The impact of biomaterial characteristics on macrophage phenotypes in tissue engineering: a review

Abstract

Macrophages are highly plastic cells central to pathogen removal, tissue regeneration, and inflammation, making them key targets in biomaterial design for improved clinical outcomes. Foreign body responses (FBRs) to implanted biomaterials often involve excessive macrophage-mediated inflammation, leading to fibrotic encapsulation, infection, and implant failure. Advances in tissue engineering demonstrate that macrophage polarization - the transition from pro-inflammatory M1 to anti-inflammatory M2 phenotypes - can be influenced by biomaterial properties to mitigate these responses and enhance regeneration. This review synthesizes the relationship between biomaterial properties, such as surface chemistry, structure, and stiffness, and their ability to modulate macrophage behavior. Key innovations, including tailored scaffold architectures, bioactive coatings, and cytokine delivery systems, have shown promise in guiding macrophage polarization for improved bone, soft tissue, and head and neck reconstruction outcomes. Strategies like hydrogels and nanostructured materials enable spatially and temporally controlled macrophage modulation, mimicking native extracellular matrix dynamics, mitigating chronic inflammation, and accelerating vascularization, extracellular matrix remodeling, and tissue integration. By integrating recent findings, this review provides a framework for designing biomaterials that actively modulate macrophage activity to overcome FBR and enhance healing. It identifies critical gaps, such as understanding macrophage-stromal interactions, developing personalized biomaterial designs to address patient variability, and leveraging advanced technologies like artificial intelligence in scaffold optimization. These insights advance the development of biomaterials that restore tissue function and address unmet clinical needs in regenerative medicine.

Keywords

Macrophage polarization / biomaterials / tissue engineering / immune response / M1 macrophages / M2 macrophages / material properties / tissue regeneration

References

[1] Tsouknidas A.Advancements in biomaterials for bioengineering and biotechnology.Int J Mol Sci2024;25:7840 PMCID:PMC11276613

[2] Smith TD,Chen EY.Harnessing macrophage plasticity for tissue regeneration.Adv Drug Deliv Rev2017;114:193-205

[3] Söhling N,Kontradowitz K,Marzi I.Early immune response in foreign body reaction is implant/material specific.Materials2022;15:2195 PMCID:PMC8950904

[4] Castañón-Cortés LG,Santoyo-Valencia G.Current advances in the development of microRNA-integrated tissue engineering strategies: a cornerstone of regenerative medicine.Front Bioeng Biotechnol2024;12:1484151 PMCID:PMC11521876

[5] Gharibshahian M,Bavisi M,Alizadeh A.Recent advances in artificial intelligent strategies for tissue engineering and regenerative medicine.Skin Res Technol2024;30:e70016 PMCID:PMC11348508

[6] Jorgensen AM,Atala A.Advances in skin tissue engineering and regenerative medicine.J Burn Care Res2023;44:S33-41 PMCID:PMC9790899

[7] Blair NF,Barbaric I.Regenerative medicine: advances from developmental to degenerative diseases. In: El-khamisy S, Editor. Personalised medicine. Cham: Springer International Publishing; 2017. pp. 225-39.

[8] Yao Y,Jin L.Macrophage polarization in physiological and pathological pregnancy.Front Immunol2019;10:792 PMCID:PMC6476302

[9] BioRender: science illustration and figure creation tool. Available from: https://www.biorender.com/. [Last accessed on 16 Apr 2025].

[10] Pang J,Koh TJ.Monocyte/macrophage heterogeneity during skin wound healing in mice.J Immunol2022;209:1999-2011 PMCID:PMC9643652

[11] Jung SH,Shin S.Spatiotemporal dynamics of macrophage heterogeneity and a potential function of Trem2^hi macrophages in infarcted hearts.Nat Commun2022;13:4580 PMCID:PMC9357004

[12] Lantz C,Liu E,Lin J.Single-cell RNA sequencing uncovers heterogenous transcriptional signatures in macrophages during efferocytosis.Sci Rep2020;10:14333 PMCID:PMC7459098

[13] Mosquera JV,Wong D.Integrative single-cell meta-analysis reveals disease-relevant vascular cell states and markers in human atherosclerosis.Cell Rep2023;42:113380

[14] Li W,Dai F.Hydrophilic surface-modified 3D printed flexible scaffolds with high ceramic particle concentrations for immunopolarization-regulation and bone regeneration.Biomater Sci2023;11:3976-97

[15] Krzyszczyk P,Palmer A.The role of macrophages in acute and chronic wound healing and interventions to promote Pro-wound healing phenotypes.Front Physiol2018;9:419 PMCID:PMC5938667

[16] Zhu Z,Ma Z,Tredget EE.Systemic depletion of macrophages in the subacute phase of wound healing reduces hypertrophic scar formation.Wound Repair Regen2016;24:644-56

[17] Kwak G,Kim H.Sustained exosome-guided macrophage polarization using hydrolytically degradable PEG hydrogels for cutaneous wound healing: identification of key proteins and MiRNAs, and sustained release formulation.Small2022;18:e2200060

[18] Chen J,Yang C.Macrophage phenotype switch by sequential action of immunomodulatory cytokines from hydrogel layers on titania nanotubes.Colloids Surf B Biointerfaces2018;163:336-45

[19] Carnicer-Lombarte A,Malliaras GG.Foreign body reaction to implanted biomaterials and its impact in nerve neuroprosthetics.Front Bioeng Biotechnol2021;9:622524 PMCID:PMC8081831

[20] Cha BH,Leijten J.Integrin-mediated interactions control macrophage polarization in 3D hydrogels.Adv Healthc Mater2017;6:1700289 PMCID:PMC5677560

[21] Pang QM,Zhang M.Peripheral blood-derived mesenchymal stem cells modulate macrophage plasticity through the IL-10/STAT3 pathway.Stem Cells Int2022;2022:5181241 PMCID:PMC9017453

[22] Nie Z,Jiang W.Placental mesenchymal stem cells suppress inflammation and promote M2-like macrophage polarization through the IL-10/STAT3/NLRP3 axis in acute lung injury.Front Immunol2024;15:1422355 PMCID:PMC11604576

[23] Waqas SFH,Röszer T.Analysis of IL-4/STAT6 signaling in macrophages. In: Badr MZ, Editor. Nuclear receptors. New York: Springer; 2019. pp. 211-24.

[24] D’Alessio FR,Singer BD.Enhanced resolution of experimental ARDS through IL-4-mediated lung macrophage reprogramming.Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol2016;310:L733-46 PMCID:PMC4836113

[25] Daniel B,Horvath A.The IL-4/STAT6/PPARγ signaling axis is driving the expansion of the RXR heterodimer cistrome, providing complex ligand responsiveness in macrophages.Nucleic Acids Res2018;46:4425-39 PMCID:PMC5961189

[26] Huang SC,Everts B.Metabolic reprogramming mediated by the mTORC2-IRF4 signaling axis is essential for macrophage alternative activation.Immunity2016;45:817-30 PMCID:PMC5535820

[27] Spiller KL,Witherel CE.Sequential delivery of immunomodulatory cytokines to facilitate the M1-to-M2 transition of macrophages and enhance vascularization of bone scaffolds.Biomaterials2015;37:194-207 PMCID:PMC4312192

[28] Wu J,Wang S,Zhang R.TGF β1 promotes the polarization of M2-type macrophages and activates PI3K/mTOR signaling pathway by inhibiting ISG20 to sensitize ovarian cancer to cisplatin.Int Immunopharmacol2024;134:112235

[29] Gaharwar AK,Khademhosseini A.Engineered biomaterials for in situ tissue regeneration.Nat Rev Mater2020;5:686-705

[30] Liu Y,Riley L,Xia J.Spatial confinement modulates macrophage response in microporous annealed particle (MAP) scaffolds.Adv Healthc Mater2023;12:e2300823 PMCID:PMC10592513

[31] Wang X,Luo D.3D printed high-precision porous scaffolds prepared by fused deposition modeling induce macrophage polarization to promote bone regeneration.Biomed Mater2024;19:035006

[32] Li W,Zhang S.Pore size of 3D-printed polycaprolactone/polyethylene glycol/hydroxyapatite scaffolds affects bone regeneration by modulating macrophage polarization and the foreign body response.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2022;14:20693-707

[33] Mahon OR,Gonzalez-Fernandez T.Nano-particle mediated M2 macrophage polarization enhances bone formation and MSC osteogenesis in an IL-10 dependent manner.Biomaterials2020;239:119833

[34] Sridharan R,Kearney CJ,O’Brien FJ.Macrophage polarization in response to collagen scaffold stiffness is dependent on cross-linking agent used to modulate the stiffness.ACS Biomater Sci Eng2019;5:544-52

[35] Hong JY,Davaa G,Kim SH.Decellularized brain matrix enhances macrophage polarization and functional improvements in rat spinal cord injury.Acta Biomater2020;101:357-71

[36] Pisani S,Genta I,Conti B.A study focused on macrophages modulation induced by the polymeric electrospun matrices (EL-Ms) for application in tissue regeneration: in vitro proof of concept.Int J Pharm2021;603:120712

[37] Luu TU,Woo BW,Liu WF.Micro- and nanopatterned topographical cues for regulating macrophage cell shape and phenotype.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2015;7:28665-72 PMCID:PMC4797644

[38] Wang M,Tang Y.Regulation of macrophage polarization and functional status by modulating hydroxyapatite ceramic micro/nano-topography.Mater Des2022;213:110302

[39] Zheng X,Tan J.Effect of micro/nano-sheet array structures on the osteo-immunomodulation of macrophages.Regen Biomater2022;9:rbac075 PMCID:PMC9580515

[40] Buck E,Stone LS.Protein adsorption on surfaces functionalized with COOH groups promotes anti-inflammatory macrophage responses.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2021;13:7021-36

[41] Bygd HC,Bratlie KM.Altering in vivo macrophage responses with modified polymer properties.Biomaterials2015;56:187-97

[42] Bessa-Gonçalves M,Costa M.Magnesium incorporation in fibrinogen scaffolds promotes macrophage polarization towards M2 phenotype.Acta Biomater2023;155:667-83

[43] Cicuéndez M,Barroca N.Benefits in the macrophage response due to graphene oxide reduction by thermal treatment.Int J Mol Sci2021;22:6701 PMCID:PMC8267858

[44] Grotenhuis N,Kops N.In vitro model to study the biomaterial-dependent reaction of macrophages in an inflammatory environment.Br J Surg2014;101:983-92

[45] Palmer JA,Mitchell GM.Macrophage phenotype in response to implanted synthetic scaffolds: an immunohistochemical study in the rat.Cells Tissues Organs2014;199:169-83

[46] Zhu S,Lu Z.Bacteroid cerium oxide particles promote macrophage polarization to achieve early vascularization and subsequent osseointegration around implants.Biochem Biophys Res Commun2024;703:149647

[47] He XT,Zhang M.Role of molybdenum in material immunomodulation and periodontal wound healing: targeting immunometabolism and mitochondrial function for macrophage modulation.Biomaterials2022;283:121439

[48] Niu Y,Yang X,Liu G.HA-coated collagen nanofibers for urethral regeneration via in situ polarization of M2 macrophages.J Nanobiotechnology2021;19:283 PMCID:PMC8456673

[49] Ziegler ME,Khoshab N.Combining allograft adipose and fascia matrix as an off-the-shelf scaffold for adipose tissue engineering stimulates angiogenic responses and activates a proregenerative macrophage profile in a rodent model.Ann Plast Surg2023;91:294-300

[50] Pan X,Xun X.Long-term recruitment of endogenous M2 macrophages by platelet lysate-rich plasma macroporous hydrogel scaffold for articular cartilage defect repair.Adv Healthc Mater2022;11:e2101661

[51] Yu X,Liu X,Zhang S.Ursolic acid loaded-mesoporous hydroxylapatite/chitosan therapeutic scaffolds regulate bone regeneration ability by promoting the M2-type polarization of macrophages.Int J Nanomedicine2021;16:5301-15 PMCID:PMC8355748

[52] Hachim D,Yates CC.Shifts in macrophage phenotype at the biomaterial interface via IL-4 eluting coatings are associated with improved implant integration.Biomaterials2017;112:95-107 PMCID:PMC5121003

[53] Tian P,Kim J.Dual stimulus responsive borosilicate glass (BSG) scaffolds promote diabetic alveolar bone defectsrepair by modulating macrophage phenotype.Bioact Mater2023;26:231-48 PMCID:PMC10020664

[54] Holt DJ,Grainger DW.Cell-cell signaling in co-cultures of macrophages and fibroblasts.Biomaterials2010;31:9382-94 PMCID:PMC2976809

[55] Jeong JH,Lobionda S.Heparin-mimicking polymer-based hydrogel matrix regulates macrophage polarization by controlling cell adhesion.Biochem Biophys Res Commun2023;642:154-61

[56] Xool-Tamayo J,Villa-de la Torre F,Vargas-Coronado RF.Macrophages morphology and cytokine reeducation by ex situ copper thiol complexes.Immunopharmacol Immunotoxicol2024;46:20-32

[57] Luo M,Liu L.IFN-γ/SrBG composite scaffolds promote osteogenesis by sequential regulation of macrophages from M1 to M2.J Mater Chem B2021;9:1867-76

[58] Hu Y,Wang Z.Inducing in situ M2 macrophage polarization to promote the repair of bone defects via scaffold-mediated sustained delivery of luteolin.J Control Release2024;365:889-904

[59] Xie J,Zheng S,Su J.Aligned electrospun poly(L-lactide) nanofibers facilitate wound healing by inhibiting macrophage M1 polarization via the JAK-STAT and NF-κB pathways.J Nanobiotechnology2022;20:342 PMCID:PMC9327399

[60] Huang C,Liu W,Liu A.Modulation of macrophages by a phillyrin-loaded thermosensitive hydrogel promotes skin wound healing in mice.Cytokine2024;177:156556

[61] Shah A,Tran D,Oh C.Infection rates of an intraoral versus extraoral approach to mandibular fracture repairs are equal: a systematic review and meta-analysis.J Oral Maxillofac Surg2024;82:449-60

[62] Perez D.Complications of mandibular fracture repair and secondary reconstruction.Semin Plast Surg2020;34:225-31 PMCID:PMC7759430

[63] Lander DP,Kallogjeri D.The impact of treatment delay on malunion and nonunion after open reduction of mandible fractures.Facial Plast Surg Aesthet Med2021;23:460-6 PMCID:PMC8905255

[64] Ginat D.Surgical implants in the head and neck: normal and abnormal imaging appearances.Semin Roentgenol2023;58:290-300

[65] Mamsen FPW,Hesselfeldt-Nielsen J.Risk stratification of local flaps and skin grafting in skin cancer-related facial reconstruction: a retrospective single-center study of 607 patients.J Pers Med2022;12:2067 PMCID:PMC9781009

[66] Ding Y,Liu S.A multifunction hydrogel-coating engineered implant for rescuing biofilm infection and boosting osseointegration by macrophage-related immunomodulation.Adv Healthc Mater2023;12:e2300722

[67] Andrade RGD,Costas B,Reis S.Modulation of macrophages M1/M2 polarization using carbohydrate-functionalized polymeric nanoparticles.Polymers2020;13:88 PMCID:PMC7796279

[68] Pei D,Geng Z.Modulation of macrophage polarization by secondary cross-linked hyaluronan-dopamine hydrogels.Int J Biol Macromol2024;270:132417

[69] Özcolak B,Odabaş S,Garipcan B.Effects of bone surface topography and chemistry on macrophage polarization.Sci Rep2024;14:12721 PMCID:PMC11148019

[70] Giri PS.Macrophage polarization dynamics in biomaterials: implications for in vitro wound healing.ACS Appl Bio Mater2024;7:2413-22

[71] Takabatake K,Nakano K.Effect of scaffold geometrical structure on macrophage polarization during bone regeneration using honeycomb tricalcium phosphate.Materials2024;17:4108 PMCID:PMC11356497

[72] Wang Y,Gao R.Biomimetic glycopeptide hydrogel coated PCL/nHA scaffold for enhanced cranial bone regeneration via macrophage M2 polarization-induced osteo-immunomodulation.Biomaterials2022;285:121538

[73] Wang Q,Ke Q.Magnetic lanthanum-doped hydroxyapatite/chitosan scaffolds with endogenous stem cell-recruiting and immunomodulatory properties for bone regeneration.J Mater Chem B2020;8:5280-92

[74] Di Francesco D, Talmon M, Carton F, Fresu LG, Boccafoschi F. Macrophage polarization guided by immunomodulatory hydrogels. Hydrogels for tissue engineering and regenerative medicine. Elsevier; 2024. pp. 765-82.

[75] Li W,Zou B.Macrophage regulation in vascularization upon regeneration and repair of tissue injury and engineered organ transplantation.Fundam Res2025;5:697-714