Comparative performance of ordinary and recycled aggregate concrete incorporating CFA as SCM

Abstract

This study aims to explore the feasibility of using circulating fluidized bed fly ash (CFA) as a supplementary cementitious material in both ordinary concrete and recycled aggregate concrete (RAC). Various properties of both concretes, including compressive strength, drying shrinkage, carbonation resistance, surface resistivity, were evaluated. Additionally, the economic and environmental benefits were assessed. Findings indicated that increasing CFA content (mass fraction) progressively increases drying shrinkage rate and carbonation depth in both concretes. At 30% CFA, ordinary concrete showed 10.9% higher 180-day shrinkage and 4.3% greater 28-day carbonation compared to the control, while RAC exhibited 14.7% higher shrinkage and a significant 34.4% increase in carbonation compared to its control. However, at 10% CFA, both concretes showed no significant reduction in compressive strength compared to their respective controls. Up to 20% CFA, a decline of 13.1% and 9.0% was observed in the 28-day compressive strength of ordinary concrete and RAC, respectively. The results indicate that RAC demonstrates better compatibility with CFA compared to ordinary concrete. Additionally, the economic and environmental benefit analysis showed that the lowest cost (8.6 and 7.4 yuan for ordinary concrete and RAC, respectively) and carbon emission (6.2 and 6.7 kg for ordinary concrete and RAC, respectively) for both concretes (normalized per unit of strength) occurred at 10% and 20% CFA, respectively. This study investigated varying CFA dosages to balance performance trade-offs against cost and carbon emissions, establishing the feasibility of CFA utilization in both ordinary concrete and RAC.

Keywords

Recycled aggregate concrete / Compressive strength / Circulating fluidized bed fly ash / Supplementary cementitious material / Carbon emission

References

[1] Wu C, Zhan B, Hong Z, Cui S, Cui P, Kou S. Hydration behavior of circulating fluidized bed fly ash (CFBFA) as a cementitious binder. Construction and Building Materials, 2022, 314 125625

[2] Li DL. Characteristics of cement with ultrafine circulating fluidized bed fly ash, 2018China University of Mining and Technology

[3] Li D, Wang D, Ren C, Rui Y. Investigation of rheological properties of fresh cement paste containing ultrafine circulating fluidized bed fly ash. Construction and Building Materials, 2018, 188: 1007-1013

[4] Dong L, Miao G, Wen W. China’s carbon neutrality policy: Objectives, impacts and paths. East Asian Policy, 2021, 13(01): 5-18

[5] Lothenbach B, Scrivener K, Hooton RD. Supplementary cementitious materials. Cement and Concrete Research, 2011, 41(12): 1244-1256

[6] Amin M, Abdelaziz N, Agwa IS, Abu El-Hassan K. Properties and microstructure of high strength concrete incorporating different supplementary cementitious materials. Key Engineering Materials, 2022, 921: 247-257

[7] Skibsted J, Snellings R. Reactivity of supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs) in cement blends. Cement and Concrete Research, 2019, 124 105799

[8] Wu B, Ye G. Development of porosity of cement paste blended with supplementary cementitious materials after carbonation. Construction and Building Materials, 2017, 145: 52-61

[9] Ahsan MB, Hossain Z. Supplemental use of rice husk ash (RHA) as a cementitious material in concrete industry. Construction and Building Materials, 2018, 178: 1-9

[10] Nasir A, Butt F, Ahmad F. Enhanced mechanical and axial resilience of recycled plastic aggregate concrete reinforced with silica fume and fibers. Innovative Infrastructure Solutions, 2024, 10(1 4

[11] Ahmad F, Rawat S, Yang R, Zhang L, Fanna DJ, Soe K, Zhang YX. Effect of Metakaolin and Ground Granulated Blast Furnace Slag on the Performance of Hybrid Fibre-Reinforced Magnesium Oxychloride Cement-Based Composites. International Journal of Civil Engineering, 2025, 23(5): 853-868

[12] Khan SA, Amjad H, Ahmad F, Khan HA. A scientometric review summarizing the impact of nanomaterials on the fresh, hardened, and durability properties of cement-based materials. Advances in Civil Engineering, 2024, 2024(1): 8639483

[13] Amin M, Zeyad AM, Agwa IS, Heniegal AM. Effect of peanut and sunflower shell ash on properties of sustainable high-strength concrete. Journal Of Building Engineering, 2024, 89 109208

[14] Zeyad AM, Agwa IS, Abd-Elrahman MH, Mostafa SA. Engineering characteristics of ultra-high performance concrete containing basil plant ash. Case Studies in Construction Materials, 2024, 21 e03422

[15] Hakeem IY, Amin M, Agwa IS, Rizk MS, Abdelmagied MF. RETRACTED: Effect of using sugarcane leaf ash and granite dust as partial replacements for cement on characteristics of ultra-high performance concrete. Case Studies in Construction Materials, 2023, 19 e02266

[16] Hakeem IY, Amin M, Zeyad AM, Tayeh BA, Agwa IS, el-hassan KA. Properties and durability of self-compacting concrete incorporated with nanosilica, fly ash, and limestone powder. Structural Concrete, 2023, 24(56738-6760

[17] Hakeem IY, Amin M, Agwa IS, Abd-Elrahman MH, Ibrahim OMO, Samy M. Ultra-high-performance concrete properties containing rice straw ash and nano eggshell powder. Case Studies in Construction Materials, 2023, 19 e02291

[18] Targan Ş, Olgun A, Erdogan Y, Sevinc V. Influence of natural pozzolan, colemanite ore waste, bottom ash, and fly ash on the properties of Portland cement. Cement and Concrete Research, 2003, 33(8): 1175-1182

[19] Elahi A, Basheer PAM, Nanukuttan SV, Khan QUZ. Mechanical and durability properties of high performance concretes containing supplementary cementitious materials. Construction and Building Materials, 2010, 24(3): 292-299

[20] Guo Y, Luo L, Liu T, Hao L, Li Y, Liu P, Zhu T. A review of low-carbon technologies and projects for the global cement industry. Journal of Environmental Sciences, 2024, 136: 682-697

[21] Benhelal E, Shamsaei E, Rashid MI. Challenges against CO2 abatement strategies in cement industry: A review. Journal of Environmental Sciences, 2021, 104: 84-101

[22] Monteiro PJM, Miller SA, Horvath A. Towards sustainable concrete. Nature Materials, 2017, 16(7): 698-699

[23] Chen X, Gao J, Yan Y, Liu Y. Investigation of expansion properties of cement paste with circulating fluidized bed fly ash. Construction and Building Materials, 2017, 157: 1154-1162

[24] Zheng D, Wang D, Cui H, Chen X. Hydration characteristics of cement with high volume circulating fluidized bed fly ash. Construction and Building Materials, 2023, 380 131310

[25] Wu C, Tang W, Huo Y, Zhan B, Kou S. Investigation of fresh properties of self-leveling cement-based pastes with CFB fly ash as an SCM. Buildings, 2025, 15(6): 966

[26] Biava G, Maciej Z, Antonic P, Laura D, Mohsen H, Elza B. Evaluation of steel slags in CO₂ sequestration and as supplementary cementitious material. Construction and Building Materials, 2025, 489 142271

[27] Ahmad F., Muhammad I. Q., Rawat S., Mohammed K. A., & Mansour A. (2025). E-waste in concrete construction: recycling, applications, and impact on mechanical, durability, and thermal properties—a review, Innovative Infrastructure Solutions, 10, Article 246. https://link.springer.com/article/, https://doi.org/10.1007/s41062-025-02038-2

[28] Shi C, Li Y, Zhang J, Li W, Chong L, Xie Z. Performance enhancement of recycled concrete aggregate – A review. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2016, 112: 466-472

[29] Ahmad F, Jamal A, Mazher KM, Umer W, Iqbal M. Performance Evaluation of Plastic Concrete Modified with E-Waste Plastic as a Partial Replacement of Coarse Aggregate. Materials, 2022, 15(1175

[30] Amjad H, Ahmad F, Qureshi MI. Enhanced mechanical and durability resilience of plastic aggregate concrete modified with nano-iron oxide and sisal fiber reinforcement. Construction and Building Materials, 2023, 401 132911

[31] Ahmad F, Qureshi MI, Ahmad Z. Influence of nano graphite platelets on the behavior of concrete with E-waste plastic coarse aggregates. Construction and Building Materials, 2022, 316 125980

[32] Limbachiya MC, Leelawat T, Dhir RK. Use of recycled concrete aggregate in high-strength concrete. Materials and Structures, 2000, 33(9574-580

[33] Wu C, Zhu Y, Zhang X, Kou S. Improving the properties of recycled concrete aggregate with bio-deposition approach. Cement and Concrete Composites, 2018, 94: 248-254

[34] Wu C, Hong Z, Zhang J, Kou S. Pore size distribution and ITZ performance of mortars prepared with different bio-deposition approaches for the treatment of recycled concrete aggregate. Cement and Concrete Composites, 2020, 111 103631

[35] Kou S, Poon C, Agrela F. Comparisons of natural and recycled aggregate concretes prepared with the addition of different mineral admixtures. Cement and Concrete Composites, 2011, 33(8): 788-795

[36] Wang J, Che Z, Zhang K, Fan Y, Niu D, Guan X. Performance of recycled aggregate concrete with supplementary cementitious materials (fly ash, GBFS, silica fume, and metakaolin): Mechanical properties, pore structure, and water absorption. Construction and Building Materials, 2023, 368 130455

[37] Sunayana S, Barai SV. Partially fly ash incorporated recycled coarse aggregate based concrete: Microstructure perspectives and critical analysis. Construction and Building Materials, 2021, 278 122322

[38] Sahraei Moghadam A, Omidinasab F, Moazami Goodarzi S. Characterization of concrete containing RCA and GGBFS: Mechanical, microstructural and environmental properties. Construction and Building Materials, 2021, 289 123134

[39] Farshad R., Mona Z., & Gopakumar K. (2020). Evaluating the Performance and Feasibility of Using Recovered Fly Ash and Fluidized Bed Combustion (FBC) Fly Ash as Concrete Pozzolan, CRC.

[40] Mona Z., & Farshad R. (2019). Fluidized Bed Combustion (FBC) Fly Ash and Its Performance in Concrete, ACI Materials Journal, 116(4), 163–172. https://doi.org/10.14359/51716720

[41] Zahedi M, Jafari K, Rajabipour F. Properties and durability of concrete containing fluidized bed combustion (FBC) fly ash. Construction and Building Materials, 2020, 258 119663

[42] Li J, Chen Z, Li L, Qiao Y, Yuan Z, Zeng L, Li Z. Study on pore and chemical structure characteristics of atmospheric circulating fluidized bed coal gasification fly ash. Journal Of Cleaner Production, 2021, 308 127395

[43] García-Segura T, Yepes V, Alcalá J. Life cycle greenhouse gas emissions of blended cement concrete including carbonation and durability. The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 2014, 19(1): 3-12

[44] Xia Y, Liu M, Zhao Y, Chi X, Lu Z, Tang K, Guo J. Utilization of sewage sludge ash in ultra-high performance concrete (UHPC): Microstructure and life-cycle assessment. Journal Of Environmental Management, 2023, 326 116690

[45] Dinakar P., Kartik Reddy M., & Sharma M. (2013). Behaviour of self compacting concrete using Portland pozzolana cement with different levels of fly ash, Materials & Design (1980–2015), 46, 609–616. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2012.11.015

[46] Ahmad F, Jamal A, Iqbal M, Alqurashi M, Almoshaogeh M, Al-Ahmadi HM, Hussein EE. Performance Evaluation of Cementitious Composites Incorporating Nano Graphite Platelets as Additive Carbon Material. Materials, 2022, 15(1): 290

[47] Xuan D, Zhan B, Poon CS. Durability of recycled aggregate concrete prepared with carbonated recycled concrete aggregates. Cement and Concrete Composites, 2017, 84: 214-221

[48] Behera M, Bhattacharyya SK, Minocha AK, Deoliya R, Maiti S. Recycled aggregate from C&D waste & its use in concrete – A breakthrough towards sustainability in construction sector: A review. Construction and Building Materials, 2014, 68: 501-516

[49] Yang K., Chung H., & Ashour A. (2008). Influence of Type and Replacement Level of Recycled Aggregates on Concrete Properties, Aci Materials Journal,105, 289–296. https://doi.org/10.14359/19826

[50] Amjad H, Khushnood RA, Ahmad F. Enhanced fracture and durability resilience using bio-intriggered sisal fibers in concrete. Journal of Building Engineering, 2023, 76 107008

[51] Rao GA. Long-term drying shrinkage of mortar — Influence of silica fume and size of fine aggregate. Cement and Concrete Research, 2001, 31(2171-175

[52] Mehta P. K., Monteiro P. J. M. (1993). Concrete: structure, properties, and materials. 2nd ed. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs.

[53] Wongkeo W., Thongsanitgarn P., & Chaipanich A. (2012). Compressive strength and drying shrinkage of fly ash-bottom ash-silica fume multi-blended cement mortars, Materials & Design (1980–2015),36, 655–662. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2011.11.043

[54] Kou S, Poon C. Long-term mechanical and durability properties of recycled aggregate concrete prepared with the incorporation of fly ash. Cement and Concrete Composites, 2013, 37: 12-19

[55] Kurda R, de Brito J, Silvestre JD. Combined influence of recycled concrete aggregates and high contents of fly ash on concrete properties. Construction and Building Materials, 2017, 157: 554-572

[56] Chidiac SE, Shafikhani M. Electrical resistivity model for quantifying concrete chloride diffusion coefficient. Cement and Concrete Composites, 2020, 113 103707

[57] Andrade C, Alonso C. Test methods for on-site corrosion rate measurement of steel reinforcement in concrete by means of the polarization resistance method. Materials and Structures, 2004, 37(9): 623-643

[58] Cunha Araújo E., Macioski G., Henrique Farias de Medeiros M. (2022). Concrete surface electrical resistivity: Effects of sample size, geometry, probe spacing and SCMs, Construction and Building Materials,324, 126659. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2022.126659

[59] Chopperla KST, Ideker JH. Using electrical resistivity to determine the efficiency of supplementary cementitious materials to prevent alkali-silica reaction in concrete. Cement and Concrete Composites, 2022, 125 104282

[60] Lin R, Oh S, Du W, Wang X. Strengthening the performance of limestone-calcined clay cement (LC3) using nano silica. Construction and Building Materials, 2022, 340 127723

[61] Dhandapani Y, Santhanam M. Assessment of pore structure evolution in the limestone calcined clay cementitious system and its implications for performance. Cement and Concrete Composites, 2017, 84: 36-47

[62] Hong S, Glasser FP. Alkali binding in cement pastes: Part I. The C-S-H phase, Cement and Concrete Research, 1999, 29(12): 1893-1903

[63] Singh N, Singh SP. Carbonation and electrical resistance of self compacting concrete made with recycled concrete aggregates and metakaolin. Construction and Building Materials, 2016, 121: 400-409

[64] Dodds W, Goodier C, Christodoulou C, Austin S, Dunne D. Durability performance of sustainable structural concrete: Effect of coarse crushed concrete aggregate on microstructure and water ingress. Construction and Building Materials, 2017, 145: 183-195

[65] Flower D. J. M., Sanjayan J. G. (2017). Chapter 1 - Greenhouse Gas Emissions Due to Concrete Manufacture, Handbook of Low Carbon Concrete, Butterworth-Heinemann, 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-804524-4.00001-4

Funding

National Key Research and Development Program of China(2023YFC3807304)

National Natural Science Foundation Project(52341801)

China Postdoctoral Science Foundation(GZC20230594)

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)