Information sharing and strategic signaling in supply chains

Abstract

Information sharing in procurement occurs in rich and varied industry contexts in which managerial decisions are made and organizational strategy is formulated. We explore how information sharing ought to work in procurement contexts that involve investments in inter-organizational information systems (IOS) and collaborative planning, forecasting and replenishment (CPFR) practices. How and under what circumstances does a firm that plays the role of a supply chain buyer decide to share information on key variables, such as point-of-sale consumer demand data with its supplier, up the supply chain? This is a key issue that crosses the boundary between supply chain management and information systems (IS) management. The answers that we provide are based on our use of a game-theoretic signaling model of buyer and supplier strategy in the presence of uncertainties about final consumer demand. We also explore the connection between operational costs that are associated with the firm’s information sharing and information withholding strategies. Our results provide normative guidance to supply chain buyers about how to interpret different demand uncertainty scenarios to improve their decisions and generate high value. From the IS management perspective, we show the impacts on the firm of different information sharing approaches that are made possible by present day technologies.

Keywords

Anticipated over-supply / collaborative planning / forecasting and replenishment (CPFR) / demand forecasting / economic analysis / information sharing / information systems (IS) / signaling / supply chain management

References

[1] Agrawal M., Pak M.S.. Getting smart about supply chain management. McKinsey Quarterly, 2001, 2: 22-26.

[2] Arcelus F.J., Pakkala T.P.M., Srinivasan G.. A purchasing framework for B2B pricing decisions and risk-sharing in supply chains. Decision Sciences, 2002, 334: 645-666.

[3] Aviv Y.A.. Gaining benefits from joint forecasting and replenishment processes: the case of auto-correlated demand. Manufacturing and Services Operations Management, 2001, 41: 55-74.

[4] Ball M., Ma M., Raschid L., Zhao Z.. Supply chain infrastructures: system integration and information sharing. SIGMOD Record, 2002, 311: 61-66.

[5] Barberá S., Hammond P.J., Seidl C.. Handbook of Utility Theory, 1998, New York, NY: Springer

[6] Bourland K., Powell S., Pyke D.. Exploiting timely demand information to reduce inventories. European Journal of Operations Research, 1996, 922: 239-253.

[7] Cachon G., Fisher M.. Supply chain inventory management and the value of shared information. Management Science, 2000, 468: 936-953.

[8] Cachon G., Lariviere M.. Contracting to assure supply: How to share demand forecasts in a supply chain. Management Science, 2001, 475: 629-646.

[9] Cameron T.S., James M.D.. Estimating willingness to pay from survey data: an alternative pre-test-market evaluation procedure. Journal of Marketing Research, 1987, 244: 389-395.

[10] Chen F.. Echelon reorder points, installation reorder points and the value of centralized demand information. Management Science, 1998, 4412: S221-S234.

[11] Chen F.. Decentralized supply chains subject to information delays. Management Science, 1999, 458: 1076-1090.

[12] Chen F.. Market segmentation, advanced demand information, and supply chain. Manufacturing and Service Operations Management, 2001, 31: 53-67.

[13] Chen F.. de Kok A. G., Graves S.C.. Information sharing and supply chain coordination. Supply chain Management: Design, Coordination and Operation, 2005, Amsterdam, Netherlands: Elsevier

[14] Chen F., Drezner Z., Ryan J.K., Simchi-Levi D.. Quantifying the bullwhip effect in a simple supply chain: the impact of forecasting, lead times, and information. Management Science, 2000, 463: 436-443.

[15] Chopra S., Reinhart G., Dada M.. The effects of lead time uncertainty on safety stocks. Decision Sciences, 2004, 351: 1-24.

[16] Cisco S.L., Strong K.V.. The value-added information chain. Information Management Journal, 1999, 331: 4-15.

[17] Clark T.H., Croson D.C., Schiano W.T.. A hierarchical model of supply-chain integration: Information sharing and operational interdependence in the U.S. grocery channel. Information Technology and Management, 2001, 23: 261-288.

[18] Clark T.H., Lee H.G.. Performance, interdependence, and coordination in business-to-business electronic commerce and supply chain management. Information Technology and Management, 2000, 11–2: 85-105.

[19] Clarke R.. Collusion and the incentives for information sharing. Bell Journal of Economics, 1983, 142: 383-394.

[20] Clemons E.K., Hitt L.. Poaching and the misappropriation of information: transaction risks of information exchange. Journal of Management Information Systems, 2004, 212: 87-107.

[21] Clemons E.K., Kleindorfer P.R.. An economic analysis of interorganizational information systems. Decision Support Systems, 1992, 85: 431-446.

[22] Clemons E.K., Reddi S., Row M.. The impact of information technology on the organization of economic activity: the ‘move to the middle’ hypothesis. Journal of Management Information Systems, 1993, 102: 9-36.

[23] Corbett C.J., Blackburn J.D., van Wassenhove L.N.. Partnerships to improve supply chains. Sloan Management Review, 1999, 404: 71-82.

[24] Dewan R., Jing B., Seidmann A.. Adoption of Internet-based product customization and pricing strategies. Journal of Management Information Systems, 2000, 172: 9-28.

[25] Doney P.M., Cannon J.P.. An examination of the nature of trust in buyer-seller relationships. Journal of Marketing, 1997, 612: 35-51.

[26] Fiala P.. Information sharing in supply chains. Omega, 2005, 335: 419-423.

[27] Fisher M.. What is the right supply chain for your product?. Harvard Business Review, 1997, 75(2): 105-116.

[28] Friedman, J., Hill, J., Folger, D., Cearley, D. & Gold, J. (2002). Tech update: BOMs the way for supply chain. ZDNet News. Available via DIALOG. zdnet.com/techupdate/stories/main/0,1417 9,2880279-1,00.html. Cited April 5, 2009

[29] Gal-Or E.. Information sharing in oligopoly. Econometrica, 1985, 532: 329-343.

[30] Gavirneni S., Kapuscinski R., Tayur S.. Value of information in capacitated supply chains. Management Science, 1999, 451: 16-24.

[31] Grover V., Ramanlal P.. Six myths of information and markets: IT networks, electronic commerce, and the battle for consumer surplus. MIS Quarterly, 1999, 234: 465-495.

[32] Grover V., Ramanlal P., Segars A.. Information exchange in electronic markets: implications for market structures. International Journal of Electronic Commerce, 1999, 34: 89-102.

[33] Grover V., Segars A.. Introduction to the special issue: electronic commerce and market transformation. International Journal of Electronic Commerce, 1999, 34: 3

[34] Gruen T.W., Shah R.. Determinants and outcomes of plan and objectivity and implementation in category management relationships. Journal of Retailing, 2000, 764: 483-510.

[35] Han K., Kauffman R.J., Nault B.R.. Information exploitation and interorganizational systems ownership. Journal of Management Information Systems, 2004, 212: 109-135.

[36] Han K., Kauffman R.J., Nault B.R.. Relative importance, specific investment, and ownership in interorganizational systems. Information Technology and Management, 2008, 93: 181-200.

[37] King R.P., Wolfson P.J., Seltzer J.M.. 2002 supermarket panel annual report. Working paper. Food Industry Center, 2002, St. Paul, MN: University of Minnesota

[38] Kinsey J., Ashman S.. IT in the retail food industry. Technology in Society, 2000, 22(1): 83-96.

[39] Kumar K.. Technology for supporting supply chain management. Comm. ACM, 2001, 44(6): 58-61.

[40] Laffont J., Tirole J.. A Theory of Incentives in Procurement and Regulation, 1999, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press

[41] Lee H.L., Padmanabhan P., Whang S.. Information distortion in a supply chain: the bullwhip effect. Management Science, 1997, 43(4): 546-558.

[42] Lee H.L., So K., Tang C.. The value of information sharing in a two-level supply chain. Management Science, 2000, 46(5): 626-643.

[43] Lee H.L., Whang S.. Information sharing in a supply chain. International Journal of Technology Management, 2000, 20(3–4): 373-387.

[44] Li L.. Cournot oligopoly with information sharing. Rand Journal of Economics, 1985, 16(4): 521-536.

[45] Li L.. Information sharing in a supply chain with horizontal competition. Management Science, 2002, 48(9): 1196-1212.

[46] Li L., Zhang H.. Song J.S., Yao D.. Supply chain information sharing in a competitive environment. Supply Chain Structures: Coordination, Information and Optimization, 2001, Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers, Amsterdam

[47] Lin F.R., Huang S.H., Lin S.C.. Effects of information sharing on supply chain performance in electronic commerce. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 2002, 49(3): 258-268.

[48] Mahajan J., Radas S., Vakharia A.J.. Channel strategies and stocking policies in uncapacitated and capacitated supply chains. Decision Sciences, 2002, 332: 191-222.

[49] Malueg D., Tsutsui S.. Distributional assumptions in the theory of oligopoly information exchange. International Journal of Industrial Organization, 1998, 166: 785-797.

[50] Nachtmann, H. (2004). Supply chain information sharing in a vendor-managed inventory partnership. Journal of Business Logistics. Available via DIALOG. www.allbusiness.com/management/10184 67-1.html. Cited April 5, 2009

[51] Nakayama M.. E-commerce and firm bargaining power shift in grocery market channels: a case of wholesaler’s structured document exchanges. Journal of Information Technology, 2000, 153: 195-210.

[52] Nistico S., Tosato D.. Competing Economic Theories: Essays in Memory of Giovanni Caravale, 2002, New York, NY: Routledge

[53] Perman, S. (2001). Automate or die. Business 2.0, July, 60–67

[54] Raghunathan S.. Interorganizational collaborative forecasting and replenishment systems and supply chain implications. Decision Sciences, 1999, 30(4): 1053-1071.

[55] Raghunathan S.. Information sharing in a supply chain: a note on its value when demand is nonstationary. Management Science, 2001, 47(4): 605-610.

[56] Raghunathan S.. Impact of demand correlation on the value of and incentives for information sharing in a supply chain. European Journal of Operational Research, 2003, 146(3): 634-649.

[57] Radhakrishnan S., Srindhi B.. Information sharing and information rents in a two-level supply chain. Working paper, 2008, TX: School of Management, University of Texas at Dallas

[58] Raith M.. A general model of information sharing in oligopoly. Journal of Economic Theory, 1996, 711: 260-288.

[59] Riggins F.J., Kriebel C.H., Mukhopadhyay T.. The growth of interorganizational systems in the presence of network externalities. Management Science, 1994, 408: 894-998.

[60] Riggins R., Kriebel C.H., Mukhopadhyay T.. Optimal policies for subsidizing supplier IOS adoption. Journal of Organizational Computing, 1995, 53: 195-325.

[61] Riggins F.J., Mukhopadhyay T.. Interdependent benefits from interorganizational systems: opportunities for business process re-engineering. Journal of Management Information Systems, 1994, 112: 37-58.

[62] Riggins F.R., Mukhopadhyay T.. Overcoming adoption and implementation risks of EDI. International Journal of Electronic Commerce, 1999, 34: 103-115.

[63] Robinson E.P. Jr., Sahin F., Gao L.L.. The impact of e-replenishment strategy on make-to-order supply chain performance. Decision Sciences, 2005, 361: 33-64.

[64] Sahin F., Robinson E.P. Jr.. Flow coordination and information sharing in supply chains: review, implications, and directions for future research. Decision Sciences, 2002, 334: 505-536.

[65] Schiano W.T., Clark T.H.. Hannaford Brothers: leading the grocery channel transformation, 1995, Cambridge, MA: Harvard Business School Press

[66] Schmalenesee R., Willig R.D.. Handbook of Industrial Organization, 1989, Amsterdam, Netherlands: North Holland

[67] Seidmann, A. & Sundararajan, A. (1997). Building and sustaining interorganizational information sharing relationships: the competitive impact of interfacing supply chain operations with marketing strategy. In: Degross, J., Kumar, K. (eds.), Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Information Systems, 205–222, Atlanta, GA

[68] Seidmann A., Sundararajan A.. Kemerer C.F.. Sharing logistics information across organizations: technology, competition and contracting. Information Technology and Industrial Competition: How IT Shapes Competitiveness, 1998, Boston, MA: Kluwer Academic Publications 107-136.

[69] Shapiro C.. Evaluation of cost information in oligopolies. Review of Economic Studies, 1986, 533: 433-446.

[70] Shore B., Venkatachalam A.R.. Evaluating the information sharing capabilities of supply chain partners: a fuzzy logic model. International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, 2003, 339: 804-824.

[71] Sinha T.. Cost transparency: the net’s real threat to prices and brands. Harvard Business Review, 2000, 782: 3-8.

[72] Strader T., Lin F., Shaw M.J.. The impact of information sharing on order fulfillment in divergent differentiation supply chains. Journal of Global Information Management, 1999, 71: 16-25.

[73] Spence A.. Job market signaling. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1973, 873: 355-374.

[74] Stern L., Kaufmann P.. Buzzell R.. Electronic interchange in selected consumer goods industries: an interorganizational perspective. Marketing in an Electronics Age, 1985, Cambridge, MA: Harvard Business School Press

[75] Stohr E.. Information systems for observing inventory levels. Management Science, 1979, 272: 242-259.

[76] Supply Chain Technology News. (2002). Ten best supply chains. Available via DIALOG. www.yantra.com/news/SCTN_10_best_supply_chain.pdf. Cited April 5, 2009

[77] Tsay A.. Risk sensitivity in distribution channel partnerships: Implications for manufacturer return policies. Journal of Retailing, 2002, 782: 147-160.

[78] Varian H.. Microeconomic Analysis, 1978, New York, NY: Norton

[79] Wang C.X., Benaroch M.. Supply chain coordination in buyer-centric B2B electronic markets. International Journal of Production Economics, 2004, 92: 113-124.

[80] Whang S.. Analysis of interorganizational information sharing. Journal of Organizational Computing, 1993, 3: 257-277.

[81] Wu Y.N., Cheng T.C.E.. The impact of information sharing in a multiple-echelon supply chain. International Journal of Production Economics, 2008, 1151: 1-11.

[82] Yao Y., Evers P.T., Dresner M.E.. Supply chain integration in vendor-managed inventory. Decision Support Systems, 2007, 432: 663-674.

[83] Yao Y., Dresner M.. The inventory value of information sharing, continuous replenishment and vendormanaged inventory. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 2008, 443: 361-378.

[84] Yao Y., Evers P., Dresner M.. Value of information sharing in vendor-managed inventory, 2001, Boston, MA: Proceedings of the American Conference on Information Systems

[85] Zhao X., Xie J., Wei J.C.. The impact of forecast errors on early order commitment in a supply chain. Decision Sciences, 2002, 332: 251-280.

[86] Zhu K.. Information transparency in electronic marketplaces: why data transparency may hinder the adoption of B2B exchanges. Electronic Markets, 2002, 122: 92-99.

[87] Zhu K.. Sprague R.. Economic implications of B2B electronic markets: the private and social desirability of information transparency. Proceedings of the 37th Annual Hawaii Inter- national Conference on System Sciences, 2004, Los Alamitos, CA: IEEE Computer Society Press

[88] Zhu K.. Information transparency of business-to-business electronic markets. Management Science, 2004, 505: 670-685.

[89] Zhu K.. Tomak K.. Information transparency hypothesis: economic implications of information transparency in electronic markets. Advances in the Economics of Information Systems, 2005, Hershey, PA: Idea Group Publishing 15-42.