Properties of Steel Slag and Stainless Steel Slag as Cement Replacement Materials: A Comparative Study

Abstract

To enhance the understanding about the utilization of steel slags as a cementitious material, we comparatively studied the chemical, mineralogical and morphological properties of two types of steel slag; basic-oxygen-furnace carbon slag (BOF C) and electric-arc-furnace stainless steel slag (EAF S). Moreover, we studied the standard consistency, setting time and the effect of the slag replacement ratios on the fluidity and compressive strength of blended cement mortar. The experimental results showed that BOF C had higher alkalinity, higher pH value and more hydraulic phases than EAF S. Both types of slag showed water reduction effect due to its high fineness. Neat BOF C paste showed flash set and acceleration in the initial setting time of blended cement especially at high slag proportions. However, EAF S prolonged the setting time of blended cement even at low slag proportions. The pH values for blended cement contained 50% BOF C or EAF S were lower than those of pure cement paste. Despite of slag type, compressive strength gradually decreased with increasing slags content. The strength of BOF C mortar was higher than that of EAF S mortar with the same replacement ratio for the same age. Slag activity index demonstrated that BOF C and EAF S conformed to the Chinese National Standard (GB/T 20491-2006) requirements for steel slag as grade one and grade two, respectively.

Keywords

steel slag / stainless steel slag / fluidity / setting time / compressive strength / activity index

References

[1] Mineral Commodity Summarizes 2015. US Department of Interior. US Geological Survey[EB/OL]. Available Online: https://doi.org/minerals.usgs.gov/minerals/pubs/mcs/2015/mcs2015.pdf

[2] World Steel Association. Crude Steel Production[EB/OL]. Available Online: https://doi.org/www.worldsteel.org/dms/internetDocumentList/statistics–archive/production–archive/steel–archive/steel–monthly/Steel–monthly–2014/document/Steel%20monthly%202014.pdf

[3] Bin Z, Zhao H W, Jianhua Y, et al. CO₂ Emission Reduction within Chinese Iron & Steel Industry[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2012, 33: 167-178.

[4] Trends in Global C₂ Emission: 2014 Report[EB/OL]. Available Online: https://doi.org/www.pbl.nl/sites/default/files/cms/publicaties/PBL_2014_Trends_in_global_CO2_emisions_2014_1490_0.pdf

[5] Cement Technology Road Map 2009. Carbon Emission Reductions up to 2050. World Business Council for Sustainable Development and International Energy Agency[EB/OL]. Available Online: https://doi.org/www.worldsteel.org/publications/position-papers/Steel-s-contribution-to-alow-carbon-future.html

[6] Qiang W, PeiYu Y, Song H. The Influence of Steel Slag on the Hydration of Cement during the Hydration Process of Complex Binder[J]. Science China Technological Sciences, 2011, 54(2): 388-394.

[7] Huang Y, Guoping X, Huigao C, et al. An Overview of Utiization of Steel Slag. The 7th International Conference on Waste Management and Technology[J]. Procedia Environmental Sciences, 2012, 16: 791-801.

[8] Zhu G, Hao Y, Xia C, et al. Study on Cementitious Properties of Steel Slag[J]. Journal of Mining and Metallurgy Section B–metallurgy, 2013, 49(2): 217-224.

[9] Yeong NS, Her YW, Te HS. A Study of Engineering Properties of Cement Mortar with Stainless Steel Oxidizing Slag and Reducing Slag Resource Materials[J]. Construction and Building Materials, 2013, 40: 239-245.

[10] Mason B. The Constitution of Some Open Heart Slag[J]. Journal of Iron and Steel Institute, 1994, 11(1): 69-80.

[11] Tossavainen M, Engstrom F, Yang Q, et al. Characteristics of Steel Slag under Different Cooling Conditions[J]. Waste Management, 2007, 27: 1 335-1 344.

[12] Muhammad S, Özlem C, Yiannis P, et al. Effect of Curing Temperatures on the Alkali Activation of Crystalline Continuous Casting Stainless Steel Slag[J]. Construction and Building Materials, 2014, 71: 308-316.

[13] Tang M. An Investigation on Mineral Composition of Steel Slag for Cement Production[R]. 1973 Nanjing, china: Nanjing institute of chemical technology.

[14] Hasan A, Mustafa C, Muharrem Y, et al. Concrete Produced by Steel–making Slag (Basic oxygen furnace) Addition in Portland Cement [J]. International Journal of Applied Ceramic Technology, 2009, 6(6): 736-748.

[15] Taylor H. Cement Chemistry[M]. 2st ed, 1997 London: Thomas Telford Publishing; Hand book.

[16] Currell BR, et al. The Acceleration and Retardation of Set High Alumina Cement by Additives[J]. Cement and Concrete Research, 1987, 17(3): 420-432.

[17] Mark W, Maciej Z, Mohsen BH, et al. The Role of the Alumina Content of Slag, Plus the Presence of Additional Sulfate on the Hydration and Microstructure of Portland Cement–slag Blends Original[J]. Cement and Concrete Research, 2014, 66: 91-101.

[18] Alexandra Q, Karen LS. Hydration of C3A–gypsum Systems[J]. Cement and Concrete Research, 2012, 42(7): 1 032-1 041.

[19] Craig WH, Ana PK, Paulo JM, et al. Early Age Hydration of Calcium Sulfoaluminate in the Presence of Gypsum and Varying Amounts of Calcium Hydroxide[J]. Cement and Concrete Research, 2013, 48: 105-115.

[20] Kourounis S, Tsivilis S, Tsakiridis PE, et al. Propertiesand Hydration of Blended Cements with Steelmaking Slag[J]. Cement and Concrete Research, 2007, 37(6): 815-22.

[21] Qiang W, Bo Z, PeiYu Y. The Influence of Steel Slag with High Al₂O₃ Content on the Initial Hydration of Cement[J]. Science China Technological Science, 2013, 56(12): 3 123-3 128.

[22] Wei S, Yunsheng Z, Sifeng L, et al. The Influence of Mineral Admixture on Resistance to Corrosion of Steel Bars of Green High–performance Concrete[J]. Cement and Concrete Research, 2004, 34(10): 1 781-1 785.

[23] GB/T 20491–2006. Chinese National Standard Test Method of Steel Slag Used for Cement and Concrete[S].

[24] ASTM C187–11e. Standard test Method for Amount of Water Required for Normal Consistency of Hydraulic Cement Paste[S].

[25] GB175–2007. Chinese National Standard Test Method for Common Portland Cement[S].

[26] ASTM C191–08. Standard Test Methods for Time of Setting of Hydraulic Cement by Vicat Needle[S].

[27] ASTM C1437–15. Standard Test Method for Flow Table of Hydraulic Cement Mortar[S].

[28] GB/T 17671–1999. Chinese National Standard Test Method of Testing Cements–determination of Strength[S].