Elective neck dissection in early oral squamous cell carcinoma: necessary?

Abstract

Aim: The indication of neck dissection in oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC) is a problem of risk-benefit evaluation between probability of neck metastases, the problem of complications associated with neck dissection and the prognostic influence of delayed diagnosis of metastasis during follow-up. There is no consensus on the elective treatment of the neck in early oral cancer patients with a clinically N0 (cN0) neck.

Methods: The author performed a search of PubMed articles with the words "elective neck dissection vs. observation", "node negative neck" and "early stage oral squamous cell carcinoma". The author selected those articles that studied the early OSCC (T1-T2), and elective neck treatment was compared with clinical observation.

Results: Many studies have compared the outcome of elective neck dissection (END) to observation of the neck in early OSCC. The results of them are described. The biologic aggressiveness of oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma, particularly in the early stages, is reflected in its ability to metastasize to regional lymph node chains. Many pretreatment imaging techniques to diminish the incidence of occult metastases haven been studied, and comparative studies have shown ultrasound guided fine needle aspiration cytology (USgFNAC) to be the most accurate.

Conclusion: A few non-randomized studies have shown no advantages of END when strict USgFNAC follow-up was employed. Thus, if routine strict follow-up using USgFNAC by a well-trained ultrasonographer cannot be assured, END is the safest strategy.

Keywords

Early stage / oral squamous cell carcinoma / negative lymph necknode / elective neck dissection versus observation

References

[1] Flach GB,De Bree R,Van der Waal I,Kuik DJ,Leemans CR.Outcome of patients with early stage oral cancer managed by an observation strategy towards the N0 neck using ultrasound guided fine needle aspiration cytology. No survival difference as compared to elective neck dissection..Oral Oncol2013;49:157-64

[2] Leemans CR,van der Waal I,Nauta JJ.The efficacy of comprehensive neck dissection with or without postoperative radiotherapy in nodal metastases of squamous cell carcinoma of the upper respiratory and digestive tracts..Laryngoscope1990;100:1194-8

[3] Weiss MH,Isaacs RS.Use of decision analysis in planning a management strategy for the stage N0 neck..Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg1994;120:699-702

[4] O'Brien CJ,McNeil E,Chaplin JM.The use of clinical criteria alone in the management of the clinically negative neck among patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity and oropharynx..Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg2000;126:360-5

[5] Kaya S,Gursel B,Sennaroğlu L.The value of elective neck dissection in treatment of cancer of the tongue..Am J Otolaryngol2001;22:59-64

[6] Dias FL,Matos de Sá G,Freitas E,Matos F.Elective neck dissection versus observation in stage I squamous cell carcinomas of the tongue and floor of the mouth..Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg2001;125:23-9

[7] Smith GI,Clark J,Clifford AR,Gao K.Management of the neck in patients with T1 and T2 cancer in the mouth..Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg2004;42:494-500

[8] Duvvuri U,D'Angelo G,Ferris RL,Myers EN.Elective neck dissection and survival in patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity and oropharynx..Laryngoscope2004;114:2228-34

[9] Amaral TM,Carvalho AL,Kowalski LP.Predictive factors of occult metastasis and prognosis of clinical stages I and II squamous cell carcinoma of the tongue and floor of the mouth..Oral Oncol2004;40:780-6

[10] Keski-Säntti H,Törnwall J,Mäkitie A.Elective neck treatment versus observation in patients with T1/T2 N0 squamous cell carcinoma of oral tongue..Oral Oncol2006;42:96-101

[11] Lim YC.Unilateral, clinically T2N0, squamous cell carcinoma of the tongue: surgical outcome analysis..Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg2007;36:610-4

[12] Iype EM,Mathew A,Varghese BT.The role of selective neck dissection (I-III) in the treatment of node negative (N0) neck in oral cancer..Oral Oncol2008;44:1134-8

[13] Huang SF,Lin CY,Yen TC,Chen IH,Cheng AJ.Neck treatment of patients with early stage oral tongue cancer: comparison between observation, supraomohyoid dissection, and extended dissection..Cancer2008;112:1066-75

[14] Yuen AP,Chow TL,Cheung WY,Wei WI,Book KS,Lam AK,Trendell-Smith NJ,Wong BY,Ho AC,Wong SY.Prospective randomized study of selective neck dissection versus observation for N0 neck of early tongue carcinoma..Head Neck2009;31:765-72

[15] D'Cruz AK,Walvekar RR,Chaukar DA,Pai PS.Elective neck dissection for the management of the N0 neck in early cancer of the oral tongue: need for a randomized controlled trial..Head Neck2009;31:618-24

[16] Feng Z,Li CZ.Elective neck dissection versus observation in the management of early tongue carcinoma with clinically node-negative neck: a retrospective study of 229 cases..J Craniomaxillofac Surg2014;42:806-10

[17] Brugère JM,Mamelle G,Buisset E,Raucourt D,Asselain BJ.Nodal failures in patients with N0 N+ oral squamous cell carcinoma without capsular rupture..Head Neck1996;18:133-7

[18] Khafif RA,Tepper P.Elective radical neck dissection in epidermoid cancer of the head and neck. A retrospective analysis of 853 cases of mouth, pharynx, and larynx cancer..Cancer1991;67:67-71

[19] Okamoto M,Kishi M,Sugimura M,Konishi N.Prediction of delayed neck metastasis in patients with stage I/II squamous cell carcinoma of the tongue..J Oral Pathol Med2002;31:227-33

[20] De Bree R.Elective neck dissection versus observation in the clinically node negative neck in early oral cancer: do we have the answer yet?.Oral Oncol2015;51:963-5

[21] Kowalski LP.Elective neck dissection in oral carcinoma: a critical review of the evidence..Acta Otorhinolaryngol Ital2007;27:113-7 PMCID:PMC2640044

[22] Vijayakumar M,Sabitha KS,Rajani BC.To operate or not to operate N0 neck in early cancer of the tongue? A prospective study..Indian J Surg Oncol2011;2:172-5 PMCID:PMC3272179

[23] Teichgraeber JF.The incidence of occult metastasis for cancer of the oral tongue and floor of the mouth: treatment rationale..Head Neck Surg1984;7:15-21

[24] DiTroia JF.Nodal metastases and prognosis in carcinoma of the oral cavity..Otolaryngol Clin North Am1972;5:333-41

[25] O'Brien CJ,Soong SJ.Surgical treatment of early-stage carcinoma of the oral tongue--wound adjuvant treatment be beneficial?.Head Neck Surg1986;8:401-8

[26] Yuen APW,Wong YM.Elective neck dissection versus observation in the treatment of early oral tongue carcinoma..Head Neck1997;19:583-8

[27] Spiro RH.Epidermoid carcinoma of the oral cavity and oropharynx..Arch Surg1973;107:382-4

[28] Spiro RH.Surgical treatment of cancer of the tongue..Surg Clin N Am1974;54:757-65

[29] Lee JG.Occult regional metastases: carcinoma of the oral tongue..Laryngoscope1972;82:1273-80

[30] Fu KK,Galante M.Carcinoma of the floor of the mouth: an analysis of treatment results and the sites and causes of failure..Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys1976;1:829-37

[31] Whitehurst JO.Surgical treatment of squamous cell carcinoma of the oral tongue..Arch Otolaryngol1977;103:212-5

[32] Johnson JT,Cummings CW.Management of TI carcinoma of the anterior aspect of the tongue..Arch Otolaryngol1980;106:249-51

[33] Ho CM,Wei WI.Occult lymph node metastases in small oral tongue cancers..Head Neck1992;14:359-63

[34] Kligerman J,Soares JR,Dias FL,Olivatto LO.Supraomohyoid neck dissection in the treatment of T1/T2 squamous cell carcinoma of oral cavity..Am J Surg1994;168:391-4

[35] Lydiatt DD,Byers RM.Treatment of stage I and II oral tongue cancer..Head Neck1993;15:308-12

[36] Van den Brekel MWM,MeijerCJ,Castelijns JA.The incidence of micrometastases in neck dissection specimens obtained from elective neck dissections..Laryngoscope1996;106:987-91

[37] Van den Brekel MWM,Stel HV,Meyer CJ.Modern imaging techniques and ultrasound-guided aspiration cytology for the assessment of neck node metastases: a prospective comparative study..Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol1993;250:11-7

[38] Snow GB,Leemans CR.Management of cervical lymph nodes in patients with head and neck cancer..Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol1992;249:187-94

[39] Cunningham MJ,Myers EN,Thearle PB.Cervical lymph node metastasis after local excision of early squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity..Am J Surg1986;152:361-66

[40] Beenken SW,Maddox WA,Soong S.T1 and T2 squamous cell carcinoma of the oral tongue: prognostic factors and the role of elective lymph node dissection..Head Neck1999;21:124-30

[41] Yii NW,Rhys-Evans PH.Management of the N0 neck in early cancer of the oral tongue..Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci1999;24:75-9

[42] Spiro RH.Discontinuous partial glossectomy and radical neck dissection in selected patients with epidermoid carcinoma of the mobile tongue..Am J Surg1973;126:544-6

[43] Dijkstra PU,Buijs RP,de Goede CJ,Koolstra M,Schoppink EM,van de Velde CF.Incidence of shoulder pain after neck dissection: a clinical explorative study for risk factors..Head Neck2001;23:947-53

[44] El Ghani F,de Goede CJT,Leemans CR.Shoulder function and patient well-being after various types of neck dissections..Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci2002;27:403-8

[45] Inoue H,Saito M,Ishida H,Fujii T,Saikawa M.Quality of life after neck dissection..Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg2006;132:662-6

[46] Stuiver MM,de Boer EM,Koolstra M,Venema P,Vincent A.Impact of shoulder complaints after neck dissection on shoulder disability and quality of life..Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg2008;139:32-9

[47] Braakhuis BJ,Leemans CR,Snow GB.Second primary tumors and field cancerization in oral and oropharyngeal cancer: molecular techniques provide new insights and definitions..Head Neck2002;24:198-206

[48] Smith GI,Clark J,Clifford AR,Gao K.Management of the neck in patients with T1 and T2 cancer in the mouth..Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg2004;42:494-500

[49] Duvvuri U,D'Angelo G,Ferris RL,Myers EN.Elective neck dissection and survival in patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity and oropharynx..Laryngoscope2004;114:2228-34

[50] Iype EM,Mathew A,Varghese BT.The role of selective neck dissection (I-III) in the treatment of node negative (N0) neck in oral cancer..Oral Oncol2008;44:1134-8

[51] Capote A,Munoz-Guerra MF,Gamallo C.Elective neck dissection in early-stage oral squamous cell carcinoma – does it influence recurrence and survival?.Head Neck2007;29:3-11

[52] Fasunla AJ,Timmesfeld N,Werner JA.A meta-analysis of the randomized controlled trials on elective neck dissection versus therapeutic neck dissection in oral cavity cancers with clinically node-negative neck..Oral Oncol2011;47:320-4

[53] D'Cruz AK.Elective versus therapeutic neck dissection in the clinically node negative neck in early oral cavity cancers: do we have the answer yet?.Oral Oncol2011;47:780-2

[54] D'Cruz AK,Kapre N.Elective versus therapeutic neck dissection in node-negative oral cancer..N Engl J Med2015;373:521-9

[55] Ganly I,Shah J.Early stage squamous cell cancer of the oral tongue–clinicopathologic features affecting outcome..Cancer2012;118:101-11

[56] Tsang RK,Howe To VS,Ho WK.Efficacy of salvage neck dissection for isolated nodal recurrences in early carcinoma of oral tongue with watchful waiting management of initial N0 neck..Head Neck2011;33:1482-5

[57] Borgemeester MC,van Tinteren H.Ultrasound-guided aspiration cytology for the assessment of the clinically N0 neck: factors influencing its accuracy..Head Neck2008;30:1505-13

[58] Van den Brekel MW,Snow GB.The size of lymph nodes in the neck on sonograms as a radiologic criterion for metastasis: how reliable is it?.AJNR Am J Neuroradiol1998;19:695-700

[59] Van den Brekel MW,Quak JJ.Sonographically guided aspiration cytology of neck nodes for selection of treatment and follow-up in patients with N0 head and neck cancer..AJNR Am J Neuroradiol1999;20:1727-31

[60] Wensing BM,de Wilde PC,van den Hoogen FJ.Assessment of preoperative ultrasonography of the neck and elective neck dissection in patients with oral squamous cell carcinoma..Oral Oncol2010;46:87-91

[61] Nieuwenhuis EJ,Pijpers R,Brakenhoff RH,Snow GB.Wait-and-see policy for the N0 neck in early-stage oral and oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma using ultrasonography-guided cytology: is there a role for identification of the sentinel node?.Head Neck2002;24:282-9

[62] Govers TM,Merkx MA,Rovers MM.Sentinel node biopsy for squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity and oropharynx: a diagnostic meta-analysis..Oral Oncol2013;49:726-32

[63] Chaturvedi P,Arya S.Prospective study of ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology and sentinel node biopsy in the staging of clinically negative T1 and T2 oral cancer..Head Neck2015;37:1504-8

[64] Andersen PE,Shaha AR.The extent of neck disease after regional failure during observation of the No neck..Am J Surg1996;172:689-91

[65] Fakih AR,Patel AR.Prophylactic neck dissection in squamous cell carcinoma of oral tongue: a prospective randomized study..Semin Surg Oncol1989;5:327-30

[66] Kowalski LP.Nodal metastases: predictive factors..Otolaryngol Clin North Am1998;31:621-37

[67] Ossoff RH.Lymphatics of the floor of the mouth and neck: anatomical studies related to contralateral drainage pathways..Laryngoscope1981;91:1847-50

[68] Shah JP,Poddar AK.The patterns of cervical lymph node metastases from squamous carcinoma of the oral cavity..Cancer1990;66:109-13

[69] Byers RM,Andrews T,Kare R.Frequency and therapeutic implications of ''skip metastases'' in the neck from squamous carcinoma of the oral tongue..Head Neck1997;19:14-9

[70] Kowalski LP,Lara JR,Silva JFJr.Prognostic significance of the distribution of neck node metastasis from oral carcinoma..Head Neck2000;22:207-14

[71] Woolgar JA.Histological distribution of cervical lymph node metastases from intraoral/oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinomas..Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg1999;37:175-80

[72] Byers RM,Lee YY,Fornage B,Sample D,Smith TL.Can we detect or predict the presence of occult nodal metastases in patients with squamous carcinoma of the oral tongue?.Head Neck1998;20:138-44

[73] Fukano H,Hasegawa Y.Depth of invasion as a predictive factor for cervical lymph node metastasis in tongue carcinoma..Head Neck1997;19:205-10

[74] Lim SC,Ishii G,Kodama K,Hayashi R,Cho JS.Predictive markers for late cervical metastasis in stage I and II invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the oral tongue..Clin Cancer Res2004;10:166-72

[75] Asakage T,Mukai K,Tsubono Y,Ebihara S.Tumor thickness predicts cervical metastasis in patients with stage I/II carcinoma of the tongue..Cancer1998;82:1443-8

[76] Kane SV,Kakade AC.Depth of invasion is the most significant histological predictor of subclinical cervical lymph node metastasis in early squamous carcinomas of the oral cavity..Eur J Surg Oncol2006;32:795-803

[77] Sparano A,Chalian A,Weber R.Multivariate predictors of occult neck metastasis in early oral tongue cancer..Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg2004;131:472-6

[78] Spiro RH,Wong GY,Gnecco CA.Predictive value of tumor thickness in squamous carcinoma confined to the tongue and floor of the mouth..Am J Surg1986;152:345-50

[79] Hiratsuka H,Nakamori K,Sunakawa H.Multivariate analysis of occult lymph node metastasis as a prognostic indicator for patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity..Cancer1997;80:351-6

[80] O'Connor R,Schilling C.The relative cost of sentinel lymph node biopsy in early oral cancer..J Craniomaxillofac Surg2013;41:721-7

[81] Alkureishi LW,Alvarez JA,Bilde A,Calabrese L,Chiti A,Gray HW,Kovacs AF,Leemans CR,McGurk M,Poli T,Sloan P,Stoeckli SJ,Trifiro G,Ross GL.Joint practice guidelines for radionuclide lymphoscintigraphy for sentinel node localization in oral/oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma..Ann Surg Oncol2009;16:3190-210 PMCID:PMC2766455

[82] Stoeckli SJ,Ross GL.Sentinel node biopsy for early oral and oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma..Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol2009;266:787-93

[83] Keski-Säntti H,Leivo I,Mätzke S,Atula T.Sentinel lymph node biopsy as an alternative to wait and see policy in patients with small T1 oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma..Acta Otolaryngol2008;128:98-102

[84] Keski-Säntti H,Törnwall J,Mätzke S,Leppänen E.Sentinel lymph node biopsy or elective neck dissection for patients with oral squamous cell carcinoma?.Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol2008;265:S13-7

[85] Thiele OC,Flechtenmacher C,Freier K.The role of elective supraomohyoidal neck dissection in the treatment of early, node-negative oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC): a retrospective analysis of 122 cases..J Craniomaxillofac Surg2012;40:67-70