Gender gap among plastic surgery residents: the Italian experience

Abstract

Aim: Despite the significant increase in the proportion of graduating female physicians in recent decades, gender representation in surgical training remains imbalanced. The initial rise in female interest in plastic surgery has reached a plateau. Gender bias, affecting women’s confidence and opportunities, negatively impacts training and career prospects. This study aims to quantify and analyze disparities in surgical training opportunities, workplace treatment, and career advancement among male and female plastic surgery residents in Italy.

Methods: Our study involved all Italian plastic surgery residents contacted between February and March 2024. A 21-item survey assessed professional, surgical, and personal aspects, focusing on gender gap differences. Responses were expressed in percentages and compared utilizing the Fisher Exact test.

Results: A total of 551 surveys were distributed to Italian plastic surgery residents, with 46 responses each among women and men. Gender disparities persisted in workplace treatment, with more women reporting discrimination. Significant differences were identified in treatment inequality by hospital personnel and patients, the occurrence of inappropriate comments in the workplace, inquiries regarding work-life balance and career advancement opportunities, an augmented gender gap in surgical vs. clinical programs, and the perception of a negative impact of gender on surgical training.

Conclusion: In conclusion, our study emphasizes the pervasive gender inequality in plastic surgery training, urging action against systemic biases hindering female surgeons’ progress. Gender equity efforts should combat discrimination, promote work-life balance, and foster inclusive training environments. Addressing these issues can create a field that empowers all surgeons to thrive.

Keywords

Gender bias / women in surgery / plastic surgery / gender gap / resident

References

[1] Association of American Medical Colleges. Table 1: medical students, selected years. 1965-2015. Available from: https://www.aamc.org/media/8661/download. [Last accessed on 30 Aug 2024]

[2] Association of American Medical Colleges. Matriculating Student Questionnaire (MSQ). Available from: https://www.aamc.org/data/msq/. [Last accessed on 30 Aug 2024]

[3] Association of American Medical Colleges. Table B3: Number of active residents, by type of medical school, GME specialty, and sex. Available from: https://www.aamc.org/data/493922/report-on-residents-2018-b3table.html. [Last accessed on 30 Aug 2024]

[4] Association of American Medical Colleges. Plastic surgery-integrated. Available from: https://www.aamc.org/media/6386/download. [Last accessed on 30 Aug 2024]

[5] American Society of Plastic Surgery. Women underrepresented in plastic surgery. Available from: https://www.plasticsurgery.org/news/press-releases/women-underrepresented-in-plastic-surgery. [Last accessed on 30 Aug 2024]

[6] Bucknor A,Phillips N.Gender inequality for women in plastic surgery: a systematic scoping review.Plast Reconstr Surg2018;141:1561-77

[7] Phillips NA,Kalliainen LK.Understanding and overcoming implicit gender bias in plastic surgery.Plast Reconstr Surg2016;138:1111-6

[8] Ehrlinger J.How chronic self-views influence (and potentially mislead) estimates of performance.J Pers Soc Psychol2003;84:5-17

[9] Moss-Racusin CA,Brescoll VL,Handelsman J.Science faculty’s subtle gender biases favor male students.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A2012;109:16474-9 PMCID:PMC3478626

[10] Hoops H,Dewey E,Brasel K.Resident autonomy in the operating room: does gender matter?.Am J Surg2019;217:301-5

[11] Stanek K,Staffa SJ,Rogers-Vizena CR.Gender differences in plastic surgery trainee confidence: a pilot analysis during cleft lip simulation.Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open2023;11:e5428 PMCID:PMC10703114

[12] Giacomelli E,Speziali S.Gender-related disparities among vascular surgeons in italy: results from a cross-sectional survey.Ann Vasc Surg2024;105:20-8

[13] Parini S,Azzolina D.Women in surgery Italia: national survey assessing gender-related challenges.J Am Coll Surg2021;233:583-92.e2

[14] Franchi E,Capelli G.Women in transplant surgery in Italy.Transplantation2023;107:793-6

[15] Keane AM,Santosa KB.Women in leadership and their influence on the gender diversity of academic plastic surgery programs.Plast Reconstr Surg2021;147:516-26 PMCID:PMC7902393

[16] Halperin TJ,Mulliken JB.Gender differences in the professional and private lives of plastic surgeons.Ann Plast Surg2010;64:775-9

[17] Lafer MP,Zhang Y,Lee JW.Gender differences in compensation, mentorship, and work-life balance within facial plastic surgery.Laryngoscope2021;131:E787-91

[18] Naidu NS,Bregman D.Challenges to professional success for women plastic surgeons: an international survey.Aesthetic Plast Surg2021;45:2464-72

[19] Caan N. Achieving gender parity: women’s role in plastic surgery. Available from: https://www.plasticsurgery.org/news/articles/achieving-gender-parity-womens-role-in-plastic-surgery#:~:text=The%20latest%20data%20on%20residents,plastic%20surgery%20residents%20were%20women. [Last accessed on 30 Aug 2024]

[20] Chen W,Bourne DA,De La Cruz C.A report of gender bias and sexual harassment in current plastic surgery training: a national survey.Plast Reconstr Surg2021;147:1454-68