Reducing the Brace Correction Stress on the Secondary Lumbar Curve Results in Excellent Muscle, Bone, and Disc Mechanical Performance: A Musculoskeletal Finite Element Simulation of AIS Patient With Rigo A3

Abstract

Objectives: The biomechanical mechanism of brace intervention on bone, muscle, and disc should be comprehensively considered for AIS patients. We aimed to developmentally construct a musculoskeletal finite element model of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis to simulate the coupling of corrective forces and analyze the mechanical properties of bone, muscle, and disc. Investigateing, more effective clinical interventions to break the vicious cycle of patients during growth.

Methods: A finite element model, including muscle, bone, and disc, was established using computed tomography data of a patient with RigoA3 adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. The three-point force coupling, antigravity, and bending effects of the Chêneau brace were simulated, and the correction force of the secondary lumbar bend was gradually reduced while observing the mechanical characteristics of bone, muscle, and disc. The correction force in line with symmetrical spine growth was comprehensively evaluated.

Results: The correction rate of the main thoracic (MT) curve, the intervertebral space height on the concave side of the vertebrae at the apex, and the stress ratio of the intervertebral discs were optimal when the maximum corrective pressure threshold was reached. However, the proximal thoracic (PT) curve was aggravated and the axial forces on the concave side were unbalanced. At this time, the biomechanical performance of the model is also not optimal. The correction rate of the Cobb Angle of the MT curve decreased with the decrease of the correction pressure in the lumbar region. When reduced to 25% of the maximum threshold, the convex side of disc stress, intervertebral space, and muscle axial force is more in line with the biomechanical mechanism of correction and can avoid sacrificing the PT curve.

Conclusions: Downward adjustment of the corrective force to the secondary lumbar curve, using the Chêneau brace, results in better primary thoracic curvature mechanics in the musculoskeletal finite element model, suggesting that breaking the vicious cycle of scoliosis progression to guide benign spinal growth is beneficial.

Keywords

downward correction pressure / finite element simulation / improved performance / lumbar spine curve / tensegrity

References

[1] S. L. Weinstein, L. A. Dolan, J. C. Cheng, A. Danielsson, and J. A. Morcuende, “Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis,” Lancet 371 (2008): 1527–1537,

[2] F. Altaf, A. Gibson, Z. Dannawi, and H. Noordeen, “Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis,” BMJ 346 (2013): f2508,

[3] J. C. Cheng, R. M. Castelein, W. C. Chu, et al., “Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis,” Nature Reviews. Disease Primers 1 (2015): 15030,

[4] H. Zhang, B. Wang, A. Wu, et al., “Assessment of Neck Imbalance in Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis Patients: A Cross-Section Study Based on Body Image of 115 Patients With Main or Double Thoracic Curve,” Orthopaedic Surgery 15 (2023): 572–578,

[5] S. Yang, L. M. Andras, G. J. Redding, and D. L. Skaggs, “Early-Onset Scoliosis: A Review of History, Current Treatment, and Future Directions,” Pediatrics 137 (2016): E20150709.

[6] R. E. Will, I. A. Stokes, X. Qiu, M. R. Walker, and J. O. Sanders, “Cobb Angle Progression in Adolescent Scoliosis Begins at the Intervertebral Disc,” Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 34 (2009): 2782–2786,

[7] T. P. Schlösser, M. van Stralen, R. C. Brink, et al., “Three-Dimensional Characterization of Torsion and Asymmetry of the Intervertebral Discs Versus Vertebral Bodies in Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis,” Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 39 (2014): E1159–E1166,

[8] T. H. Smit, “Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis: The Mechanobiology of Differential Growth,” JOR Spine 3 (2020): e1115,

[9] J. Clin, C. E. Aubin, S. Parent, and H. Labelle, “A Biomechanical Study of the Charleston Brace for the Treatment of Scoliosis,” Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 35 (2010): E940–E947,

[10] M. Rigo, G. Quera-Salvá, N. Puigdevall, and M. Martínez, “Retrospective Results in Immature Idiopathic Scoliotic Patients Treated With a Chêneau Brace,” Studies in Health Technology and Informatics 88 (2002): 241–245.

[11] D. Ovadia, S. Eylon, A. Mashiah, S. Wientroub, and E. D. Lebel, “Factors Associated With the Success of the Rigo System Chêneau Brace in Treating Mild to Moderate Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis,” Journal of Children’s Orthopaedics 6 (2012): 327–331,

[12] S. L. Weinstein, L. A. Dolan, J. G. Wright, and M. B. Dobbs, “Effects of Bracing in Adolescents With Idiopathic Scoliosis,” New England Journal of Medicine 369 (2013): 1512–1521,

[13] J. Li, Z. An, J. Wu, et al., “Construction of the Adjusted Scoliosis 3D Finite Element Model and Biomechanical Analysis Under Gravity,” Orthopaedic Surgery 15 (2023): 606–616,

[14] A. Guy, H. Labelle, S. Barchi, et al., “Braces Designed Using CAD/CAM Combined or Not With Finite Element Modeling Lead to Effective Treatment and Quality of Life After 2 Years: A Randomized Controlled Trial,” Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 46 (2021): 9–16,

[15] S. Bidari, M. Kamyab, H. Ghandhari, and A. Komeili, “Efficacy of Computer-Aided Design and Manufacturing Versus Computer-Aided Design and Finite Element Modeling Technologies in Brace Management of Idiopathic Scoliosis: A Narrative Review,” Asian Spine Journal 15 (2021): 271–282,

[16] Z. Kamal, G. Rouhi, N. Arjmand, and S. Adeeb, “A Stability-Based Model of a Growing Spine With Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis: A Combination of Musculoskeletal and Finite Element Approaches,” Medical Engineering & Physics 64 (2019): 46–55,

[17] T. Guan, Y. Zhang, A. Anwar, Y. Zhang, and L. Wang, “Determination of Three-Dimensional Corrective Force in Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis and Biomechanical Finite Element Analysis,” Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology 8 (2020): 963,

[18] M. Hajihosseinali, N. Arjmand, A. Shirazi-Adl, F. Farahmand, and M. S. Ghiasi, “A Novel Stability and Kinematics-Driven Trunk Biomechanical Model to Estimate Muscle and Spinal Forces,” Medical Engineering & Physics 36 (2014): 1296–1304,

[19] R. E. Hawary, D. Zaaroor-Regev, Y. Floman, B. S. Lonner, Y. I. Alkhalife, and R. R. Betz, “Brace Treatment in Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis: Risk Factors for Failure-a Literature Review,” Spine Journal 19 (2019): 1917–1925,

[20] C. Yuan, A Retrospective Study and Finite Element Analysis of Compensatory Proximal Thoracic Curves in Rigo Type A AIS Following Brace Treatment (Master’s thesis of Guangzhou Sport University, 2023),

[21] M. Sharma, N. A. Langrana, and J. Rodriguez, “Role of Ligaments and Facets in Lumbar Spinal Stability,” Spine 20 (1995): 887–900,

[22] N. Bogduk, J. E. Macintosh, and M. J. Pearcy, “A Universal Model of the Lumbar Back Muscles in the Upright Position,” Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 17 (1992): 897–913,

[23] I. A. Stokes and M. Gardner-Morse, “Quantitative Anatomy of the Lumbar Musculature,” Journal of Biomechanics 32 (1999): 311–316,

[24] N. Bogduk, M. Pearcy, and G. Hadfield, “Anatomy and Biomechanics of Psoas Major,” Clinical Biomechanics (Bristol, Avon) 7, no. 2 (1992): 109–119,

[25] J. E. Macintosh, F. Valencia, N. Bogduk, and R. R. Munro, “The Morphology of the Human Lumbar Multifidus,” Clinical Biomechanics (Bristol, Avon) 1, no. 4 (1986): 196–204,

[26] J. E. Macintosh and N. Bogduk, “Volvo Award in Basic Science. The Morphology of the Lumbar Erector Spinae,” Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 12, no. 7 (1987): 658–668,

[27] M. Gatton, M. Pearcy, and G. Pettet, “Modelling the Line of Action for the Oblique Abdominal Muscles Using an Elliptical Torso Model,” Journal of Biomechanics 34 (2001): 1203–1207,

[28] N. Arjmand, D. Gagnon, A. Plamondon, A. Shirazi-Adl, and C. Larivière, “A Comparative Study of Two Trunk Biomechanical Models Under Symmetric and Asymmetric Loadings,” Journal of Biomechanics 43 (2010): 485–491,

[29] G. A. Dumas, M. J. Poulin, B. Roy, M. Gagnon, and M. Jovanovic, “A Three-Dimensional Digitization Method to Measure Trunk Muscle Lines of Action,” Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 13 (1988): 532–541,

[30] N. Arjmand, A. Shirazi-Adl, and B. Bazrgari, “Wrapping of Trunk Thoracic Extensor Muscles Influences Muscle Forces and Spinal Loads in Lifting Tasks,” Clinical Biomechanics (Bristol, Avon) 21, no. 7 (2006): 668–675,

[31] S. B. Roberts and P. H. Chen, “Elastostatic Analysis of the Human Thoracic Skeleton,” Journal of Biomechanics 3 (1970): 527–545,

[32] N. Brown, C. Saputa, and J. Black, “Young’s Modulus of Living Human Bone Transactions of the Orthopaedic Research Society,” (1981).

[33] H. Wang, “Development of a Side Impact Finite Element Human Thoracic Model,” (PhD thesis, Wayne State University, 1995).

[34] J. Clin, C. Aubin, S. Parent, and H. Labelle, “Biomechanical Modeling of Brace Treatment of Scoliosis: Effects of Gravitational Loads,” Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing 49 (2011): 743–753,

[35] J. Clin, C. E. Aubin, and H. Labelle, “Virtual Prototyping of a Brace Design for the Correction of Scoliotic Deformities,” Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing 45 (2007): 467–473,

[36] D. Périé, C. E. Aubin, Y. Petit, H. Labelle, and J. Dansereau, “Personalized Biomechanical Simulations of Orthotic Treatment in Idiopathic Scoliosis Clinical,” Biomechanics (Bristol, Avon) 19 (2004): 190–195,

[37] C. T. Mehlman, A. Araghi, and D. R. Roy, “Hyphenated History: The Hueter–Volkmann Law,” American Journal of Orthopedics (Belle Mead, NJ) 26 (1997): 798–800.

[38] I. Villemure, C. E. Aubin, J. Dansereau, and H. Labelle, “Biomechanical Simulations of the Spine Deformation Process in Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis From Different Pathogenesis Hypotheses,” European Spine Journal 13 (2004): 83–90,

[39] A. Nachemson, “The Load on Lumbar Disks in Different Positions of the Body,” Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research 45 (1966): 107–122.

[40] A. Schultz, G. Andersson, R. Ortengren, K. Haderspeck, and A. Nachemson, “Loads on the Lumbar Spine. Validation of a Biomechanical Analysis by Measurements of Intradiscal Pressures and Myoelectric Signals,” Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery (American Volume) 64 (1982): 713–720.

[41] S. Íñiguez-Macedo, R. Lostado-Lorza, R. Escribano-García, and M. Martínez-Calvo, “Finite Element Model Updating Combined With Multi-Response Optimization for Hyper-Elastic Materials Characterization,” Materials (Basel) 12 (2019): 109,

[42] R. Lostado-Lorza, M. Corral-Bobadilla, and I. M. Somovilla-Gomez, “Characterization, LCA and FEA for an Efficient Ecodesign of Novel Stainless Steel Woven Wire Mesh Reinforced Recycled Aluminum Alloy Matrix Composite,” Journal of Cleaner Production 411 (2023): 13780.

[43] R. Dong, To Study the Modular Design of ScoliosisOrthosis Considering Multiple Factors (Master’s Thesis of Dalian Jiaotong University, 2023),

[44] F. Desbiens-Blais, J. Clin, S. Parent, H. Labelle, and C. E. Aubin, “New Brace Design Combining CAD/CAM and Biomechanical Simulation for the Treatment of Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis,” Clinical Biomechanics (Bristol, Avon) 27, no. 10 (2012): 999–1005,

[45] N. Cobetto, C. E. Aubin, S. Parent, et al., “Effectiveness of Braces Designed Using Computer-Aided Design and Manufacturing (CAD/CAM) and Finite Element Simulation Compared to CAD/CAM Only for the Conservative Treatment of Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis: A Prospective Randomized Controlled Trial,” European Spine Journal 25 (2016): 3056–3064,

[46] J. H. Ferziger and M. Peric, “Computational Methods in Computational Fluid Dynamics,” Artificial Intelligence and Sustainable Computing Conference paper (Springer, Online: 24 September 2023).

[47] S. L. Gould, L. Cristofolini, G. Davico, and M. Viceconti, “Computational Modelling of the Scoliotic Spine: A Literature Review,” International Journal for Numerical Methods in Biomedical Engineering 37 (2021): e3503,

[48] I. Busscher, J. H. van Dieën, I. Kingma, A. J. van der Veen, G. J. Verkerke, and A. G. Veldhuizen, “Biomechanical Characteristics of Different Regions of the Human Spine: An In Vitro Study on Multilevel Spinal Segments,” Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 34 (2009): 2858–2864,

[49] W. Sheng, Finite Element Modeling and Analysis of Personalized Scoliosis (Taiyuan, China: Taiyuan University of Technology, 2022), Master’s Thesis.

[50] D. Xin, H. Huo, J. Hu, et al., “Construction of Lenke3 Type Adult Idiopathic Scoliosis Finite Element Model and Thoracic Screw Guide Target 3D Model,” Chinese Journal of Tissue Engineering Research 19 (2015): 8597–8602,

[51] Z. Kamal and G. Rouhi, “Stress Distribution Changes in Growth Plates of a Trunk With Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis Following Unilateral Muscle Paralysis: A Hybrid Musculoskeletal and Finite Element Model,” Journal of Biomechanics 111 (2020): 109997,

[52] P. L. Sylvestre, I. Villemure, and C. E. Aubin, “Finite Element Modeling of the Growth Plate in a Detailed Spine Model,” Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing 45 (2007): 977–988,

[53] J. M Mac-Thiong, Y. Petit, C. E. Aubin, S. Delorme, J. Dansereau, and H. Labelle, “Biomechanical Evaluation of the Boston Brace System for the Treatment of Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis: Relationship Between Strap Tension and Brace Interface Forces,” Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 29 (2004): 26–32,

[54] N. Cobetto, C. E. Aubin, J. Clin, et al., “Braces Optimized With Computer-Assisted Design and Simulations Are Lighter, More Comfortable, and More Efficient Than Plaster-Cast Braces for the Treatment of Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis,” Spine Deformity 2 (2014): 276–284,

[55] D. Visser, D. Xue, J. L. Ronsky, J. Harder, and R. F. Zernicke, “Computer-Aided Optimal Design of Custom Scoliosis Braces Considering Clinical and Patient Evaluations,” Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine 107 (2012): 478–489,

[56] X. Wang Yidan, W. H. Yangyang, L. Xiaohe, et al., “Finite Element Analysis of Facet Joint Between Normal and Lumbar Disc Herniation in Adolescents,” Acta Anatomica Sinica 53 (2022): 776–784,

[57] T. Mingxing, Finite Element Model Construction and Its Biomechanics Study of Lenke Type 1A-Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis (Changsha: Central South University, 2009),

[58] M. Rigo and M. Jelačić, “Brace Technology Thematic Series: The 3D Rigo Chêneau-Type Brace,” Scoliosis and Spinal Disorders 12 (2017): 10,

[59] T. P. Andriacchi, A. B. Schultz, T. B. Belytschko, and R. Dewald, “Milwaukee Brace Correction of Idiopathic Scoliosis. A Biomechanical Analysis and a Restrospective Study,” Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery (American Volume) 58 (1976): 806–815,

[60] A. A. White, 3rd and M. M. Panjabi, “The Clinical Biomechanics of Scoliosis,” Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research 118 (1976): 100–112.

[61] M. Matsumoto, K. Watanabe, N. Hosogane, et al., “Postoperative Distal Adding-On and Related Factors in Lenke Type 1A Curve,” Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 38 (2013): 737–744,

[62] Y. Liu, X. Li, X. Dou, et al., “Correlational Analysis of Three-Dimensional Spinopelvic Parameters With Standing Balance and Gait Characteristics in Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis: A Preliminary Research on Lenke V,” Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology 10 (2022): 1022376,

[63] S. de Reuver, R. C. Brink, J. F. Homans, et al., “Anterior Lengthening in Scoliosis Occurs Only in the Disc and Is Similar in Different Types of Scoliosis,” Spine Journal 20 (2020): 1653–1658,

[64] Z. Kamal and G. Rouhi, “Significance of Spine Stability Criteria on Trunk Muscle Forces Following Unilateral Muscle Weakening: A Comparison Between Kinematics-Driven and Stability-Based Kinematics-Driven Musculoskeletal Models,” Medical Engineering & Physics 73 (2019): 51–63,

[65] P. Duncombe, M. T. Izatt, P. Pivonka, A. Claus, J. P. Little, and K. Tucker, “Quantifying Muscle Size Asymmetry in Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis Using Three-Dimensional Magnetic Resonance Imaging,” Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 48 (2023): 1717–1725,

[66] N. Barba, D. Ignasiak, T. M. T. Villa, F. Galbusera, and T. Bassani, “Assessment of Trunk Muscle Activation and Intervertebral Load in Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis by Musculoskeletal Modelling Approach,” Journal of Biomechanics 114 (2021): 110154,

[67] I. A. Stokes, M. G Gardner-Morse, and S. M. Henry, “Abdominal Muscle Activation Increases Lumbar Spinal Stability: Analysis of Contributions of Different Muscle Groups,” Clinical Biomechanics (Bristol, Avon) 26 (2011): 797–803,

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2024 The Author(s). Orthopaedic Surgery published by Tianjin Hospital and John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd.