Biomechanical principles of a permanently durable abdominal wall reconstruction: current status and potential future development

Abstract

The article reviews the biomechanical principles of durable abdominal wall reconstructions. The aim is to provide insights and conclusions for future research in this area. Incisional hernia repair implies the creation of a compound made of tissue, textile, and fixation elements. A pulse load bench test for incisional hernia repair has been available since 2014, and its influences are evaluated in three different versions of the test stand. Based on these evaluations, a biomechanical concept for long-term durable reconstructions was determined. To apply the concept to individual patients, computed tomography of the abdomen at rest and during the Valsalva maneuver was used. A load limit can be given for every patient based on the hernia defect area (CRIP- critical resistance to impacts related to pressure). By considering the mesh to defect area ratio, the retention strength of a planned reconstruction can be calculated (GRIP-gained resistance to impacts related to pressure). The gripping coefficients for tissues vary significantly, up to 18 fold. About half of the patients have overall tissue distensions up to 350% or more, with potential high regional variations. The surface retention forces for hernia meshes and for different sutures, tacks, and adhesives span a wide range of 14fold. Suturing a defect strengthens the reconstruction up to 3fold. Furthermore, recalculating data taken from multicentric randomized studies on primary sutures reveals that improved GRIP values are associated with reduced rates of incisional hernia. Repairing consecutive incisional hernias according to the GRIP concept results in no recurrence and low pain levels after one year. A future policy for market access of repair materials should include cyclic load bench testing. Moreover, a tailored approach to incisional hernia repair should take into account the biomechanical aspects involved.

Keywords

Hernia / incisional hernia / biomechanics / GRIP / biomechanically calculateed hernia repair / durable hernia repair / durable incisional hernia repair

References

[1] Hoffmann H,Adolf D.Analysis of 4,015 recurrent incisional hernia repairs from the Herniamed registry: risk factors and outcomes.Hernia2021;25:61-75

[2] Kallinowski F,Harder F.The grip concept of incisional hernia repair-dynamic bench test, CT abdomen with Valsalva and 1-Year clinical results.Front Surg2021;8:602181 PMCID:PMC8080034

[3] Nessel R,Rinn J.Primary and recurrent repair of incisional hernia based on biomechanical considerations to avoid mesh-related complications.Front Surg2021;8:764470 PMCID:PMC8714753

[4] Kallinowski F,Löffler T.Biomechanics applied to incisional hernia repair - considering the critical and the gained resistance towards impacts related to pressure.Clin Biomech2021;82:105253

[5] Kallinowski F,Gutjahr D.Biomechanical influences on mesh-related complications in incisional hernia repair.Front Surg2021;8:763957 PMCID:PMC8586217

[6] Kallinowski F,Harder F.Dynamic intermittent strain can rapidly impair ventral hernia repair.J Biomech2015;48:4026-36

[7] Kallinowski F,Gutjahr D.Assessing the GRIP of ventral hernia repair: how to securely fasten DIS classified meshes.Front Surg2017;4:78 PMCID:PMC5780431

[8] Kallinowski F,Vollmer M,Nessel R.Increasing hernia size requires higher GRIP values for a biomechanically stable ventral hernia repair.Ann Med Surg2019;42:1-6 PMCID:PMC6488564

[9] Romanowicz P.Estimation of notched composite plates fatigue life using residual strength model calibrated by step-wise tests.Materials2018;11:2180 PMCID:PMC6266408

[10] Zenner H. 2017.Fatigue of components: August Wöhler (1819-1914): a historical review. DVM Sonderhefte, German Association for Material Research and Testing eV. ISBN: 978-3-9814516-6-5; Available from: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/stab.201900041. [Last accessed on 15 Jun 2023] (In German)

[11] Kurrer KE. The history of the theory of structures: searching for equilibrium. In: Wiley, Ernst & Sohn, Berlin 2018 P. 1082. Available from: https://www.wiley.com/en-us/The+History+of+the+Theory+of+Structures%3A+Searching+for+Equilibrium%2C+2nd+Edition-p-9783433609132. [Last accessed on 15 Jun 2023]

[12] Schütz W.Zur geschichte der schwingfestigkeit.Materwiss Werksttech1993;24:203-232(In German)

[13] Perren SM,Rüedi R.Biomechanics of fracture healing after internal fixation.Surg Annu1975;7:361-90.

[14] Wale ME,Henderson BS,Creechley JJ.Applying ASTM standards to tensile tests of musculoskeletal soft tissue: methods to reduce grip failures and promote reproducibility.J Biomech Eng2021;143 PMCID:PMC7976171

[15] Soucasse A,Edin L,Masson C.A better understanding of daily life abdominal wall mechanical solicitation: Investigation of intra-abdominal pressure variations by intragastric wireless sensor in humans.Med Eng Phys2022;104:103813

[16] Moriyama S,Huang Z.Intra-abdominal pressure during swimming.Int J Sports Med2014;35:159-63

[17] Hackett DA.The Valsalva maneuver: its effect on intra-abdominal pressure and safety issues during resistance exercise.J Strength Cond Res2013;27:2338-45

[18] Lesch C,Uhr K.Cyclic pulse loads generate the new concept in abdominal wall reconstruction: suture closure.Mini-invasive Surg2023;7:20.

[19] Irwin RS,French CL.CHEST Expert Cough PanelLife-threatening and non-life-threatening complications associated with coughing: a scoping review.Chest2020;158:2058-73 PMCID:PMC8640838

[20] Turner RD.How to count coughs? Counting by ear, the effect of visual data and the evaluation of an automated cough monitor.Respir Med2014;108:1808-15

[21] Iqbal A,Stadlhuber RJ,Corkill S.A study of intragastric and intravesicular pressure changes during rest, coughing, weight lifting, retching, and vomiting.Surg Endosc2008;22:2571-5

[22] Kawabata M,Hamada H,Nishizono H.Changes in intra-abdominal pressure and spontaneous breath volume by magnitude of lifting effort: highly trained athletes versus healthy men.Eur J Appl Physiol2010;109:279-86

[23] Kawabata M,Nishizono H.Regular change in spontaneous preparative behaviour on intra-abdominal pressure and breathing during dynamic lifting.Eur J Appl Physiol2014;114:2233-9

[24] Blazek D,Maszczyk A,Matykiewicz P.Systematic review of intra-abdominal and intrathoracic pressures initiated by the Valsalva manoeuvre during high-intensity resistance exercises.Biol Sport2019;36:373-86 PMCID:PMC6945051

[25] Bower AF. Applied mechanics of solids. Available from: https://solidmechanics.org/contents.php 2019. [Last accessed on 14 Jun 2023]

[26] König JA. Shakedown of elastic-plastic structures. Available from: https://shop.elsevier.com/books/shakedown-of-elastic-plastic-structures/mcgonagle/978-0-444-98979-6. [Last accessed on 14 Jun 2023]

[27] Lesch C,Vollmer M,Nessel R.Standardized suturing can prevent slackening or bursting suture lines in midline abdominal incisions and defects.Hernia2022;26:1611-23 PMCID:PMC9684257

[28] Kallinowski F,Silva TG,Vollmer M.Bridging with reduced overlap: fixation and peritoneal grip can prevent slippage of DIS class A meshes.Hernia2017;21:455-67

[29] Szczesny SE,Pedersen P.Quantification of interfibrillar shear stress in aligned soft collagenous tissues via notch tension testing.Sci Rep2015;5:14649 PMCID:PMC4606738

[30] Elmasry A,El-safty SA.A comparative review of multiscale models for effective properties of nano- and micro-composites.Prog Mater Sci2023;132:101022

[31] Spagnoli A,Brighenti R,Carpinteri A.How soft polymers cope with cracks and notches.Appl Sci2019;9:1086

[32] Liu Z,Wang D.Recent advances in soft biological tissue manipulating technologies.Chin J Mech Eng2022;35:89

[33] Pierrat B,Avril S.Mechanical characterization and modeling of knitted textile implants with permanent set.J Mech Behav Biomed Mater2021;114:10421089

[34] Aryeetey OJ,Lorenz A.Fracture toughness determination of porcine muscle tissue based on AQLV model derived viscous dissipated energy.J Mech Behav Biomed Mater2022;135:105429

[35] Bircher K,Pensalfini M,Mazza E.Tear resistance of soft collagenous tissues.Nat Commun2019;10:792 PMCID:PMC6377632

[36] Le Ruyet A,Hartog FPJD.Differences in biomechanics of abdominal wall closure with and without mesh reinforcement: A study in post mortem human specimens.J Mech Behav Biomed Mater2020;105:103683

[37] Kallinowski F,Rinn J,Görich J.BJS-05 DIS class a meshes permit biomechanically strong reconstructions which are durable after a 3 year follow up.Br J Surg2023;110:znad080.005

[38] Alcañiz P,Gutiérrez A.Soft-Tissue simulation for computational planning of orthognathic surgery.J Pers Med2021;11:982 PMCID:PMC8540582

[39] Alcañiz P,Gutiérrez A.Soft-tissue simulation of the breast for intraoperative navigation and fusion of preoperative planning.Front Bioeng Biotechnol2022;10:976328 PMCID:PMC9554225

[40] Pachera P,Todros S,Fontanella CG.A numerical investigation of the healthy abdominal wall structures.J Biomech2016;49:1818-23

[41] Tuset L,Fortuny G,Herrero J.Virtual simulation of the biomechanics of the abdominal wall with different stoma locations.Sci Rep2022;12:3545 PMCID:PMC8894338

[42] Pott PP,Gundling R,Hohenberger P.Mechanical properties of mesh materials used for hernia repair and soft tissue augmentation.PLoS One2012;7:e46978 PMCID:PMC3470559

[43] Münster S,Leslie BA,Fabry B.Strain history dependence of the nonlinear stress response of fibrin and collagen networks.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A2013;110:12197-202 PMCID:PMC3725119

[44] Licup AJ,Sharma A.Stress controls the mechanics of collagen networks.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A2015;112:9573-8 PMCID:PMC4534289

[45] Franz MG.The biology of hernia formation.Surg Clin North Am2008;88:1-15, vii PMCID:PMC2276402

[46] Leake M,Grossmann T,Lafreniere B.PatchProv: Supporting improvisational design practices for modern quilting. CHI '21: proceedings of the 2021 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems. 2021. p. 1-17.

[47] Sahoo S,Erdemir A.Clinically relevant mechanical testing of hernia graft constructs.J Mech Behav Biomed Mater2015;41:177-88

[48] Lauro E,Luciani L.Stapled fascial suture: ex vivo modeling and clinical implications.Surg Endosc2022;36:8797-806

[49] Barthel C,Gamble JG,Rauer T.Recreational skydiving-really that dangerous?.Int J Environ Res Public Health2023;20:1254 PMCID:PMC9859333

[50] Kallinowski F. Biomechanics of mesh repair of the herniated abdominal wall: requires some knowledge of stochastic processes. Available from: http://websurg.com/doi/lt03en24558. [Last accessed on 14 Jun 2023]