In vitro human gut microbiota fermentation models: opportunities, challenges, and pitfalls

Abstract

The human gut microbiota (HGM) plays a pivotal role in health and disease. Consequently, nutritional and medical research focusing on HGM modulation strategies as a means of improving host health is steadily increasing. In vitro HGM fermentation models offer a valid complement to human and animal studies when it comes to the mechanistic exploration of novel modulation approaches and their direct effects on HGM composition and activity, while excluding interfering host effects. However, in vitro cultivation of HGM can be challenging due to its high oxygen sensitivity and the difficulties of accurately modeling the physio-chemical complexity of the gut environment. Despite the increased use of in vitro HGM models, there is no consensus about appropriate model selection and operation, sometimes leading to major deficiencies in study design and result interpretation. In this review paper, we aim to analyze crucial aspects of the application, setup and operation, data validation and result interpretation of in vitro HGM models. When carefully designed and implemented, in vitro HGM modeling is a powerful strategy for isolating and investigating biotic and abiotic factors in the HGM, as well as evaluating their effects in a controlled environment akin to the gut. Furthermore, complementary approaches combining different in vitro and in vivo models can strengthen the design and interpretation of human studies.

Keywords

Human gut microbiota / intestinal fermentation technology / in vitro modeling / ex vivo cultivation

References

[1] Rooks MG.Gut microbiota, metabolites and host immunity.Nat Rev Immunol2016;16:341-52 PMCID:PMC5541232

[2] Power SE,Stanton C,Fitzgerald GF.Intestinal microbiota, diet and health.Br J Nutr2014;111:387-402

[3] Fan Y.Gut microbiota in human metabolic health and disease.Nat Rev Microbiol2021;19:55-71

[4] Sun P,Zhu H.Gut Microbiota regulation and their implication in the development of neurodegenerative disease.Microorganisms2021;9:2281 PMCID:PMC8621510

[5] Carding S,Vipond DT,Owen LJ.Dysbiosis of the gut microbiota in disease.Microb Ecol Health Dis2015;26:26191 PMCID:PMC4315779

[6] Vangay P,Gerber JS.Antibiotics, pediatric dysbiosis, and disease.Cell Host Microbe2015;17:553-64 PMCID:PMC5555213

[7] Wild CP.Complementing the genome with an “exposome”: the outstanding challenge of environmental exposure measurement in molecular epidemiology.Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev2005;14:1847-50

[8] Brüssow H.Problems with the concept of gut microbiota dysbiosis.Microb Biotechnol2020;13:423-34 PMCID:PMC7017827

[9] Koh A.From association to causality: the role of the gut microbiota and its functional products on host metabolism.Mol Cell2020;78:584-96

[10] Lacroix C,Chassard C.Integrated multi-scale strategies to investigate nutritional compounds and their effect on the gut microbiota.Curr Opin Biotechnol2015;32:149-55

[11] Pham VT.The application of in vitro human intestinal models on the screening and development of pre- and probiotics.Benef Microbes2018;9:725-42

[12] Veintimilla-gozalbo E,Calvo-lerma J,Andrés A.In vitro simulation of human colonic fermentation: a practical approach towards models’ design and analytical tools.Applied Sciences2021;11:8135

[13] van de Steeg E,Obach RS.An ex vivo fermentation screening platform to study drug metabolism by human gut microbiota.Drug Metab Dispos2018;46:1596-607

[14] Roupar D,Gonçalves DA.Evaluation of microbial-fructo-oligosaccharides metabolism by human gut microbiota fermentation as compared to commercial inulin-derived oligosaccharides.Foods2022;11:954 PMCID:PMC8997964

[15] Kastl AJ Jr,Wu GD.The structure and function of the human small intestinal microbiota: current understanding and future directions.Cell Mol Gastroenterol Hepatol2020;9:33-45 PMCID:PMC6881639

[16] Ohland CL.Microbial activities and intestinal homeostasis: a delicate balance between health and disease.Cell Mol Gastroenterol Hepatol2015;1:28-40 PMCID:PMC4339954

[17] Booijink CC,Rajilić-Stojanović M.High temporal and inter-individual variation detected in the human ileal microbiota.Environ Microbiol2010;12:3213-27

[18] Hewes SA,Estes MK,Blutt SE.In Vitro models of the small intestine: engineering challenges and engineering solutions.Tissue Eng Part B Rev2020;26:313-26 PMCID:PMC7462033

[19] Stolaki M,Venema K.Microbial communities in a dynamic in vitro model for the human ileum resemble the human ileal microbiota.FEMS Microbiol Ecol2019;95:fiz096

[20] Cieplak T,Nielsen S,van den Berg F.The smallest intestine (TSI) -a low volume in vitro model of the small intestine with increased throughput.FEMS Microbiol Lett2018;365

[21] Akritidou T,Akkermans S.A protocol for the cultivation and monitoring of ileal gut microbiota surrogates.J Appl Microbiol2022;133:1919-39

[22] Kheadr E,Dabour N,Le Blay G.Study of the physicochemical and biological stability of pediocin PA-1 in the upper gastrointestinal tract conditions using a dynamic in vitro model.J Appl Microbiol2010;109:54-64

[23] Fernandez B,Fliss I.Survival and metabolic activity of pediocin producer pediococcus acidilactici ul5: its impact on intestinal microbiota and listeria monocytogenes in a model of the human terminal ileum.Microb Ecol2016;72:931-42

[24] Microbiome Project Consortium. Structure, function and diversity of the healthy human microbiome.Nature2012;486:207-14 PMCID:PMC3564958

[25] Gregory AC,Zayed AA,Bolduc B.The gut virome database reveals age-dependent patterns of virome diversity in the human gut.Cell Host Microbe2020;28:724-740.e8 PMCID:PMC7443397

[26] Camarillo-Guerrero LF,Rangel-Pineros G,Lawley TD.Massive expansion of human gut bacteriophage diversity.Cell2021;184:1098-1109.e9 PMCID:PMC7895897

[27] Chibani CM,Borrel G.Publisher correction: a catalogue of 1,167 genomes from the human gut archaeome.Nat Microbiol2022;7:339 PMCID:PMC8813613

[28] Raimondi S,Gozzoli C.Longitudinal survey of fungi in the human gut: its profiling, phenotyping, and colonization.Front Microbiol2019;10:1575 PMCID:PMC6636193

[29] Vemuri R,Chieppa M,Kavanagh K.Beyond just bacteria: functional biomes in the gut ecosystem including virome, mycobiome, archaeome and helminths.Microorganisms2020;8:483 PMCID:PMC7232386

[30] Sender R,Milo R.Are we really vastly outnumbered?.Cell2016;164:337-40

[31] Rajilić-Stojanović M.The first 1000 cultured species of the human gastrointestinal microbiota.FEMS Microbiol Rev2014;38:996-1047 PMCID:PMC4262072

[32] Oren A.Valid publication of the names of forty-two phyla of prokaryotes.Int J Syst Evol Microbiol2021;71

[33] Olsson LM,Nilsson S.Dynamics of the normal gut microbiota: a longitudinal one-year population study in Sweden.Cell Host Microbe2022;30:726-739.e3

[34] Gill SR,Deboy RT.Metagenomic analysis of the human distal gut microbiome.Science2006;312:1355-9 PMCID:PMC3027896

[35] Tap J,Levenez F.Towards the human intestinal microbiota phylogenetic core.Environ Microbiol2009;11:2574-84

[36] Coyte KZ.Understanding competition and cooperation within the mammalian gut microbiome.Curr Biol2019;29:R538-44 PMCID:PMC6935513

[37] Almeida A,Boland M.A unified catalog of 204,938 reference genomes from the human gut microbiome.Nat Biotechnol2021;39:105-14 PMCID:PMC7801254

[38] Clavel T,Segata N.Next steps after 15 stimulating years of human gut microbiome research.Microb Biotechnol2022;15:164-75 PMCID:PMC8719818

[39] Hoek MJAV.Emergence of microbial diversity due to cross-feeding interactions in a spatial model of gut microbial metabolism.BMC Syst Biol2017;11:56 PMCID:PMC5434578

[40] Vos WM, Tilg H, Van Hul M, Cani PD. Gut microbiome and health: mechanistic insights.Gut2022;71:1020-32 PMCID:PMC8995832

[41] Albenberg L,Judge CP.Correlation between intraluminal oxygen gradient and radial partitioning of intestinal microbiota.Gastroenterology2014;147:1055-63.e8 PMCID:PMC4252572

[42] Singhal R.Oxygen battle in the gut: Hypoxia and hypoxia-inducible factors in metabolic and inflammatory responses in the intestine.J Biol Chem2020;295:10493-505 PMCID:PMC7383395

[43] Whon TW,Kim JY.Omics in gut microbiome analysis.J Microbiol2021;59:292-7

[44] Louis P.Formation of propionate and butyrate by the human colonic microbiota.Environ Microbiol2017;19:29-41

[45] Pimentel M,Chang C.Gas and the microbiome.Curr Gastroenterol Rep2013;15:356

[46] Rios-Covian D,Nogacka AM.An overview on fecal branched short-chain fatty acids along human life and as related with body mass index: associated dietary and anthropometric factors.Front Microbiol2020;11:973 PMCID:PMC7271748

[47] Galloway-Peña J.Tools for analysis of the microbiome.Dig Dis Sci2020;65:674-85 PMCID:PMC7598837

[48] Jian C,Yki-Järvinen H,Korpela K.Quantitative PCR provides a simple and accessible method for quantitative microbiota profiling.PLoS One2020;15:e0227285 PMCID:PMC6961887

[49] Liu YX,Chen T.A practical guide to amplicon and metagenomic analysis of microbiome data.Protein Cell2021;12:315-30 PMCID:PMC8106563

[50] Hillmann B,Shields-Cutler RR.Evaluating the information content of shallow shotgun metagenomics.mSystems2018;3 PMCID:PMC6234283

[51] Laudadio I,Palone F,Cucchiara S.Quantitative assessment of shotgun metagenomics and 16S rDNA amplicon sequencing in the study of human gut microbiome.OMICS2018;22:248-54

[52] Mailhe M,Vitton V.Repertoire of the gut microbiota from stomach to colon using culturomics and next-generation sequencing.BMC Microbiol2018;18:157 PMCID:PMC6201554

[53] Vuik F,Lam SY.Composition of the mucosa-associated microbiota along the entire gastrointestinal tract of human individuals.United European Gastroenterol J2019;7:897-907 PMCID:PMC6683645

[54] Bircher L,Geirnaert A,Lacroix C.Planktonic and sessile artificial colonic microbiota harbor distinct composition and reestablish differently upon frozen and freeze-dried long-term storage.mSystems2020;5 PMCID:PMC6977070

[55] Demuth T,Bircher L,Nyström L.In vitro colon fermentation of soluble arabinoxylan is modified through milling and extrusion.Front Nutr2021;8:707763 PMCID:PMC8424098

[56] Ramirez Garcia A,Greppi A.Impact of manipulation of glycerol/diol dehydratase activity on intestinal microbiota ecology and metabolism.Environ Microbiol2021;23:1765-79

[57] Aguirre M,Koenen ME,Budding AE.Evaluation of an optimal preparation of human standardized fecal inocula for in vitro fermentation studies.J Microbiol Methods2015;117:78-84

[58] Kerckhof FM,Geirnaert A.Optimized cryopreservation of mixed microbial communities for conserved functionality and diversity.PLoS One2014;9:e99517 PMCID:PMC4061060

[59] Papanicolas LE,Wang Y.Bacterial viability in faecal transplants: Which bacteria survive?.EBioMedicine2019;41:509-16 PMCID:PMC6444077

[60] Bircher L,Geirnaert A.Cryopreservation of artificial gut microbiota produced with in vitro fermentation technology.Microb Biotechnol2018;11:163-75 PMCID:PMC5743790

[61] Walker AW,Duncan SH.Dominant and diet-responsive groups of bacteria within the human colonic microbiota.ISME J2011;5:220-30 PMCID:PMC3105703

[62] Zmora N,Suez J.Personalized gut mucosal colonization resistance to empiric probiotics is associated with unique host and microbiome features.Cell2018;174:1388-1405.e21

[63] Hou Q,Liu W.Probiotic-directed modulation of gut microbiota is basal microbiome dependent.Gut Microbes2020;12:1736974 PMCID:PMC7524168

[64] Chen T,Zhang C,Zhao L.Fiber-utilizing capacity varies in prevotella- versus bacteroides-dominated gut microbiota.Sci Rep2017;7:2594 PMCID:PMC5453967

[65] Paepe K, Kerckhof FM, Verspreet J, Courtin CM, Van de Wiele T. Inter-individual differences determine the outcome of wheat bran colonization by the human gut microbiome.Environ Microbiol2017;19:3251-67

[66] Isenring J,Jans C,Geirnaert A.Identification of valerate as carrying capacity modulator by analyzing lactiplantibacillus plantarum colonization of colonic microbiota in vitro.Front Microbiol2022;13:910609 PMCID:PMC9197689

[67] Poeker SA,Berchtold L.Understanding the prebiotic potential of different dietary fibers using an in vitro continuous adult fermentation model (PolyFermS).Sci Rep2018;8:4318 PMCID:PMC5847601

[68] An R,Logtenberg MJ.In vitro metabolic capacity of carbohydrate degradation by intestinal microbiota of adults and pre-frail elderly.ISME COMMUN2021;1

[69] Pérez-Burillo S,Navajas-Porras B.An in vitro batch fermentation protocol for studying the contribution of food to gut microbiota composition and functionality.Nat Protoc2021;16:3186-209

[70] Payne AN,Chassard C.Advances and perspectives in in vitro human gut fermentation modeling.Trends Biotechnol2012;30:17-25

[71] Nissen L,Gianotti A.Intestinal fermentation in vitro models to study food-induced gut microbiota shift: an updated review.FEMS Microbiol Lett2020;367:fnaa097

[72] Sanabria J,Masuda R.Overview of the nomenclature and network of contributors to the development of bioreactors for human gut simulation using bibliometric tools: a fragmented landscape.J Agric Food Chem2022;70:11458-67 PMCID:PMC9501909

[73] De Boever, Roel Wouters, Va. Development of a six-stage culture system for simulating the gastrointestinal microbiota of weaned infants.Microbial Ecology in Health and Disease2001;13:111-23

[74] Blay G, Chassard C, Baltzer S, Lacroix C. Set up of a new in vitro model to study dietary fructans fermentation in formula-fed babies.Br J Nutr2010;103:403-11

[75] den Abbeele P, Duysburgh C, Vazquez E, Chow J, Buck R, Marzorati M. 2′-Fucosyllactose alters the composition and activity of gut microbiota from formula-fed infants receiving complementary feeding in a validated intestinal model.J. Funct Foods2019;61:103484

[76] Doo EH,Schwab C.Effect of dietary nucleosides and yeast extracts on composition and metabolic activity of infant gut microbiota in polyferms colonic fermentation models.FEMS Microbiol Ecol2017;93

[77] Fournier E,Dominicis A.A child is not an adult: development of a new in vitro model of the toddler colon.Appl Microbiol Biotechnol2022;106:7315-36

[78] Brodkorb A,Alminger M.INFOGEST static in vitro simulation of gastrointestinal food digestion.Nat Protoc2019;14:991-1014

[79] Kleigrewe K,Baudin M.Dietary modulation of the human gut microbiota and metabolome with flaxseed preparations.Int J Mol Sci2022;23:10473 PMCID:PMC9499670

[80] Pan L,Shang Q.In vitro fermentation and isolation of heparin-degrading bacteria from human gut microbiota.Anaerobe2021;68:102289

[81] Valentová K,Kosina P.Biotransformation of silymarin flavonolignans by human fecal microbiota.Metabolites2020;10:29 PMCID:PMC7023230

[82] Li L,Zhang X.RapidAIM: a culture- and metaproteomics-based Rapid Assay of Individual Microbiome responses to drugs.Microbiome2020;8:33 PMCID:PMC7066843

[83] Li L,Ning Z.An in vitro model maintaining taxon-specific functional activities of the gut microbiome.Nat Commun2019;10:4146 PMCID:PMC6742639

[84] Yao CK,Ou JZ,Muir JG.Modulation of colonic hydrogen sulfide production by diet and mesalazine utilizing a novel gas-profiling technology.Gut Microbes2018;9:510-22 PMCID:PMC6287689

[85] So D,Gill PA,Gibson PR.Screening dietary fibres for fermentation characteristics and metabolic profiles using a rapid in vitro approach: implications for irritable bowel syndrome.Br J Nutr2021;126:208-18

[86] Fekry MI,Zhang J.The strict anaerobic gut microbe Eubacterium hallii transforms the carcinogenic dietary heterocyclic amine 2-amino-1-methyl-6-phenylimidazo[4,5-b]pyridine (PhIP).Environ Microbiol Rep2016;8:201-9

[87] Macfarlane GT,Gibson GR.Validation of a three-stage compound continuous culture system for investigating the effect of retention time on the ecology and metabolism of bacteria in the human colon.Microb Ecol1998;35:180-7

[88] Molly K,Verstraete W.Development of a 5-step multi-chamber reactor as a simulation of the human intestinal microbial ecosystem.Appl Microbiol Biotechnol1993;39:254-8

[89] Gibson GR,Macfarlane GT.Use of a three-stage continuous culture system to study the effect of mucin on dissimilatory sulfate reduction and methanogenesis by mixed populations of human gut bacteria.Appl Environ Microbiol1988;54:2750-5 PMCID:PMC204367

[90] Zihler Berner A,Dostal A.Novel Polyfermentor intestinal model (PolyFermS) for controlled ecological studies: validation and effect of pH.PLoS One2013;8:e77772 PMCID:PMC3813750

[91] Minekus M,Bernalier A.A computer-controlled system to simulate conditions of the large intestine with peristaltic mixing, water absorption and absorption of fermentation products.Appl Microbiol Biotechnol1999;53:108-14

[92] Zihler A,Chassard C.Unexpected consequences of administering bacteriocinogenic probiotic strains for Salmonella populations, revealed by an in vitro colonic model of the child gut.Microbiology (Reading)2010;156:3342-53

[93] Fehlbaum S,Haug MC,Derrien M.Design and investigation of polyferms in vitro continuous fermentation models inoculated with immobilized fecal microbiota mimicking the elderly colon.PLoS One2015;10:e0142793 PMCID:PMC4641611

[94] García-Villalba R,Pitart J.Gastrointestinal simulation model twin-shime shows differences between human urolithin-metabotypes in gut microbiota composition, pomegranate polyphenol metabolism, and transport along the intestinal tract.J Agric Food Chem2017;65:5480-93

[95] Van den Abbeele P,Eeckhaut V.Incorporating a mucosal environment in a dynamic gut model results in a more representative colonization by lactobacilli.Microb Biotechnol2012;5:106-15 PMCID:PMC3815277

[96] Deschamps C,Uriot O.Comparative methods for fecal sample storage to preserve gut microbial structure and function in an in vitro model of the human colon.Appl Microbiol Biotechnol2020;104:10233-47

[97] McDonald JA,Schroeter K.Simulating distal gut mucosal and luminal communities using packed-column biofilm reactors and an in vitro chemostat model.J Microbiol Methods2015;108:36-44

[98] Pham VT,Rifa E.Lactate metabolism is strongly modulated by fecal inoculum, ph, and retention time in polyferms continuous colonic fermentation models mimicking young infant proximal colon.mSystems2019;4 PMCID:PMC6538849

[99] Possemiers S,Uyttendaele S.PCR-DGGE-based quantification of stability of the microbial community in a simulator of the human intestinal microbial ecosystem.FEMS Microbiol Ecol2004;49:495-507

[100] Van den Abbeele P,Marzorati M.Microbial community development in a dynamic gut model is reproducible, colon region specific, and selective for Bacteroidetes and Clostridium cluster IX.Appl Environ Microbiol2010;76:5237-46 PMCID:PMC2916472

[101] McDonald JA,Fuentes S.Evaluation of microbial community reproducibility, stability and composition in a human distal gut chemostat model.J Microbiol Methods2013;95:167-74

[102] Franzosa EA,Avila-Pacheco J.Gut microbiome structure and metabolic activity in inflammatory bowel disease.Nat Microbiol2019;4:293-305

[103] Rodionov DA,Khoroshkin MS.Micronutrient requirements and sharing capabilities of the human gut microbiome.Front Microbiol2019;10:1316 PMCID:PMC6593275

[104] den Abbeele P, Sprenger N, Ghyselinck J, Marsaux B, Marzorati M, Rochat F. A comparison of the in vitro effects of 2'fucosyllactose and lactose on the composition and activity of gut microbiota from infants and toddlers.Nutrients2021;13:726 PMCID:PMC7996240

[105] Langille MG,Caporaso JG.Predictive functional profiling of microbial communities using 16S rRNA marker gene sequences.Nat Biotechnol2013;31:814-21 PMCID:PMC3819121

[106] Douglas GM,Zaneveld JR.PICRUSt2 for prediction of metagenome functions.Nat Biotechnol2020;38:685-8 PMCID:PMC7365738

[107] Gao B,Zhu Y.An introduction to next generation sequencing bioinformatic analysis in gut microbiome studies.Biomolecules2021;11:530 PMCID:PMC8066849