Reviewing immunosuppressive regimens in animal models for vascularized composite allotransplantation

Abstract

The development of vascularized composite allotransplantation (VCA) and its clinical need has led to the need for more animal models to study and perform the research required to further this specialty in terms of functional recovery and immunomodulatory improvements. Much of the animal models are reported in individual series in the literature but there has not been a review as such of these models. Here we present a compilation of the animal models reported in the literature thus far in VCA. A comprehensive review of the literature was performed for any studies which involved the use of animal models in various aspects of VCA research. The models were organized according to the type of VCA transplant, whether they were orthotopic or heterotopic, immunosuppressive regimen each study used and investigation purpose. Twenty-one facial transplant models were reported, 3 abdominal wall transplants, 4 penile transplantations, 21 uterus transplantations, 12 hindlimb transplantations and 4 myocutaneous flap transplantation animal models were reported. Primates, swine, rats, mice, rabbits, sheep and dog animal models in VCA were also reported. The most used immunosuppressive drugs are calcineurin inhibitor such as cyclosporin A and tacrolimus in these VCA animal models. They can significantly suppress lymphocyte function by blocking the phosphatase activity of calcineurin of lymphocytes. They are sometimes used combined with mycophenolate mofetil or steroids or antilymphocyte serum. The review of existing animal models will allow further research to be focused in other areas of VCA where there is a current paucity of literature. The immunosuppressive regimens used in each animal model can also be reviewed to determine which regimen works in which type of animal model which will save time and resources for future research.

Keywords

Animal models / vascularized composite allotransplantation / immunosuppressive regimens

References

[1] Murray JE.Organ transplantation (skin, kidney, heart) and the plastic surgeon..Plast Reconstr Surg1971;47:425-31

[2] Thaunat O,Dubois V,Petruzzo P.Immunopathology of rejection: do the rules of solid organ apply to vascularized composite allotransplantation?.Curr Opin Organ Transplant2015;20:596-601

[3] Kahan BD.Cosmas and Damian revisited..Transplant Proc1983;15:2211-6

[4] Guimberteau JC,Panconi B,Potaux L.Human allotransplant of a digital flexion system vascularized on the ulnar pedicle: a preliminary report and 1-year follow-up of two cases..Plast Reconstr Surg1992;89:1135-47

[5] Petit F,Dubernard JM,Lee WP.Composite tissue allotransplantation and reconstructive surgery: first clinical applications..Ann Surg2003;237:19-25 PMCID:PMC1513974

[6] Dubernard JM,Morelon E,Badet L,Beziat JL,Kanitakis J,El Jaafari A,Lefrancois N,Sirigu A,Carmi E,Cremades S,Burloux G,Parquet N,Michallet M,Devauchelle B.Outcomes 18 months after the first human partial face transplantation..N Engl J Med2007;357:2451-60

[7] Silverman RP,Detolla LJ,Panda A,Azimzadeh AM,Wang D,Holton LH3rd.A heterotopic primate model for facial composite tissue transplantation..Ann Plast Surg2008;60:209-16

[8] Santiago GF,Al Rakan M,Rada EM,Shores JT,Cooney D,Murphy RJ,Brandacher G,Liacouras P,Armand M.Establishing cephalometric landmarks for the translational study of Le Fort-based facial transplantation in Swine: enhanced applications using computer-assisted surgery and custom cutting guides..Plast Reconstr Surg2014;133:1138-51 PMCID:PMC4010130

[9] Uygur S,Kwiecien G,Siemionow M.Sheep hemifacial and auricular transplantation models: an anatomic study..Ann Plast Surg2014;72:469-74

[10] Shengwu Z,Hao J,Kaiding F,Huiyong W,Bing G,Lujia T,Yuping L.Developing a canine model of composite facial/scalp allograft transplantation..Ann Plast Surg2007;59:185-94

[11] Lee KM.Experimental canine facial transplantation..Transplant Proc2014;46:1208-11

[12] Eduardo Bermú Dez L,Romero T.Experimental model of facial transplant..Plast Reconstr Surg2002;110:1374-5

[13] Höhnke C,Subbotin V,Starzl TE.Vascularized composite tissue mandibular transplantation in dogs..Transplant Proc1997;29:995

[14] Baek RM,Heo CY.Experimental facial transplantation surgery..J Craniofac Surg2010;21:648-51

[15] Washington KM,Sacks JM,Unadkat JV,Simons DJ.A model for functional recovery and cortical reintegration after hemifacial composite tissue allotransplantation..Plast Reconstr Surg2009;123:S26-33

[16] Ulusal BG,Ozmen S,Siemionow MZ.A new composite facial and scalp transplantation model in rats..Plast Reconstr Surg2003;112:1302-11

[17] Kulahci Y.A new composite hemiface/mandible/tongue transplantation model in rats..Ann Plast Surg2010;64:114-21

[18] Ulusal AE,Hung LM.Establishing a composite auricle allotransplantation model in rats: introduction to transplantation of facial subunits..Plast Reconstr Surg2005;116:811-7

[19] Landin L,Gonzalez E,Caballero A.Functional outcome after facial allograft transplantation in rats..J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg2008;61:1034-43

[20] Climov M,Stefănescu A,Lascăr I.Learning curve in hemifacial transplantation in rats..Chirurgia (Bucur)2013;108:234-40

[21] Ulusal BG,Wei FC.Long-term outcomes of composite auricle as a neurosensorial facial subunit allotransplant..Ann Plast Surg2009;62:311-6

[22] Chiu DT,Patsis MC.Rat ear transplantation: a feasibility study..J Reconstr Microsurg1993;9:33-8

[23] Landin L,Gonzalez E,Rodriguez-Perez JC.Sensorimotor recovery after partial facial (mystacial pad) transplantation in rats..Ann Plast Surg2009;63:428-35

[24] Demir Y,Klimczak A,Siemionow M.Tolerance induction in composite facial allograft transplantation in the rat model..Plast Reconstr Surg2004;114:1790-801

[25] Ramirez AE,Wang YL,Wei FC.Two-stage face transplantation: a new concept in vascularized composite allotransplantation..Microsurgery2015;35:218-26

[26] Sucher R,Oberhuber R,Zheng XX,Pratschke J,Lee WP.Hemiface allotransplantation in the mouse..Plast Reconstr Surg2012;129:867-70

[27] Jiang J,Gracia B.Surgical technique for vascularized ear transplantation in mice..Microsurgery1998;18:42-6

[28] Lao WW,Ramirez AE,Wei FC.A new rat model for orthotopic abdominal wall allotransplantation..Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open2014;2:e136

[29] Quigley MA,Zhang W.Development of a reliable model of total abdominal wall transplantation..Plast Reconstr Surg2013;132:988-94

[30] Ramirez AE,Lao WW,Wen CJ,Lin CF,Chuang SH.A novel rat full-thickness hemi-abdominal wall/hindlimb osteomyocutaneous combined flap: influence of allograft mass and vascularized bone marrow content on vascularized composite allograft survival..Transpl Int2014;27:977-86

[31] Seyam RM,Assad LW,Almohanna FH.Penile autotransplantation in rats: an animal model..Urol Ann2013;5:255-8 PMCID:PMC3835983

[32] Akyurek M,Safak T,Dunn RM.The penile flap in the rat: description and autotransplantation..Ann Plast Surg2005;55:94-100; discussion 101

[33] Koga H,Wang K,Lane GJ,Sueyoshi N.Experimental allogenic penile transplantation..J Pediatr Surg2003;38:1802-5

[34] Sonmez E,Siemionow M.Penis allotransplantation model in the rat..Ann Plast Surg2009;62:304-10

[35] Kisu I,Mihara M,Umene K,Nogami Y.A surgical technique using the ovarian vein in non-human primate models of potential living-donor surgery of uterus transplantation..Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand2015;94:942-8

[36] Kisu I,Banno K,Masugi Y,Iida T,Kato Y,Suganuma N.Uterus allotransplantation in cynomolgus macaque: a preliminary experience with non-human primate models..J Obstet Gynaecol Res2014;40:907-18

[37] Johannesson L,Mölne J,Hanafy A,Tekin A,Morales P,Ruiz P,Olausson M.Preclinical report on allogeneic uterus transplantation in non-human primates..Hum Reprod2013;28:189-98

[38] Wranning CA,Mölne J,Enskog A.Transplantation of the uterus in the sheep: oxidative stress and reperfusion injury after short-time cold storage..Fertil Steril2008;90:817-26

[39] Saso S,David AL,Chatterjee J,Marco-Jimenez F,Boyd M,Lindsay I,Ghaem-Maghami S.Achieving an early pregnancy following allogeneic uterine transplantation in a rabbit model..Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol2015;185:164-9

[40] Gonzalez-Pinto IM,Avison DL,Tekin A,Tzakis AG.Uterus transplantation model in sheep with heterotopic whole graft and aorta and cava anastomoses..Transplant Proc2013;45:1802-4

[41] Ramirez ER,Pillari VT,Ramirez HA.Modified uterine transplant procedure in the sheep model..J Minim Invasive Gynecol2008;15:311-4

[42] Wei L,Yang H,Zhang G,Huang YH,Liu HX,Yang F.Modified uterine allotransplantation and immunosuppression procedure in the sheep model..PLoS One2013;8:e81300

[43] Gauthier T,Fourcade L,Saint Marcoux F,Marquet P,Plainard X,Cornuejols MJ,Aubard Y.Uterine allotransplantation in ewes using an aortocava patch..Hum Reprod2011;26:3028-36

[44] Saso S,Chatterjee J,Thum Y,Hakim N,Boyd M,Lindsay I,Del Priore G.Test of long-term uterine survival after allogeneic transplantation in rabbits..J Obstet Gynaecol Res2014;40:754-62

[45] Wranning CA,Kurlberg G.Uterus transplantation in the rat: model development, surgical learning and morphological evaluation of healing..Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand2008;87:1239-47

[46] Díaz-García C,Martínez-Varea A.The effect of warm ischemia at uterus transplantation in a rat model..Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand2013;92:152-9

[47] Jiga LP,Zoica BS.Experimental model of heterotopic uterus transplantation in the laboratory rat..Microsurgery2003;23:246-50

[48] Groth K,Mölne J,Brännström M.Effects of immunosuppression by cyclosporine A on allogenic uterine transplant in the rat..Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol2012;163:97-103

[49] Akhi SN,El-Akouri RR,Mölne J.Uterine rejection after allogeneic uterus transplantation in the rat is effectively suppressed by tacrolimus..Fertil Steril2013;99:862-70

[50] Díaz-García C,Wallin A,Brännström M.First report on fertility after allogeneic uterus transplantation..Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand2010;89:1491-4

[51] Racho El-Akouri R,Dindelegan G,Wallin A.Heterotopic uterine transplantation by vascular anastomosis in the mouse..J Endocrinol2002;174:157-66

[52] Parkening TA,Elder FF.Orthotopic ovarian transplantations in young and aged C57BL/6J mice..Biol Reprod1985;32:989-97

[53] Wranning CA,Groth K,Parra AK.Rejection of the transplanted uterus is suppressed by cyclosporine A in a semi-allogeneic mouse model..Hum Reprod2007;22:372-9

[54] Cendales LC,Bacher J,Kleiner DE.Composite tissue allotransplantation: development of a preclinical model in nonhuman primates..Transplantation2005;80:1447-54

[55] Kiermeir DM,Müller S,Vögelin E.Evaluation of a porcine whole-limb heterotopic autotransplantation model..Microsurgery2013;33:141-7

[56] Solla F,Watrelot D,Dubernard JM.Composite tissue allotransplantation in newborns: a swine model..J Surg Res2013;179:e235-43

[57] Kuo YR,Lee WP,Kueh NS,Chiang YC.Porcine heterotopic composite tissue allograft transplantation using a large animal model for preclinical studies..Chang Gung Med J2006;29:268-74

[58] Ren X,Ustüner ET,Edelstein J,Breidenbach WC,Tobin GR,Barker JH.Osteomyocutaneous flap as a preclinical composite tissue allograft: swine model..Microsurgery2000;20:143-9

[59] Ustüner ET,Ren X,Maldonado C,Breidenbach WC.Swine composite tissue allotransplant model for preclinical hand transplant studies..Microsurgery2000;20:400-6

[60] Kremer T,Friedrich PF,Bishop AT.Knee joint transplantation combined with surgical angiogenesis in rabbits--a new experimental model..Microsurgery2012;32:118-27 PMCID:PMC3321575

[61] Ogur S,Ozturk C.A new composite flap model in the rat: combined cremaster muscle and pubic bone flap..Ann Plast Surg2008;60:692-7

[62] Adamson LA,Breidenbach WC,Xu H,Pidwell DJ,Tobin G.A modified model of hindlimb osteomyocutaneous flap for the study of tolerance to composite tissue allografts..Microsurgery2007;27:630-6

[63] Sacks JM,Horibe EK,Mohan K,Lee WP.An optimized dual-surgeon simultaneous orthotopic hind-limb allotransplantation model in rats..J Reconstr Microsurg2012;28:69-75

[64] Tang J,Luo X,Levin LS.A vascularized elbow allotransplantation model in the rat..J Shoulder Elbow Surg2015;24:779-86

[65] Nasir S,Sonmez E,Gibson S.New composite tissue allograft model of vascularized bone marrow transplant: the iliac osteomyocutaneous flap..Transpl Int2010;23:90-100

[66] Leto Barone AA,Torabi R,Glor T,Randolph MA,Cetrulo CLJr.The gracilis myocutaneous free flap in swine: an advantageous preclinical model for vascularized composite allograft transplantation research..Microsurgery2013;33:51-5

[67] Leonard DA,Mallard C,Duran-Struuck R,Crepeau R,Horner BM,Sachs DH,Cetrulo CLJr.Vascularized composite allograft tolerance across MHC barriers in a large animal model..Am J Transplant2014;14:343-55 PMCID:PMC3971524

[68] Mathes DW,Graves S,Miwongtum T.A preclinical canine model for composite tissue transplantation..J Reconstr Microsurg2010;26:201-7 PMCID:PMC2975549

[69] Yang J,Chang JC,Zhang Y,Hodavance MS,Levinson H,Levin LS.A model of sequential heart and composite tissue allotransplant in rats..Plast Reconstr Surg2010;126:80-6