Managing Discretionary Services: A Review and Research Opportunities

Abstract

Discretionary services typically refer to professional work and complex service work by physicians, software developers, web designers, lawyers, or financial analysts, where there are no standard working processes and customer perceived quality of service increases with the time spent on it. Recently, research on these services, especially the corresponding speed-quality tradeoff problem, has gained more and more attention. This paper reviews both the analytical models and the empirical studies in this area, highlighting their contributions and pointing out potential directions for future research.

Keywords

Discretionary service / speed-quality tradeoff / queueing

References

[1] Alizamir S, de Vericourt F, Sun P. Diagnostic accuracy under congestion. Management Science, 2013, 59(1): 157-171.

[2] Anand KS, Paç MF, Veeraraghavan S. Quality-speed conundrum: Trade-offs in customer-intensive services. Management Science, 2011, 57(1): 40-56.

[3] Apte UM, Mason RO. Global disaggregation of information-intensive services. Management Science, 1995, 41(7): 1250-1262.

[4] Apte UM, Cavaliere RA, Kulkarni SS. Analysis and improvement of information-intensive services: Evidence from insurance claims handling operations. Production and Operations Management, 2010, 19(6): 665-678.

[5] Berry Jaeker JA, Tucker AL. The value of process friction: The role of justification in reducing medical costs. Journal of Operations Management, 2020, 66(1–2): 12-34.

[6] Buell RW, Norton MI. The labor illusion: How operational transparency increases perceived value. Management Science, 2011, 57(9): 1564-1579.

[7] Chan CW, Yom-Tov G, Escobar G. When to use speedup: An examination of service systems with returns. Operations Research, 2014, 62(2): 462-482.

[8] Chase RB, Tansik DA. The customer contact model for organization design. Management Science, 1983, 29(9): 1037-1050.

[9] Dai T, Akan M, Tayur S. Imaging room and beyond: The underlying economics behind physicians’ test-ordering behavior in outpatient services. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 2017, 19(1): 99-113.

[10] Debo L, Li C (2020). Design and pricing of discretionary service lines. SSRN Electronic Journal, 2017.

[11] Debo L, Veeraraghavan S. Equilibrium in queues under unknown service times and service value. Operations Research, 2014, 62(1): 38-57.

[12] Guo P, Tang CS, Wang Y, Zhao M. The impact of reimbursement policy on social welfare, revisit rate, and waiting time in a public healthcare system: Feeforservice versus bundled payment. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 2019, 21(1): 154-170.

[13] Hassin R, Haviv M (2003). To Queue or Not to Queue: Equilibrium Behavior in Queueing Systems, vol 59. Springer Science & Business Media.

[14] Hopp WJ, Iravani SMR, Yuen GY. Operations systems with discretionary task completion. Management Science, 2007, 53(1): 61-77.

[15] Hu K, Allon G, Bassamboo A (2016). Understanding customers retrial in call centers: Preferences for service quality and service speed. Available at SSRN 2838998.

[16] Kc DS, Terwiesch C. Impact of workload on service time and patient safety: An econometric analysis of hospital operations. Management Science, 2009, 55(9): 1486-1498.

[17] Kostami V, Rajagopalan S. Speed-quality trade-offs in a dynamic model. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 2014, 16(1): 104-118.

[18] Laker LF, Froehle CM, Windeler JB, Lindsell CJ. Quality and efficiency of the clinical decision-making process: Information overload and emphasis framing. Production and Operations Management, 2018, 27(12): 2213-2225.

[19] Li X, Guo PF, Lian ZT. Quality-speed competition in customer-intensive services with boundedly rational customers. Production and Operations Management, 2016, 25(11): 1885-1901.

[20] Li X, Li QY, Guo PF, Lian ZT. On the uniqueness and stability of equilibrium in quality-speed competition with boundedly-rational customers: The case with general reward function and multiple servers. International Journal of Production Economics, 2017, 193: 726-736.

[21] Lovejoy WS, Sethuraman K. Congestion and complexity costs in a plant with fixed resources that strives to make schedule. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 2000, 2(3): 221-239.

[22] Lu LX, Van Mieghem JA, Savaskan RC. Incentives for quality through endogenous routing. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 2009, 11(2): 254-273.

[23] Mason RO, Apte UM. Using knowledge to transform enterprises. Transforming Enterprise: The Economic and Social Implications of Information Technology, 2005, 131: 131-154.

[24] McCausland P (2017). Public defenders nationwide say they’re overworked and underfunded. NBC News, URL: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/publicdefenders-nationwide-say-they-re-overworked-underfunded-n828111, downloaded on September 19, 2020.

[25] Mehrotra M, Natarajan KV. Value of combining patient and provider incentives in humanitarian health care service programs. Production and Operations Management, 2020, 29(3): 571-594.

[26] Ni G, Xu Y, Dong Y. Price and speed decisions in customer-intensive services with two classes of customers. European Journal of Operational Research, 2013, 228(2): 427-436.

[27] Ogden J, Bavalia K, Bull M, Frankum S, Goldie C, Gosslau M, Jones A, Kumar S, Vasant K. “I want more time with my doctor”: A quantitative study of time and the consultation. Family Practice, 2004, 21(5): 479-483.

[28] Oliva R, Sterman JD. Cutting corners and working overtime: Quality erosion in the service industry. Management Science, 2001, 47(7): 894-914.

[29] Peng T (2015). I’m a public defender. It’s impossible for me to do a good job representing my clients. The Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/our-public-defender-systemisnt-just-brokenT1∈xtendashits-unconstitutional/2015/09/03/aadf2b6c-519b-11e5-9812-92d5948a40f8_story.html, September 19, 2020.

[30] Rajan B, Tezcan T, Seidmann A (2019). Service systems with heterogeneous customers: Investigating the effect of telemedicine on chronic care. Management Science. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2017.2979.

[31] Saghafian S, Hopp WJ, Iravani SMR, Cheng Y, Diermeier D. Workload management in telemedical physician triage and other knowledge-based service systems. Management Science, 2018, 64(11): 5180-5197.

[32] Song H, Tucker AL, Murrell KL. The diseconomies of queue pooling: An empirical investigation of emergency department length of stay. Management Science, 2015, 61(12): 3032-3053.

[33] Tan TF, Netessine S. When does the devil make work? an empirical study of the impact of workload on worker productivity. Management Science, 2014, 60(6): 1574-1593.

[34] Tong CY, Rajagopalan S. Pricing and operational performance in discretionary services. Production and Operations Management, 2014, 23(4): 689-703.

[35] Tong CY, Nagarajan M, Cheng Y. Operational impact of service innovations in multi-step service systems. Production and Operations Management, 2016, 25(5): 833-848.

[36] Van Brunt A (2015). Poor people rely on public defenders who are too overworked to defend them. The Guardian, URL https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jun/17/poor-rely-publicdefenders-too-overworked#comments, downloaded on September 19, 2020.

[37] Vogel J, Stolletz R (2020). Pooling queues with strategic servers: The effects of customer ownership. Available at SSRN: https://papersssrncom/abstract=3640460.

[38] Wang XF, Debo LG, Scheller-Wolf A, Smith SF. Design and analysis of diagnostic service centers. Management Science, 2010, 56(11): 1873-1890.

[39] Wang XF, Policella N, Smith SF, Oddi A. Constraint-based methods for scheduling discretionary services. Ai Communications, 2011, 24(1): 51-73.

[40] Wang XF, Debo LG, Scheller-Wolf A, Smith SF. Service design at diagnostic service centers. Naval Research Logistics, 2012, 59(8): 613-628.

[41] Xu Y, Scheller-Wolf A, Sycara K. The benefit of introducing variability in single-server queues with application to quality-based service domains. Operations Research, 2015, 63(1): 233-246.

[42] Yeung CW, Soman D. The duration heuristic. Journal of Consumer Research, 2007, 34(3): 315-326.

[43] Zhan DY, Ward AR. Staffing, routing, and payment to trade off speed and quality in large service systems. Operations Research, 2019, 67(6): 1738-1751.

[44] Zhan DY, Ward AR. Threshold routing to trade off waiting and call resolution in call centers. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 2014, 16(2): 220-237.

[45] Zhao C, Zhang Y. Dynamic quality and pricing decisions in customer-intensive service systems with online reviews. International Journal of Production Research, 2019, 57(18): 5725-5748.