Designing an assessment tool for integrated evaluation of sustainable fisheries in China

Abstract

Fisheries are social-ecological systems. Evaluating the sustainability of fisheries requires methods to measure performance from ecological, economic, social, and governance aspects. Whereas a number of multi-dimensional evaluation tools such as fishery performance indicators (FPIs) have been used for assessing fishery management systems, fishery management practices and data availability are likely to differ substantially among fisheries in different countries. This makes it at least somewhat problematic to precisely adapt this methodology to fisheries within a given country. This study constructed a practical tool to evaluate and compare fishery systems in China. On the basis of an established indicator library and the FPIs tool, indicators in the newly developed tool for comprehensive fisheries evaluation were selected according to the management objectives, data availability, and the authority of relevant indicators. The sustainability assessment tool for Chinese fisheries (SAT-fish) provides a three-tier hierarchical framework covering 60 indicators, of which 48 indicators were extracted from the FPIs tool and 12 indicators were associated with policy statements. Applicability and comprehensiveness of this tool in comparison with six other well-established frameworks were investigated. This tool offers a promising new method to assess the sustainability of fishery systems in China, with great potential to guide Chinese fisheries towards a higher level of sustainability.

References

[1] Anderson JL, Anderson CM, Chu J, Meredith J, Asche F, Sylvia G, Smith MD, Anggraeni D, Arthur R, Guttormsen A, McCluney JK, Ward T, Akpalu W, Eggert H, Flores J, Freeman MA, Holland DS, Knapp G, Kobayashi M, Larkin S, et al. . The fishery performance indicators: a management tool for triple bottom line outcomes. PLoS ONE, 2015, 10: e0122809.

[2] Anderson JL, Anderson CM, Chu J, Meredith J (2016) Fishery performance indicators manual (Version 1.3). http://isfs.institute.ifas.ufl.edu/projects/new-metrics/fpi-manual.

[3] Asche F, Garlock TM, Anderson JL, Bush SR, Smith MD, Anderson CM, Chu J, Garrett KA, Lem A, Lorenzen K, Oglend A, Tveteras S, Vannuccini S. Three pillars of sustainability in fisheries. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 2018, 115: 11221-11225.

[4] Belschner T, Ferretti J, Strehlow H, Kraak SBM, Döring R, Kraus G, Kempf A, Zimmermann C. Evaluating fisheries systems: a comprehensive analytical framework and its application to the EU's common fisheries policy. Fish Fish, 2019, 20: 97-109.

[5] Bennett NJ, Schuhbauer A, Skerritt D, Ebrahim N. Socio-economic monitoring and evaluation in fisheries. Fish Res, 2021, 239: 105934.

[6] Benson AJ, Stephenson RL. Options for integrating ecological, economic, and social objectives in evaluation and management of fisheries. Fish Fish, 2018, 19: 40-56.

[7] Berrios F, González JE, Campos L, Campbell DE, Bonnail E. Brown algae (Lessonia nigrescens, species complex) fisheries of northern Chile evaluated through the DPSIR approach: Social and economic impact of management strategies. Ocean Coastal Manage, 2022, 224: 106198.

[8] Brown CJ, Broadley A, Adame MF, Branch TA, Turschwell MP, Connolly RM. The assessment of fishery status depends on fish habitats. Fish Fish, 2019, 20: 1-14.

[9] Bucaram SJ (2016) Baseline assessment eastern Pacific Ocean tuna fisheries using the fisheries performance indicator methodology. Report prepared for the World Wildlife Fund, Washington, DC. https://www.fao.org/fileadmin/user_upload/common_oceans/docs/EPO_FPI%20_report.pdf

[10] Chávez C, Dresdner J, González N, Leiva M, Quiroga M. The performance of shared fish stock fisheries under varying institutional and socioeconomic conditions: evidence from the South Eastern Pacific Anchoveta Fishery. Mar Pol, 2021, 125: 104262.

[11] Chu J, Garlock TM, Sayon P, Asche F, Anderson JL. Impact evaluation of a fisheries development project. Mar Pol, 2017, 85: 141-149.

[12] Chu J, Anderson JL, Anderson CM (2012) Evaluation of new fishery performance indicators (FPIs): a case study of the blue swimming crab fisheries in Indonesia and Philippines. ARD 52, The World Bank Group, Washington, D.C. (100 pp). https://policycommons.net/artifacts/1524330/evaluation-of-new-fishery-performance-indicators-fpis/2210282/

[13] Costello C, Cao L, Gelcich S, Cisneros-Mata MÁ, Free CM. The future of food from the sea. Nature, 2020, 588: 95-100.

[14] Danielsen R, Anderson CM, Agnarsson S. Trawling for triple bottom line results: applying the fishery performance indicators in the Faroe Islands. Mar Pol, 2021, 125: 104250.

[15] Eggert H, Anderson CM, Anderson JL, Garlock TM. Assessing global fisheries using fisheries performance indicators: introduction to special section. Mar Pol, 2021, 125: 104253.

[16] Fisheries Bureau of the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs China Fisheries Statistical Yearbook 2023, 2023 Beijing China Agricultural Press

[17] Gari SR, Newton A, Icely JD. A review of the application and evolution of the DPSIR framework with an emphasis on coastal social-ecological systems. Ocean Coastal Manage, 2015, 103: 63-77.

[18] Garlock T, Anderson JL, Asche F, Smith MD, Camp E, Chu J, Lorenzen K, Vannuccini S. Global insights on managing fishery systems for the three pillars of sustainability. Fish Fish, 2022, 23: 899-909.

[19] Gentner B, Arocha F, Anderson C, Flett K, Obregon P, van Anrooy R (2018) Fishery performance indicator studies for the commercial and recreational pelagic fleets of the Dominican Republic and Grenada. FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Circular No.1162, Rome.

[20] Gray CA, Kennelly SJ. Bycatches of endangered, threatened and protected species in marine fisheries. Rev Fish Biol Fish, 2018, 28: 521-541.

[21] Halpern BS, Longo C, Hardy D, McLeod KL, Samhouri JF. An index to assess the health and benefits of the global ocean. Nature, 2012, 488: 615-620.

[22] Han Y. Marine fishery resources management and policy adjustment in China since 1949. China Rural Econ, 2018, 9: 14-28

[23] Hilborn R, Amoroso RO, Anderson CM, Baum JK, Branch TA. Effective fisheries management instrumental in improving fish stock status. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 2020, 117: 2218-2224.

[24] Hobday AJ, Hartog JR, Ogier E, Thomas L, Fleming A, Hornborg S (2019). Healthcheck Phase 2, FRDC Project 2016/060. Available at: FRDC. https://www.frdc.com.au/project/2016-060

[25] Jimenez ÉA, Gonzalez JG, Amaral MT, Fredou FL. Sustainability indicators for the integrated assessment of coastal small-scale fisheries in the Brazilian Amazon. Ecol Econ, 2021, 181: 106910.

[26] Johnson AE, Cinner JE, Hardt MJ, Jacquet J, McClanahan TR, Sanchirico JN. Trends, current understanding and future research priorities for artisanal coral reef fisheries research. Fish Fish, 2013, 14: 281-292.

[27] Juwana I, Muttil N, Perera BJC. Indicator-based water sustainability assessment—A review. Sci Total Environ, 2012, 438: 357-371.

[28] Kinds A, Sys K, Schotte L, Mondelaers K, Polet H. VALDUVIS: an innovative approach to assess the sustainability of fishing activities. Fish Res, 2016, 182: 158-171.

[29] Kleisner K, Zeller D, Froese R, Pauly D. Using global catch data for inferences on the world’s marine fisheries. Fish Fish, 2013, 14: 293-311.

[30] Liu L, Chu J, Anderson JL, Xu J. Sustainability comparisons in the triple bottom line for Chinese fisheries. Mar Pol, 2021, 125: 104259.

[31] Liu H, Peng D, Yang HJ, Mu Y, Zhu Y. Exploring the evolution of sustainable fisheries development: focusing on ecological, environmental and management issues. Ecol Inform, 2023, 75: 102004.

[32] Mangi SC, Roberts CM, Rodwell LD. Reef fisheries management in Kenya: Preliminary approach using the driver–pressure–state–impacts–response (DPSIR) scheme of indicators. Ocean Coastal Manage, 2007, 50: 463-480.

[33] Marco J, Valderrama D, Rueda M. Evaluating management reforms in a Colombian shrimp fishery using fisheries performance indicators. Mar Pol, 2021, 125: 104258.

[34] Marshall KN, Levin PS, Essington TE, Koehn LE, Anderson LG, Bundy A, Carothers C, Coleman F, Gerber LR, Grabowski JH, Houde E, Jensen OP, Möllmann C, Rose K, Sanchirico JN, Smith ADM. Ecosystem-based fisheries management for social–ecological systems: renewing the focus in the United States with next generation fishery ecosystem plans. Conserv Lett, 2018, 11: e12367.

[35] Martins JH, Camanho AS, Gaspar MB. A review of the application of driving forces–Pressure–State–Impact–Response framework to fisheries management. Ocean Coastal Manage, 2012, 69: 273-281.

[36] Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs (2021) The 14th Five-year Plan for National Fishery Development. http://www.moa.gov.cn/govpublic/YYJ/202201/t20220106_6386439.htm (accessed 1 March 2023).

[37] Ou CH, Liu WH. Developing a sustainable indicator system based on the pressure–state–response framework for local fisheries: A case study of Gungliau. Taiwan Ocean Coastal Manage, 2010, 53: 289-300.

[38] Pitcher TJ, Lam ME, Ainsworth C, Martindale A, Nakamura K, Perry RI, Ward T. Improvements to Rapfish: a rapid evaluation technique for fisheries integrating ecological and human dimensions. J Fish Biol, 2013, 83: 865-889.

[39] Rindorf A, Dichmont CM, Thorson J, Charles A, Clausen LW, Degnbol P, Garcia D, Hintzen NT, Kempf A, Levin P, Mace P, Maravelias C, Minto C, Mumford J, Pascoe S, Prellezo R, Punt AE, Reid DG, Röckmann C, Stephenson RL, et al. . Inclusion of ecological, economic, social, and institutional considerations when setting targets and limits for multispecies fisheries. ICES J Mar Sci, 2017, 74: 453-463.

[40] Salas S, Chuenpagdee R, Seijo JC, Charles A. Challenges in the assessment and management of small-scale fisheries in Latin America and the Caribbean. Fish Res, 2007, 87: 5-16.

[41] Shen G, Heino M. An overview of marine fisheries management in China. Mar Pol, 2014, 44: 265-272.

[42] Smith SL, Karasik R, Stavrinaky A, Uchida H, Burden M. Fishery socioeconomic outcomes tool: a rapid assessment tool for evaluating socioeconomic performance of fisheries management. Mar Pol, 2019, 105: 20-29.

[43] Stephenson RL, Paul S, Wiber M, Angel E, Benson AJ, Charles A, Chouinard O, Clemens M, Edwards D, Foley P, Jennings L, Jones O, Lane D, McIsaac J, Mussells C, Neis B, Nordstrom B, Parlee C, Pinkerton E, Saunders M, et al. . Evaluating and implementing social–ecological systems: a comprehensive approach to sustainable fisheries. Fish Fish, 2018, 19: 853-873.

[44] Stephenson RL, Paul S, Wiber M, Angel E, Benson AJ, Charles A, Chouinard O, Edwards D, Foley P, Lane D, McIsaac J, Neis B, Parlee C, Pinkerton E, Saunders M, Squires K, Sumaila UR. Integrating diverse objectives for sustainable fisheries in Canada. Can J Fish Aquat Sci, 2019, 76: 480-496.

[45] Su S, Tang Y, Chang B, Zhu W, Chen Y. Evolution of marine fisheries management in China from 1949 to 2019: How did China get here and where does China go next?. Fish Fish, 2020, 21: 435-452.

[46] Su M, Wang L, Xiang J, Ma Y. Adjustment trend of China’s marine fishery policy since 2011. Mar Pol, 2021, 124: 104322.

[47] Su S, Tang Y, Kritzer JP, Chen Y. Using systems thinking to diagnose science-based fisheries management in China. Mar Pol, 2022, 138: 104974.

[48] Sumaila UR, Ebrahim N, Schuhbauer A, Skerritt D, Li Y, Kim HS, Mallory TG, Lam VWL, Pauly D. Updated estimates and analysis of global fisheries subsidies. Mar Pol, 2019, 109: 103695.

[49] Teh LCL, Sumaila UR. Contribution of marine fisheries to worldwide employment. Fish Fish, 2013, 14: 77-88.

[50] Teh LCL, Ota Y, Cisneros-Montemayor AM, Harrington L, Swartz W. Are fishers poor? Getting to the bottom of marine fisheries income statistics. Fish Fish, 2020, 21: 471-482.

[51] Voyer M, Barclay K, McIlgorm A, Mazur N. Using a well-being approach to develop a framework for an integrated socio-economic evaluation of professional fishing. Fish Fish, 2017, 18: 1134-1149.

[52] Xu Z, Chau SN, Chen X, Zhang J, Li Y, Dietz T, Wang J, Winkler JA, Fan F, Huang B, Li S, Wu S, Herzberger A, Tang Y, Hong D, Li Y, Liu J. Assessing progress towards sustainable development over space and time. Nature, 2020, 577: 74-78.