Robotic versus open and video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery approaches for lobectomy

Abstract

More and more data are available on the benefits of minimally invasive thoracic surgery compared to open thoracic surgery in the curative treatment of early-stage non-small cell lung cancer. However, results are conflicting, especially when video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) is compared to robotic-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (RATS) for lobectomy. Our goal is to report the main results of recent systematic reviews and meta-analyses comparing RATS, VATS, and open surgery for lobectomy. Using PubMed database, we selected systematic reviews and meta-analyses, which compared the short-term outcomes of patients treated by RATS, VATS, or open surgery for lobectomy. In all but one of the systematic reviews, robotic lobectomy allowed similar short-term outcomes as VATS lobectomy and better short-term outcomes than open surgery. One meta-analysis by O’Sullivan et al. found that robotic lobectomy was associated with fewer adverse events (P < 0.00001) and lower 30-day mortality (P = 0.001), compared to VATS lobectomy. Robotic lobectomy could be a valid alternative to VATS and open lobectomy. Short-term outcomes do not appear to be different between VATS and RATS cohorts, except in one recent meta-analysis, which reported the superiority of RATS compared to VATS. Without cost analysis and randomized controlled trials with long-term outcomes, no strong conclusions can be drawn.

Keywords

Minimally invasive surgery / robotic surgery / robotic-assisted thoracoscopic surgery / video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery / lobectomy / lung cancer / short-term outcomes / review

References

[1] Donington J,Mazzone P,Schuchert M.American college of chest physicians and society of thoracic surgeons consensus statement for evaluation and management for high-risk patients with stage I non-small cell lung cancer..Chest2012;142:1620-35

[2] Postmus PE,Oudkerk M,Waller DA.Early and locally advanced non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC): ESMO Clinical Practice Guidelines for diagnosis, treatment and follow-up..Ann Oncol2017;28:iv1-21

[3] Melfi FMA,Mariani AM.Early experience with robotic technology for thoracoscopic surgery..Eur J Cardiothorac Surg2002;21:864-8

[4] Rami-Porta R,Goldstraw P.Complete resection in lung cancer surgery: proposed definition..Lung Cancer2005;49:25-33

[5] Thomas P,Riquet M,Falcoz PE.Pratiques chirurgicales dans le traitement du cancer primitif non à petites cellulesdu poumon..Rev Mal Respir2008;25:1031-6

[6] Thomas PA.Lymph node dissection during sublobar resection: why, when and how?.J Thorac Dis2018;10:S1145-50 PMCID:PMC5949390

[7] Dahan M,Riquet M.Cancer primitif non à petites cellules du poumon: pratiques chirurgicales..Société française de chirurgie thoracique et cardiovasculaire.2008;1-96

[8] Lardinois D,Van Schil P,Waller D.ESTS guidelines for intraoperative lymph node staging in non-small cell lung cancer..Eur J Cardiothorac Surg2006;30:787-92

[9] Darling GE,Decker PA,Malthaner RA.Number of lymph nodes harvested from a mediastinal lymphadenectomy..Chest2011;139:1124-9 PMCID:PMC3087457

[10] Ramnath N,Harris LJ,Michaud GC.Treatment of Stage III non-small cell lung cancer: diagnosis and management of lung cancer, 3rd ed: American College of Chest Physicians Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guidelines..Chest2013;143:e314S-e40S

[11] Detterbeck FC,Diekemper R,Alberts WM.Executive summary: diagnosis and management of lung cancer, 3rd ed: American College of Chest Physicians Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guidelines..Chest2013;143:7S-37S

[12] McDonald F,Hendriks LEL,Dingemans A-MC.Management of stage I and II nonsmall cell lung cancer..Eur Respir J2017;49:

[13] Ng CSH,Gilbert S,Kim YT.Optimal approach to lobectomy for non-small cell lung cancer: systemic review and meta-analysis..Innovations2019;14:90-116

[14] O’Sullivan KE,Hebert AE,Redmond KC.A systematic review and meta-analysis of robotic versus open and video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery approaches for lobectomy..Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg2018;28:526-34

[15] Kent M,Whyte R,Flores R.Open, video-assisted thoracic surgery, and robotic lobectomy: review of a national database..Ann Thorac Surg2014;97:236-4

[16] Yang CFJ,Speicher PJ,Gulack BC.Use and outcomes of minimally invasive lobectomy for Stage I non-small cell lung cancer in the national cancer data base..Ann Thorac Surg2016;101:1037-42 PMCID:PMC4763985

[17] Wang Z,Tang J,Chen N.Video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery versus muscle-sparing thoracotomy for non-small cell lung cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis..BMC Surg2019;19:144 PMCID:PMC6794906

[18] Bendixen M,Kronborg C,Licht PB.Postoperative pain and quality of life after lobectomy via video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery or anterolateral thoracotomy for early stage lung cancer: a randomised controlled trial..Lancet Oncol2016;17:836-44

[19] Boffa DJ,Paul S,Onaitis M.Lymph node evaluation by open or video- assisted approaches in 11,500 anatomic lung cancer resections..Ann Thorac Surg2012;94:347-53

[20] Wilson JL,Cerfolio RJ,Vallières E.The prevalence of nodal upstaging during robotic lung resection in early stage non-small cell lung cancer..Ann Thorac Surg2014;97:1901-7

[21] Zirafa C,Ricciardi S,Davini F.Nodal upstaging evaluation in NSCLC patients treated by robotic lobectomy..Surg Endosc2019;33:153-8

[22] Park BJ.Cost concerns for robotic thoracic surgery..Ann Cardiothorac Surg2012;1:56-8 PMCID:PMC3741707

[23] Cerfolio RJ,Dylewski M,Spaggiari L.The long term survival of robotic lobectomy for non-small cell lung cancer: a multi-institutional study..J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2018;155:778-86 PMCID:PMC5896345

[24] Kneuertz PJ,D’Souza DM,Abdel-Rasoul M.Propensity-score adjusted comparison of pathologic nodal upstaging by robotic, video-assisted thoracoscopic, and open lobectomy for non-small cell lung cancer..J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2019;158:1457-66.e2

[25] Yang HX,Sima CS,Adusumilli PS.Long-term survival based on the surgical approach to lobectomy for clinical Stage I nonsmall cell lung cancer: comparison of robotic, video-assisted thoracic surgery, and thoracotomy lobectomy..Ann Surg2017;265:431-7 PMCID:PMC5033685

[26] Zirafa CC,Ricciardi S,Davini F.Long-term oncologic results for robotic major lung resection in non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients..Surg Oncol2019;28:223-7

[27] Medbery RL,Liu Y,Lipscomb J.Nodal upstaging is more common with thoracotomy than with VATS during lobectomy for early-stage lung cancer: an analysis from the national cancer data base..J Thorac Oncol2016;11:222-33 PMCID:PMC4729646

[28] Yang CF,Deng J,Lui NS.A national analysis of short-term outcomes and long-term survival following thoracoscopic versus open lobectomy for clinical Stage II non-small-cell lung cancer..Ann Surg2019;

[29] Adams RD,Stephenson JE,Robbins ET.Initial multicenter community robotic lobectomy experience: comparisons to a national database..Ann Thorac Surg2014;97:1893-8

[30] Agzarian J,Shargall Y,Waddell TK.The use of robotic-assisted thoracic surgery for lung resection_ a comprehensive systematic review..Semin Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2016;28:182-92

[31] Rajaram R,Bentrem DJ,Odell DD.Nationwide assessment of robotic lobectomy for non-small cell lung cancer..Ann Thorac Surg2017;103:1092-100 PMCID:PMC6714562

[32] Cao C,Ang SC.A systematic review and meta-analysis on pulmonary resections by robotic video-assisted thoracic surgery..Ann Cardiothorac Surg2012;1:3-10 PMCID:PMC3741728

[33] Paul S,Isaacs AJ,Isom OW.Comparative effectiveness of robotic-assisted vs thoracoscopic lobectomy..Chest2015;146:1505-12

[34] Louie BE,Kim S,Park BJ.Comparison of video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery and robotic approaches for clinical Stage I and Stage II non-small cell lung cancer using the society of thoracic surgeons database..Ann Thorac Surg2016;102:917-24 PMCID:PMC5198574

[35] Emmert A,Buentzel J.Robotic versus thoracoscopic lung resection..Medicine2017;96:e7633 PMCID:PMC5585477

[36] Wei S,Chen N.Feasibility and safety of robot-assisted thoracic surgery for lung lobectomy in patients with non-small cell lung cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis..World J Surg Oncol2017;15:98 PMCID:PMC5422947

[37] Petersen RP,Toloza EM,Harpole Jr DH.Thoracoscopic lobectomy: a safe and effective strategy for patients receiving induction therapy for non-small cell lung cancer..Ann Thorac Surg2006;82:214-8

[38] Yang CFJ,Mayne NR,Toomey CB.Long-term survival following open versus thoracoscopic lobectomy after preoperative chemotherapy for non-small cell lung cancer..Eur J Cardiothorac Surg2016;49:1615-23 PMCID:PMC4867396

[39] Veronesi G,Cerfolio R,Toker A.Robotic resection of Stage III lung cancer: an international retrospective study..Eur J Cardiothorac Surg2018;54:912-9 PMCID:PMC6454562

[40] Okamura AM.Haptic feedback in robot-assisted minimally invasive surgery..Curr Opin Urol2009;19:102-7 PMCID:PMC2701448

[41] Lim E,Shackcloth M,McGonigle N.Study protocol for VIdeo assisted thoracoscopic lobectomy versus conventional Open LobEcTomy for lung cancer, a UK multicentre randomised controlled trial with an internal pilot (the VIOLET study)..BMJ Open2019;9:e029507 PMCID:PMC6797374

[42] Cao C,Melfi F,Razzak R.Outcomes of major complications after robotic anatomic pulmonary resection..J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2020;159:681-6

[43] Swanson SJ,D’Amico TA,McKenna Jr RJ.Video-assisted thoracic surgery lobectomy: report of CALGB 39802 - a prospective, multi-institution feasibility study..J Clin Oncol2007;25:4993-7

[44] Cao C,Ang SC.A meta-analysis of unmatched and matched patients comparing video-assisted thoracoscopic lobectomy and conventional open lobectomy..Ann Cardiothorac Surg2012;1:16-23 PMCID:PMC3741727

[45] Reddy RM,Oh DS,Reed MF.Robotic-assisted versus thoracoscopic lobectomy outcomes from high-volume thoracic surgeons..Ann Thorac Surg2018;106:902-8

[46] Gondé H,Gillibert A,Varin R.The affordability of minimally invasive procedures in major lung resection: a prospective study..Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg2017;25:469-75

[47] Bendixen M,Jørgensen OD,Licht PB.Cost-utility analysis of minimally invasive surgery for lung cancer: a randomized controlled trial..Eur J Cardiothorac Surg2019;56:754-61

[48] Subramanian MP,Chapman Jr WC,Yan Y.Utilization trends, outcomes, and cost in minimally invasive lobectomy..Ann Thorac Surg2019;108:1648-55 PMCID:PMC6878158

[49] Kneuertz PJ,D’Souza DM,Moffatt-Bruce SD.Hospital cost and clinical effectiveness of robotic-assisted versus video-assisted thoracoscopic and open lobectomy: a propensity score-weighted comparison..J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2019;157:2018-26.e2

[50] Hennon MW.Video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) for locally advanced lung cancer..Ann Cardiothorac Surg2012;1:37-42 PMCID:PMC3741708

[51] Hennon MW,Huang M,Nwogu C.Does thoracoscopic surgery decrease the morbidity of combined lung and chest wall resection?.Ann Cardiothorac Surg2015;99:1929-34

[52] Shao W,Wang W,Peng G.Glasses-free three-dimensional endoscopic bronchoplasty, arterioplasty, and angioplasty of the superior vena cava for the radical treatment of right middle upper lung cancer..J Thorac Dis2016;8:608-11 PMCID:PMC4805833

[53] Lyscov A,Ryabova V,Zuiev V.Double-sleeve and carinal resections using the uniportal VATS technique: a single centre experience..J Thorac Dis2016;8:S235-41 PMCID:PMC4783727

[54] Turner SR,Park BJ.Robotic assisted VATS lobectomy for loco-regionally advanced non-small cell lung cancer..Video Assist Thorac Surg2017;2: PMCID:PMC6124676

[55] Chen S,Cerfolio RJ.Techniques for lung surgery: a review of robotic lobectomy..Expert Rev Respir Med2018;12:315-22

[56] Baste JM.Locally advanced N2 non-small cell lung cancer and the robotic platform: are we asking the right question?.J Thorac Dis2019;11:S1184-5 PMCID:PMC6560548

[57] Gerull W,Awad M.Operative performance outcomes of a simulator-based robotic surgical skills curriculum..Surg Endosc2019;Epub ahead of print [PMID: 31732857 DOI: 10.1007/s00464-019-07243-6]

[58] Bric JD,Frelich MJ.Current state of virtual reality simulation in robotic surgery training: a review..Surg Endosc2016;30:2169-78

[59] Soler L,Pessaux P,Marescaux J.Real-time 3D image reconstruction guidance in liver resection surgery..Hepatobiliary Surg Nutr2014;3:73-81 PMCID:PMC3999422