Limited recovery following acellular nerve allograft reconstruction in major peripheral nerve injuries

Abstract

Recent studies suggest that acellular nerve allografts (ANA) have similar efficacy as nerve autografts in certain applications of nerve surgery. However, multiple studies also demonstrate the limitations of nerve allografts, resulting in poor patient outcomes. This submission discusses a recent case series of patients who failed allograft use with subsequent histologic analyses of these allografts. Recommendations on the treatment of nerve gaps are presented, drawing from our current understanding of allograft and autograft utility in reconstruction. Factors taken into account include recipient critical nerve function, existent nerve gap, and nerve diameter.

Keywords

Nerve reconstruction / peripheral nerve / acellular nerve allograft / nerve autograft

References

[1] Lans J,Evans PJ,Greenberg JA.A systematic review and meta-analysis of nerve gap repair: comparative effectiveness of allografts, autografts, and conduits.Plast Reconstr Surg2023;151:814e-27e

[2] Safa B,Desai MJ.Peripheral nerve repair throughout the body with processed nerve allografts: results from a large multicenter study.Microsurgery2020;40:527-37 PMCID:PMC7496926

[3] Peters BR,Hunter DA.Acellular nerve allografts in major peripheral nerve repairs: an analysis of cases presenting with limited recovery.Hand2023;18:236-43 PMCID:PMC10035101

[4] Mackinnon SE, Yee A, Barbour JR. Nerve surgery.Available from: http://www.kubalibri.cz/files/229---Nerve-Surgery.pdf [Last accessed on 28 Dec 2023]

[5] Saheb-Al-Zamani M,Farber SJ.Limited regeneration in long acellular nerve allografts is associated with increased Schwann cell senescence.Exp Neurol2013;247:165-77 PMCID:PMC3863361

[6] George SC.An evidence-based structured review to assess the results of common peroneal nerve repair.Plast Reconstr Surg2014;134:302e-11e

[7] Peters BR,Chi D.Complete foot drop with normal electrodiagnostic studies: sunderland "zero" ischemic conduction block of the common peroneal nerve.Ann Plast Surg2022;88:425-8

[8] Carlson TL,Konofaos P.Cadaveric nerve allograft: single center's experience in a variety of peripheral nerve injuries.Ann Plast Surg2018;80:S328-32

[9] Leckenby JI,Haug L,Vögelin E.A retrospective case series reporting the outcomes of avance nerve allografts in the treatment of peripheral nerve injuries.Plast Reconstr Surg2020;145:368e-81e

[10] Best TJ,Midha R,Evans PJ.Revascularization of peripheral nerve autografts and allografts.Plast Reconstr Surg1999;104:152-60

[11] Pan D,Wood MD.Advances in the repair of segmental nerve injuries and trends in reconstruction.Muscle Nerve2020;61:726-39 PMCID:PMC7230025

[12] Farber SJ,Hunter DA.Vascularization is delayed in long nerve constructs compared with nerve grafts.Muscle Nerve2016;54:319-21 PMCID:PMC4940276

[13] Gordon T,Ayer K,Tyreman N.Recovery potential of muscle after partial denervation: a comparison between rats and humans.Brain Res Bull1993;30:477-82

[14] Upton AR.The double crush in nerve entrapment syndromes.Lancet1973;302:359-62

[15] Asaad M,Huang TCT,Moran SL.Vascularized bone flap options for complex thoracic spinal reconstruction.Plast Reconstr Surg2022;149:515e-25e

[16] Kazmers NH,Levin LS.A scapholunate ligament-sparing technique utilizing the medial femoral condyle corticocancellous free flap to reconstruct scaphoid nonunions with proximal pole avascular necrosis.J Hand Surg Am2016;41:e309-15

[17] Boyd KU,Mackinnon SE.Nerve reconstruction in the hand and upper extremity.Clin Plast Surg2011;38:643-60