Robotic or laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer - which is the best answer? A comprehensive review of oncological outcomes

Abstract

Treatment of rectal cancer is ever evolving with the introduction of newer surgical technologies and multimodal treatment approach. The literature evaluating the various surgical treatment options with regards to operative and nonoperative outcomes is abundant. This is a comprehensive review focused on oncological outcomes of rectal cancer resection performed robotically or laparoscopically. Based on the current literature available, there is no significant difference in total mesorectal excision completeness, lymph node harvest, positive circumferential resection margin, or proximal resection margin between robotic and laparoscopic approaches for rectal resection. Selection of surgical approach should not be based on pathological outcomes as they are equivalent.

Keywords

Robotic / robotics / laparoscopic / laparoscopy / rectal cancer / rectal carcinoma / total mesorectal excision

References

[1] Heald RJ,Ryall RD.The mesorectum in rectal cancer surgery--the clue to pelvic recurrence?.Br J Surg1982;69:613-6

[2] Fleshman J,Sargent DJ.Effect of laparoscopic-assisted resection vs open resection of stage II or III rectal cancer on pathologic outcomes..JAMA2015;314:1346-55 PMCID:PMC5140087

[3] Fleshman J,Sargent DJ.Disease-free survival and local recurrence for laparoscopic resection compared with open resection of stage II to III rectal cancer: follow-up results of the ACOSOG Z6051 randomized controlled trial..Ann Surg2019;269:589-95 PMCID:PMC6360134

[4] Bonjer HJ,Abis GA.A randomized trial of laparoscopic versus open surgery for rectal cancer..N Engl J Med2015;372:1324-32

[5] van der Pas MH,Cuesta MA.Laparoscopic versus open surgery for rectal cancer (COLOR II): short-term outcomes of a randomised, phase 3 trial..Lancet Oncol2013;14:210-8

[6] Stevenson AR,Lumley JW.Effect of laparoscopic-assisted resection vs open resection on pathological outcomes in rectal cancer: the ALaCaRT randomized clinical trial..JAMA2015;314:1356-63

[7] Kang S,Jeong S.Open versus laparoscopic surgery for mid or low rectal cancer after neoadjuvant chemoradiotherapy (COREAN trial): short-term outcomes of an open-label randomised controlled trial..Lancet Oncol2010;11:637-45

[8] Jeong S,Nam BH.Open versus laparoscopic surgery for mid-rectal or low-rectal cancer after neoadjuvant chemoradiotherapy (COREAN trial): survival outcomes of an open-label, non-inferiority, randomised controlled trial..Lancet Oncol2014;15:767-74

[9] Holder-Murray J.Minimally invasive surgery for colorectal cancer: past, present, and future..Int J Surg Oncol2011;2011:490917 PMCID:PMC3263673

[10] Jayne D,Marshall H.Effect of robotic-assisted vs conventional laparoscopic surgery on risk of conversion to open laparotomy among patients undergoing resection for rectal cancer: the ROLARR randomized clinical trial..JAMA2017;318:1569-80 PMCID:PMC5818805

[11] Kim MJ,Park JW.Robot-assisted versus laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer: a phase II open label prospective randomized controlled trial..Ann Surg2018;267:243-51

[12] Baik SH,Kang CM.Robotic tumor-specific mesorectal excision of rectal cancer: short-term outcome of a pilot randomized trial..Surg Endosc2008;22:1601-8

[13] Eltair M,Hajibandeh S.Meta-analysis and trial sequential analysis of robotic versus laparoscopic total mesorectal excision in management of rectal cancer..Int J Colorectal Dis2020;35:1423-38

[14] Simillis C,Thoukididou SN.Open versus laparoscopic versus robotic versus transanal mesorectal excision for rectal cancer: a systematic review and network meta-analysis..Ann Surg2019;270:59-68

[15] Rausa E,Kelly ME.Systemic review and network meta-analysis comparing minimal surgical techniques for rectal cancer: quality of total mesorectum excision, pathological, surgical, and oncological outcomes..J Surg Oncol2019;119:987-98

[16] Milone M,Velotti N.Completeness of total mesorectum excision of laparoscopic versus robotic surgery: a review with a meta-analysis..Int J Colorectal Dis2019;34:983-91

[17] Compton CC.The staging of colorectal cancer: 2004 and beyond..CA Cancer J Clin2004;54:295-308

[18] Compton CC,Burgart LJ.Prognostic factors in colorectal cancer. College of American Pathologists Consensus Statement 1999..Arch Pathol Lab Med2000;124:979-94

[19] Sobin LH.TNM classification: clarification of number of regional lymph nodes for pn0..Cancer2001;92:452

[20] Park JS,Kim SH.Multicentre study of robotic intersphincteric resection for low rectal cancer..Br J Surg2015;102:1567-73

[21] Kim J,Kang DW.Robotic resection is a good prognostic factor in rectal cancer compared with laparoscopic resection: long-term survival analysis using propensity score matching..Dis Colon Rectum2017;60:266-73

[22] Panteleimonitis S,Abbas H.Robotic rectal cancer surgery in obese patients may lead to better short-term outcomes when compared to laparoscopy: a comparative propensity scored match study..Int J Colorectal Dis2018;33:1079-86 PMCID:PMC6060802

[23] Law WL.Comparison of short-term and oncologic outcomes of robotic and laparoscopic resection for mid- and distal rectal cancer..Surg Endosc2017;31:2798-807

[24] Hoshino N,Hida K.Robotic versus laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer: an overview of systematic reviews with quality assessment of current evidence..Surg Today2019;49:556-70

[25] Gavriilidis P,Spinelli A,Simopoulos C.Robotic vs laparoscopic total mesorectal excision for rectal cancers: has a paradigm change occurred? A systematic review by updated meta-analysis..Colorectal Dis2020;doi: 10.1111/codi.15084

[26] Zheng B,Wang X.A comparison of open, laparoscopic and robotic total mesorectal excision: trial sequential analysis and network meta-analysis..Colorectal Dis2020;22:382-91

[27] Liao G,Deng H.Comparison of pathological outcomes between robotic rectal cancer surgery and laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery: a meta-analysis based on seven randomized controlled trials..Int J Med Robot2019;15:e2027

[28] Lee SH,Lim SW.Robotic versus laparoscopic intersphincteric resection for low rectal cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis..Int J Colorectal Dis2018;33:1741-53

[29] Kavalukas SL,Sharp SP.Robotic or laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer - which is the best answer? a comprehensive review of non-oncological outcomes and learning curve..Mini-invasive Surg2020;4:61

[30] American College of Surgeons. National Accreditation Program for Rectal Cancer. Available from: https://www.facs.org/quality-programs/cancer/naprc#. [Last accessed on 9 Nov 2020]

[31] Richardson B,Lichliter W.The effect of multidisciplinary teams for rectal cancer on delivery of care and patient outcome: has the use of multidisciplinary teams for rectal cancer affected the utilization of available resources, proportion of patients meeting the standard of care, and does this translate into changes in patient outcome?.Am J Surg2016;211:46-52

[32] Karagkounis G,Lavery IC.Multidisciplinary conference and clinical management of rectal cancer..J Am Coll Surg2018;226:874-80