Sundine M.A comparison of immediate and staged reconstruction of the dorsum of the hand..J Hand Surg Br1996;21:216-21

[25] Scheker LR,Martin DL.Primary extensor tendon reconstruction in dorsal hand defects requiring free flaps..J Hand Surg Br1993;18:568-75

[26] Adani R,Castagnetti C,Marcoccio I.Tendinous cutaneous dorsal hand injuries. One-stage reconstruction..Chir Organi Mov2002;87:87-95

[27] Adani R,Tarallo L.Flap coverage of dorsum of hand associated with extensor tendons injuries: a completely vascularized single-stage reconstruction..Microsurgery2003;23:32-9

[28] Cautilli D.Extensor tendon grafting on the dorsum of hand in massive tendon loss..Hand Clin1995;11:423-9

[29] Al-Qattan MM.Two-staged extensor tendon reconstruction for zone 6 extensor tendon loss of the fingers: indications, technique and results..J Hand Surg Eur Vol2015;40:276-80

[30] Benhaim T,Qassemyar Q,Robbe M.Reconstruction of hand dorsum soft tissue defect using anterolateral thigh perforator flap: description, case study and review of literature..Chir Main2011;30:56-61

[31] Lukas B,Bäcker K.[Soft-tissue reconstruction of the dorsum of the hand and finger to cover the extender tendons]..Handchir Mikrochir Plast Chir.2008;40:110-4

[32] Hammond K,Katz D.Effect of aftercare regimen with extensor tendon repair: a systematic review of the literature..J Surg Orthop Adv2012;21:246-52

[33] Koul AR,Philip V.Complex extensor tendon injuries: early active motion following single-stage reconstruction..J Hand Surg (European Volume)2008;33:753-9

[34] Kitis A,Bagdatli D,Kara IG.Comparison of static and dynamic splinting regimens for extensor tendon repairs in zones V to VII..J Plast Surg Hand Surg2012;46:267-71

[35] Sameem M,Ignacy T,Strumas N.A systematic review of rehabilitation protocols after surgical repair of the extensor tendons in zones V-VIII of the hand..J Hand Ther2011;24:365-72

[36] Sultana SS,Grewal R.The effectiveness of early mobilization after tendon transfers in the hand: a systematic review..J Hand Ther2013;26:1-20