A survey of Stackelberg differential game models in supply and marketing channels

Abstract

Stackelberg differential game models have been used to study sequential decision making in noncooperative games in diverse fields. In this paper, we survey recent applications of Stackelberg differential game models to the supply chain management and marketing channels literatures. A common feature of these applications is the specification of the game structure: a decentralized channel composed of a manufacturer and independent retailers, and a sequential decision procedure with demand and supply dynamics and coordination issues. In supply chain management, Stackelberg differential games have been used to investigate inventory issues, wholesale and retail pricing strategies, and outsourcing in dynamic environments. The underlying demand typically has growth dynamics or seasonal variation. In marketing, Stackelberg differential games have been used to model cooperative advertising programs, store brand and national brand advertising strategies, shelf space allocation, and pricing and advertising decisions. The demand dynamics are usually extensions of the classical advertising capital models or sales-advertising response models. We begin by explaining the Stackelberg differential game solution methodology and then provide a description of the models and results reported in the literature.

Keywords

Stackelberg differential games / supply chain management / marketing channels / open-loop equilibria / feedback policies / channel coordination / optimal control

References

[1] Bagchi A.. Stackelberg Differential Games in Economic Models, 1984, New York, NY: Springer-Verlag.

[2] Basar T., Olsder G.J.. Dynamic Noncooperative Game Theory, 1999, 2nd ed. Philadelphia, PA: SIAM.

[3] Bass F.M.. A new product growth for model consumer durables. Management Science, 1969, 15(5): 215-2.

[4] Bensoussan E.E., Hurst Jr., Naslund B.. Management Application of Modern Control Theory, 1974, Amsterdam: North-Holland

[5] Bergen M., John G.. Understanding cooperative advertising participation rates in conventional channels. Journal of Marketing Research, 1997, 34(3): 357-369.

[6] Berger P.D.. Vertical cooperative advertising ventures. Journal of Marketing Research, 1972, 9(3): 309-312.

[7] Breton M., Jarrar R., Zaccour G.. A note on feedback Stackelberg equilibria in a Lanchester model with empirical application. Management Science, 2006, 52(5): 804-811.

[8] Chintagunta P., Jain D.. A dynamic model of channel member strategies for marketing expenditures. Marketing Science, 1992, 11(2): 168-188.

[9] Deal K.R.. Optimizing advertising expenditures in a dynamic duopoly. Operations Research, 1979, 27(4): 682-692.

[10] Deal K.R., Sethi S.P., Thompson G.L.. Liu P.-T., Sutinen J. G.. A bilinear-quadratic differential game in advertising. Control Theory in Mathematical Economics, 1979, New York, NY: Marcel Dekker, Inc. 91-109.

[11] Derzko N.A., Sethi S.P., Thompson G.L.. Necessary and sufficient conditions for optimal control of quasilinear partial differential systems. Journal of Optimal Theory and Application, 1984, 43: 89-101.

[12] Desai V.S.. Marketing-production decisions under independent and integrated channel structure. Annals of Operations Research, 1992, 34: 275-306.

[13] Desai V.S.. Interactions between members of a marketing-production channel under seasonal demand. European Journal of Operational Research, 1996, 90: 115-141.

[14] Dockner, E., Jørgensen, S., Long, N.V. & Sorger, G. (2000). Differential Games in Economics and Management Science. Cambridge University Press

[15] Eliashberg J., Steinberg R.. Marketing-production decisions in an industrial channel of distribution. Management Science, 1987, 33(8): 981-1000.

[16] Erickson G.M.. Empirical analysis of closed-loop duopoly advertising strategies. Management Science, 1992, 38: 1732-1749.

[17] Erichson G.M.. Differential game models of advertising competition. uropean Journal of Operational Research, 1995, 83(3): 431-438.

[18] Erickson G.M.. Dynamic conjectural variations in a Lanchester oligopoly. Management Science, 1997, 43(11): 1603-1608.

[19] Feichtinger G., Hartel R.F., Sethi S.P.. Dynamic optimal control models in advertising: recent developments. Management Science, 1994, 40: 29-31.

[20] Fruchter G.E., Kalish S.. Closed-loop advertising strategies in a duopoly. Management Science, 1997, 43: 54-63.

[21] Fruchter G.E., Kalish S.. Dynamic promotional budgeting and media allocation. European Journal of Operational Research, 1998, 111: 15-27.

[22] Gutierrez, G.J. & He, X. (2007). Life-cycle channel coordination issues in launching an innovative durable product. Production and Operations Management, to appear

[23] Harris C., Vickers J.. Innovation and natural resources: a dynamic game with uncertainty. RAND Journal of Economics, 1995, 26(3): 418-430.

[24] He, X. & Sethi, S.P. (2008). Dynamic slotting and pricing decisions in a durable product supply chain. Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications, 134 (8), to appear

[25] He, X., Prasad, A. & Sethi, S.P. (2007). Cooperative advertising and pricing in a stochastic supply chain: feedback Stackelberg strategies. Working paper. The University of Texas at Dallas

[26] Huang Z., Li S.X., Mahajan V.. An analysis of manufacturer-retailer supply chain coordination in cooperative advertising. Decision Sciences, 2002, 33(3): 469-494.

[27] Isaacs R.. Differential Games, 1965, New York: Wiley.

[28] Jarrar R., Martin-Herran G., Zaccour G.. Markov perfect equilibrium advertising strategies of Lanchester duopoly model: a technical note. Management Science, 2004, 50(7): 995-1000.

[29] Jørgensen S.. A survey of some differential games in advertising. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 1982, Berlin: Springer-Verlag

[30] Jørgensen S., Sigue S.P., Zaccour G.. Dynamic cooperative advertising in a channel. Journal of Retailing, 2000, 76(1): 71-92.

[31] Jørgensen S., Sigue S.P., Zaccour G.. Stackelberg leadership in a marketing channel. International Game Theory Review, 2001, 3(1): 13-26.

[32] Jørgensen S., Taboubi S., Zaccour G.. Cooperative advertising in a marketing channel. Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications, 2001, 110(1): 145-158.

[33] Jørgensen S., Taboubi S., Zaccour G.. Retail promotions with negative brand image effects: is cooperation possible?. European Journal of Operational Research, 2003, 150: 395-405.

[34] Jørgensen S., Taboubi S., Zaccour G.. Incentives for retailer promotion in a marketing channel. Annals of the International Society of dynamic Games, 2006, 8: 365-378.

[35] Jorsengen S., Zaccour G.. Differential Games in Marketing, 2005, New York, NY: Springer

[36] Karray S., Zaccour G.. Haurie A., Zaccour G.. A differential game of advertising for national and store brands. Dynamic Games: Theory and Applicatoins, 2005, New York, NY: Springer 213-230.

[37] Kogan K., Tapiero C.S.. Supply Chain Games: Operations Management and Risk Valuation, 2007, New York, NY: Springer.

[38] Kogan K., Tapiero C.S.. Co-investment in supply chain infrastructure. Working Paper, 2007, Israel: Bar Ilan University

[39] Little J.D.C.. Aggregate advertising models: the state of the art. Operations Research, 1979, 27(4): 629-667.

[40] Martin-Herran G., Taboubi S.. Haurie A., Zaccour G.. Incentive strategies for shelf-space allocation in duopolies. Dynamic Games Theory and Applicatoins, 2005, New York, NY: Springer 231-253.

[41] Nerlove M., Arrow K.J.. Optimal advertising policy under dynamic conditions. Economica, 1962, 39: 129-142.

[42] Pekelman D.. Simultaneous price production in channels. Marketing Science, 1974, 7: 335-355.

[43] Rubio S.J.. On coincidence of feedback Nash equilibria and Stackelberg equilibria in economic applications of differential games. Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications, 2006, 128(1): 203-221.

[44] Sethi S.P.. Deterministic and stochastic optimization of a dynamic advertising model. Optimal Control Applications and Methods, 1983, 4: 179-184.

[45] Sethi S.P., Thompson G.L.. Optimal Control Theory: Applications to Management Science and Economics, 2000, 2nd ed. New York, NY: Springer.

[46] Stackelberg, H.V. (1952). The Theory of the Market Economy, translated by Peacock A.T. William Hodge and Co., London

[47] Teng J.T., Thompson G.L.. Oligopoly models for optimal advertising when production costs obey a learning curve. Management Science, 1983, 29(9): 1087-1101.

[48] Thompson G.L., Teng J.T.. Optimal pricing and advertising policies for new product. Marketing Science, 1984, 3(2): 148-168.

[49] Urban T.L.. An inventory-theoretic approach to product assortment and shelf-space allocation. Journal of Retailing, 1998, 74(1): 15-35.

[50] Vidale M.L., Wolfe H.B.. An operations research study of sales response to advertising. Operations Research, 1957, 5: 370-381.