Robotic or laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer - which is the best answer? a comprehensive review of non-oncological outcomes and learning curve

Abstract

Much effort has been spent evaluating the difference between robotic and laparoscopic surgery platforms for rectal cancer. There is a plethora of literature comparing outcomes for intraoperative events, postoperative complications, long term outcomes, cost, and learning curve. The data are conclusive regarding the higher cost of robotic surgery compared to laparoscopic surgery. This article is a comprehensive review of the available literature regarding intraoperative and postoperative outcomes. For practically all parameters evaluated, there are no significant differences between the two platforms. The ultimate decision on whether to perform robotic vs. laparoscopic surgery should be based on surgeon preference and familiarity with equipment, as well as local resources.

Keywords

Rectal cancer / rectal carcinoma / robotic / robotics / laparoscopy / total mesorectal excision

References

[1] Jacobs M,Goldstein HS.Minimally invasive colon resection (laparoscopic colectomy)..Surg Laparosc Endosc1991;1:144-50

[2] Guller U,Hervey S,Pietrobon R.Laparoscopic vs open colectomy: outcomes comparison based on large nationwide databases..Arch Surg2003;138:1179-86

[3] Masoomi H,Nguyen B,Stamos MJ.Outcomes of laparoscopic versus open colectomy in elective surgery for diverticulitis..World J Surg2011;35:2143-8

[4] Klaristenfeld DD,Li BH,Abbas MA.Significant reduction in the incidence of small bowel obstruction and ventral hernia after laparoscopic compared to open segmental colorectal resection..Langenbeck’s Arch Surg2015;400:505-12

[5] Wexner SD.Laparoscopic bowel resection: advantages and limitations..Ann Med1992;24:105-10

[6] Weber PA,Wasielewski A,Delaney CP.Telerobotic-assisted laparoscopic right and sigmoid colectomies for benign disease..Dis Colon Rectum2002;45:1689-94

[7] Al-Mazrou AM,Kiran RP.Propensity score-matched analysis of clinical and financial outcomes after robotic and laparoscopic colorectal resection..J Gastrointest Surg2018;22:1043-51

[8] Vasudevan V,Wallace H.Clinical outcomes and cost-benefit analysis comparing laparoscopic and robotic colorectal surgeries..Surg Endosc2016;30:5490-3

[9] Sawada H,Hattori M,Shimomura M.Initial experiences of robotic versus conventional laparoscopic surgery for colorectal cancer, focusing on short-term outcomes: a matched case-control study..World J Surg Oncol2015;13:1-6 PMCID:PMC4363064

[10] Akmal Y,Baek JH,Pigazzi A.Oncological outcomes of laparoscopic colon resection for cancer after implementation of a full-time preceptorship..Surg Endosc2011;25:2967-71

[11] Feinberg AE,Bashir S,Quereshy FA.Comparison of robotic and laparoscopic colorectal resections with respect to 30-day perioperative morbidity..Can J Surg2016;59:262-7 PMCID:PMC4961489

[12] Tam MS,Mullard AJ,Franz MG.A population-based study comparing laparoscopic and robotic outcomes in colorectal surgery..Surg Endosc2016;30:455-63

[13] Liao G,Lin S,Yuan Y.Robotic-assisted versus laparoscopic colorectal surgery: A meta-analysis of four randomized controlled trials..World J Surg Oncol2014;12:1-11 PMCID:PMC4002581

[14] Cheng H,Soleas IM,Cameron CG.Prolonged operative duration increases risk of surgical site infections: a systematic review..Surg Infect (Larchmt)2017;18:722-35 PMCID:PMC5685201

[15] Harnsberger CR,Alavi K.Postoperative ileus..Clin Colon Rectal Surg2019;32:166-70 PMCID:PMC6494613

[16] Harrison OJ,White P,Carlisle ER.Operative time and outcome of enhanced recovery after surgery after laparoscopic colorectal surgery..J Soc Laparoendosc Surg2014;18:265-72 PMCID:PMC4035638

[17] Dehal A,Park H,Yuhan R.Robotic colorectal surgery: our initial experience..Am Surg2016;82:907-10

[18] Shin JY.Comparison of short-term surgical outcomes between a robotic colectomy and a laparoscopic colectomy during early experience..J Korean Soc Coloproctol2012;28:19-26 PMCID:PMC3296937

[19] Nolan HR,Honaker MD.Operative time and length of stay is similar between robotic assisted and laparoscopic colon and rectal resections..J Robot Surg2018;12:659-64

[20] Lorenzon L,Balducci G,Salvi PF.Laparoscopic versus robotic-assisted colectomy and rectal resection: a systematic review and meta-analysis..Int J Colorectal Dis2016;31:161-73

[21] Alharthi S,Arishi A,Chulkov M.Robotic versus laparoscopic sigmoid colectomy: analysis of healthcare cost and utilization project database..Am Surg2020;86:256-60

[22] Silva-Velazco J,Stocchi L,Gorgun E.Considering value in rectal cancer surgery: an analysis of costs and outcomes based on the open, laparoscopic, and robotic approach for proctectomy..Ann Surg2017;265:960-8

[23] Roh HF,Kim JM.Robot-assisted laparoscopic surgery versus conventional laparoscopic surgery in randomized controlled trials: a systematic review and meta-analysis..PLoS One2018;13:e0191628 PMCID:PMC5779699

[24] Ramji KM,Josse JM,O’Brien C.Comparison of clinical and economic outcomes between robotic, laparoscopic, and open rectal cancer surgery: early experience at a tertiary care center..Surg Endosc2016;30:1337-43

[25] Kelley SR,Larson DW.Short-term outcomes with robotic right colectomy..Am Surg2018;84:1768-73

[26] Tolstrup R,Lundbech L,Iversen LH.Perioperative pain after robot-assisted versus laparoscopic rectal resection..Int J Colorectal Dis2018;33:285-9

[27] Trastulli S,Cirocchi R,Avenia N.Robotic resection compared with laparoscopic rectal resection for cancer: systematic review and meta-analysis of short-term outcome..Colorectal Dis2012;14:e134-56

[28] Chang YS,Chang DW.A meta-analysis of robotic versus laparoscopic colectomy..J Surg Res2015;195:465-74

[29] Jayne D,Marshall H,Corrigan N.Effect of robotic-assisted vs conventional laparoscopic surgery on risk of conversion to open laparotomy among patients undergoing resection for rectal cancer the rolarr randomized clinical trial..JAMA - J Am Med Assoc2017;318:1569-80 PMCID:PMC5818805

[30] Ye SP,Liu DN,Jiang QG.Robotic- vs laparoscopic-assisted proctectomy for locally advanced rectal cancer based on propensity score matching: Short-term outcomes at a colorectal center in China..World J Gastrointest Oncol2020;12:424-34 PMCID:PMC7191331

[31] Schootman M,Loux T,Eberth JM.Differences in effectiveness and use of robotic surgery in patients undergoing minimally invasive colectomy..J Gastrointest Surg2017;21:1296-303 PMCID:PMC5576564

[32] Park JS,Lim KH,Jun SH.Robotic-assisted versus laparoscopic surgery for low rectal cancer: Case-matched analysis of short-term outcomes..Ann Surg Oncol2010;17:3195-202

[33] Hopkins MB,Bethurum AJ,Muldoon RL.Comparing pathologic outcomes for robotic versus laparoscopic surgery in rectal cancer resection: a propensity adjusted analysis of 7616 patients..Surg Endosc2020;34:2613-22

[34] Kim HJ,Park JS,Yang CS.The impact of robotic surgery on quality of life, urinary and sexual function following total mesorectal excision for rectal cancer: a propensity score-matched analysis with laparoscopic surgery..Colorectal Dis2018;20:O103-13

[35] Panteleimonitis S,Ramachandra M,Harper M.Urogenital function in robotic vs laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery: a comparative study..Int J Colorectal Dis2017;32:241-8 PMCID:PMC5285426

[36] Park SY,Park JS,Ryuk JP.Urinary and erectile function in men after total mesorectal excision by laparoscopic or robot-assisted methods for the treatment of rectal cancer: a case-matched comparison..World J Surg2014;38:1834-42

[37] Tang X,Wu X,Wang D.Robotic versus laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer in male urogenital function preservation, a meta-analysis..World J Surg Oncol2018;16:196 PMCID:PMC6169007

[38] Luca F,Ghezzi TL,Cenciarelli S.Impact of robotic surgery on sexual and urinary functions after fully robotic nerve-sparing total mesorectal excision for rectal cancer..Ann Surg2013;257:672-8

[39] Barrie J,Wright J,Collinson FJ.Attaining surgical competency and its implications in surgical clinical trial design: a systematic review of the learning curve in laparoscopic and robot-assisted laparoscopic colorectal cancer surgery..Ann Surg Oncol2014;21:829-40

[40] Lee JM,Han YD,Hur H.Can better surgical outcomes be obtained in the learning process of robotic rectal cancer surgery? A propensity score-matched comparison between learning phases..Surg Endosc2020;

[41] Park EJ,Cho MS,Min BS.Is the learning curve of robotic low anterior resection shorter than laparoscopic low anterior resection for rectal cancer?: a comparative analysis of clinicopathologic outcomes between robotic and laparoscopic surgeries..Med (United States)2014;93:1-11 PMCID:PMC4616378

[42] De’Angelis N,Azoulay D.Robotic versus laparoscopic right colectomy for colon cancer: analysis of the initial simultaneous learning curve of a surgical fellow..J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech2016;26:882-92

[43] Kim IK,Park YA,Sohn SK.Is prior laparoscopy experience required for adaptation to robotic rectal surgery?: Feasibility of one-step transition from open to robotic surgery..Int J Colorectal Dis2014;29:693-9

[44] Catanzarite T,Whitcomb EL.Ergonomics in surgery: a review..Female Pelvic Med Reconstr Surg2018;24:1-12

[45] Zárate Rodriguez JG,Ohu I,Ray S.Ergonomic analysis of laparoscopic and robotic surgical task performance at various experience levels..Surg Endosc2019;33:1938-43

[46] Lee GI,Green I,Marohn MR.Surgeons’ physical discomfort and symptoms during robotic surgery: a comprehensive ergonomic survey study..Surg Endosc2017;31:1697-706