System Dynamic Modelling of Patient Flow and Transferral Problem in a Mixed Public-Private Healthcare System: A Case Study of Hong Kong SAR

Abstract

The current healthcare system in Hong Kong is experiencing pressure due to constrained resources, with dramatic increases in inpatient services queue lengths, dissatisfaction with the working environment, unacceptable workforce arrangements and high turnover rate of hospital staff. To maintain the robustness of the healthcare system and a sustainable inpatients flow, the Food and Health Bureau launched a public-private partnership programme to utilise the resources of the public and private hospitals. This research investigates the potential for extension of the programme and further enhancing the sustainability of the long-term inpatient services under a mixed public-private healthcare policy via system dynamic modelling. The findings show that an increase of human resources in public hospitals does not substantially improve inpatient flow rate performance. Further, the results from the system dynamic approach provide insights into the expansion of the service areas of the programme and suggest increasing the number of referrals to private hospitals.

Keywords

System dynamic models / scenario analysis / inpatient transferral / mixed public-private healthcare system

References

[1] Ahsan K, Rahman S. Green public procurement implementation challenges inAustralian public healthcare sector. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2017, 152: 181-197.

[2] Barlas Y. Model validation in system dynamics. Proceedings of the 1994 Iinternational System Dynamics Conference, 1994, Scotland: Sterling 1-10.

[3] Bastian N D, Munoz D V M. A mixedmethods research framework for healthcare process improvement. Journal of Pediatric Nursing, 2016, 31(1): 39-51.

[4] Brailsford S C. System dynamics: What's in it for healthcare simulation modelers. 2008 Winter Simulation Conference, 2008 1478-1483.

[5] Caterina Cavicchi, Emidia Vagnoni Does intellectual capital promote the shift of healthcare organizations towards sustainable development? Evidence from Italy. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2017, 153: 275-286.

[6] CensusStatistics Department Hong Kong population projections 2015–2064, 2015

[7] CensusStatistics Department Gross domestic product, 2016

[8] CensusStatistics Department Hong kong annual digest of statistics, 2016

[9] CensusStatistics Department. Population by age group and sex, 2016

[10] CensusStatistics Department Women and men in Hong Kong key statistics, 2016

[11] Chaerul M, Tanaka M, Shekdar A V. A system dynamics approach for hospitalwaste management. Waste Management, 2008, 28(2): 442-449.

[12] Cheng TC, Haisken-DeNew J P, Yong J. Cream skimming and hospital transfers in a mixed public-private system. Social Science & Medicine, 2015, 132: 156-164.

[13] Chiarini A, Opoku A, Emidia V. Public healthcare practices and criteria for a sustainable procurement: A comparative study between UK and Italy. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2017, 162: 391-399.

[14] Comendeiro-Maaløe M, Ridao-López M, Gorgemans S, Bernal-Delgado E. Public-private partnerships in the spanish national health system: The reversion of the Alzira model. Health Policy, 2019, 123(4): 408-411.

[15] Coyle R G (1996). System Dynamics Modelling: A practical approach, Volume 1. CRC Press.

[16] Dangerfield B C. System Dynamics Applications to European Healthcare Issues, 2016, London: Palgrave Macmillan UK

[17] Du LL, Li XZ, Zhao HJ, Ma W C, Jiang P. System dynamic modeling of urban carbon emissions based on the regional national economy and social development plan: A case study of Shanghai city. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2018, 172: 1501-1513.

[18] Faezipour M, Ferreira S. A system dynamics perspective of patient satisfaction in healthcare. Procedia Computer Science, 2013, 16: 148-156.

[19] FoodHealth Bureau Report of the steering committee on review of hospital authority, 2015

[20] FoodHealth Bureau Health expenditure, 2017

[21] Forrester JW. Industrial Dynamics, 1961, Massachusetts: MIT Press, Cambridge

[22] Forrester JW. Waiting lists in Spanish public hospitals: A system dynamics approach. Urban Dynamics, 1969, 15(3): 201-224.

[23] Guo QX, Wang E, Nie YY, Shen JY. Profit or environment? A system dynamic model analysis of waste electrical and electronic equipment management system in China. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2018, 194: 34-42.

[24] Hejazi T H, Badri H, Yang K. A reliability-based approach for performance optimization of service industries: An application to healthcare systems. European Journal of Operational Research, 2019, 273(3): 1016-1025.

[25] Hirsch G, Immediato C S. Microworlds and generic structures as resources for integrating care and improving health. System Dynamics Review, 1999, 15(3): 315-330.

[26] Homer J, Hirsch G, Minniti M, Pierson M. Models for collaboration: Howsystem dynamics helped a community organize cost-effective care for chronic illness. System Dynamics Review, 2004, 20(3): 199-222.

[27] Homer J, Jones A, Don S, Essien J, Bobby M, Dara M. The CDC's diabetes systems modeling project: Developing a newtool for chronic disease prevention and control. 22nd International Conference of the System Dynamics Society, 2004 25-29.

[28] Homer J B, Hirsch B G M B. Chronic illness in a complex health economy: The perils and promises of downstream and upstream reforms. SystemDynamics Review, 2007, 23(2-3): 313-343.

[29] Homer J B, Hirsch B G. System dynamics modeling for public health: Background and opportunities. American Journal of Public Health, 2006, 96(3): 452-458.

[30] Hong Kong Government Health facts of Hong Kong, 2017

[31] Hospital Authority Hospital authority annual report 2010–2011, 2011

[32] Hospital Authority Hospital authority statistical report 2011–2012, 2013

[33] Hospital Authority Annual plan 2018–2019, 2018

[34] Hospital Authority Waiting time for total joint replacement surgery, 2018

[35] Keung KL, Lee C, Ng KKH, Leung S S, Choy KL. An empirical study on patients' acceptance and resistance towards electronic health record sharing system: Acase study of Hong Kong. International Journal of Knowledge and Systems Science(?KSS), 2018, 9(2): 1-27.

[36] Lai H Y, Chen C H, Zheng P, Li P K. Investigating the evolving context of an unstable approach in aviation from mental model disconnects with an agent-based model. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, 2020, 193: 106-657.

[37] Lane D C, Monefeldt C, Rosenhead J V. Looking in the Wrong Place for Healthcare Improvements: A System Dynamics Study of an Accident and Emergency Department, 2016, London: Palgrave Macmillan UK.

[38] Lee C K M, Keung K L, Ng K K H, Lai D C P. Simulation-based multiple automated guided vehicles considering charging and collision-free requirements in automatic warehouse. 2018 IEEE International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management (IEEM), 2018 1376-1380.

[39] Lee C K M, Ng K K H, Chan K L, Choy W C, Tai L S C. A multi-group analysis of social media engagement and loyalty constructs between fullservice and low-cost carriers in hong kong. Journal of Air Transport Management, 2018, 73: 46-57.

[40] Lee C K M, Ng K K H. A system dynamics model for evaluating foodwaste management in Hong Kong, China. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, 2018

[41] Lee C K M, Ng K K H, Kwong C K, Tay S T. A system dynamics model for evaluating foodwaste management in Hong Kong, China. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, 2019, 21(3): 433-456.

[42] Lee C K M, Huo Y Z, Zhang S Z, Ng K K. Design of a smart manufacturing system with the application of multi-access edge computing and blockchain technology. IEEE Access, 2020

[43] Legislative Council Lcq1: Waiting time for public hospital services, 2012

[44] Legislative Council Lcq15: Nursing manpower in public hospitals, 2015

[45] Leung G M, Wong I O, Chan W S, Choi S, Lo S V. The ecology of health care in Hong Kong. Social Science & Medicine, 2005, 61(3): 577-590.

[46] Julien Mercille The public-private mix in primary care development: The case of Ireland. International Journal of Health Services, 2019, 49(3): 412-430.

[47] Ng K K H, Lee C K M, Chan F T S, Qin Y C. Robust aircraft sequencing and scheduling problem with arrival/departure delay using the min-max regret approach. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 2017, 106: 115-136.

[48] Ng KKH, Lee CKM, Felix T S C, Yaqiong L. Review on meta-heuristics approaches for airside operation research. Applied Soft Computing, 2018, 66: 104-133.

[49] Ng K K H, Lee C K M, Chan F T S, Chen C H, Qin Y C. A two-stage robust optimisation for terminal traffic flow problem. Applied Soft Computing, 2020, 89: 106048

[50] Nikolaou I, Evangelinos K, Filho W L. A system dynamic approach for exploring the effects of climate change risks on firms' economic performance. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2015, 103: 499-506.

[51] Qudrat-Ullah H, Seong B S. How to do structural validity of a system dynamics type simulation model: The case of an energy policy model. Energy Policy, 2010, 38(5): 2216-2224.

[52] Rashwan W, Abo-Hamad W, Arisha A. A system dynamics viewof the acute bed blockage problem in the Irish healthcare system. European Journal of Operational Research, 2015, 247(1): 276-293.

[53] Ritchie-Dunham J L, Galván J F M. Evaluating epidemic intervention policies with systems thinking: A case study of dengue fever in Mexico. System Dynamics Review, 1999, 15(2): 119

[54] Royston G, Dost A, Townshend J, Turner H. Using system dynamics to help develop and implement policies and programmes in health care in England. System Dynamics Review, 1999, 15(3): 293

[55] Sabounchi N S, Hovmand P S, Osgood N D, Dyck R F, Jungheim E S. A novel system dynamics model of female obesity and fertility. American Journal of Public Health, 2014, 104(7): 1240-1246.

[56] Sahin O, Siems R S, Stewart R A, Porter M G. Paradigm shift to enhanced water supply planning through augmented grids, scarcity pricing and adaptive factory water: A system dynamics approach. Environmental Modelling & Software, 2016, 75: 348-361.

[57] Amir S, Savage E. Private and public patients in public hospitals in Australia. Health Policy, 2014, 115(2): 189-195.

[58] Schaffernicht M, Groesser S N. A comprehensive method for comparing mental models of dynamic sys LEE et al.: System Dynamic Modelling of Patient Flow and Transferral Problem in a Mixed Public-Private Healthcare System 19 tems. European Journal of Operational Research, 2011, 210(1): 57-67.

[59] Senge P M, Forrester J W. Tests for building confidence in system dynamics models. System Dynamics, TIMS Studies in Management Sciences, 1980, 14: 209-228.

[60] Smits M. Impact of policy and process design on the performance of intake and treatment processes in mental health care: A system dynamics case study. Journal of the Operational Research Society, 2010, 61(10): 1437-1445.

[61] Swanson J D. Business dynamics - Systems thinking and modeling for a complex world. Journal of the Operational Research Society, 2002, 53(4): 472-473.

[62] Tsui Y M, Fong B Y F. Waiting time in public hospitals: case study of total joint replacement in HongKong. Public Administration and Policy, 2018

[63] Ackere A V, Smith P C. Towards a macro model of national health servicewaiting lists. System Dynamics Review, 1999, 15(3): 225

[64] Olmen J V, Criel B, Bhojani U, Marchal B, Van Belle S, Chenge MF, Hoerée T, Pirard M, Van Damme W, Kegels G. The health system dynamics framework: The introduction of an analytical model for health system analysis and its application to two case-studies. Health, Culture and Society, 2012, 2(1): 1-21.

[65] Wickramasinghe N, Chalasani S, Boppana R V, Madni A M. Healthcare system of systems. 2007). IEEE International Conference on System of Systems Engineering, 2007 1-6.

[66] Wolstenholme E. A patient flow perspective of UK health services: exploring the case for new “intermediate care” initiatives. System Dynamics Review, 1999, 15(3): 253

[67] Wolstenholme E, Monk D, McKelvie D, Arnold S. Coping but not coping in health and social care: Masking the reality of running organisations beyond safe design capacity. System Dynamics Review, 2007, 23(4): 371-389.

[68] Xie T, Liu WB, Anderson B D, Liu XR, Gray G C. A system dynamics approach to understanding the one health concept. PloS One, 2017, 12(9): e0184430

[69] Zebda A. Using cost-benefit analysis for evaluating decision models in operational research. Journal of American Academy of Business, 2002, 2(1): 106-114.